I experience, therefore I am

So, we can conclude that there is at least one sort of chemistry in this world wich has an invisible nature.

No, we cannot conclude that.

And it revealed its Invisible nature to us because we are these electrochemicals.

Thus, it is not invisible.

Based on "this solid evidence" (or own experience) we may be a little suspecious about some materials in Nature.

There is more than the eye can see or the detector can measure in this world.

Unsupported claim. There is more than our eyes see and our detectors presently detect, but that does not mean it is not seeable or detectable.

Hans
 
To be clear for the people who do not understand this idea (or won't understand this idea)=

Light has absolute properties.
It means: reference-frame-independent it has always the same value:
Its value is exactly 299,792,458 metres per second in vacuüm, reference-frame-independent.

Light is een Absolute object in this world.

It means: its clock is always zero.
And whenever a clock of an object is always equal to zero, this object cannot have any spatial dimension.
Because space=time and vice versa. Space means: a timescale and vice versa.

Ergo light is not from this world as we understand it.

It has properties independent from space and time-measurements.
It's absolute value, c, is the backbone for the referenceframes for time and space-measurements. (and observers of course)

So, we may have reasons to be suspicious when we discover the values of this object.

I wouldn't believe what light says about it's values, I don't think it's being very transparent there.
 
Objectively speaking, there is no qualitative difference between the two. Of course, from a subjective point of view, there is, but that's the whole thing with subjectivity.

When we look at subjectivity objectively we see that it's all a matter of opinion and since to me my opinion is true then it follows objectively that my woo is true.

:duck:
 
Does light dream? How can you know if light is only light or if it has a life? Could light be heavy, nay, pregnant with dissatisfaction? Could it indeed be heavy?


Of course, it dreams of shadow sheep jumping thru slits.
 
Last edited:
Of course you are right. But that's not what I mean.
Without humans (or animals) or conscious objects in general in this world, this detector, on its own, can never discover such things like conscousness, awareness, experiening, believing, imagination, etc... in the chemistry he is anilizing.

Only when it's a conscious object itself.


This is an epistemological issue.

Have you ever considered the fact that 'consciousness' is only one phenomenon of a whole category of phenomena.
Our sort of matter has awareness. When you are such an object, you discover what 'awareness' is. (that's your only tool)

But how would you exclude the fact that other materials, totally different from brains or computers in this world have something like conscousness or awareness too, but different. They look different and are at the same time something else, but different from awareness.
How would our instruments be able to discover such thing? How would we be able to know what these immaterial things of some sort of non-brainlike materials are?

Not. That's an objective limit about what we can know.

How would you exclude that electromagnetic radiation is 'something else too'? That light is not only what we can measure when we are studying the properties of electromagnetic radiation or fields?

How would you be able to exclude that a wave is not only a wave?

Ok, I give up, how would you do it?
 
So, the people who want to discuss on topic (with the content):

The tools of the materialist are limited to discover everything there is to know about this world.
The materialist is a blind fool when it comes to our own existence. Your awareness or consciousness is nonsense for him. Your 'experiening the world' is gibberish or wordsalad in his language.
How foolish and blind can you be?

Ergo (logic conclusion)

He cannever make a descent model of the whole Nature of the Universe with his poor tools. Never. He will be blind for certain 'things' in this world and his language will stay limited to describe them.

But, you may have some reasonable doubts about his model, when you look at his tools (math and verifiable evidence).
You may have doubts that he is capable a giving us a descend description of the whole Nature of the Universe.

You are wrong.

I can't really put it more succintly. Your entire argument is flawed, from premise to conclusion. It's also nonsenseical.
 
Tsig,

it is logically and practically impossible.

Just like it is impossible to explain in the materialistic language of the philosophical zombie (without consciousness) with superior mathskills and superior measuring devices that we are more than the chemistry he is investigating.

We have not the language to tell him that we are more than the systemic chemical interaction process he is mapping with his superior mathskills.

Our words like 'feelings, experiencing, awareness, consciousness' are nonsense to him.
Our real Nature is wordsalad or gibberish for his tools. We do not need to exist in his model.
He (assumes that he) doesn't need our existence at all to make his superior mathmodels.
This zombie will never assume an Invisible Nature in chemical processes.

This zombie concludes: ergo, this 'consciousness' does not exist. Error.


Whenever EMR or other materials in this world, non-brainlike materials, have another Invisible Nature too, but different from ours,
they cannot communicate it to us in our language and we will never be able to detect or describe it.

Their true Nature stays hidden in the dark.
Our tools are limited.
Our mathematical and operational terms have no word for it.
And they cannot communicate or reveal themselves to us. These things can only let see their material appearance.

But when we accept our own Nature as real (Consciousness, Awareness, Experiencing this world)
we can only believe in the existence of other minds, because we, chemical processes,
experience that we are more than a chemical process.

So, at least, other chemicals, like us, must be minds too.

But, we have no tools to discover wether other materials in this world are more than only what we can measure when we detect their material appearance.

We would have no language to describe their hidden Nature.

We are unable to describe the whole Nature of the Universe with the language of the philosophical zombie.

It's a frontiere we cannot pass.
An objective epistemological boundery.

There is a limit to what can be revealed with our tools of knowledge.

We are clueless about wether some other materials have hidden Natures or not.

But we can only become suspicious.

Because we know that there is more then the eye can see and the detector can measure.
Because we, electrochemical processes, know we are more than the detector can detect when this zombie is investigating and mapping our electrochemical system.


So, when we accept that we are 'awareness', consciousness' and 'experiencing', we
can become suspicious about some other materials in this world.
 
Last edited:
Tsig,

it is logically and practically impossible.

Just like it is impossible to explain in the materialistic language of the philosophical zombie (without consciousness) with superior mathskills and superior measuring devices that we are more than the chemistry he is investigating.

We have not the language to tell him that we are more than the systemic chemical interaction process he is mapping with his superior mathskills.

Our words like 'feelings, experiencing, awareness, consciousness' are nonsense to him.
Our real Nature is wordsalad our gibberish for his tools. We do not exist in his model.


Whenever EMR or other objects have another nature too, it cannot communicate it to us and we will never be able to detect it.

It's true Nature stays in the dark.
Our tools are limited.
Our mathematical or operational terms has no word for it.

It's a hidden nature of this Universe.

We can only believe in the existence of other minds, because we, chemicals, experience that we are more than chemicals.

So, at least, other chemicals, like us, must be minds too.
But, we have no tools to discover wether other materials in this world are more than only what we can measure.
We would have no language to describe it.

We are unable to describe the whole Nature of the Universe.
That's a wall we must accept. A frontiere we cannot pass.
That's an objective epistemological boundery.
A limit to what can be revealed with our tools.

We are clueless about some other materials.

We can only become suspicious when there is more then the eye can see and and the detector can measure.

We can only become suspicious and unsatisfied that we cannot go behind this limit of what we can know about this world.

A lot of words to say nothing. What is an ''Absolute object''?
 
So, there is a Hidden Door in this world.
A dark territory.
An Invisible World wich can only be entered,
when you are this sort of materials.

Otherwise there is no Key to this Door.
To Be or not to be.

You are this Door or you are not.

There is only one Portal to this Kingdom.

It's a World wich cannot be described in material terms only.
We have no words for this area of knowledge.

yet This World exists,
and it is real.
 
Last edited:
So, there is a Hidden Door in this world.
A dark territory.
An Invisible World wich can only be entered,
when you are this sort of materials.

Otherwise there is no Key to this Door.
To Be or not to be.

You are this Door or you are not.

There is only one Portal to this Kingdom.

It's a World wich cannot be described in material terms only.
We have no words for this area of knowledge.

yet This World exists,
and it is real.

Is that Vogon poetry? We are doors? This sort of materials? Which sort of materials? Be specific. Where is your evidence that this Kingdom, whatever that is, actually exists? Why the Shakespeare quote about suicide? What is an ''Absolute object''? If you have no answers then just say so instead of inflicting bad poetry on us.
 
Last edited:
Light is not an object. What do you mean by ''absolute object''? Please stop peddling your mistaken ''theories'' and actually answer some questions. Why can't you do that?
I am pretty sure he thinks he is answering the questions and that the answers he gives would be perfectly meaningful, logical and correct to a real scientist. I do not think at this point that he has any capability to understand that this is not and cannot be correct in any functional way nor is it meaningful in any functional way. He cannot answer the questions because he does not have the background to understand where he has gone wrong in so many ways. The phrasing he uses is an absolute indicator of that.
 
Note: the alternatives to this involve the "t" word and/or a processing problem if you get my drift and I think you do.
 
I am pretty sure he thinks he is answering the questions and that the answers he gives would be perfectly meaningful, logical and correct to a real scientist. I do not think at this point that he has any capability to understand that this is not and cannot be correct in any functional way nor is it meaningful in any functional way. He cannot answer the questions because he does not have the background to understand where he has gone wrong in so many ways. The phrasing he uses is an absolute indicator of that.

Now he has descended into new age woo poetry. I agree that he does not understand why he is wrong and does not realize that real scientists will never take him seriously.
 
Last edited:
So, there is a Hidden Door in this world.
A dark territory.
An Invisible World wich can only be entered,
when you are this sort of materials.

Otherwise there is no Key to this Door.
To Be or not to be.

You are this Door or you are not.

There is only one Portal to this Kingdom.

It's a World wich cannot be described in material terms only.
We have no words for this area of knowledge.

yet This World exists,
and it is real.

The Green Door?

Midnight one more night without sleepin' -
Watchin' till the morning comes creepin'.
Green door what's that secret you're keepin'?
There's an old piano
And they play it hot
Behind the green door (Green Door)
Don't know what they're doin'
But they laugh a lot
Behind the green door. (Green Door)
Wish they'd let me in
So I could find out
What's behind the green door. (Green Door)
Knocked once tried to tell 'em I'd been there

Door slammed hospitality's thin there.
Wonder just what's goin' on in there.

Saw an eyeball peepin' through a smokey cloud
Behind the green door (Green Door)

When I said Joe sent me

Someone laughed out loud
Behind the green door. (green Door)
AII I want to do is join the happy crowd
Behind the green door. (green door)


Shaking Steven
 
haha, Tsig.

The one who seeks for it in the visible world will not find it.
The One Who search for it in the Invisible Nature of this world, It will reveal itself to Him or Her.


The Universe has ways to reveal itself, a materialist cannot even imagine...

But please keep on trying to find this Door in your visible material world. It will be hidden. It will not exist.

Please try to describe this Door with your mathematical or materialistic language. Maybe your dark language is able to describe it. Who knows.
Maybe it is a green door, Tsig, who knows?
:D
 
Last edited:
Hokulele, how can I tell you this?

How can I tell you that your Nature can not only be described by describing the chemical interacting process of your being?

I have no words for that.

The only thing I can say: you are these chemicals,
therefore
You know that you are not only chemical interactions.

You are the Portal to this knowledge.
To be = to know.

To be these materials = to know that you are not only the electro-chemical system you appear to be.

There is no material language for You. Only for the electrochemical process.

We have no words for You.

The description for your being is wordsalad and gibberish. Consciousness, Awareness, Experiencing, etc.
But You exist and you are real.

You are not only the chemistry we measure when we meet you.
You are more than the mathematical model we can make of your system.

But you have no language to tell the materialist of your True Nature.

There is no operational term for your existence in this world.
You are Invisible in the model of the philosophical zombie.

The Portal = to be a certain kind of materials.
That's the only Door to this undescribable Kingdom.
 
Last edited:
Hokulele, how can I tell you this?

How can I tell you that your Nature can not only be described by describing the chemical interacting process of your being?


By answering my question. Why does material changes affect experience so drastically if experience isn't material?

I have no words for that.

The only thing I can say: you are these chemicals,
therefore
You know that you are not only chemical interactions.

You are the Portal to this knowledge.
To be = to know.

To be these materials = to know that you are not only the electro-chemical system you appear to be.

There is no material language for You. Only for the electrochemical process.

We have no words for You.

The description for your being is wordsalad and gibberish. Consciousness, Awareness, Experiencing, etc.
But You exist and you are real.

You are not only the chemistry we measure when we meet you.
You are more than the mathematical model we can make of your system.

But you have no language to tell the materialist of your True Nature.

There is no operational term for your existence in this world.
You are Invisible in the model of the philosophical zombie.

The Portal = to be a certain kind of materials.
That's the only Door to this undescribable Kingdom.


So when science doesn't know the answer to a question, it is automatically insufficient, yet when your mysticism doesn't know the answer to my question, it is simply because of mystery.

Hypocrisy at its finest.
 
Have we gone through a time portal back to the 1960's? It's a long time since I heard such hippie gibberish.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom