I experience, therefore I am

But we still think that the experienced present moment is super special; the one specific (though moving) point in all of time where the protean future becomes the immutable past; the center of time, as it were. I've been wondering if that will be the next to go.

If I remember my special relativity lectures well, the speciality of the 'experienced present moment' has already gone. We just have not realized it yet, just as we still have not fully realized the Sun does not revolve around the Earth. According to the theory of relativity, even simultanity (spelling?) is relative. Of course, we are talking about minus I-do-not-what degree, but my now (in the Netherlands below sea level) differs slightly from your now (on, let me assume, some mountain somewhere). Or something, relativity is difficult.

Although if you are talking about your personal now, then I would agree that it is somehow special. However not in the degree that the laws of physics (and chemistry, biology etc) do not apply to them.
 
But we still think that the experienced present moment is super special; the one specific (though moving) point in all of time where the protean future becomes the immutable past; the center of time, as it were. I've been wondering if that will be the next to go.

Even if it's somehow explained away, the explanation will likely fall flat in the face of such an intimate, convincing, useful "illusion".
 
Even if it's somehow explained away, the explanation will likely fall flat in the face of such an intimate, convincing, useful "illusion".


Up to a point, sure. Just as, if you ask someone where the next sunrise will occur, he or she will invariably point toward somewhere on the horizon, not toward the sun. It's not that the person "believes" the sun revolves around the earth, but the sun revolving around the earth remains a useful mental model and is the one that gets applied when answering that question.

An explanation of the subjective experience of time that is as complete and convincing as that of the true movements of the earth and sun, that explained how the illusion occurs rather than just declaring it an illusion, would do a little better than fall flat, I think. It wouldn't affect everyday experience directly (nor does the Galilean model of the solar system), but the philosophical implications would be extensive. For instance, for the experienced present to have no special quality compared to any other coordinates in spacetime would clearly imply that the past exists, not just in memory but in actuality; that the future is as determined as we think the past is (unless instead the past is as alterable as we think the future is, which would be really strange); and that my awareness is not moving through the chronology of my life but simply exists as a constant at each of a set of moments (so that, for instance, death is of no more significance than the space to the right of the bottom-rightmost book on a bookshelf). These are ideas that even mystics could have trouble with; we certainly can't claim them with any authority yet.

But, your point stands. Just as the possible nonexistence of free will doesn't (upon careful thought) actually suggest any radical differences in how we approach criminal justice, the possible nonexistence of linear time wouldn't really change how we plan, remember, or aspire. We'd go on doing them the way evolution equipped us to. It might, though, give us a deeper understanding of what it really means to do those things, just as, every once in a while, while watching the sun come up, we might remember that we're actually watching it wind into view from the side of a tilted spinning sphere.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Up to a point, sure. Just as, if you ask someone where the next sunrise will occur, he or she will invariably point toward somewhere on the horizon, not toward the sun. It's not that the person "believes" the sun revolves around the earth, but the sun revolving around the earth remains a useful mental model and is the one that gets applied when answering that question.

An explanation of the subjective experience of time that is as complete and convincing as that of the true movements of the earth and sun, that explained how the illusion occurs rather than just declaring it an illusion, would do a little better than fall flat, I think. It wouldn't affect everyday experience directly (nor does the Galilean model of the solar system), but the philosophical implications would be extensive. For instance, for the experienced present to have no special quality compared to any other coordinates in spacetime would clearly imply that the past exists, not just in memory but in actuality; that the future is as determined as we think the past is (unless instead the past is as alterable as we think the future is, which would be really strange); and that my awareness is not moving through the chronology of my life but simply exists as a constant at each of a set of moments (so that, for instance, death is of no more significance than the space to the right of the bottom-rightmost book on a bookshelf). These are ideas that even mystics could have trouble with; we certainly can't claim them with any authority yet.

But, your point stands. Just as the possible nonexistence of free will doesn't (upon careful thought) actually suggest any radical differences in how we approach criminal justice, the possible nonexistence of linear time wouldn't really change how we plan, remember, or aspire. We'd go on doing them the way evolution equipped us to. It might, though, give us a deeper understanding of what it really means to do those things, just as, every once in a while, while watching the sun come up, we might remember that we're actually watching it wind into view from the side of a tilted spinning sphere.

Respectfully,
Myriad

Why shouldn't they point to the horizon since:

Sunrise or sun up is the instant at which the upper edge of the Sun appears over the eastern horizon in the morning.[1] The term can also refer to the entire process of the Sun crossing the horizon and its accompanying atmospheric effects.[2]
 
Why shouldn't they point to the horizon since:

Sunrise or sun up is the instant at which the upper edge of the Sun appears over the eastern horizon in the morning.[1] The term can also refer to the entire process of the Sun crossing the horizon and its accompanying atmospheric effects.[2]


I didn't say they shouldn't point to the horizon. In fact, I said just the opposite, that indicating a horizontal direction is the expected response.

My point is, that expectation shows that a geocentric mental model (that the terrestrial surroundings are the stationary reference frame around which the sun moves) is normal, and heliocentric thinking is unusual, under such ordinary circumstances. If that were not the case, then indicating that the sunrise will occur in the direction of the sun would be the preferred response, or at least an expected alternative response.
 
Only in dutch I can give this to you:

Daffyd can translate this for you.
It's been given to me:

Schepsels van Satan
Verneder Mij
En gij zult kruipen

Gij ziet Mij niet
Doorgrond niet alles
Kent niet elk oogmerk

Zoek Mij in het zichtbare
En gij vindt Mij niet
Ik ben Verborgen werkzaam

Doorheen Elk wezen
Kijk ik U aan

U bent slechts een naamgever
Dat toont Mij wie u bent

Noem Mij 'woo'
En u toont zich 'woo' aan Mij

Noem Mij het Onkenbare
En een Verborgen werking komt in U

U verklaarde zich een levende dode
Enkel brein, zenuwstelsel
en u ontkent het Onmeetbare eraan

Zo zal het zijn.

Maarten Vergucht
De Verborgen Werking
 
Posting Woo in other languages (which is against the MA by the way) doesn't make you any deeper.
 
Only in dutch I can give this to you:

Daffyd can translate this for you.
It's been given to me:

Schepsels van Satan
Verneder Mij
En gij zult kruipen

Gij ziet Mij niet
Doorgrond niet alles
Kent niet elk oogmerk

Zoek Mij in het zichtbare
En gij vindt Mij niet
Ik ben Verborgen werkzaam

Doorheen Elk wezen
Kijk ik U aan

U bent slechts een naamgever
Dat toont Mij wie u bent

Noem Mij 'woo'
En u toont zich 'woo' aan Mij

Noem Mij het Onkenbare
En een Verborgen werking komt in U

U verklaarde zich een levende dode
Enkel brein, zenuwstelsel
en u ontkent het Onmeetbare eraan

Zo zal het zijn.

Maarten Vergucht
De Verborgen Werking

Creatures of Satan
Humiliate me
And you will suffer
You do not see me
You do not fathom everything
You do not know every objective
Seek me in the invisible
And you will not find me
I am hidden activity
Through every creature
I look at you
I am only the name giver
That shows me who you
Call me woo
And you show your woo to me
Call me the unknown
And a hidden process enters you
You declare yourself a living dead
Only brain and nervous system
And you deny the unmeasurable
So it shall be

It's still gibberish in English. How will you make us suffer for humiliating you? You are not a name giver, whatever that means. So shall what be? Are you threatening us? If you really mean this then I think that you have a problem and you need help. Seriously, this is not to make fun of you, I really think you need help. Satan does not exist, we are just human beings like you and none of us are controlled by an imaginary being. Are you a member of that weird church based in the former Astrid cinema in Antwerp? You ''poem'' is very redolent of their posters.
 
Last edited:
I didn't say they shouldn't point to the horizon. In fact, I said just the opposite, that indicating a horizontal direction is the expected response.

My point is, that expectation shows that a geocentric mental model (that the terrestrial surroundings are the stationary reference frame around which the sun moves) is normal, and heliocentric thinking is unusual, under such ordinary circumstances. If that were not the case, then indicating that the sunrise will occur in the direction of the sun would be the preferred response, or at least an expected alternative response.

I'd say they point at the horizon because that's where sunrise takes place and not because they don't understand the Earth is rotating.

Pointing at the sun when asked "Where does sunrise occur" would be decidedly odd.
 
It's still gibberish in English. How will you make us suffer for humiliating you?

I don't think Maartenn was suggesting that he, personally would make us suffer. I think he's speaking from the perspective of the Unmoved Mover, First Cause, God, Unknown Knower, Lightning-Bolt-Thrower, Watch-Maker, Radiant 'Is', What-Have-You. Secret knowledge is the hallmark of many mystics. Nothing particularly interesting, aside from whatever artistic value it might have--
 
Last edited:
I don't think Maartenn was suggesting that he, personally would make us suffer. I think he's speaking from the perspective of the Unmoved Mover, First Cause, God, Unknown Knower, Lightning-Bolt-Thrower, Watch-Maker, Radiant 'Is', What-Have-You. Secret knowledge is the hallmark of many mystics. Nothing particularly interesting, aside from whatever artistic value it might have--

At least we now know that religion is behind it.
 
Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>

The language of this forum is English. Occasional words and phrases in other languages are, of course, permitted, but entire long posts in other languages, without any good reason or any translation, are not.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If Maartenn will pm me I will be happy to translate, out of morbid curiosity.
 
I'd say they point at the horizon because that's where sunrise takes place and not because they don't understand the Earth is rotating.

Pointing at the sun when asked "Where does sunrise occur" would be decidedly odd.


I never said they "don't understand" the earth is rotating. They understand and believe it in the abstract; if asked a question on a quiz, most of them (well, half of them, at least) would correctly state that the earth revolves and rotates around the sun. But our everyday mental model of day, night, sunrise, etc. is of the sun moving around in the sky, because that's what we directly experience.

(This might seem to be a bizarre tangent in the topic, but it's actually an issue central to understanding of religion and mysticism. "Belief in" something is not the same as utilizing that thing as a mental model; the two can coincide but they don't have to. But because to utilize any model, one acts and thinks as if it's real, it can be difficult to tell the difference. A liberal Christian can, for instance, remind people that "the devil makes work for idle hands" without actually believing in a literal sentient devil, or a mystic can describe entire elaborate worlds populated by a menagerie of beings without necessarily believing they have any independent external existence, just as an astronomy textbook can devote chapters to the components and behaviors of the celestial sphere, without actually believing that the stars are actually attached to a big sphere that rotates around the earth.)

So the point here is, why would pointing at the sun when asked "Where does sunrise occur" be decidedly odd? The sunrise occurs where one curve (the sun's) intersects another (the horizon's). It's quite normal to describe the intersection or juxtaposition of a moving object with a fixed object as occurring at the fixed object's location. If a ship were on a collision course with a lighthouse, and you were asked where the collision would occur if the ship doesn't change course, you'd probably point to the lighthouse, not to the ship.

But we know that the sun is actually close to fixed and it's the earth that's rotating (and the horizon with it). The horizon is the ship and the sun is the lighthouse. So, it should not be odd at all to point to the sun, the thing whose location is close to fixed, when asked where the horizon, the thing that's moving, will intersect it (that is, the sunrise). And yet, as you say, it is. That's because in the prevailing everyday mental model, it's the sun that's the moving object and the horizon that's fixed, Copernicus notwithstanding.

Likewise (returning to my original point), whatever we discover about the nature of time, even if it differs significantly from our subjective experience of time, the prevailing everyday mental model of time won't change. We won't all start sounding like Doctor Who or Dr. Manhattan. Even though it might be kind of fun. ("Yes, I'm late for our appointment. I always have been too late, and I always shall be too late. It's what we call a fixed point in time, like every other point. Shall I apologize for the inalterable shape of the universe?")

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Last edited:
I never said they "don't understand" the earth is rotating. They understand and believe it in the abstract; if asked a question on a quiz, most of them (well, half of them, at least) would correctly state that the earth revolves and rotates around the sun. But our everyday mental model of day, night, sunrise, etc. is of the sun moving around in the sky, because that's what we directly experience.

(This might seem to be a bizarre tangent in the topic, but it's actually an issue central to understanding of religion and mysticism. "Belief in" something is not the same as utilizing that thing as a mental model; the two can coincide but they don't have to. But because to utilize any model, one acts and thinks as if it's real, it can be difficult to tell the difference. A liberal Christian can, for instance, remind people that "the devil makes work for idle hands" without actually believing in a literal sentient devil, or a mystic can describe entire elaborate worlds populated by a menagerie of beings without necessarily believing they have any independent external existence, just as an astronomy textbook can devote chapters to the components and behaviors of the celestial sphere, without actually believing that the stars are actually attached to a big sphere that rotates around the earth.)

So the point here is, why would pointing at the sun when asked "Where does sunrise occur" be decidedly odd? The sunrise occurs where one curve (the sun's) intersects another (the horizon's). It's quite normal to describe the intersection or juxtaposition of a moving object with a fixed object as occurring at the fixed object's location. If a ship were on a collision course with a lighthouse, and you were asked where the collision would occur if the ship doesn't change course, you'd probably point to the lighthouse, not to the ship.

But we know that the sun is actually close to fixed and it's the earth that's rotating (and the horizon with it). The horizon is the ship and the sun is the lighthouse. So, it should not be odd at all to point to the sun, the thing whose location is close to fixed, when asked where the horizon, the thing that's moving, will intersect it (that is, the sunrise). And yet, as you say, it is. That's because in the prevailing everyday mental model, it's the sun that's the moving object and the horizon that's fixed, Copernicus notwithstanding.

Likewise (returning to my original point), whatever we discover about the nature of time, even if it differs significantly from our subjective experience of time, the prevailing everyday mental model of time won't change. We won't all start sounding like Doctor Who or Dr. Manhattan. Even though it might be kind of fun. ("Yes, I'm late for our appointment. I always have been too late, and I always shall be too late. It's what we call a fixed point in time, like every other point. Shall I apologize for the inalterable shape of the universe?")

Respectfully,
Myriad

If it's dark when asked "Where does the sun rise" it will be hard to point at the sun.:)

Shall we consider this nit picked?
 
Up to a point, sure. Just as, if you ask someone where the next sunrise will occur, he or she will invariably point toward somewhere on the horizon, not toward the sun. It's not that the person "believes" the sun revolves around the earth, but the sun revolving around the earth remains a useful mental model and is the one that gets applied when answering that question.

I had something a bit more intimate in mind. When talking "the experienced present moment", to my mind we're talking consciousness.

Say, for instance, you tell someone that his consciousness doesn't exist. He might even follow your argument with bated breath, and be moved to tears by the beauty and implications of it. But at some point, he's going to say, "Hey... Wait a minute." Then the argument is reduced to so many beautiful, powerful-sounding words that don't apply to the "real" world.

If we manage to explain away the experience of the present moment as an illusion (or whatever), we're left with a question: How do we distinguish between the experience of the present moment and an illusion that is indistinguishable from it? An exercise in the use of language ensues, but the first-hand, intimate experience remains.

But I get your point.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom