How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

I went to school in Yorkshire and was not taught that it was between Yorkshire and Lancashire!
ah, I went to school in an area which has switched between being in both counties over the years and was. I have certainly met plenty of people who thought of it in those terms- you must have had a good history teacher. ;)

Other things that people know about the UK that ain't so:

1. The monarchy is hereditary. In fact, while the post of king/queen is normally for life, successors are chosen by Parliament.
I thought that it was the privy council rather than parliament?

2. The Prime Minister is elected. In fact s/he is appointed by the monarch. It is the usual practice for the monarch to appoint the leader of the biggest faction in Parliament because due to our FPTP system, the biggest faction usually has an overall majority and thus will be able to form a government. In a hung parliament, there'd be nothing to stop the monarch appointing the leader of an alliance of smaller parties as PM.
true, although the post of "prime minister" has few constitutional powers, it is the "first lord of the treasury" who has all of the powers. In fact the UK did not have an official "prime Minister" until the 20th century- PM being an informal title until then. Also The PM/ FLotT does not have to be an MP- there is nothing except public opinion to stop a Lord of Parliament being appointed PM/ FLotT.
 
I remember being taught about the Brontosaurus, then several years later it was said, ”oops we made a mistake” there is no Brontosaurus. Pluto is a planet, oh, wait, no it’s not. 30 years ago I rented a house that had a set of Encyclopedia Britannica from around 1890. Virtually every bit of science in it was wrong. It makes you think, what will be fact in 100 years? Will everything we know right now be proved wrong?

I think Firesign Theater said it along time ago…Everything you know is wrong.

How about, "Paint from the top down"?
Didn't "Happy" Harry Cox say that? Or was it "Mickey" Michael Hunt?
 
Last edited:
What do you accept as evidence?
Correction, the best evidence.

There's a whole slew of guidelines. It's part of critical thinking, science and media literacy.

You can look up the science rules, prospective double blind placebo controlled clinical trials with large subject groups trumps systematically collected retrospective anecdotes yadda yadda yadda. For different kinds of science research protocols differ. Out of my field of expertise I rely on peer review.

Repeatable matters. The conclusions need to actually be supported by the evidence. So for example measuring how many germs are killed doesn't tell you how many infections you prevented.

Results vary in certainty from overwhelming evidence for or against to no evidence.

For media literacy I start by checking the bias the source might have. I look for corroborating evidence from multiple sources. I look for how the information is being framed and consider the essence of the evidence without the frame.

And so on and so on. There is a lot to it but there is an evidence based world out there and the better you get at determining the validity of evidence and the ways in which one is deceived or tripped up the better you get at recognizing and interpreting the best evidence.
 
Whenever I see it on the menu (and these days, it's always called mahi-mahi or dorado) I always order it. For one, it's delicious, and secondly, to shock the ignorant diners around me. I refer to it as 'dolphin' loudly and often. I say "This DOLPHIN'S sooooo tasty!" and wait for someone to ask if I'm really eating dolphin. I point out that Mahi-mahi is actually dolphin and that they call it that because they don't want people to know what it REALLY is. People say "That's Dolphin? You mean like Flipper?!" I point to the tasty peice of fish on my plate and say "well, I'm pretty sure that this one isn't Flipper. I think Flipper's been dead for a number of years".

Mahi mahi, aka Dolphin Fish, aka Coryphaena hippurus is a fish. Dolphins are mammals. The name change is to stop confusion between two entirely different types of beings.

And mahi mahi is boring. Gimmie a good trout over that any day!
 
Mahi mahi, aka Dolphin Fish, aka Coryphaena hippurus is a fish. Dolphins are mammals. The name change is to stop confusion between two entirely different types of beings.

And mahi mahi is boring. Gimmie a good trout over that any day!
Or a Brooklyn perch, fresh outta da East Rivah. Like buttah, comes wid ribs and some spermicidal lubricant.
 
blue

When I was very young, I asked a teacher why the sky was blue. He told me that it was reflecting the color of the sky. In retrospect, i wonder if he was an idiot or just pulling my leg. Either way, it did me great damage - I decided then and there that teachers were useless, and generally ignored them. I might have been better off if I had paid a bit more attention in school, actually...

Since that moment, i have often asked people why the sky is blue. Their answers are often... illuminating. it's amazing how little people understand the world around us. Worst of all are the ones who *think* they know. Seriosuly: Anyone who tells a little kid "The sky is blue because of Rayleigh scattering" has not answered the question at all.

The trick of course, is that kids don't really care why the sky is blue, they care why it has a color at all! Mostly, kids are asking you "Why can I see the sky if it's made of air, which I usually can't see?"

Remember that the next time you're talking to kid - otherwise, she might end up ignoring her studies!
 
Pressure from ice skates causes the ice to melt making it easy to skate.

Reading in low light hurts your eyes.

Sitting too close to the TV will expose you to excessive radiation. (7th grade science teacher)

glenn
 
So, why does the sky look blue?
Rayleigh scattering is when atmospheric particles smaller than the wavelenght of light cause it to deflect away from us on the surface of the planet. Thus blue light at about 300 nm is not deflected and the higher ones are.
Of course on Vulcan, the sky is orange and the particles in the atmosphere must be different.
On planet X, they have no particles and the sky is puce.
 
Rayleigh scattering is when atmospheric particles smaller than the wavelenght[sic] of light cause it to deflect away from us on the surface of the planet. Thus blue light at about 300 nm is not deflected and the higher ones are.

That isn't correct.
 
Rayleigh scattering is when atmospheric particles smaller than the wavelength of light cause it to deflect away from us on the surface of the planet. Thus blue light at about 300 nm is not deflected and the higher ones are.
Of course on Vulcan, the sky is orange and the particles in the atmosphere must be different.
On planet X, they have no particles and the sky is puce.

That isn't correct.

Robinson is right. Jeff got it the wrong way round. We see the scattered light. Hence at dusk and dawn the sun is red. We see only the light that is not scattered. Reference http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rayleigh_scattering
 
Dammit, Jim. I'm just an old country doctor, not a quantum mechanic. At least I corrected the original flub with a valid link.
 
Mahi mahi, aka Dolphin Fish, aka Coryphaena hippurus is a fish. Dolphins are mammals. The name change is to stop confusion between two entirely different types of beings.

And mahi mahi is boring. Gimmie a good trout over that any day!

Yes, thanks, but I'm pretty sure everyone here already knew the difference between the fish and the mammal. Back when I was a kid, the fish was commonly called "dolphin" on menues. It was only in the '70's when restaurants started calling it "mahi-mahi" because of the "save the whales" trend. I've even had wait-staff tell me in all seriousness that mahi-mahi is "flipper".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom