Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

LOL. Got some kind of inferiority complex about it?
No, I tried my hand at it freshman year in college (I completely sucked at it, got involved too late in life) and I used to watch the Navy Lacrosse team rather frequently when I was there.

You call lacrosse a sissy sport? You haven't a clue.

DR
 
I am so sick of people blaming others for their own lack. Jesus Christ, every individual on this planet is constantly being affected by all sorts of external input. It behooves every person to sort the crap from the kernel.

IMHO when you slip on someone's walkway, on a toy or ice patch that was clearly visible, and you sue, that is blaming someone else for your lack of attention.

If you buy a jug of bleach, and accidental pour it into your coffee water, and die from drinking it, that's your fault.

In MOST cases of product liability that I know of, I side with the manufacture/distributer. This is not a case of someone doing something stupid on their own. It was something (apparently stupid, but it surprises me that the consequences were fatal!) promoted on the air by a radio station! No one hearing that contest advertised appeared to feel there was anything dangerous about it! It's not like she was answering an obscure add in the back of some mostly unread tabloid. It was broadcast on the local airwaves for everyone to hear and evaluate. It would be, again, IMHO normal to expect that such a thing would be safe.

I don't know how prevalent water intoxication is. Based solely on the fact that I have never heard of it, I'm assuming it doesn't happen every day. My question is did the radio station do any checks about the safety of the contestants for the contest they were going to run? If they did, and whomever would be the appropriate reference for such things, gave the OK, then I would consider what happened to the lady a fluke. A sad fluke, but a fluke. If the station did not check to determine if there was the possibility of harm to the contestants, then I think there very well could be a justified liability suit in the wings.

Obviously there are not that many facts available now. Time will tell.
 
No, I tried my hand at it freshman year in college (I completely sucked at it, got involved too late in life) and I used to watch the Navy Lacrosse team rather frequently when I was there.

You call lacrosse a sissy sport? You haven't a clue.

DR

Dude, you're arguing in circles with yourself. Nobody said anything about *removes hat, places across heart reverently* lacrosse *spoken with catch in voice, moist doe-eyes, trembling lip and reverence on my worshipful visage*.

Dang! Happy now?
 
IMHO when you slip on someone's walkway, on a toy or ice patch that was clearly visible, and you sue, that is blaming someone else for your lack of attention.
Indeed it is and it should be generally discouraged to blame anyone but yourself.
If you buy a jug of bleach, and accidental pour it into your coffee water, and die from drinking it, that's your fault.

In MOST cases of product liability that I know of, I side with the manufacture/distributer. This is not a case of someone doing something stupid on their own. It was something (apparently stupid, but it surprises me that the consequences were fatal!) promoted on the air by a radio station! No one hearing that contest advertised appeared to feel there was anything dangerous about it! It's not like she was answering an obscure add in the back of some mostly unread tabloid. It was broadcast on the local airwaves for everyone to hear and evaluate. It would be, again, IMHO normal to expect that such a thing would be safe.
It would, IMHO, like everything in life, be up to the individual to assess the pros and cons of following some advice.
I don't know how prevalent water intoxication is. Based solely on the fact that I have never heard of it, I'm assuming it doesn't happen every day. My question is did the radio station do any checks about the safety of the contestants for the contest they were going to run? If they did, and whomever would be the appropriate reference for such things, gave the OK, then I would consider what happened to the lady a fluke. A sad fluke, but a fluke. If the station did not check to determine if there was the possibility of harm to the contestants, then I think there very well could be a justified liability suit in the wings.
In a perfect world they would have no liability whatsoever. Suppose they had a contest where the first person to kill himself by jumping off a particular bridge, got a prize. So what?
Obviously there are not that many facts available now. Time will tell.
Time will tell what?
 
Having already had children, she's not actually removed herself from the gene pool.

True. But along the lines of the Nature vs. Nurture debate about fitness of offspring, at least now the kids have a chance to be raised by somebody whose IQ exceeds that of your average eggplant.

Nurture now gets its chance to strut its stuff.
 
SNIP

In a perfect world they would have no liability whatsoever. Suppose they had a contest where the first person to kill himself by jumping off a particular bridge, got a prize. So what?

Well, at least the possible consequences would be more obvious :)

This contest was not billed as a contest to see who could kill themselves by drinking too much water though. If that was the objective, it should have been stated in the rules ;)

Time will tell what?

Hopefully, time will tell whether or not the station did any checks on the potential for injury from this contest.

I also consider there is a possibility that this woman had some (perhaps undiagnosed) medical condition that made her death more likely. I suspect we will hear, if such is the case, as time goes on.
 
Indeed it would.

I'm pretty sure education is vital.

Nahhhhhh!

Stupid people, having inherently poor reasoning and memory, remain stupid until they die. Then they're stupid corpses. Ignorant people, due to a paucity of facts, figures and examples in their gray matter, manage to off themselves or their potential through sheer lack of knowledge.

Education helps ignorance. Education CAN'T help stupidity. Overriding your basic survival instincts to drink a bazillion gallons of water is stupid. It gets you on "Jackass, the movie" maybe, but you'd still be stupid. Alive or dead.
 
It's very sad, and frankly, most people probably don't know you can die from drinking too much water.

I suspected that when I read about this in local paper. A rather large number of people do not know things of that nature - which is one of the reasons wooism survives - but is also just plain dangerous. On the other... nobody knows everything - why I keep telling my students to learn whatever they have the opportunity to.
 
Nahhhhhh!

Stupid people, having inherently poor reasoning and memory, remain stupid until they die. Then they're stupid corpses. Ignorant people, due to a paucity of facts, figures and examples in their gray matter, manage to off themselves or their potential through sheer lack of knowledge.

Education helps ignorance. Education CAN'T help stupidity. Overriding your basic survival instincts to drink a bazillion gallons of water is stupid. It gets you on "Jackass, the movie" maybe, but you'd still be stupid. Alive or dead.
There is much in what you say, but nevertheless education will raise the average. Education will help you not win the Darwin Award.
 
There is much in what you say, but nevertheless education will raise the average. Education will help you not win the Darwin Award.

Hmmm. You might have something there. I haven't won it yet. Yet. Maybe the education thing helped. We'll see.

;)
 
I put my application in last week. Still waiting on the results :crazy:

The competition is stiff (ha, ha... stiff! get it? Stiff! Oh, boy, I just kill myself! hey there's another one!!!!) and the potter's field is crowded with candidates (get it? potter's field! hoo boy, that's a good 'un!)! Don't hold your breath waiting (ohhhhh, lordy the inner laughter HURTS)!

ROFLMAO!
 
Water intoxication is not widely thought of as a potential problem. I'd call this an accidental death.

What was not accidental is that the radio station, and other people, thought it entertaining and funny to require people to "hold their water". That's torture for monetary gain. Sad, very sad, and somewhat despicable. Also sad is that people were willing to subject themselves to humiliation and pain for a few lousy bucks...although many parents would do anything for their kids, as the unfortunate victim tried to do. I feel bad for her children.

Had the radio station used something like Gatorade instead of water, she might not have died. The problem is not so much "intoxication" as it is sodium depletion.

http://www.alpharubicon.com/med/watertox.html
 
Last edited:
Well, at least the possible consequences would be more obvious :)

This contest was not billed as a contest to see who could kill themselves by drinking too much water though. If that was the objective, it should have been stated in the rules ;)
Are you a lawyer? Or do you just feel that commen sense is overrated?
Hopefully, time will tell whether or not the station did any checks on the potential for injury from this contest.
Why should they?
I also consider there is a possibility that this woman had some (perhaps undiagnosed) medical condition that made her death more likely. I suspect we will hear, if such is the case, as time goes on.
Perhaps we will. So what?
 
I really feel for the poor woman's kids. It's bad enough going through life without your mother, but to know she died trying to win you a games console must be awful. :(

I agree with the people who are defending the victim here. The fact that you can die through drinking too much water is not common knowledge, and is certainly not common sense. After all, the competition organisers seemed not to know...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom