Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

It could have been worse. Nintendo could have named their system the Poo instead of the Wii.
 
I think calling the woman stupid is a bit of an assumption.

Was what she did the most brilliant thing? Of course not. But, for what it's worth, I have never heard of water intoxication, in all of my 52 years. And most people, I believe, would assume that a contest held by a local station (radio or TV) would be safe. Hell, I would consider drinking water to be safer than say, seeing how many hot dogs you can eat in a given period of time!

I think the question now is what liability does the station have? Did they do any checking on the possible downsides to their contest? I suspect we'll find out when the lawsuits start.

As for the woman, she was trying to do something for her kids. It was drinking water! Hell, she carried them for 9 months, and then gave them birth! Neither of which I'm sure I would be willing to do! Drinking water should have been as easy as...well drinking water!

I think it's a sad story, and I regret the loss of her life, and the loss to her family and friends.


I couldn't agree more.
 
My understanding of US cases indicates that the wavier would have no effect on a liability suit in a case like this. I'm sure if (when) a suit is brought, the wavier will be shown as evidence for the defense. I'm also pretty sure it will be pretty much ignored.

The fact that the station told the contestants "They told us if you don't feel like you can do this, don't put your health in risk." really says nothing to me. It COULD mean that they were aware of the risk of water intoxication, but I get the impression, right or wrong, that it was just a general warning. From what I understand the lady didn't show signs of a problem until after the contest.

IMHO the station should have consulted with at least an MD on the potential risk involved. They should have had a medically trained person in attendance, at least a nurse, if not an MD. The contestants should have been told about water intoxication. They should have used a sports drink, or something that would have helped balance the water with sodium to prevent or at least lesson the chance of something like this happening. And before leaving, the contestants should have been told of the warning signs of water intoxication, and given instructions on what to do if the signs were noticed. Perhaps some salt tablets would have been a good idea also, though I think those have lost favor due to high blood pressure issues.

From the article and video in post #74, by Dann, it appears likely that multiple contestants got sick from the excessive water intake. At least the guy that was interviewed, and I'd bet dollars to donuts that others were affected also.

This is, IMHO a sad situation from several points of view. First, there is a woman dead, and all the issues there.

Second, there is a group of people at a radio station that tried to have what I'm sure they thought would be a fun contest. I'm confidant that there was no ill intent. None the less, their contest resulted in the death of a person. Now the folks there have to live with that. I know I would feel like crap in a case like that.

The contest the station had, no doubt with the hope that it would boost their audience, will likely decrease their audience, at least in the short term. Pure speculation on my part of course.

The station will most likely, and rightfully in my opinion, be sued for wrongful death, or whatever applies in a case like this (negligent homicide?).

The fixes for this (consulting a doctor before, having one on hand during, Gatorade or some sports drink) wouldn't have cost them too much I wouldn't think. Maybe a couple more hundred dollars. No more than $500 - $1000 I would think. Would have been a lot cheaper in the long run. And would probably have saved this woman's life.

In my opinion, the station was the more ignorant of those involved. I think they had a responsibility to insure the contest was safe for the contestants, and it appears they failed to even check what that entailed.

Of course, if it comes out that the wavier actually warned of a water intoxication possibility, or if there were steps taken, but not mentioned in the articles, then my opinion might change. But I suspect if there's any major changes to this story, it will be from the full autopsy report, when it's completed. Those results of course, could change things drastically, but I doubt it.


I also agree with all that, except the part about a decrease in audience share. I'd bet that more people will tune in now, if only to hear the station's spin on why it did nothing wrong. There's no such thing as bad publicity, they say...
 
So you are pro con artist I see.

Okay, I'm pro-con artist AND I'm also pro-"people get to shoot the con artist who tries to rip them off". Cool that how when you start scrubbing all the Nanny State laws things have a way of fixing themselves, eh?

A tad more seriously, all you crybaby bedwetting sucker-for-a-sob-story sensitive types who are just all broken up over this vacuum-skulled dame's self-inflicted death... you've got yourselves a little problem.

On the one hand, some of you are traumatized and heartbroken because water poisoning is NOT intuitively understood or generally known therefore she's not responsible for her actions. On the other hand, others of you are boo-hooing into your lace hankies because the big bad mean old radio station should have known what is commonly known to everybody, that water dilution of the body has numerous deleterious and potentially fatal effects. Therefore, wacky morning DJ Mike "Madman" Antony and the Q-Morning Zoo Crew is grossly negligent and responsible.

The funny part is that you two types are agreeing with each other. She's a put-upon Joan-of-Arc for our times. At the very least you two types need to get together and decide which way you're gonna go... either it IS or ISN'T known. But you CAN'T have it both ways at once. See? Mutually-exclusive posits may not be simultaneously held without incurring cognitive dissonance which must be eventually resolved. So start resolving, already!

The thread of commonality between you two types of sobsisters is not logic or rationality. Rather, it's the reflexive desire to absolve the "little people" of responsibility for conducting their lives in a fit and healthy way. With you people, it's always the "big guy" who's to blame no matter whatever dumb d*mn thing the "little people" get into.

Sorry, you whine-miners. Reflexive posturing based on "caring," always mugging smugly for the crowd, is NOT critical thinking. It's just sanctimony dressed up as thoughtfulness in a cheap attempt to shame others into not closely evaluating your inconsistent and poorly based religious-y beliefs.

In short, you're saps. Just don't expect the rest of us to fall for it too.:D
 
Those of you oh so smug about your water knowledge, calling this lady stupid, probably have no idea of more than a small fraction of the things that can kill you when you get in the water of an ocean say. Dont be so smug

To say its obvious because its like drowning is assinine BTW. It is in NO WAY like drowning
 
Those of you oh so smug about your water knowledge, calling this lady stupid, probably have no idea of more than a small fraction of the things that can kill you when you get in the water of an ocean say. Dont be so smug

To say its obvious because its like drowning is assinine BTW. It is in NO WAY like drowning

Sure it is. Here's one way. You got too much water inside you. :D
 
No one says the people involved in organising the competition should've just known. Rather, it was their duty to have checked.
 
On the one hand, some of you are traumatized and heartbroken because water poisoning is NOT intuitively understood or generally known therefore she's not responsible for her actions. On the other hand, others of you are boo-hooing into your lace hankies because the big bad mean old radio station should have known what is commonly known to everybody, that water dilution of the body has numerous deleterious and potentially fatal effects. Therefore, wacky morning DJ Mike "Madman" Antony and the Q-Morning Zoo Crew is grossly negligent and responsible.

So common wisdom is now the standard for professional negligence? You think that if it makes sense to the average person it should be legal for professionals to do things that way?

You are removing all kinds of liability that your car or house or anything is built right, becuase after all if it makes sense to the layperson why should a professional say different. You neatly get rid of houseing codes and all safety codes.
The funny part is that you two types are agreeing with each other. She's a put-upon Joan-of-Arc for our times. At the very least you two types need to get together and decide which way you're gonna go... either it IS or ISN'T known. But you CAN'T have it both ways at once. See? Mutually-exclusive posits may not be simultaneously held without incurring cognitive dissonance which must be eventually resolved. So start resolving, already!

Ah so just because professionals understand something that means that everyone understands it? Why do doctors go to med school for so long, the word of someone on the street is just as informed as they are.

The fundamental thing you are missing here is this, you might be able to build a treehouse for your kids how ever you want, but if you start building them for others, you are now the one responcible to see that they are built properly not the parents who are paying you. As you want it, it is the parents job to make sure that what you build is safe and structuraly sound.
The thread of commonality between you two types of sobsisters is not logic or rationality. Rather, it's the reflexive desire to absolve the "little people" of responsibility for conducting their lives in a fit and healthy way. With you people, it's always the "big guy" who's to blame no matter whatever dumb d*mn thing the "little people" get into.

And you see no responcibility for the actions of others. Manson should be let out of prison after all he never killed anyone himself.
 
Sure it is. Here's one way. You got too much water inside you. :D

Yea, just like people should know cars are dangerous because you can get run over by them and killed, and it is so much like running them in an enclosed space, they are just obviously dangerous in exactly the same way.
 
No one says the people involved in organising the competition should've just known. Rather, it was their duty to have checked.

Not bad. Now here's another one. Why isn't it HER duty to have checked? I mean, it IS her life right? Surely it wouldn't be too much trouble for her to wikipedia "if I drink Lake Huron down at the Q in an attempt to win a fad toy will I, like, totally die or what?"

I did. And the wikipedia result is, "H*ll yes! What... are you stupid?"
 
I should warn you that this pile of straw (badly shaped to resemble something vaguely human) constitutes a fire hazard.

Okay, I'm pro-con artist AND I'm also pro-"people get to shoot the con artist who tries to rip them off". Cool that how when you start scrubbing all the Nanny State laws things have a way of fixing themselves, eh?
No, not only do you defend con artists, you also advocate extra-judicial killings. It's not the "nanny sate" you want rid of, its the State altogether.

A tad more seriously, all you crybaby bedwetting sucker-for-a-sob-story sensitive types who are just all broken up over this vacuum-skulled dame's self-inflicted death... you've got yourselves a little problem.

On the one hand, some of you are traumatized and heartbroken because water poisoning is NOT intuitively understood or generally known therefore she's not responsible for her actions. On the other hand, others of you are boo-hooing into your lace hankies because the big bad mean old radio station should have known what is commonly known to everybody, that water dilution of the body has numerous deleterious and potentially fatal effects. Therefore, wacky morning DJ Mike "Madman" Antony and the Q-Morning Zoo Crew is grossly negligent and responsible.
Commercial undertakings organising an event have responsibilities, both moral and legal, to ensure that the activities which they are organising are reasonably safe, to ensure that they know the risks they are asking people to undertake and to properly inform participants of those risks. Given that society has placed a moral and legal duty on such undertakings, it is a reasonable assumption for this woman to make that the radio station had done so.

The funny part is that you two types are agreeing with each other. She's a put-upon Joan-of-Arc for our times. At the very least you two types need to get together and decide which way you're gonna go... either it IS or ISN'T known. But you CAN'T have it both ways at once. See? Mutually-exclusive posits may not be simultaneously held without incurring cognitive dissonance which must be eventually resolved. So start resolving, already!
it doesn’t matter what is and is not known to the general public, its IS known to health professionals. this radio station had a duty to employ health professionals to advise them of the safety of the commercial activities which they where engaged in.
The radio station may not have known, but legally, and ethically, it SHPOLD have known.


The thread of commonality between you two types of sobsisters is not logic or rationality. Rather, it's the reflexive desire to absolve the "little people" of responsibility for conducting their lives in a fit and healthy way. With you people, it's always the "big guy" who's to blame no matter whatever dumb d*mn thing the "little people" get into.

Sorry, you whine-miners. Reflexive posturing based on "caring," always mugging smugly for the crowd, is NOT critical thinking. It's just sanctimony dressed up as thoughtfulness in a cheap attempt to shame others into not closely evaluating your inconsistent and poorly based religious-y beliefs.

In short, you're saps. Just don't expect the rest of us to fall for it too.:D

You seem very at home with insults, and decrying other peoples rationality, but your "arguments" seem to be based on nothing but your own political ideology, and a mixture of straw men, ad hom attacks and well poisoning.

When I go to a restaurant and am served a meal, it is NOT my duty to ensure that I don't get food poisoning, it is the restaurants. Ii is the same in this case, it was not this woman's duty to determine if the water she was given to drink would prove fatal, it was the radio stations, for very good reasons both moral and economic.
 
Not bad. Now here's another one. Why isn't it HER duty to have checked? I mean, it IS her life right? Surely it wouldn't be too much trouble for her to wikipedia "if I drink Lake Huron down at the Q in an attempt to win a fad toy will I, like, totally die or what?"

I did. And the wikipedia result is, "H*ll yes! What... are you stupid?"
Well, for one thing the radio station is creating the contest. Therefore, they are responsible for the situation it creates. They could have run the contest at a level that would not cause death. They chose not to. There should be consequences for that.

Also, if you are telling the truth about your academic background, I find it humourous that someone who spent upwards of $40,000 a year to study Middle Latin has the gall to call anyone else stupid.
 
As we've already established, it wouldn't even occur to the average person that drinking too much water can be bad for you, or even fatal. It is unreasonable to expect the contestants to anticipate this. However, the people who organised the competition are professionals, and establishing the competition was safe is not too much to demand.

I know next to nothing about wiring a house. I have to trust my electrician. It's not unreasonable to expect my electrician to do a safe job.
 
Not bad. Now here's another one. Why isn't it HER duty to have checked? I mean, it IS her life right? Surely it wouldn't be too much trouble for her to wikipedia "if I drink Lake Huron down at the Q in an attempt to win a fad toy will I, like, totally die or what?"
Sure, she could have checked. She could also have said, "I'm not going to subject myself to humiliation." She made a fatal mistake. So did the contest organizers.
I did. And the wikipedia result is, "H*ll yes! What... are you stupid?"
Not stupid, just ignorant. People just do not usually expect that drinking too much water can be fatal. They expect a full bladder and maybe a painfully distended stomach.
 
Last edited:
So common wisdom is now the standard for professional negligence? You think that if it makes sense to the average person it should be legal for professionals to do things that way?

You are removing all kinds of liability that your car or house or anything is built right, becuase after all if it makes sense to the layperson why should a professional say different. You neatly get rid of houseing codes and all safety codes.


Ah so just because professionals understand something that means that everyone understands it? Why do doctors go to med school for so long, the word of someone on the street is just as informed as they are.

The fundamental thing you are missing here is this, you might be able to build a treehouse for your kids how ever you want, but if you start building them for others, you are now the one responcible to see that they are built properly not the parents who are paying you. As you want it, it is the parents job to make sure that what you build is safe and structuraly sound.


And you see no responcibility for the actions of others. Manson should be let out of prison after all he never killed anyone himself.

So, if I get your drift, Dimbulb is absolved because she doesn't have a medical degree. But the Q-Morning Zoo Crew, who ALSO doesn't have a medical degree IS responsible? Shucks. I must have missed the part where they went to Dimbulb's house, kidnapped her, dragged her to the radio station, forced her to drink the Ogallala Aquifer with a gun to her head, then laughed callously as she didn't pee her panties. LOL. Better check that again.
 
There is a difference between stupidity and ignorance. She was ignorant. We don't have enough information to know whether she was stupid as well.

Until I read this thread, I was ignorant about this as well. I've never heard of water intoxication, never considered there was such a thing. And I consider myself a fairly intelligent person. The radio station should have done their homework before offering the contest. Granted, the woman *could* have done her homework too, but how many (even intelligent) people are likely to assume that it is up to them to make sure the contest is a safe one?
 
So, if I get your drift, Dimbulb is absolved because she doesn't have a medical degree. But the Q-Morning Zoo Crew, who ALSO doesn't have a medical degree IS responsible?

Yes, Dimbulb - responsible for checking with someone who has a medical degree. It might not be obvious that drinking to much water can be fatal, but it's common sense to consult with experts before launching a competition which involves disturbing the body's natural routines.

Quite apart from water intoxification, did the radio station consider what effect this exercise might have on a diabetic? On someone with a heart condition? On someone with kidney problems? You can excuse someone in good health entering the competition without knowing something that isn't widely known, but cam you really absolve the organisers for not taking medical advice about issues which go way beyond what might happen to Joe Ordinary?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom