I experience, therefore I am

It's obvious that some of them here don't even know what Wikipedia is.
It explains perfectly what a philosophical zombie is.

It's something which can only be a brain.
No Awareness, no Consiousness, no Experience nor Feelings. Gibberisch nonsense in his models of Nature.
Okay. Thank you for the link; I now know what you mean.

I claim, here and now, that I am a p-zombie.

How could you refute my claim?
How could I refute my claim?
 
Okay. Thank you for the link; I now know what you mean.

I claim, here and now, that I am a p-zombie.

How could you refute my claim?
How could I refute my claim?

I'm a p-zombie! Who are you? Are you -- a pzombie -- too? Then there's a pair of us? Don't tell! they'd advertise -- you know!
Apologies to E.D.
 
Actually, that's cooler than anything Maartenn is spouting - and figuring out how a bunch of chemical reactions leads to consciousness has got to be one of the most fascinating jobs ever.

That takes work, and talent, it's much easier to close your eyes and dream your way to truth.
 
That takes work, and talent, it's much easier to close your eyes and dream your way to truth.

Truth? I disagree sir! Surely you are not implying that Maartenn has discovered the Key To The Universal Hidden Door by merely relaxing?
 
I'm a p-zombie! Who are you? Are you -- a pzombie -- too? Then there's a pair of us? Don't tell! they'd advertise -- you know!
Apologies to E.D.
There's lots of us. You didn't get invited to the con? I'll drop a note to our chairman, Joe Biden. :D
 
Truth? I disagree sir! Surely you are not implying that Maartenn has discovered the Key To The Universal Hidden Door by merely relaxing?
He slumped sleepily into it and it turned out it was not a door at all. It was, of course a jar.

Maybe the Maartens of this world are not so much skilled at finding a way as they are stymied by imagined doors where others saunter through without a worry.
 
He slumped sleepily into it and it turned out it was not a door at all. It was, of course a jar.

Maybe the Maartens of this world are not so much skilled at finding a way as they are stymied by imagined doors where others saunter through without a worry.

I remember thinking there was some magic knowledge that when I learned it I would understand everything gradually I became aware that knowledge required effort to grasp and there was no hidden door to knowing.
 
I remember thinking there was some magic knowledge that when I learned it I would understand everything gradually I became aware that knowledge required effort to grasp and there was no hidden door to knowing.

The Doors to libraries are not hidden. No need to go on a Magic Quest to find them.
 
I am woo for you
you are woo for Me.

Dada.


Is Maartenn100 suggesting that because there are some things, such as consciousness, that we cannot (yet) describe in terms of mathematics, it is just as valid to use non-mathematical descriptions of those things that we can describe using maths?

It's a bit like someone who has dropped his keys under a streetlight insisting that we should search for them with our eyes closed because it is dark under the bushes on the other side of the street.
 
So, you could say that every point in space-time is the centre. (This is my own possibly bogus conceptualisation. If anyone can correct me on this point, please do!)

I believe it ould be more accurate to say that there is no centre. Over the decades and centuries, science has done a pretty good job of showing how we are not the centre of the universe or somehow special within it. First the Earth was not the centre of the univese anymore, then the Sun wasn't the centre, now there is no centre of the univese at all. First we found out that the Earth was not made for humans, then that humans were not a special species, now that our brains or minds follow the same laws of nature and biology as everything else in the universe.

Of course, everybody wants to feel special, which is a part of the reason some people do not want to see the above process, I think.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom