I experience, therefore I am

Is Maartenn100 suggesting that because there are some things, such as consciousness, that we cannot (yet) describe in terms of mathematics, it is just as valid to use non-mathematical descriptions of those things that we can describe using maths?

It's a bit like someone who has dropped his keys under a streetlight insisting that we should search for them with our eyes closed because it is dark under the bushes on the other side of the street.

He seems to be claiming, as most consciousness plus proponents do, that the human brain is more than matter, that the operation of the mind transcends the bounds of the physical world. In other words humans have a supernatural component.

They might as well say they believe in a soul and be done with it.
 
I believe it ould be more accurate to say that there is no centre. Over the decades and centuries, science has done a pretty good job of showing how we are not the centre of the universe or somehow special within it. First the Earth was not the centre of the univese anymore, then the Sun wasn't the centre, now there is no centre of the univese at all. First we found out that the Earth was not made for humans, then that humans were not a special species, now that our brains or minds follow the same laws of nature and biology as everything else in the universe.

Of course, everybody wants to feel special, which is a part of the reason some people do not want to see the above process, I think.

No doubt a physicist will correct me if I am wrong but I have been given to understand that the Big Bang happened at every point in the universe. My apologies for bringing science into this fantasy thread.
 
No doubt a physicist will correct me if I am wrong but I have been given to understand that the Big Bang happened at every point in the universe. My apologies for bringing science into this fantasy thread.

I'm not saying the Big Bang did not happen everywhere, but that that fact does not make any single point in space more special than any other. So while you could say that everything can be the centre of the universe, that takes away a lot of the meaning of the tem 'centre.' That's why I think it is better to say there is no centre of the universe.

Although I'd be happily corrected as well.
 
I'm not saying the Big Bang did not happen everywhere, but that that fact does not make any single point in space more special than any other. So while you could say that everything can be the centre of the universe, that takes away a lot of the meaning of the tem 'centre.' That's why I think it is better to say there is no centre of the universe.

Although I'd be happily corrected as well.

Thank you for the explanation.
 
Thank you for the explanation.

You're welcome. Thinkng about it some more, you could probably put morality in there too, as another area where there is not a special, absolute or correct answer.

I really AM arelativist. :eek:
 
That's what you revealed about your nature.
So, you are absolutely right. Nothing more than detectable electro-chemistry, only describable in exact operational terms.
Only what the detector can detect or the mathematical model can make of you.
That's Tsig. That's what Adman and Tsig are revealing Us about their nature.

So be it.

Uncomfortable thought, isn't it ?

Now, tell me, why should the universe offer us a comfortable solution to our insecurities ?
 
Uncomfortable thought, isn't it ?

Now, tell me, why should the universe offer us a comfortable solution to our insecurities ?

Perhaps somebody should tell Maartenn that most of the universe is inimical to human life and that the universe is not a sentient being.
 
That isn't a nice thing to say about Tsig.

:D:):o:(

Maybe these are the Doors we are hearing about:

The Doors were an American rock band formed in 1965 in Los Angeles, California, with vocalist Jim Morrison, keyboardist Ray Manzarek, drummer John Densmore and guitarist Robby Krieger. The band took its name from the title of Aldous Huxley's book The Doors of Perception,[1



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Doors
 
:D:):o:(

Maybe these are the Doors we are hearing about:

The Doors were an American rock band formed in 1965 in Los Angeles, California, with vocalist Jim Morrison, keyboardist Ray Manzarek, drummer John Densmore and guitarist Robby Krieger. The band took its name from the title of Aldous Huxley's book The Doors of Perception,[1



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Doors

The Doors were actually formed by the Carpenters.
 
:D:):o:(

Maybe these are the Doors we are hearing about:

The Doors were an American rock band formed in 1965 in Los Angeles, California, with vocalist Jim Morrison, keyboardist Ray Manzarek, drummer John Densmore and guitarist Robby Krieger. The band took its name from the title of Aldous Huxley's book The Doors of Perception,[1



http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Doors

:heartbeat::heartbeat::heartbeat: Jim Morrison...<<sigh>>
 
I believe it ould be more accurate to say that there is no centre. Over the decades and centuries, science has done a pretty good job of showing how we are not the centre of the universe or somehow special within it. First the Earth was not the centre of the univese anymore, then the Sun wasn't the centre, now there is no centre of the univese at all. First we found out that the Earth was not made for humans, then that humans were not a special species, now that our brains or minds follow the same laws of nature and biology as everything else in the universe.


But we still think that the experienced present moment is super special; the one specific (though moving) point in all of time where the protean future becomes the immutable past; the center of time, as it were. I've been wondering if that will be the next to go.
 
But we still think that the experienced present moment is super special; the one specific (though moving) point in all of time where the protean future becomes the immutable past; the center of time, as it were. I've been wondering if that will be the next to go.

Go where?
 
Alright Woo Slingers that's how you want it to be? That's how you want to play this game? You want to step away from logic and reason and reality where you have no chance and play this as a game of passion?

Fine. Bring it. You want passion? I'll show you passion.

Being alive is awesome.

I have a gorgeous wife who loves me dearly, a dog that wags his tail so hard it looks like he's gonna take off like a helicopter whenever I come home from work, a cat that loves to curl up in my lap purring while I read, a job I find challenging and rewarding, a comfortable roof over my head and a car with a sunroof and a good music system. I have good friends and a good family.

I live in a world of good music, good books, good films, good games. I get to have a nice thick juicy sirloin for dinner every Sunday and follow it up with a Cohiba and nice glass of whiskey while I watch the sunset from my porch. I get to sit in my comfy recliner and watch hockey games. I get the run on the beach and hike in the mountains. I get to laugh at jokes and get engaged by drama and get scared by slasher films. Right now the two neighbor kids are laughing their heads off outside my window chasing their dog around and throwing snowballs at each other.

I have A Tale of Two Cities, Don Quixote, Following the Equator, the House of Blue Leaves, and Watchmen. I have Tom Wait's guttural growl, Jimmy Buffett's beach bum escapism, Springsteen's blue collar mourning, Neal Peart's drumming, Eric Clapton's guitar work, and Miles Davis' trumpeting. I have George Carlin "Seven Words You Can't Say on TV." I have the Feynman Lectures on Physics. I have Breaking Bad and Sherlock and Mystery Science Theater 3000. I have the trench run in Star Wars and Abbott and Costello doing "Who's on First" and the Silent Cartographer level from Halo, and Da Vinci's the Last Supper and Escher's Waterfalls and the bar shootout from Desperado and Bruce Lee fighting Chuck Norris in the Colosseum and the Muppets singing "Manamana" and Kevin Spacey losing his limp at the end of a Usual Suspects and the "You Can't Handle the Truth" speech in A Few Good Men and not being able to not sing along to cheesy 80s songs no matter how much I try. I live in a world that has produced both Citizen Kane and Robocop and I am free and able to love them both.

I have the feel of the air after a good summer rain. I have the smell of freshly cut grass. I have the taste of mangoes. I have the look of how the sun streams in through our bay window. I have sleeping in on my days off. I have long drives with my wife down the coast to that one place in the Outer Banks that has those great slaw dogs.

I have roller coasters and Cards Against Humanity and faking my dog out by pretending to throw the ball and the way my wife rolls her eyes but still laughs when I make a bad pun. I have strumming out bad songs on my old Les Paul. I have yanking a 16 pound Great Barracuda into the boat after fighting it for two hours. I have my wife holding while I cried the night my dad died. I have holding my wife while she cried when the doctors said we couldn't have kids.

I've traveled the world. I've climbed to the top of Mount Vesuvius, seen the Pyramids at Giza, drunk a pint in a bar in England, seen the Mona Lisa, played Blackjack in Monte Carlo, seen the ruins of Rome, seen combat in Afghanistan, jumped off the side of an aircraft carrier into the ocean, and overall I consider my life to have been rather boring.

I live in a world in which man has walked on the Moon, landed a nuclear powered SUV on Mars, cloned higher mammals, split the atom, photographed a live giant squid, eradicated Smallpox, in which there has been at least one human being in frickin' space at all times for over a decade.

I live on both the Big Blue Marble and the Pale Blue Dot.

I've experienced love and hate, bravery and fear, nostalgia and hope, ecstasy and ennui, joy and sadness, and I wouldn't give up either side of that equation.

I've burned bridges, buried hatches, mended fences, and tortured my share of metaphors.

The width and breath of what I have experienced and what I have left to experience is wonderful. I've seen birth and death, I've had highs and lows, I've seen humanity at its best and its worst.

So listen up Woo Slingers and listen well. The world is far too interesting for you all to dare act like you have to make stuff up in order to be fulfilled.

You live in the same world I do and you haven't experienced a billionth of a percent of it same as me. There's already more in the world that operates within the structure of how we know this world works then you could experience in a thousand long lifetimes.

There is no, absolutely no, excuse to resort to making up unsupported Woo in this world. I can't even wrap my head around being so intellectually vapid as to make reality not enough for you.

If this world is not good enough for you then you Sir or M'am don't know crap about this world!
 
Last edited:
It must be a major disappointment finding out that you are not the universe but merely a hypothetical non-existent p-zombie, although I suspected as much. I wonder which one of us is the universe?
I think I am. The question is why did I imagine this thread? :p
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom