Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

I freely admit to being a total ignoramus here...I have come in from the desert and drank LOT of water at a sitting...you already have a hedache and stomach ache, so it would be hard to know...I didnt realize just how little amount of water is deadly
 
So, if I get your drift, Dimbulb is absolved because she doesn't have a medical degree. But the Q-Morning Zoo Crew, who ALSO doesn't have a medical degree IS responsible? Shucks. I must have missed the part where they went to Dimbulb's house, kidnapped her, dragged her to the radio station, forced her to drink the Ogallala Aquifer with a gun to her head, then laughed callously as she didn't pee her panties. LOL. Better check that again.

Ah you see here this is where you are showing yet again that you do not understand anything. If you are promoting and organizing an activity then you have a different legal and moral responsibility than if you are just practicing an activity.

If she had decided that she needed to drink all this water for to remove toxins from her system, then she would be entirely responsible. But it is like any product or activity, you make the assumption that the promoters of it have made adequate tests of its safety.

If you go an a roller coaster and it falls down, you are not responsible it is the engineers or maintenance crews who failed in their professional responsibilities. Just like the contest organizers had professional responsibilities to ensure that the contest was safe.
 
I also hadn't heard of water intoxication, but surely anyone with an ounce of common sense would realize that consuming ANYTHING in too large quantities, even more so without excreting it, is bad and potentially fatal for anyone?

While I think the radio station are idiots and probably deserve a lawsuit, I just can't feel any sympathy for that wretched woman. She wasn't just ignorant, she was also stupid. I do feel bad for the kids, though.
 
Some of you people crack me up.

It's clueless navel gazers who have created a world in which coffee cups have printed on them, "Caution. Coffee is HOT. Do not spill on yourself or you could suffer burns. Please consult a medical professional before taking possession of this cup of HOT coffee."

What's next? Warnings to Hawaiians that ice cubes are cold? "Don't make a bed out of these ice cubes and go to sleep on them because you could freeze to death"?

:jaw-dropp This ain't pretty, people! Get a grip.
 
Those things are common sense. Water intoxication is not common sense. Your posts lack all sense of proportion (or, indeed, propriety).
 
What's next? Warnings to Hawaiians that ice cubes are cold? "Don't make a bed out of these ice cubes and go to sleep on them because you could freeze to death"?

Interestingly, a large chunk of hawaiians died, the first time they got the cold or the flu, because they got hot from their fever and figured they needed to go lie in the ocean to cool down

The population has never recovered from that
 
Some of you people crack me up.

It's clueless navel gazers who have created a world in which coffee cups have printed on them, "Caution. Coffee is HOT. Do not spill on yourself or you could suffer burns. Please consult a medical professional before taking possession of this cup of HOT coffee."

What's next? Warnings to Hawaiians that ice cubes are cold? "Don't make a bed out of these ice cubes and go to sleep on them because you could freeze to death"?

:jaw-dropp This ain't pretty, people! Get a grip.

Yes, it is just like those MSDS and safety placards. Totaly unnessacary crap that is just trying to protect idiots from them selves. Let them die.
 
Those things are common sense. Water intoxication is not common sense. Your posts lack all sense of proportion (or, indeed, propriety).

I guess it is common sense. If it wasn't, cave babies would have drunk too much water at about, say, age 2 out of their sippy cups and the species would be extinct. Yes?

Ditto putting your feet into the fire to warm them up. And skydiving without parachutes. And cutting off your own oxygen supply. There. We've covered, lessee here, earth, air, fire, and, what, WATER? Is there anything else elemental, I said ELEMENTARY my dear Watson, we haven't covered?

:rolleyes:
 
But the cave babies would stop because they had no incentive to drink so much water they felt physically uncomfortable. It was by providing an incentive that the radio station took responsibility for what happened.
 
But the cave babies would stop because they had no incentive to drink so much water they felt physically uncomfortable. It was by providing an incentive that the radio station took responsibility for what happened.

Yep. People don't drink too much water if they only drink when they are thirsty, it is drinking when you are not thirsty that you get into problems.
 
I freely admit to being a total ignoramus here...I have come in from the desert and drank LOT of water at a sitting...you already have a hedache and stomach ache, so it would be hard to know...I didnt realize just how little amount of water is deadly
It certainly depends on the circumstances how much water is deadly. In a hot desert, drinking 4 or 5 liters a day is about the minimum necessary to keep yourself from dehydrating, at least for the average European who isn't adapted to such conditions. Drinking that much on a cold winter day in Northern Europe is not likely going to kill you, as long as you go to the toilet frequently. And you'll want to go very frequently, if you manage to chug away that much, which is fairly unlikely.

This contest asked people to do two dangerous things at the same time, apperently took no precautions to ensure it could have been done without permanent harm. Even if you think the people participating were "stupid", I'm fairly certain that it is illegal to let stupid people step into a deadly trap.
 
Last edited:
Yes, it is just like those MSDS and safety placards. Totaly unnessacary crap that is just trying to protect idiots from them selves. Let them die.

Water. Invented a long, long time ago. First encountered by humans at age split second after conception the very first time after Pa barely-pre-Human and Ma barely-pre-Human got the initial gleam in their eyes.

Benzene. Isolated in 1825 by Michael Faraday. Not intrinsic to the human experience. Flammable as all h*ll. (CAUTION, CRYBABIES: DO NOT TRY THIS IN YOUR OWN HOMES. ONLY PROFESSIONALS SHOULD TINKER AROUND BLOWING SIHT UP WITH BENZENE! :rolleyes:)

So, no, the two are not equivalent in either common knowledge or characteristics. For example, the last time I tried to set water on fire, it was sort of an all day affair until I got bored and gave up. How's setting water on fire been going for you?

At last, the truth outs. You're calling for MSDS sheets for WATER! :jaw-dropp
 
Water. Invented a long, long time ago. First encountered by humans at age split second after conception the very first time after Pa barely-pre-Human and Ma barely-pre-Human got the initial gleam in their eyes.

Benzene. Isolated in 1825 by Michael Faraday. Not intrinsic to the human experience. Flammable as all h*ll. (CAUTION, CRYBABIES: DO NOT TRY THIS IN YOUR OWN HOMES. ONLY PROFESSIONALS SHOULD TINKER AROUND BLOWING SIHT UP WITH BENZENE! :rolleyes:)

So, no, the two are not equivalent in either common knowledge or characteristics. For example, the last time I tried to set water on fire, it was sort of an all day affair until I got bored and gave up. How's setting water on fire been going for you?

At last, the truth outs. You're calling for MSDS sheets for WATER! :jaw-dropp

THere is one for salt

So when something is not obvious there need to be warnings of the risks? And how obvious is it that drinking to much water will alter your mental status and cause you to die as opposed to possibly rupturing your bladder?
 
http://thelede.blogs.nytimes.com/2007/01/15/too-high-a-price-for-a-wii/

http://www.sacbee.com/101/story/108103.html

or

http://www.sacbee.com/101/v-print/story/108103.html

Jennifer Lea Strange died after drinking well over a half gallon of water Friday during the "Morning Rave" program on The End (KDND, 107.9 FM). About 18 contestants vied for a Nintendo Wii gaming console by drinking as much water as they could without going to the bathroom; Strange took second place.

James Ybarra, a Woodland man who gave up after drinking eight 8-fluid-ounce bottles of water, or half a gallon, said that Strange kept going.

...

"It is sad that a mother had to lose her life to get something for her kids," he said. "None of us knew this could be a risk to our health."

..

Gina Sherrod, who competed with Strange in the contest, said her family listened to the radio show, and told her that a nurse was on air warning that drinking too much water is dangerous. Sherrod said a DJ rebuffed the nurse, saying the contestants signed waivers that addressed only publicity issues and made no mention of health or safety concerns.

Ahem. If that last part is true, then the station was duly informed of the dangers and failed to act appropriately.
 
Last edited:
It's very sad, and frankly, most people probably don't know you can die from drinking too much water.

I had no idea it was remotely possible until some fratboy died during a hazing incident somewhere around here a couple of years ago.
 
I had no idea it was remotely possible until some fratboy died during a hazing incident somewhere around here a couple of years ago.

So what do you people do? Drink 5 gallons of water when you're thirsty? If not, why not?
 
So what do you people do? Drink 5 gallons of water when you're thirsty? If not, why not?

there is a differnce between something being unpleasant, and something being dangerous.
I find listening to Chris DeBurgh unpleasant, but if I where to enter a Chris DeBurgh listening endurance competition, not only would I not expect to be physically harmed by the music I would expect the organizers to make sure that I was not going to be physically harmed.
 
I find listening to Chris DeBurgh unpleasant, but if I where to enter a Chris DeBurgh listening endurance competition, not only would I not expect to be physically harmed by the music I would expect the organizers to make sure that I was not going to be physically harmed.
Wow, you really must be stupid. Not only are you ignoring the glaringly obvious risks to mental health involved in such a challenge, but most assuredly one of your major internal organs would stage some sort of attack in order to remove the whole of your being from harm's way.

As for the organizers, the only possible reason to stage a Chris DeBurgh listening endurance competition is to inflict tortuous, ceaseless, debilitating harm on the participants.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom