If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's like teaching calculus to a baby. There's no point. When someone's understanding hasn't reached the level of an 11 year old then it's pointless to continue.

That's why video's such as Cole's manage to gain traction. They are produced and lapped up by those who simply have no level of education in the subjects being discussed.

It's pure Dunning-Kruger effect. What's the point in arguing just because someone on the internet is wrong and can never be taught or educated to get it right?
 
I have followed this 9/11 "discussion" for years and the arguments made which reveal the flaws in the 9/11 truth points are well made. At this point it like beating a dead horse. The only issue for me is why are people so resistant to reason and so unwilling to change their "beliefs" when shown with rational thinking how misguided they were?

I blame our education system for instilling two harmful ideas in the young.

1) No matter how difficult a problem may seem, there's always a tidy answer in the back of the book.

2) If I'm having difficulty, I can always copy off of someone else's answer sheet.

Confronted with a real world problem, is it any wonder they fall back on these tried-and-true techniques for passing the class?
 
It's like teaching calculus to a baby. There's no point. When someone's understanding hasn't reached the level of an 11 year old then it's pointless to continue.

That's why video's such as Cole's manage to gain traction. They are produced and lapped up by those who simply have no level of education in the subjects being discussed.

It's pure Dunning-Kruger effect. What's the point in arguing just because someone on the internet is wrong and can never be taught or educated to get it right?


This is the problem in a nut shell... Most truthers... probably all but a handful have insufficient technical background education to comprehend the issues properly. They essentially view the physical world with the understanding of a child. Try to explain how a plane flies to a child. Ain't happenin. But a child might be able to steer a plane! And certainly identify one and fly as a passenger in one. So a child BELIEVES they understand enough about planes to discuss them and their behavior.

The more dangerous ones are those with a little bit of knowledge and too proud to admit their limitations when confronted with arguments that fly over their head.

And then there are the very very few like Tony who is clearly smart enough, and educated enough to understand but refuses to for some mysterious reason. Gage is willfully ignorant because his livelihood depends on it.

I suppose many are in it for the ego.. being a big cheese in a small political movement... even though it goes nowhere aside from the occasional off the wall media outlet or their own events attended by their own followers.

It's all good!

++++

Parroting an expert seems to work for the true believers... no need to understand...
 
Last edited:
It's like teaching calculus to a baby. There's no point. When someone's understanding hasn't reached the level of an 11 year old then it's pointless to continue.

That's why video's such as Cole's manage to gain traction. They are produced and lapped up by those who simply have no level of education in the subjects being discussed.

It's pure Dunning-Kruger effect. What's the point in arguing just because someone on the internet is wrong and can never be taught or educated to get it right?

Correction, too an earthworm, no insult to earthworms intended.:D
 
Physical models to mimic the behavior of the buildings is a fool's errand... a non starter and misguided. Cole is showing his ignorance or dishonesty or both.

++++

I have followed this 9/11 "discussion" for years and the arguments made which reveal the flaws in the 9/11 truth points are well made. At this point it like beating a dead horse. The only issue for me is why are people so resistant to reason and so unwilling to change their "beliefs" when shown with rational thinking how misguided they were? Surely some are in it for the attention, the money, just to be contrary and consistent in their distrust for all things coming from authority figures or the media. But there are so many who refuse to accept sound reasoning and science and no otherwise intelligent people. That is stunning. It's a waste of time for those in denial... they seem unreachable by reason and science. And so 9/11 conspiracy beliefs will never go away.


This is rooted in basic Con-Man and Scam Artist rules of thumb:

1: Get the mark (Truthers/CTers) emotionally invested in the deal. Emotion trumps common sense. They will ignore good advice.

2: Convince the mark that this is the "best deal" they "are ever going to get." Once sold, they will dismiss all alternatives.


9-11 Truth is driven by the belief that the attacks were staged by sinister US Government forces/Illuminati/Bush-Cheney/Neocon/*insert your bogey man here* to lead us into war and take away our civil rights and blah, blah, blah. They've bought into a scam, and can't walk away.

The facts are these:

Al Qaeda operatives hijacked 4 commercial jetliners and crashed 3 into buildings while losing one in PA.

The Bush Administration, and CONGRESS, feeling the heat from the American people...overreacted. Bad choices were made with respect to Iraq. Some in the Bush Administration saw 9-11 as a chance to implement policy beliefs that the middle east would be a better place with American-style democracy, but because they're morons, they failed to understand that American-style Democracy only works in America. Chaos ensued.

That's it. That should be bad enough, because it is. For "debunkers" it is.
 
Instead of attacking me, or Mr. Cole, I challenge anyone in this forum to conduct an experiment proving just ONE of Mr. Cole's claims are wrong. You pick the claim, and you make your own video showing how he is wrong. Words and computer models don't count. Prove, by an experiment conducted by yourself and documented in your own video, just one of Mr. Cole's claims are wrong.

I know this challenge will go unanswered until the end of time, but good luck, anyway.
.
Since you apparently aren't going to respond to my request to state in your own words what you think Cole proved, I watched the second video. What a waste of time, and rather than waste more time critiquing it, the simple proof that the conclusion he draws from his experiments is wrong is the Vérinage demolition technique, as shown by these "experiments":



If the predictions that Cole infers from his experiments don't match the real world, they're useless.


 
.
Since you apparently aren't going to respond to my request to state in your own words what you think Cole proved, I watched the second video. What a waste of time, and rather than waste more time critiquing it, the simple proof that the conclusion he draws from his experiments is wrong is the Vérinage demolition technique, as shown by these "experiments":



If the predictions that Cole infers from his experiments don't match the real world, they're useless.


Cole and his b-boy followers will never have enough brain power amongst themselves to "get" this. Let 'em just keep simmering till they are well done and have to be thrown out.
 
Sure I don't. /sarcasm

That's why the formula F=ma changes depending on the size of the object, right? F=ma is only valid for certain sized objects. Once you get to skyscrapers, the formulas are different, right? So, if scale is relevant, like you claim, please post the formulas that apply to large objects only, and explain how they don't apply to smaller objects. Please post the formulas that apply to Mr. Cole's experiments, and then post the formulas that apply to the WTC buildings.



It's your video, do whatever you want.

Just out of interest, if you drop a 6kg bowling ball from a given height (say 3m ) and you want to know what force it experiences when it hits the floor what figure would you use for acceleration in the formula F=ma? Do you think that might vary depending on drop height?
 
Just out of interest, if you drop a 6kg bowling ball from a given height (say 3m ) and you want to know what force it experiences when it hits the floor what figure would you use for acceleration in the formula F=ma? Do you think that might vary depending on drop height?
:thumbsup: Neat parody.




(...I hope... :o
...let's see if any members fall for the misdirection.)
 
Last edited:
The Blessed IPU alone knows how many times I have posted this in this forum but it appears to relevant yet once again. If pigs had wings, they still couldn't fly. The Square-cube_lawWP you know. Yes, I know at least two other posters in this thread have mentioned it but they did not post this:

:pigsfly

:bwall
 
The Blessed IPU alone knows how many times I have posted this in this forum but it appears to relevant yet once again. If pigs had wings, they still couldn't fly. The Square-cube_lawWP you know. Yes, I know at least two other posters in this thread have mentioned it but they did not post this:

:pigsfly

:bwall

Good point!!!:D:thumbsup:
 
I know no one here is going to read this, but I will post it anyway. This article discusses the second video I posted at the beginning of the thread.

Here is a link to the article - http://www.ae911truth.org/news/254-...n-towers-civil-engineer-tests-3-theories.html

Here is a quote from the article that addresses scale -

So while we may not be able to tell what caused the force, we can tell the direction of the net force by observing the direction of the motion. The direction of the net force applied is independent of scale, which is why a coconut launched from a catapult or a bullet blasted from a gun or a thrown bean bag all have similar motions, and therefore all have similar directions of applied net force — yet none of them scale whatsoever. We can study the trajectory of the coconut, the bullet, and the beanbag and understand that they travel in similar motions or paths, and therefore all have a similar direction of net force that caused the motion.
 
Last edited:
I know no one here is going to read this.......

You don't bother reading what we post, so you're hardly in a strong position to start pointing fingers. When you've bothered to read and respond to this, (below) and particularly to the report it references showing the loss of strength in steel with increasing temperature, then, and only then, will you be in a position to demand that I read your stuff:

Surely no-one argues that steel has to melt to lose its strength?

As an architect, I've visited a number of fire damaged buildings. The most interesting ones are the old oak-framed half-timbered ("black & white") buildings from the 17th century, particularly when there has been a modern extension. Inevitably, the old frame remains, and can almost always be entirely re-used in the re-build, but the modern steel beam sag in damn great U shapes, sometimes reaching the floor in the middle whilst remaining on their ceiling-high supports at either end. Catastrophic collapse of steel occurs at lower temperatures than that required to take out a timber framed building, and without any jet fuel involved.

If someone's experiment shows anything different from that, the experiment is flawed, or deliberately contrived.

Here's someone else's photo.


Here's a report into the effect of fire on steel. Scroll to figure 2.1, which shows that steel loses 80% of its strength at 700C. It would be unlikely to be able to support itself at that point, let alone any imposed loads. Fig 2.4 shows that bolts give up even sooner.
 
Here is a quote from the article that addresses scale -

No, it does not. "The direction of the net force applied is independent of scale" is a strange and rather pointless observation, but it has nothing whatsoever to do with the problem of scaling a structural model. Not only does Cole not address that problem, he clearly has no clue that he needs to. Maybe this will help:


.
ETA: For the dynamic situation that Cole is attempting to model, by the way, there's another scaling problem that he ignores: He isn't scaling the acceleration of gravity.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom