If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Given FalseFlags likes little demonstrations, here are some ideas for him:

1. Build a simple house of cards.

2. Very carefully place a penny on it. The house should remain standing.

3. Now take the same penny but drop it from 5 feet up on top of the house of cards. What happens? Yet the house of cards clearly was able to support the penny in #2. Why do you think it collapsed in #3?

4. Alternatively consider that a parked car is easily supported by its tires, suspension, and chassis. Now push that car off the roof of a 4 story parking garage. Do you think that the tires, suspension, and chassis will remain intact after the car hits the street? Why does the car undergo such damage when dropped if the weight of the car was easily supported by its structure in the static situation?

5. As to issues of scale: drop a toy car from a height ten times its length. It probably bounces off the floor intact, right? Try that with a real car from a height ten times its length. Is the resulting destruction due to a conspiracy? A controlled demolition?
 
See those dark columns in the middle. How come those weren't still standing after the collapse? ...
http://imgur.com/mnW1wgW
The dark columns are walls, and you are seeing wallboard which is the fire proofing, and the walls around the elevator shafts.
The central core has no lateral support, and will fall after the floors and shell are gone. Study the WTC before falling for BS models.

The dumb part of Cole's idiotic models are the fire crackers, there was no evidence of explosives on 911, and no blasts. Ironically Cole shows the WTC falling, and the video has no blasts, no giant fire crackers showing supersonic blasts.

BIG CLUE - a floor in the WTC fails over 29,000,000 pounds; the upper section is not stopped by the lower floor, the upper section weighs more than 29,000,000 pounds, AND it is moving.

Cole's model floor should fail if 11 or more floors hit a lower floor, and his model fails to model the WTC, since the floors don't fail. Cole has failed to model the weight of the WTC properly with respect to the toy scale he did.

911 truth's last stand based on idiotic models, the final BS blast of woo; like some failed Hitler move, spread lies of BS, keep the failed minds of 911 truth followers believing in woo, dumbed down with fire crackers. What Cole proves, tiny floors which could be offices for roaches and ants, will not collapse; and Cole proves 911 truth followers are clueless in the areas of physics, and engineering. Cole also proves 911 truth followers have no clue what supersonic blasts look like, even when Cole uses fireworks which have blast wave velocity over 400 m/s (that is 800 knots, 920 mph wave fronts, not seen on 911), and not one blast wave was seen on 911.

We see debris expelled by air due to a gravity collapse, not explosives. Big fail for a 911 truth failed "expert".
 
Last edited:
If he had been at the White House and responded to the crisis immediately, I'm sure it would've been taken as proof that he knew it was going to happen.

This is why we need sarcasm tags, because I'm pretty sure that's sarcasm.
 
The Blessed IPU alone knows how many times I have posted this in this forum but it appears to relevant yet once again. If pigs had wings, they still couldn't fly. The Square-cube_lawWP you know. Yes, I know at least two other posters in this thread have mentioned it but they did not post this:

:pigsfly

:bwall

Your square/cube law will not keep down a determined piglet/pigasuslet. :D
I find it difficult to think of any argument that would penetrate the stupidity in that "Debunking" video. It must be willfull.
 
The thread title is part of a famous quote by Richard P. Feynman. The full quote is, "It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong."

Recently, two new videos were posted by Jonathan H. Cole, PE.

The first video is a response to the blacksmith video which recently went viral. The second video discusses the collapse of WTC1 and WTC2.

Everyone should watch them both.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WgCtvTmshZ8

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TJNzaMRsN00


OMG! That is the most unintentionally hilarious Truther video yet! Cole trying to hammer a steel rod through its own length! Does he REALLY think anyone claims that this is what happened? :dl:

Maybe he should try suspending the rod horizontally between two other rods, attaching a weight to it to try to create some simulation of the Twin Tower floor truss assemblies, however crude. Then heat the rod and see what happens. Has he even read the NIST reports? I'm beginning to doubt it! :rolleyes:
 

Attachments

  • Cole Hammer Steel Rod.jpg
    Cole Hammer Steel Rod.jpg
    66.6 KB · Views: 18
In this case, scale is irrelevant.

Best laugh I've had all week.!!

Here's a tiny sample of what you need to know - cold - in order to have a meaningful opinion on Cole's crappola.

Structural Modeling and Experimental Techniques
By Harry G. Harris, Gajanan Sabnis
http://tinyurl.com/z5ob9nj
Chapter 2, 5, 6, 8, 9 11, 12 App A

Why don't you read thru that & then get back here with your opinion.

In order to BEGIN to set up a meaningful experiment, you need the above, plus at least a BS in mechanical or structural, and about 15 years of real world experience in building & validatng structural models & experimentation.

His first major, laughable flaw is a scaling factor of about 120:1.
Regardless of your assertion that "it is irrelevant."
If you scan thru the text that I provided above, you'll see just how critical scaling is.

His other 99 major, laughable flaws follow close behind.

Cole's nonsense should be humiliating to him.
Presenting this crap to the public, under the rubric of his PE license, SHOULD get his PE license revoked.
His crap is infuriating to competent structural & mechanical engineers around the globe.

Yeah, yeah, I know that AE911Twoof thinks his junk is really spiffy.
But I said "competent structural & mechanical engineers".
They don't qualify.
 
Last edited:
OMG! That is the most unintentionally hilarious Truther video yet! Cole trying to hammer a steel rod through its own length! Does he REALLY think anyone claims that this is what happened? :dl:

Maybe he should try suspending the rod horizontally between two other rods, attaching a weight to it to try to create some simulation of the Twin Tower floor truss assemblies, however crude. Then heat the rod and see what happens. Has he even read the NIST reports? I'm beginning to doubt it! :rolleyes:

I can't believe you called that a hammer, can't be more than 4 pounds.

He didn't even use a rose bud, and heat the steel properly.

Pipe would have been closer to that actual core columns not a steel rod.

This video is like all of Cole's video a laugh riot he is totally clueless.

Take some fine bone China plates, and some carpenters pencils, sand the pencil leads
Until they are 1/8th max thick. Glue the pencils on bottom of the fine China.

Suspend the China, by the pencil leads between wooden boards, drop a four inch concrete
Block from 4 feet, and observe the reaction.
 
Cole's nonsense should be humiliating to him.
Presenting this crap to the public, under the rubric of his PE license, SHOULD get his PE license revoked.

:eusa_clap: Engineers need to protect their reputations.
 
Before we even get into the scaling issues that others noted, the first thing that Cole gets wrong in #2 is that he doesn't have a clue how the building was constructed, or if he does, then he is intentionally deceptive because not a single one of his experiments come close to replicating the actual building structure.

The collapse initiation was caused by the sagging floor trusses pulling the columns inwards, this is confirmed by photos and video of the exterior columns bowing inwards and then collapsing inwards at the moment of collapse.

You can model this pretty easily with a straw a table and your fingers. Hold the straw so it stand upright on the table and place a finger from your right hand on top of it, pushing downwards hard enough to hold it in place, but not to deform or bow it. Now, without increasing the pressure on the top of the straw, push the center of it sideways with your other finger and watch what happens.

This is what happen in the towers, when the first wall columns deformed to the point of collapsing, the weight of the upper tower transfers instantly to the remaining columns meaning that those almost compromised by their deformation had more load to hold, and this collapses as well, resulting in further weight shifting and more deformed columns collapsing.

Cole show instead a pressure pushing the walls outwards, this is just totally wrong.

Next, his first experiment concentrates on breaking the "floors", but this isn't the mechanism in the WTC collapses. In fact it was the connectors between the outer walls and the floor trusses that failed once collapse had begun, not the floors themselves.

Cole's first experiment totally fails here because 1) His connectors aren't to scale. 2) His floors aren't to scale. 3) His outer shell is rigid. 4) The connectors, which were the fail point in the WTC are solidly attached to the outer wall and can't fail.

Experiment #1 has no relevance to the WTC collapse

I could keep going, but in the end only one of his experiments came close to the WTC structure, the one with the plastic Pizza thingies on their side, where they were thrust out and the floors all collapsed pancake style, and even this one wasn't entirely correct because the floors in the WTC didn't have columns between them.

The WTC was like a tall thin hollow box made up of jigsaw puzzle pieces with a much thinner box of jigsaw puzzle pieces in its centre. To keep these two boxes stable, floors were hooked onto them to connect one to the other and to hold them together in position. Unlike conventional buildings, the WTC support columns were on the outside of the floors, rather than between them, as Cole places them in every one of his experiments.

Each of his experiments is invalid for this reason alone, even without the scaling issues.

On scaling.... To simulate the building in a scale model you need to scale the components strength to their size, which means changing the material. You also have to scale for mass because Momentum is important in the collapse, but volume and thus mass, scales at a different rate to linear dimensions. If I take a 1,000kg, 1m3 of water and half the linear dimensions, I end up with a 0.25m 0.125m3 of water with a mass of just 250kg 125kg.

This means that if we were to do a 50% scale of the WTC, we'd have to find a material 50% 25% weaker and twice four times as dense to replicate it.

Except this isn't true either because we need to have our impact scaled as well. Since Gravity is the same, if in the 1:1 version of our WTC each floor was falling 3m before hitting the next one, accelerating at about 10m/s2 between each floor, in our scale model each floor only accelerates for 1.5m between impacts so the delta-v is only 0.7071 that of the the same object falling from 3m. (I'll let you figure out why, but I'll give you a clue, it has to do with the formula for determining velocity by distance fallen and the square root of 1/2. Thus the Momentum is still 0.7071 of what it should be (P = mv). Thus to get the Impact Momentum at the right scale, we actually have to use a material 2.83x 5.66x as dense as our original, and this is just for a 50% scale model, it only gets worse as you get smaller! If we made the model 25% in size, we'd have to use materials 22.6 32 times as dense and 4 16 times as weak as that the WTC was constructed in, it's debatable that such a structure could even actually stand up without collapsing all by itself.

Cole didn't do any of this. His experiments were a fail.

Finally, he shows a video with firecrackers. This should raise red flags for anyone with a brain. You can clearly hear the crackers going off, and see the paper being exploded outwards. He then shifts to a bunch of firemen saying they heard pop, pop, pop, pop, but what doesn't he do? He doesn't show a video where those explosions are clearly heard as they are in his own model, and in every single CD video on the net. If explosives were used in the WTC, then just like in his video, and the thousands of CD videos, we'd be able to hear them! We be able to see the shock wave hit the camera as we do in CD videos. It wouldn't be a few fire fighters talking about pop, pop, pop, pop. There would be audio of the explosives going off, just as we heard the fire crackers.

The video is a total joke. He doesn't understand the collapse method, he doesn't understand the buildings construction, and he doesn't understand scale.

That is what he got wrong.
 
Last edited:
When the WTC towers collapsed, they continued to fall at or near freefall speeds. The only way this could have happened is if an external force removed the lower floor before the falling part above hit it. Controlled demolition is the ONLY way the WTC towers could have collapsed the way they did. The laws of physics support this, and Mr. Cole's experiments demonstrate this as well.
Progressive collapse, demonstrated. It doesn't decelerate, quite the contrary.

 
I hope as many of you as possible go on record stating that scale matters in the experiments performed by Mr. Cole. What you are really doing is destroying your credibility. Please continue.
A simpler introduction than that given by tfk is
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scale_model

For structural engineering scale models, it is important for several specific quantities to be scaled according to the theory of similitude. These quantities can be broadly grouped into three categories: loading, geometry, and material properties.​
(bolding mine, cursive in the original)

You could give that article a good read.
 
A simpler introduction than that given by tfk is
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scale_model
For structural engineering scale models, it is important for several specific quantities to be scaled according to the theory of similitude. These quantities can be broadly grouped into three categories: loading, geometry, and material properties.​
(bolding mine, cursive in the original)

You could give that article a good read.

And again, those three properties are just for a static structural model. A dynamic model of collapse propagation needs a fourth consideration: the acceleration of gravity. The gravitational potential energy of the mass depends on its height, so when you scale down the size of the model you are also scaling down that gravitational energy, and hence the kinetic energy of the impacts. In addition to the other scale problems in Cole's experiments, a mass that falls 3.7 meters, as in the towers, has more than 10 times more kinetic energy than the same mass falling 0.5 meters. I think this is probably the most serious flaw in Cole's experiments.
 
Last edited:
I know no one here is going to read this, but I will post it anyway. This article discusses the second video I posted at the beginning of the thread.

Here is a link to the article - http://www.ae911truth.org/news/254-...n-towers-civil-engineer-tests-3-theories.html

Here is a quote from the article that addresses scale -

Summary of the article:

What do a coconut, a beanbag and a bullet have in common? Nothing but direction of force which is not scalable therefore CD.
 
See those dark columns in the middle. How come those weren't still standing after the collapse?

Once again, you are insinuating that the building had some sort of design flaw. It did not. The top floors, the upper center column, and the outer support structure of the towers all came straight down through the lower, undamaged structure of the building. The fall of the top part of the building should have been slowed down, and eventually stopped, by the undamaged, lower part of the building. This did not happen. The reason it did not happen is because the lower floors were removed in sequence as the top fell. The only explanation for this is controlled demolition.

In 15 years not one organization or person has performed a real-world experiment that supports the collapse as described in the official story. No one.
For clarification, all of the building didn't come straight down. Some of the building structure was blasted laterally, in sequence, as the towers fell. This also supports CD.

You got a 110 story building you'd like to donate to the cause?
 
In addition to the other scale problems in Cole's experiments, a mass that falls 3.7 meters, as in the towers, has more than 10 times more kinetic energy than the same mass falling 0.5 meters.

Not quite. Kinetic energy after falling is equal to potential energy released, which is proportional to height fallen, so in fact it's just over 7 times. Cole's real howler is equating impacts between flat surfaces of rigid bodies, in his model, to sequential impacts of small parts of a complex structure of varying strengths, shapes and sizes, in the actual collapses. His entire argument can be debunked by picking up one of his planks and balancing it on a finger, and anyone who doesn't understand why that debunks it has failed to understand anything at all about structural strength and scaling.

Dave
 
I think we may have driven our conspiracy theorists away with a smattering of facts. If only we could somehow convert them and recruit them, so that this idiocy would die a natural death.
 
The Blessed IPU alone knows how many times I have posted this in this forum but it appears to relevant yet once again. If pigs had wings, they still couldn't fly. The Square-cube_lawWP you know. Yes, I know at least two other posters in this thread have mentioned it but they did not post this:

:pigsfly

:bwall

You're gonna need bigger wings.
 
They were so clever. That is why GW was reading a children's story at the time.

The childrens' story was an indicator that the whole official story was a fairy tale.

Villains love to leave little indicators like that.
 
His entire argument can be debunked by picking up one of his planks and balancing it on a finger, and anyone who doesn't understand why that debunks it has failed to understand anything at all about structural strength and scaling.

Um... Anything can be balanced on a fulcrum if you know the center of gravity or can find it. What does that have anything to do with structural strength or scaling, and how does it in any way debunk his argument(s)?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom