I experience, therefore I am

I suppose it might escape some that there is a reason why p-zombies are theoretical. The idea that a non-spiritual approach to reality makes consciousness and awareness impossible is far from obvious to all.

I should point out too that many words and ideas can be found in Wikipedia to describe people and ideas here, many of them tempting to name but risking violation of forum rules. It's not finally such a fruitful line of defense.
 
It's obvious that some of them here don't even know what Wikipedia is.
It explains perfectly what a philosophical zombie is.

It's something which can only be a brain.
No Awareness, no Consiousness, no Experience nor Feelings. Gibberisch nonsense in his models of Nature.

Whenever a professor claims he has no Inner Eye or does not know what Awareness is in his view of Nature,
there are only two logical options:

or he lies or he is a zombie.

The only two logical conclusions you can make.

A living dead. It acts like Us, It talks like Us, but it cannot see or discover Our Invisible Nature with its poor tools.
and it will let Us believe that his model and his math can tell
Us everything there is to know about the Universe.

You may even kill it, because it is already a living dead. (don't kill it!)
A zombie without an Inner Eye. Or that is what it claims.
And please, do not take lessons from zombies.

But, you can also expect that it is a lyer when it tells you that it has no Inner Eye and it is only a brain.

Ask this zombie how he is going to reveal the Invisible nature of things in this world with his poor tools.
He can't.

The only thing what he can do = to believe.

To believe that you are not only chemicals in his classroom, living deads.
You are of an Invisible Nature.

But his tools cannot find this.
So, he must believe that fact.

He can only believe in your Invisible Nature
when he is not a zombie himself.
When he is of an Invisible Nature too.

But, step away from it, when it tells you it cannot find such things as Consciousness, Feelings, Integrity (the Honest Feeling) Awareness, Experiences in this world with his models of Nature, and it can only make mathematical models of your chemical structure, and that's everything wich exists in Nature.
Step away from it. You do not need lessons from a zombie.

It cannot assume the Unseen in this world because it has declared that it has no Invisible Nature of its own.
Step away from it. It is already a living dead. It declared this.

It's very good to study mathematics and physics, when you want to. It's very useful to survive in this world! It can heal you and give medicine to survive.
But you are more than the detector can see and the mathematical model can make of you. You are of an Undescribable and Undetectable Nature.

I thought I was the universe

or a p zombie

Now I'm Indescribable and Undetectable.


My wife is unimpressed.
 
You are right Tsig.

You can only be described with operational terms.
Like a P-zombie. But, indeed you don't know what it is.

So: only chemistry, and that's it. (you can call it 'a brain' or whatever= only electrochemical interacting system)
That's you.

Operational terms, and nothing more. That's exactly what you are.

That's what you revealed about your nature.
So, you are absolutely right. Nothing more than detectable electro-chemistry, only describable in exact operational terms.
Only what the detector can detect or the mathematical model can make of you.
That's Tsig. That's what Adman and Tsig are revealing Us about their nature.

So be it.
 
Last edited:
You are right Tsig.

You can only be described with operational terms.
Like a P-zombie. But, indeed you don't know what it is.

So: only chemistry, and that's it. (you can call it 'a brain' or whatever= only electrochemical interacting system)
That's you.

Operational terms, and nothing more. That's exactly what you are.

That's what you revealed about your nature.
So, you are absolutely right. Nothing more than detectable electro-chemistry, only describable in exact operational terms.
That's Tsig.

So be it.


Oh, please, Maartenn. You aren't being a fraction as profound and insightful as you apparently think you are.

It's still mostly new-age woo that you're spouting, except now you're trying to sound as if you're smarter than everyone else.

You're not fooling anyone.
 
So, you are absolutely right. Nothing more than detectable electro-chemistry, only describable in exact operational terms.
Only what the detector can detect or the mathematical model can make of you.
That's Tsig. That's what Adman and Tsig are revealing Us about their nature.

So be it.

Why does this idea scare people so much?

Why does your "being" being an understandable, natural process bother you?

Yeah that's pretty much all I am. An electro-chemical process. I'm perfectly okay with it. I don't have to make up mystical woo-woo to add to it.
 
You are right Tsig.

You can only be described with operational terms.
Like a P-zombie. But, indeed you don't know what it is.

So: only chemistry, and that's it. (you can call it 'a brain' or whatever= only electrochemical interacting system)
That's you.

Operational terms, and nothing more. That's exactly what you are. That's what you revealed about your nature.
So, you are absolutely right. Nothing more than detectable electro-chemistry, only describable in exact operational terms.
Only what the detector can detect or the mathematical model can make of you.
That's Tsig. That's what Adman and Tsig are revealing Us about their nature.

So be it.

What's wrong with that? For all their profound gibberish mystics have yet to provide any deeper understanding of the world, with science we went to the moon for real, with mysticism you only dream of the moon..

Daydreaming is a fine idle pastime but you don't want to spend your life that way.
 
Last edited:
Why does this idea scare people so much?

Why does your "being" being an understandable, natural process bother you?
Yeah that's pretty much all I am. An electro-chemical process. I'm perfectly okay with it. I don't have to make up mystical woo-woo to add to it.

It takes away their "specialness" and removes their cause to feel superior to the rest of us.

Plus you don't have to do any math.
 
It takes away their "specialness" and removes their cause to feel superior to the rest of us.

Plus you don't have to do any math.

It must be a major disappointment finding out that you are not the universe but merely a hypothetical non-existent p-zombie, although I suspected as much. I wonder which one of us is the universe?
 
Why does this idea scare people so much?

Why does your "being" being an understandable, natural process bother you?

Yeah that's pretty much all I am. An electro-chemical process. I'm perfectly okay with it. I don't have to make up mystical woo-woo to add to it.

Actually, that's cooler than anything Maartenn is spouting - and figuring out how a bunch of chemical reactions leads to consciousness has got to be one of the most fascinating jobs ever.
 
Dig this: Since the universe is this space-time which came into existence at the Big Bang (whether through a sudden inflation of a speck of a larger already existing space-time, as Alan Guth is suggesting currently, or through some kind of quantum fluctuation or what have you), I understand that there is no "centre" to the volume it creates. You cannot find a spot in the space-time which is the geometrical centre in the way that you could put your finger on the centre of the plane described by a circle.

So, you could say that every point in space-time is the centre. (This is my own possibly bogus conceptualisation. If anyone can correct me on this point, please do!)

So this means that every one of us is the centre of the universe!

I reckon this is sort of what Maartenn100 is trying to say when he accuses Tsig of being the universe…. or maybe not.

Still, I find this sort of extrapolation from actual physics far more entertaining and awe-inspiring than the Cthuluesque fantasias Maartenn has been folding into his Vogon poetry in this thread.

ETA I see Elizabeth I has just made a similar suggestion that real science is a far richer source of awe and wonder than idle noodlings scooped from mush.
 
Last edited:
Dig this: Since the universe is this space-time which came into existence at the Big Bang (whether through a sudden inflation of a speck of a larger already existing space-time, as Alan Guth is suggesting currently, or through some kind of quantum fluctuation or what have you), I understand that there is no "centre" to the volume it creates. You cannot find a spot in the space-time which is the geometrical centre in the way that you could put your finger on the centre of the plane described by a circle.

So, you could say that every point in space-time is the centre. (This is my own possibly bogus conceptualisation. If anyone can correct me on this point, please do!)

So this means that every one of us is the centre of the universe!

I reckon this is sort of what Maartenn100 is trying to say when he accuses Tsig of being the universe…. or maybe not.

Still, I find this sort of extrapolation from actual physics far more entertaining and awe-inspiring than the Cthuluesque fantasias Maartenn has been folding into his Vogon poetry in this thread.

Accuses? So this is all Tsig's fault?
 
The cold and dark language of math cannot describe nor discover Your Inner Eye. The detector cannot detect this Hidden Door.
The zombie does not understand Our language.

The words to tell him about our existence: Awareness, Experiencing, Feeling, Integrity, images in the mind,
are terrorising its models of Nature.

This creature excludes the Invisible Nature of things from its description of the world.

He cannot assume that the Unseen exists.
He cannot grasp that there is more than the eye can see or the detector can measure.
The fool.

And it has no knowledge about The Invisible Door, The Inner Eye, wich is part of Nature.
And must be part of the description of Nature. This blind fool can't see nor describe Us and we useless in his world.

So, whenever you study physics or math on a University, begin to fight for the right that The Unseen must be part of the whole model of Nature.
Whenever a fool tells you that only the measurable world exists on these universities, begin to talk about the Invisible Nature of at least some sort of electrochemical material in this world, wich is part of The Universe.

First you will be seen as a 'believer', as a fool, who believes in farytales and old stories.

But when you have patience, the philosophical zombie with the superior mathskills and superior measuring devices will lose the battle against Our existence.
Because it cannot see nor describe the Inner Eye of at least some chemical systems in this world: We. It has no Invisible Nature of its own.

Succes.
Maarten Vergucht

I'm glad you've forsaken your battle for pseudoscience, but I don't know if your crusade for new age claptrap is going to be any more productive.

I almost wish justintime were here to witness this nonsense.
 
I thought I was the universe

or a p zombie

Now I'm Indescribable and Undetectable.


My wife is unimpressed.
So.....who p's zombies?? On their finally dead bodies, sure - you have to celebrate some way!!!
 
Actually, that's cooler than anything Maartenn is spouting - and figuring out how a bunch of chemical reactions leads to consciousness has got to be one of the most fascinating jobs ever.
You might want to ask M. what p-process you went through to change your horsie into a birdie!!!!!:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp:jaw-dropp
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom