If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Normally, I would just ignore you, but you handed me a meatball, and I just can't refuse.

What about the path of least resistance? The top floors of the WTC towers fell straight down through almost 90,000 tons of undamaged, unmelted structural steel, which had been supporting the upper floors for almost 30 years. Is that the path of least resistance? How is it possible for the top portion of a building to accelerate at or near freefall through the path of most resistance? This clearly violates Newton's third law. The only way the top portion can travel at or near freefall is if an external force removed the building below it. That external force was explosives.

Deal with it.

It didn't. No matter how often, or how loudly, you make this false claim.
 
.

If Mr. Cole dropped a two-ton steel beam onto his mock towers they would be crushed. This is obvious. But, if you had a super high speed camera, you would be able to see the two-ton steel beam decelerate as it impacted each of Mr. Cole's mock floors. This is expected because of Newton's third law.

There were high speed cameras trained on the WTC buikdings?

Nahhhh, they were all 29.97 frame per second, common video cameras.

However, I would not expect noticeable jolts or a slowing of collapse given that the velocity of the falling mass and the quantity of falling mass both increase thus increasing the dynamic forces on the floor pans and connections between floor pans and columns, while what is visible to the cameras is the effect of loss of floor lateral support to perimeter columns.
 
Actually FF thinks removing the columns sequentially as the top section comes down , is required to allow for free fall. He thinks this because "Newton's Third Law of Motion". However that law would require that the accreting mass slow even in his simplistic scenario since the initially falling mass will encounter slower mass.

First mass falls through 3 meters then encounters the next floor's mass. If that next floor began falling just before the upper mass reached it(sequential column destruction) , that lower mass is moving slower than the original mass.

Since this was not observed, instead we see an accelleration, the premise of simple application of N's 3rd Law must be in error.
 
Sure I don't, and neither did Isaac Newton. Mr. Cole's and his models don't understand the laws of physics either. /sarcasm

His connections are too strong, he has already been proven wrong experimentially and mathematically, he is incapable of understanding simple engineering.
Did he get his license, in a cracker Jackbox?
The maxwell equation proves him wrong.
 
His connections are too strong, he has already been proven wrong experimentially and mathematically, he is incapable of understanding simple engineering.
Did he get his license, in a cracker Jackbox?
The maxwell equation proves him wrong.
Wave functions prove him wrong? Or is this a different Maxwell? :)

Then again Maxwell's silver hammer might have some connection as to why Cole thinks as he does.
 
Last edited:
There were high speed cameras trained on the WTC buikdings?

Nahhhh, they were all 29.97 frame per second, common video cameras.

However, I would not expect noticeable jolts or a slowing of collapse given that the velocity of the falling mass and the quantity of falling mass both increase thus increasing the dynamic forces on the floor pans and connections between floor pans and columns, while what is visible to the cameras is the effect of loss of floor lateral support to perimeter columns.

At 29.97 you might catch something, if you were closer; because of the frame rate, and scale, you are right, you can't catch the details of the speed for the WTC collapse; we need 50 or 100 frames or better and a lot more resolution. As it is, the speed variations are seen based on the resolution and frame rates.

911 truth could study the collapse and see the video is not able to show the BS made up by Tony.

And of course your other point, the collapse is not a block on a block, it is a floor hitting at angles which would average out the famous BS 911 truth "missing jolt"...

Did I get close...
 
Last edited:
The path of least resistance was the floor pans/slabs themselves. The building collapse followed the path of least resistance, actually banana-peeling outer columns away from the building as the broken floors fell onto the next unbroken floor and exceeded all static and dynamic load designs.
 
Yes. M = mass. As mass changes, the force changes, but the formula stays the same.

True, but that isn't the problem you're having understanding 'scale'. When you double the dimensions of an object the mass rises with the cube of the increase. Double all the dimensions and the mass becomes 8 times that of the original. This is why the behaviour of a small model can't be easily extrapolated to real life situations. Someone upthread illustrated the point with the legs of ants and elephants. Elephants need relatively sturdier legs even though f=ma applies equally to both animals.

Or maybe you're kidding just to see how much you can irritate people?
 
You could try, but you won't. You will just make excuses.

We already gave you example of why.

The easiest way to understand this is that while length grows linearly , cross section grow in square , volume grows in cubics.

That's 3rd grade maths right here for you.

Now think about it : some stuff like tensile strength , support weight force etc... will grows in function of cross section so in square, while the volume they support will grow in cubic.

Think about it. This is the same problem as ant carrying 100 times their weight while we cannot : the muscle strength grow in square of the cross section, while the volume grows cubic so carry weight will grow much quicker than strength acquired from muscle as you scale up to ant, then bigger insects, then small animal than medium animal then humans.

Now try to think about support column and other support stuff : do their strength grows with length, cross section or volume ? Do the weight they support grows with length, cross section or volume ?

And poof you get a feeling why scale is a factor.

I a,m expecting you to ignore this.
 
Last edited:
FalseFlag: I have a question for you in the Skeptibunkers thread, in the Skepticism forum, regarding your accusations that some members are here "solely to misinform". I look forward to your reply.
 
Physical models to mimic the behavior of the buildings is a fool's errand... a non starter and misguided. Cole is showing his ignorance or dishonesty or both.

++++

I have followed this 9/11 "discussion" for years and the arguments made which reveal the flaws in the 9/11 truth points are well made. At this point it like beating a dead horse. The only issue for me is why are people so resistant to reason and so unwilling to change their "beliefs" when shown with rational thinking how misguided they were? Surely some are in it for the attention, the money, just to be contrary and consistent in their distrust for all things coming from authority figures or the media. But there are so many who refuse to accept sound reasoning and science and no otherwise intelligent people. That is stunning. It's a waste of time for those in denial... they seem unreachable by reason and science. And so 9/11 conspiracy beliefs will never go away.
 
Wave functions prove him wrong? Or is this a different Maxwell? :)

Then again Maxwell's silver hammer might have some connection as to why Cole thinks as he does.

Maxwell's equation for a pinned beam, 2600, pounds dropped twelve feet will sheer any connection in the towers that's the maximum energy they can absorb.

False Flag says the building fell as they did without a Jolt, yet a jolt is detectable in the speed of the collapses in fact it takes millions of jolts to slow the collapses down to such a slow collapse.

False flag there fore has to be looked at as some one who does not understand physics, to slow the buildings below free fall millions of jolts have to occur the boom, boom sound heard, is evidence of them.
 

Could be. Certainty troll and not truther.

The "Raw Trolling Index" on this page of posts 7:1 which is very efficient trolling - 7 (seven) "bites" for each trolling (or Poeing) post.


BTW the highest I ever saw was around 25:1 in one spurt of frenzied responses to a SINGLE trolling post. I think that was ergo - not C7 or MM who would normally come to mind if we were assessing effectiveness or efficiency of trolling.
 
I may have a simple experiment that someone could reproduce on video, that may help with the situation. It's based on my observations.

Take a long piece of steel box section and place it on the ground.

Take a large concrete slab (paving slab or similar), and raise it 10 feet off the ground, above the steel.

Drop the slab. Chances are that it will snap at the point of impact with the steel.

Drop another slab beside this one, so that it does not impact the steel. Does it break?

Clear the area, take the largest piece from each side, return to your previous height, drop them again. One onto steel, one not.

Repeat until the slab does not break.

Publish your findings.



I have found that it is a lot easier to break the slab the larger it is.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom