Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

Well then lets just do away with all commercial responsibility. You eat in a restaurant, the your taking on the responsibility that you won't get food poisoning. Or you buy a car, and you take on the responsibility that the breaks won't fail the first time you do 70mph. Welcome to libertopia.


Donoghue vs Stevenson. One of the most important liability decisions in legal history.
 
Donoghue vs Stevenson. One of the most important liability decisions in legal history.

From a civil point of view yes, however given my time working for the HSE, I tend to look at these things from a criminal, rather than civil point of view.
If this had have happened in the UK the radio station would face prosecution under s3 HSWA for failing, so far as is reasonably practicable, to protect the health, safety and welfare of "other persons" affected by their undertaking. Getting the contestants to sign wavers would almost certainly not protect the radio station from this prosecution. They could also face a charge of "corporate manslaughter", but that's notoriously difficult to prosecute.
 
I've seen water intoxication four times in my career.

The first time was in the late 1980's and was a guru who drank too much during a fast.

The second was a girl who drank excessively after she took an ecstasy tablet. Not uncommon as someone else has pointed out.

The third was a gentleman with psychogenic polydipsia secondary to delusions of persecution related to the government putting toxins in his fillings. He drank the contents of a dentist's water cooler in six hours while waiting to have his fillings removed.

The fourth is my personal favourite and involved a chap who decided to run the London marathon. In his case though run was somewhat subjective and consisted more of a gentle amble. He did however follow the organisers advice and drink plenty of water on the way round the course. In fact he stopped at every watering station and downed several cups of the stuff. When the paramedics found him stumbling around near the finish they thought he was exhausted and dehydrated so they put in an iv line and gave him a litre of normal saline, which probably did not help the situation in the short term.

I don't think it's fair to accuse the woman who died in this situation of stupidity. It's extremely unlikely that anyone would ever have mentioned that drinking too much water can be dangerous and it is not an intuitive concept.
 
My understanding of US cases indicates that the wavier would have no effect on a liability suit in a case like this. I'm sure if (when) a suit is brought, the wavier will be shown as evidence for the defense. I'm also pretty sure it will be pretty much ignored.

The fact that the station told the contestants "They told us if you don't feel like you can do this, don't put your health in risk." really says nothing to me. It COULD mean that they were aware of the risk of water intoxication, but I get the impression, right or wrong, that it was just a general warning. From what I understand the lady didn't show signs of a problem until after the contest.

IMHO the station should have consulted with at least an MD on the potential risk involved. They should have had a medically trained person in attendance, at least a nurse, if not an MD. The contestants should have been told about water intoxication. They should have used a sports drink, or something that would have helped balance the water with sodium to prevent or at least lesson the chance of something like this happening. And before leaving, the contestants should have been told of the warning signs of water intoxication, and given instructions on what to do if the signs were noticed. Perhaps some salt tablets would have been a good idea also, though I think those have lost favor due to high blood pressure issues.

From the article and video in post #74, by Dann, it appears likely that multiple contestants got sick from the excessive water intake. At least the guy that was interviewed, and I'd bet dollars to donuts that others were affected also.

This is, IMHO a sad situation from several points of view. First, there is a woman dead, and all the issues there.

Second, there is a group of people at a radio station that tried to have what I'm sure they thought would be a fun contest. I'm confidant that there was no ill intent. None the less, their contest resulted in the death of a person. Now the folks there have to live with that. I know I would feel like crap in a case like that.

The contest the station had, no doubt with the hope that it would boost their audience, will likely decrease their audience, at least in the short term. Pure speculation on my part of course.

The station will most likely, and rightfully in my opinion, be sued for wrongful death, or whatever applies in a case like this (negligent homicide?).

The fixes for this (consulting a doctor before, having one on hand during, Gatorade or some sports drink) wouldn't have cost them too much I wouldn't think. Maybe a couple more hundred dollars. No more than $500 - $1000 I would think. Would have been a lot cheaper in the long run. And would probably have saved this woman's life.

In my opinion, the station was the more ignorant of those involved. I think they had a responsibility to insure the contest was safe for the contestants, and it appears they failed to even check what that entailed.

Of course, if it comes out that the wavier actually warned of a water intoxication possibility, or if there were steps taken, but not mentioned in the articles, then my opinion might change. But I suspect if there's any major changes to this story, it will be from the full autopsy report, when it's completed. Those results of course, could change things drastically, but I doubt it.
 
I agree, particularly when it's part of an organised event - presumably she trusted the radio station to not run a competition that could put her at risk.

I don't think there's anything funny or ironic about this story at all, and the only stupid people are the competition organisers.

Exactly, especialy with the not too long ago death of a frat guy who died from drinking too much water, if they had paid attention they would have known about the risks.
 
And I guess that the other contestants and the listeners who didn't interfere were all either clueless idiots who also deserve to die or cynics who couldn't wait for 'Darwin' to eliminate a few of the idiots?

But don't you understand, they got to watch someone die, and really that is the funniest thing you can ever do.
 
The station will most likely, and rightfully in my opinion, be sued for wrongful death, or whatever applies in a case like this (negligent homicide?).
Criminal liability is tricker; harder to prove, though perhaps possible in this case if the local prosecutor wanted to pursue it. The civil action would be for wrongful death, and, unless there was a waiver that the court deems sufficient to preclude the lawsuit, I can't imagine that the station could have any valid defense to such a suit.
 
It's hardly an academic distinction. People don't think water is dangerous, they think that not being able to breathe is dangerous. If the water is in your stomach, then obviously your ability to breath will not be hampered, so where's the danger? I can think of absolutely no reason why it should be considered obvious that consuming massive amounts of water in a short amount of time should be bad for you. The idea that too much water is dangerous depends on fully understanding some slightly non-intuitive biological facts.

You are not going to explain anything to him, I get the distinct impression that he would, if he saw someone was going to be hit by a train they where unaware of, get out his camera to film the highly amusing event, and not shout a warning to them.
 
The radio station will still be in hot water because as far as I know it's illegal to pay people to hurt themselves.

Another idiotic Howard Stern-ripoff station tried to have a contest where people slapped each other to win concert tickets, they wound up in a lot of legal trouble for the same reason. (and Howard Stern is not stupid enough to have any contest like that)

Yeah, well, it's not fair to paint all MENSA chapters with the tarbrush of your experience with the one at Harvard. I mean, you're not exactly playing varsity there. All those Professor Longhair types? Eeessshhhhh. As Twain said, we'd be better off having a Congress made up of names randomly chosen from the Boston phonebook than of the professors at Harvard. LOL. Dang I love gigging 'em!

And I'm a great test taker too. I copied off the smart oriental kid next to me. That's how I got in. Shoot. Weren't nuthin' to it!
The conversation level here is much higher than at the Mensa forums. It seems that criticial thinking and logic lends itself to much more rigorous thinking than simply having a somewhat-high IQ.
 
It's better to blame the one who dies than the organizer of the prank, right? Remember your own opening post?!

It is a great idea, it removes all legal contraints on people who promote ineffective medicine and quack treatments. Consumers should expect no protection from anything.
 
Oh come on! Next you're going to be saying that Tom Sawyer should give back the loot he was paid by the boys he convinced to paint the fence for him. Like, full disclosure of how stupid you are is now mandatory, ethical, AND gets you hot dates to boot?

Sheesh.

So you are pro con artist I see.
 
Water toxication is unusual and not widely known, but there were a number of cases in the 90s when youngsters drunk large quantities after taking E.

It has also killed marathon runners, who are getting quack information about how they need to drink constantly to fight of dehydration. More die from drinking to much than ever did from dehydration.
 
Excellent point! She was too stupid to even be a candidate for the Darwin Awards.

The Darwin Award folks gave up arguing about that kind of crap. They don't care if the person beyond child bearing years or not. They are still eligible for Darwin Award.
 
The Darwin Award folks gave up arguing about that kind of crap. They don't care if the person beyond child bearing years or not. They are still eligible for Darwin Award.

And she would not be elligible for a darwin award anyway. The dangers of her action are not obvious enough to the average person. They just don't know about the risks of too much water and electrolyte ballance, so it fails to be an obvious lack of judgement needed for a darwin award.
 
Pris: Then we're stupid and we'll die.

Water intoxication is not a myth and it is not a simple process such as drowning. When you drink a large amount of water (excess of 2 liters) quickly the sodium density in your blood drops, causing potentially fatal changes in your brain chemistry. Ever wondered why sports drinks contain sodium?
No, you are right. I was referring to the death of Danish astronomer Tycho Brahe, allegedly from a ruptured bladder:
Most Danes would consider this risk even though it may just be a myth. Children are still warned against this by concerned parents - how is that for Darwin?:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tycho_Brahe
The irony is that this myth would probably make a Danish radio station think twice before making a stunt like this, i.e. not because of good science, but because of bad science.
But don't you understand, they got to watch someone die, and really that is the funniest thing you can ever do.
Yes, Jackass totally missed the point!
It is a great idea, it removes all legal contraints on people who promote ineffective medicine and quack treatments. Consumers should expect no protection from anything.
Consumers, hell, fraud victims are victims of nothing but their own inherent stupidity, and all you Americans have the president you deserve. Every death in Iraq is one more candidate for the Darwin Award.
 
Ok, for the record:

I wrote that she was required to drink water and to not go to the bathroom; that was the requirement to win the contest. That's not the same as "forced", as in the classic water torture, or as in "drink this water or we will beat you".

The dead woman was ignorant; try as we might, we really cannot blame her for being ignorant. The contest organizers were ignorant and stupid. It was their responsibility to run a safe contest, and they failed to meet that obligation.

Requiring people to drink a lot of water and to not go to the bathroom is to require them to subject themselves to pain and humiliation; in this case, for purposes of entertainment. I find it despicable and horrifying.

That said, people with self respect do not subject themselves to pain and humiliation. People who respect other people do not subject them to pain and humiliation, nor do they find it funny or entertaining.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom