Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

Within reason. There is no evidence to show they didn't.

Oh come on! Next you're going to be saying that Tom Sawyer should give back the loot he was paid by the boys he convinced to paint the fence for him. Like, full disclosure of how stupid you are is now mandatory, ethical, AND gets you hot dates to boot?

Sheesh.
 
Yes, DD, you are very busy trying to portray the poor victim of this radio prank as very stupid because people should never blame "others for their own lack" and nobody can take advantage of you if you don't want them to, and yet you complain when somebody with Marx and Brecht in his sig line doesn't tell you explicitly that he's a commie!
The irony!
(One shouldn't poke fun at people's spelling, but you didn't notice that one either!)
I fail to see the irony. Oh wait....yes...I think I see it now. There is indeed great irony in someone who wants no laws at all implying that he want's some protection for stupid people.

Sorry, it took me a while to understand your blather.
 
Having been at a number of Mensa meetings some years back (I had the test results putting me in the category - I'm a great test taker), I ultimately and with no quibble decided I really wasn't interested. One of the points I noted (though the exact names would be different) is I had every reason to suspect that a good number of the members would indeed have gotten advice that way.

Yeah, well, it's not fair to paint all MENSA chapters with the tarbrush of your experience with the one at Harvard. I mean, you're not exactly playing varsity there. All those Professor Longhair types? Eeessshhhhh. As Twain said, we'd be better off having a Congress made up of names randomly chosen from the Boston phonebook than of the professors at Harvard. LOL. Dang I love gigging 'em!

And I'm a great test taker too. I copied off the smart oriental kid next to me. That's how I got in. Shoot. Weren't nuthin' to it!
 
And I'm a great test taker too. I copied off the smart oriental kid next to me. That's how I got in. Shoot. Weren't nuthin' to it!
I am having fun deciphering your handle.

It seems you went to Harvard, and now you work for the MTA. Let me tell you a story about a man named Charlie . . . ;)

DR
 
I am having fun deciphering your handle.

It seems you went to Harvard, and now you work for the MTA. Let me tell you a story about a man named Charlie . . . ;)

DR

Well, there you are. You found me out. ;)

I majored in Middle Latin at Fair Harvard. ;) And now I have an exciting and responsible position in the fast-paced but socially conscious field of global warming alleviation through mass transit solutions for interlinking and networking people in their professional and personal spheres. In other words, in non-Harvard speak, I drive a big ol' god*mned bus for the Mass Transit Authority, third shift. ;)

And I belong to the union. So, one smart word out of you and it's to the moon, Alice, to the moon! See? ;)
 
Farmall MTA was a tractor produced in the 1950's It was a Super M with a torque amplifier transmission.

Be careful, there are some 1486's running around here.
Not me, I'm more of an AC WD-45. :p
 
Darwin??! Or some @$$holes at a radio station who took advantage of a woman who happened to want to please her children, but did not have quite enough money to do so!

if she knowingly risked her life to buy her children a stupid video game, she was stupid, no matter how poor she was or how much she wanted to please them.

However, it's almost certainly a case of ignorance, not of stupidity: neither her nor her childrn realized she was taking any great risk with what she was doing. For that matter, I doubt the people who originated the challange in the radio station did.
 
No, it wasn't.

Yes, it was, unless you think there's such a thing as consensual torture. There isn't, and the idea that this was "torture for monetary gain" is absurd and dilutes (no pun intended) the meaning of the word "torture."

That said, the radio organizers most certainly owed a duty of care to the decedent. Her next-of-kin has a very good wrongful death case, although the station probably required participants to sign a liability waiver.

On that note, I read in some article on this event that the organizers encouraged the participants to stop if they felt sick, or something to that effect. That suggests to me that the organizers knew that it was possible to die of water intoxication, but held this event anyway. Regardless of legal liability, that suggests to me a high degree of moral culpability for this woman's death.

Or maybe that was in high school chemistry. I forget. I was kind of dozing through both experiences so I may be crossing the two up.

Anyways, you learn that pretty early in life. Dose makes the poison.
I would think that's quite a large difference between learning that something is dangerous in high school chemistry, and knowing it instinctively from birth. It's not particularly surprising that this woman may not have known that water intoxication can be dangerous, and it's simply ridiculous to suggest that the danger is as obvious as drowning.
 
Last edited:
Farmall MTA was a tractor produced in the 1950's It was a Super M with a torque amplifier transmission.

Be careful, there are some 1486's running around here.
Not me, I'm more of an AC WD-45. :p

Hey not bad, esperdome! More specifically, made just one year, in '54. Then the same tractor was given a number instead of a name (sounds like a Johnny Cash prison lament, eh?) and soldiered on gamely until IH wrecked their name with the POS 560 in '58... a hot to trot tractor with the old SuperM rear end. But enough about my girlfriend's butt.

And how'd you know that 1486 is both the PIN and Password to my multimillion dollar Swiss bank account in Banque De Mouffettes de Geneve? Under my nomme de guerre of Wilhelm Klink?

Man. You do spiritual healings, too?

Yo! The WD-45 is wack in front of the AC little round baler. I loved the orange roofed-ones with the pitman arm. So much fun to change them out and have them break again right away. More profanity generating than the later white-roofed ones, yes?

But back to water poisoning. Does Dimbulb's life insurance pay double indemnity on that? I'd love to be a fly on the wall during that meeting at Aetna!
 
Water toxication is unusual and not widely known, but there were a number of cases in the 90s when youngsters drunk large quantities after taking E.

The legal situation in the UK would be quite clear; the radio station had a duty of care to take reasonable steps to ensure the safety of those participating in the event. Given that water toxicity is a known health risk, it should have included appropriate restrictions.

For those who think the victim was solely responsible, although primarily concerned with product quality you shoulod acquaint yourself with Donoghue Vs Stevenson, one of the most legal liability cases in legal history.
 
I'm flashing back to this board's reaction to Irwin's death from perusing this thread. It's reminiscient of religious fundamentalism, the fanatically emotionless negativity that passes for skepticism occasionally.
 
Most Danes would consider this risk even though it may just be a myth. Children are still warned against this by concerned parents - how is that for Darwin?:
Tycho died on October 24, 1601, eleven days after straining his bladder during a banquet(drinking contest). It had been said that to leave the banquet before it concluded would be the height of bad manners, and so he remained. His bladder, stretched to its limit, exploded; however, this is regarded as impossible by most physicians.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tycho_Brahe
 
I don't believe this woman was an idiot, but even if she was I don't think that she or her children would deserve any less sympathy for what has happened to them. I find the whole idea of the Darwin awards to be pretty distasteful. In my opinion it's one thing to joke about death and quite another to find the fact that someone has died to be uproariously funny.
 
I think if you participate in a stunt like this, you are taking on the responsibility that it's safe.

Well then lets just do away with all commercial responsibility. You eat in a restaurant, the your taking on the responsibility that you won't get food poisoning. Or you buy a car, and you take on the responsibility that the breaks won't fail the first time you do 70mph. Welcome to libertopia.
 
Water intoxication is not a myth and it is not a simple process such as drowning. When you drink a large amount of water (excess of 2 liters) quickly the sodium density in your blood drops, causing potentially fatal changes in your brain chemistry. Ever wondered why sports drinks contain sodium?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom