Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

Water intoxication is not widely thought of as a potential problem. I'd call this an accidental death.

What was not accidental is that the radio station, and other people, thought it entertaining and funny to require people to "hold their water". That's torture for monetary gain. Sad, very sad, and somewhat despicable. Also sad is that people were willing to subject themselves to humiliation and pain for a few lousy bucks...although many parents would do anything for their kids, as the unfortunate victim tried to do. I feel bad for her children.

Not entirely disrespecting your feelings here, man, but Dang! Lighten up, already. The woman died of self-inflicted piss poisoning. I mean, how many times does a comedy opportunity like this come along? The Bob and Tom's are going to be having a field day with it! I can hardly wait!
 
Water intoxication is not widely thought of as a potential problem. I'd call this an accidental death.

What was not accidental is that the radio station, and other people, thought it entertaining and funny to require people to "hold their water". That's torture for monetary gain.
No, that's weeding out anyone impecile enough to follow the advice of a radio DJ.
Sad, very sad, and somewhat despicable. Also sad is that people were willing to subject themselves to humiliation and pain for a few lousy bucks...although many parents would do anything for their kids, as the unfortunate victim tried to do. I feel bad for her children.
I feel bad for her kids too. Ce la vie.
Had the radio station used something like Gatorade instead of water, she might not have died. The problem is not so much "intoxication" as it is sodium depletion.

http://www.alpharubicon.com/med/watertox.html
They could have used air. It would have made no difference.
 
Are you a lawyer? Or do you just feel that commen sense is overrated?

Why should they?

Perhaps we will. So what?

I think I've stated my views fairly clearly above. Rather than get into a back and forth, saying the same things, I'll rest on my above post :)

But, no I'm no lawyer, and generally don't care for them (unless I need them to sort through some legal mess that lawyers got implemented in the first place ;-)
 
No kidding. I'm not aware of any MENSA members who take their investment advice, family planning advice, romance advice, career advice, or any other kind of life advice from wacky morning DJ "Madman" Mike Antony or anybody else from the Q Morning Zoo Crew (ref Onion.com/content/node/29372). To do so would indeed be Darwin Award-bait idiocy.

.


Having been at a number of Mensa meetings some years back (I had the test results putting me in the category - I'm a great test taker), I ultimately and with no quibble decided I really wasn't interested. One of the points I noted (though the exact names would be different) is I had every reason to suspect that a good number of the members would indeed have gotten advice that way.

Or - knowledge and wisdom are related in certain ways but are not the same thing. A lack of either may kill you and having the lack of either you may still pass through life largely unscathed.

This woman lacked knowledge and I suspect the station staff did also, but as pro-Darwin awards as I am, I can't find the ability/evidence here to show that she should get one.
 
I thought that was called "drowning?" One of mankind's basic avoidance instincts? As in, "stay away from the water! You hear me young man? Don't you dare drown or sure as the Pope says Mass on roller skates I'll cut a switch and tan your little 8 yr. old hide!"

And don't, like, totally bore me with the distinction between inhaling water thereby preventing blood oxygenation vs. imbibition resulting in solute dilution of cellular contents and membrane rupture. Yawn.

It's hardly an academic distinction. People don't think water is dangerous, they think that not being able to breathe is dangerous. If the water is in your stomach, then obviously your ability to breath will not be hampered, so where's the danger? I can think of absolutely no reason why it should be considered obvious that consuming massive amounts of water in a short amount of time should be bad for you. The idea that too much water is dangerous depends on fully understanding some slightly non-intuitive biological facts.
 
Last edited:
I think I've stated my views fairly clearly above. Rather than get into a back and forth, saying the same things, I'll rest on my above post :)

But, no I'm no lawyer, and generally don't care for them (unless I need them to sort through some legal mess that lawyers got implemented in the first place ;-)
Fair enough!
 
It's hardly an academic distinction. People don't think water is dangerous, they think that not being able to breathe is dangerous. If the water is in your stomach, then obviously your ability to breath will not be hampered, so where's the danger? I can think of absolutely no reason why it should be considered obvious that consuming massive amounts of water in a short amount of time should be bad for you. The idea that too much water is dangerous depends on fully understanding some slightly non-intuitive biological facts.

Well, I don't know about your birth, but first they tonged me out of the birth canal. Then they spanked my bottom which I richly deserved for making my mother sick in the mornings for 9 whole months. Then they put some kind of drops that stung a bit in my eyes. Then they gave the bill to my Dad, who still talks about how much I set him back. THEN...

THEN they told me, and I accurately quote from my distinct recollection, "Dose makes the poison, boy! Dose makes the poison! Don't forget now!"

Or maybe that was in high school chemistry. I forget. I was kind of dozing through both experiences so I may be crossing the two up.

Anyways, you learn that pretty early in life. Dose makes the poison.

So despite all the sobsistering going on around here, I'm still not all broken up over this dimbulb's failure to Grok how she should avoid drinking Lake Superior to win some fad gameboy gadget.
 
It's hardly an academic distinction. People don't think water is dangerous, they think that not being able to breathe is dangerous. If the water is in your stomach, then obviously your ability to breath will not be hampered, so where's the danger? I can think of absolutely no reason why it should be considered obvious that consuming massive amounts of water in a short amount of time should be bad for you. The idea that too much water is dangerous depends on fully understanding some slightly non-intuitive biological facts.
Yes, perhaps it does require a minimum of education to realize this.
 
I am so sick of people blaming others for their own lack. Jesus Christ, every individual on this planet is constantly being affected by all sorts of external input. It behooves every person to sort the crap from the kernel.
Nobody can take advantage of you without your permission.
Exactly!
Wish you had told the truth to me.
The poor woman's children probably wish that the radio people had told her the truth about water poisoning. Apparently they were too dumb to check it out, though, but Darwin didn't punish them anyway.
 
The poor woman's children probably wish that the radio people had told her the truth about water poisoning. Apparently they were too dumb to check it out, though, but Darwin didn't punish them anyway.
Is there some point to your babbling?
 
Yes, DD, you are very busy trying to portray the poor victim of this radio prank as very stupid because people should never blame "others for their own lack" and nobody can take advantage of you if you don't want them to, and yet you complain when somebody with Marx and Brecht in his sig line doesn't tell you explicitly that he's a commie!
The irony!
(One shouldn't poke fun at people's spelling, but you didn't notice that one either!)
 
The fact that you can die through drinking too much water is not common knowledge, and is certainly not common sense. After all, the competition organisers seemed not to know...

That is an important point. Everyone seems to want to absolve the "victim" from all blame because it is not common knowledge, but don't want to give the organizers the same benefit.
 
That is an important point. Everyone seems to want to absolve the "victim" from all blame because it is not common knowledge, but don't want to give the organizers the same benefit.
It's better to blame the one who dies than the organizer of the prank, right? Remember your own opening post?!
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom