If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
The first video proves, via experiment, that the viral blacksmith video is BS.

False. Steel has been around for thousands of years and is fairly well understood by now, so it's not like humanity started working with it yesterday.

When it was first produced it was worked using bloomeries made of earth, clay, or stones in fires produced by wood. So I'm pretty certain that, given the right circumstances, you could use jet fuel to melt steel.

A moot point because the steel was not melted, it didn't need to be melted. You see steel, like all other metals, expands and losses its rigidity as it's heated causing it to loss strength. Eventually it'll catastrophically fail, like it did on 9/11.

Putting all that aside, you know what does not melt steel? Explosives.

FF said:
The second video proves, via several experiments, that the official story is BS. The video also contains an experiment that closely replicates the actual collapse of WTC1 and WTC2. Mr. Cole does this by blowing out the support columns in sequence, much like a controlled demolition.

The highlighted part is also false. All he's done, if what you stated is true, is work out CD collapse model that looks similar to what actually happened. I am not impressed.
 
Here is a quote from the article that addresses scale -

I read the article and my IQ dropped 15 points. Utter, meaningless drivel where he tosses in some sciencey words to impress the gullible. Even then he manages to be virtually incoherent about it.
 
Jet fuel will do nicely for melting steel as long as it is fueling the right kind of furnace.
We (my dad and myself) have a home workshop we use for model engineering.
We have a home made furnace, it is fueled by propane with a forced air blast.
We can cast up to 5kg of iron.
Propane and Jet Fuel have similar energy density and specific energy.
I don't doubt that with a new atomizer nozzle and feed pump we could fuel the furnace with Jet Fuel.
 
Last edited:
I know no one here is going to read this, but I will post it anyway. This article discusses the second video I posted at the beginning of the thread.

First lie: End of paragraph 2, "symmetrically," one of the classic truth movement lies.

First scaling error: The use of rigid wooden planks to simulate the floors.

Can't be bothered to read any more.

Dave
 
Hahaha, wow. Coming up on 15 years and you still have no idea how the towers were constructed :boggled:

http://i.imgur.com/mnW1wgW.jpg

See those dark columns in the middle. How come those weren't still standing after the collapse?

Once again, you are insinuating that the building had some sort of design flaw. It did not. The top floors, the upper center column, and the outer support structure of the towers all came straight down through the lower, undamaged structure of the building. The fall of the top part of the building should have been slowed down, and eventually stopped, by the undamaged, lower part of the building. This did not happen. The reason it did not happen is because the lower floors were removed in sequence as the top fell. The only explanation for this is controlled demolition.

In 15 years not one organization or person has performed a real-world experiment that supports the collapse as described in the official story. No one.

For clarification, all of the building didn't come straight down. Some of the building structure was blasted laterally, in sequence, as the towers fell. This also supports CD.
 
Last edited:
See those dark columns in the middle. How come those weren't still standing after the collapse?

Some of them were, for a while. But as their lateral support was stripped away they became unstable and eventually succumbed to their sudden thinness and the jostling of falling debris lower down



The fall of the top part of the building should have been slowed down, and eventually stopped, by the undamaged, lower part of the building. This did not happen. The reason it did not happen is because the lower floors were removed in sequence as the top fell. The only explanation for this is controlled demolition.

I suppose this is where you say "Newton's Third Law" ?
 
Wile we are on the subject of scale.

The top portion of the photo below is a screen shot from one of Gage's videos.

Do you think it's fair for gage to scale up the size of the comparison building to visually match the size WTC7. When the real comparison should look more like the bottom half of the photo?


Screen%20shot%202015-08-14%20at%207.51.57%20PM.jpg
 
See those dark columns in the middle. How come those weren't still standing after the collapse?

Once again, you are insinuating that the building had some sort of design flaw. It did not. The top floors, the upper center column, and the outer support structure of the towers all came straight down through the lower, undamaged structure of the building. The fall of the top part of the building should have been slowed down, and eventually stopped, by the undamaged, lower part of the building. This did not happen. The reason it did not happen is because the lower floors were removed in sequence as the top fell. The only explanation for this is controlled demolition.

In 15 years not one organization or person has performed a real-world experiment that supports the collapse as described in the official story. No one.

For clarification, all of the building didn't come straight down. Some of the building structure was blasted laterally, in sequence, as the towers fell. This also supports CD.

That's a lie, I did the experiment that lead to The discovery of how the energy was distributed though the structure, during the collapse that was used in the Greening, Banzant, Benson, Computer program, of which the paper you refer too is merely an abstract.
As long as the energy value is greater than the value of the connections ability to absorb it the towers will collapse, and that energy builds over time!
Cole is not doing experiments to promote truth, he is doing experiments as a huckster and scam artist, that is clear from the total of the flawed experiments he has preformed.
 
Wile we are on the subject of scale.

The top portion of the photo below is a screen shot from one of Gage's videos.

Do you think it's fair for gage to scale up the size of the comparison building to visually match the size WTC7. When the real comparison should look more like the bottom half of the photo?


[qimg]http://i995.photobucket.com/albums/af74/waypastvne/Screen%20shot%202015-08-14%20at%207.51.57%20PM.jpg[/qimg]

Doesn't that make less sense? That makes WTC 7 fall twice as fast, or am I getting it backwards?
 
I know no one here is going to read this, but I will post it anyway. This article discusses the second video I posted at the beginning of the thread.

Here is a link to the article - http://www.ae911truth.org/news/254-...n-towers-civil-engineer-tests-3-theories.html

Here is a quote from the article that addresses scale -

What has given you the...odd...(and completely incorrect) idea that the problem with scaling is with "direction"? COle managed to get the "direction" correct--his "model" collapsed down.

"Direction" is not the problem with scaling, nor has anyone here said so.
 
Doesn't that make less sense? That makes WTC 7 fall twice as fast, or am I getting it backwards?
WTC 7 took over 18 seconds to collapse, what are you talking about? It does not make sense Gage spreads lies... why does Richard Gage lie.

A momentum model of the towers proves no CD; the Cole video is moronic, and only capable of fooling people who can't think for themselves; followers, and paranoid conspiracy theorists included.
 
WTC 7 took over 18 seconds to collapse, what are you talking about? It does not make sense Gage spreads lies... why does Richard Gage lie.

A momentum model of the towers proves no CD; the Cole video is moronic, and only capable of fooling people who can't think for themselves; followers, and paranoid conspiracy theorists included.

If he didn't lie he wouldn't have a pay check.:D
 
Frankly I am surprised that the "conversation" from FalseFag has continued this long.

I only wish to point out three things:

1. It is very true that theory must be subservient to experimentally-derived facts, but the experiment has to be an appropriate and accurate test of the reality that the theory seeks to explain. The basic theory of gravitational acceleration seeks to explain how objects fall in a vacuum. If one does an experiment examining ball bearing falling in a beaker of water, you will get out different data from those predicted by the theory of gravitational acceleration in a vacuum (due to water resistance). This in no way invalidates the theory- it is simply the wrong experimental test for this theory.

2. Scale plays a central role in determining behavior at almost all levels of science. One may have heard that an ant the size of a human could lift a care. But this is wrong due to the actual physical effects of the change in scale. An ant the size of a human would collapse under its own weight, would probably split open its exoskeleton, and would be unable to breath. let alone support a car. In my own field of biochemistry, it is absolute routine to find that scaling up a purification using exactly the same materials yields very different results from those of a smaller pilot experiment (in part because volume scales as the cube, whereas area scales as the square). Scale effects all aspects of science and physics.

3. The "direction" argument FalseFlag makes is largely irrelevant, as others have stated, but I will take issue with it as just another example of a misuderstanding of the effects of "scale."

"The direction of the net force applied is independent of scale, which is why a coconut launched from a catapult or a bullet blasted from a gun or a thrown bean bag all have similar motions, and therefore all have similar directions of applied net force — yet none of them scale whatsoever. We can study the trajectory of the coconut, the bullet, and the beanbag and understand that they travel in similar motions or paths, and therefore all have a similar direction of net force that caused the motion."
This is not true- the motion of a coconut launched from a catapult, a bullet blasted from a gun, or a thrown bean bag will all be different in air (which I gather the WWC was immersed in)- even if fired at the same speed horizontally, a bean bag will fairly rapidly slow and hit the ground within a few 100 meters, whereas the bullet will travel a lot longer distance, maybe miles. The exact direction of impact at any distance will be quite different for the three. Not to mention that the quote also implies quite different speeds for the three objects (thus different trajectories), and the additional likelihood that the coconut will be shattered by the force of the gun and the bean bag will be torn apart by the air resistance. There is no way the paths or motions would be similar or the same. Anyone who blithely proposes otherwise does not understand even elementary physics.
 
Last edited:
Frankly I am surprised that the "conversation" from FalseFag has continued this long.

I only wish to point out three things:

1. It is very true that theory must be subservient to experimentally-derived facts, but the experiment has to be an appropriate and accurate test of the reality that the theory seeks to explain. The basic theory of gravitational acceleration seeks to explain how objects fall in a vacuum. If one does an experiment examining ball bearing falling in a beaker of water, you will get out different data from those predicted by the theory of gravitational acceleration in a vacuum (due to water resistance). This in no way invalidates the theory- it is simply the wrong experimental test for this theory.

2. Scale plays a central role in determining behavior at almost all levels of science. One may have heard that an ant the size of a human could lift a care. But this is wrong due to the actual physical effects of the change in scale. An ant the size of a human would collapse under its own weight, would probably split open its exoskeleton, and would be unable to breath. let alone support a car. In my own field of biochemistry, it is absolute routine to find that scaling up a purification using exactly the same materials yields very different results from those of a smaller pilot experiment (in part because volume scales as the cube, whereas area scales as the square). Scale effects all aspects of science and physics.

3. The "direction" argument FalseFlag makes is largely irrelevant, as others have stated, but I will take issue with it as just another example of a misuderstanding of the effects of "scale."

"The direction of the net force applied is independent of scale, which is why a coconut launched from a catapult or a bullet blasted from a gun or a thrown bean bag all have similar motions, and therefore all have similar directions of applied net force — yet none of them scale whatsoever. We can study the trajectory of the coconut, the bullet, and the beanbag and understand that they travel in similar motions or paths, and therefore all have a similar direction of net force that caused the motion."
This is not true- the motion of a coconut launched from a catapult, a bullet blasted from a gun, or a thrown bean bag will all be different in air (which I gather the WWC was immersed in)- even if fired at the same speed horizontally, a bean bag will fairly rapidly slow and hit the ground within a few 100 meters, whereas the bullet will travel a lot longer distance, maybe miles. The exact direction of impact at any distance will be quite different for the three. Not to mention that the quote also implies quite different speeds for the three objects (thus different trajectories), and the additional likelihood that the coconut will be shattered by the force of the gun and the bean bag will be torn apart by the air resistance. There is no way the paths or motions would be similar or the same. Anyone who blithely proposes otherwise does not understand even elementary physics.

I share your surprise at the length of the thread. Though "amusement" might better describe my feelings. ;)

And I assume that the vast majority of the posters here understand and agree with pretty much every else you have posted.

But one participant in the thread does not.

And as long as there is something wrong on the Internet some of us are dedicated to fixing it. :w2:

"Think of the Lurkers".
 
I don't expect anyone to prove him wrong, because it can't be done. The issue isn't trying to prove Mr. Cole wrong, the issue is trying to prove that the laws of physics are wrong. That can't be done.

Is this the part where someone points out that materials don't have the same proportional strength when scaling the model up or down? Do you know about the square-cube thing?

What about the path of least resistance? The top floors of the WTC towers fell straight down through almost 90,000 tons of undamaged, unmelted structural steel, which had been supporting the upper floors for almost 30 years.

Please tell me you know that a moving mass isn't the same as a static one.

Let me translate: Word salad intended to confuse the weak-minded.

The weak-minded here would be you. Admittedly, you have zero knowledge of physics, but pretend to be able to educate your betters in the matter.

*speechless

Apparently you don't know anything about building construction, either.

Perhaps you should read up on a few topics rather than gulp down truther propaganda.

I know no one here is going to read this, but I will post it anyway.

Well, again, if you post truther nonsense, don't expect it to be taken seriously.

Once again, you are insinuating that the building had some sort of design flaw.

Not at all. It just wasn't designed to handle this much damage. No building is, but the WTC towers 1 and 2 were particularily vulnerable to this.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom