How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

The electrons move around very quickly, but this is random thermal motion. Their drift velocity is, as DRBUZZ0 says, small.
 
Some wrong things I was taught:

Eating immediately before swimming causes "cramps," with dangerous or even lethal consequences.

Marching armies are always ordered to march out of step on bridges, lest the resonance of a synchronized march destroy the bridge. (Mythbusters looked at this one.)

Bicycles stay upright because the wheels act as gyroscopes.

Water puts out fires by smothering them.

"Electronic brain" is an apt description of a digital computer.

If you fall from a great height, you're already dead (or at least, in some versions, unconscious) by the time you reach the ground because "it's the fall itself that kills you." (Though I never actually believed this one.)

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
"there is no gravity in space" or the concept that astronauts are weightless because they are away from the earth. This would be true in very deep space, but it's because they are in orbit and their bodies have the same momentum as the shuttle which is 'falling' around the earth. I had this misconception when I was much younger.

I still hear reports which say such things as "Tritium waste will be radioactive for about 12 years." This clearly does not understand the concept of half-life but seems to be somewhat common.

Marie Curie discovered radiation - false, she discovered radium, and how to extract it from pitchblende. She also discovered polonium. These two substances were the first highly radioactive isotopes available for experimentation and they were vital to understanding radiation. She also contributed to the understanding of particle radiation, but she did NOT discover radiation itself. That had been known about since roentgen and later been shown to exist in pitchblende.

Henry Fold was the first to use the assembly line - No. It had been used by manufacturers. Even cars had been made this way, with the Oldsmobile. However, it was on a small scare. Ford was the first to introduce a large mass-production assembly-line system for low-cost cars. Not to take away that, but it wasn't the first.

AC Power travels over long distances better than DC - False! False! This has been taught many times that it's because AC power is inherently better in that manner. All things being equal, DC will actually do better because it does have have the same issues of impedance and "skin effect" or other conductor problems. AC is superior because it can easily be converted to high voltage and then back down to more usable and safe voltage using a simple inductive transformer. DC must be generated, distributed and used at the same voltage, which is very limited.

(note, that's not as true today with solid-state inverters and DC-DC voltage converters, but for a long time it was just about impossible)
 
"there is no gravity in space" or the concept that astronauts are weightless because they are away from the earth. This would be true in very deep space, ...

Nope. There is always gravity.
 
Last edited:
Nope. There is always gravity.

Clarify: In deep space away from the influences of major bodies gravity would be negligible. You could float around in your spacecraft even if it weren't orbiting something or on a trajectory of some sort with equal acceleratiion to yourself...
 
Eating immediately before swimming causes "cramps," with dangerous or even lethal consequences.

To be fair, eating before any exercise isn't such a great idea because you are likely to get a stitch because blood will be focussed on the digestive system and not available for the exercise and probably upset your stomach because all the food is being bounced around in it. It won't be lethal, but it's not especially pleasant. Of course, it depends on the exact definition of "before". Eating a three course meal and then immediately doing a triathlon wouldn't be sensible, but going for a gentle swim half an hour after a normal meal would probably be fine.

Marching armies are always ordered to march out of step on bridges, lest the resonance of a synchronized march destroy the bridge. (Mythbusters looked at this one.)

I don't know about what armies are ordered, but look up the Millenium Bridge in the UK to see a great example of what can happen when everyone walks in step.
 
Marching armies are always ordered to march out of step on bridges, lest the resonance of a synchronized march destroy the bridge. (Mythbusters looked at this one.)

My problem with their analysis of that was they only looked at resonance, and not at momentary load. For bridges when this mattered(I remember hearing about how when the Brooklyn bridge was built they did not do that to show how strong the bridge was).

So break step might well have prevented bridges from falling but it was not a resonance effect, but that when your foot comes down it applies a lot more force than is the average.
 
To be fair, eating before any exercise isn't such a great idea because you are likely to get a stitch because blood will be focussed on the digestive system and not available for the exercise and probably upset your stomach because all the food is being bounced around in it. It won't be lethal, but it's not especially pleasant. Of course, it depends on the exact definition of "before". Eating a three course meal and then immediately doing a triathlon wouldn't be sensible, but going for a gentle swim half an hour after a normal meal would probably be fine.
When you eat, blood is shunted to the gut to collect the absorbed nutrients. However, skeletal muscle will get plenty when it is needed. In addition, it wouldn't be the gut that cramped, it would be muscles that were running on less O2 than they they needed, thus switching to anaerobic metabolism. From Wiki
During intense exercise, aerobic metabolism cannot produce ATP quickly enough to supply the demands of the muscle. As a result, anaerobic metabolism becomes the dominant energy producing pathway as it can form ATP at high rates. Due to the large amounts of ATP being produced and hydrolysed in a short period of time, the buffering systems of the tissues are overcome, causing pH to fall and creating a state of acidosis. This may be one factor, among many, that contributes to the acute muscular discomfort experienced shortly after intense exercise
You can get gas pains, actually. Cramping usually refers to muscle and is therefore a misnomer. What happens is the digestion is slowed as the body diverts attention to skeletal muscle. When food takes longer to transit the gut, and depending on which foods because some produce more gas than others, you can get gas expanding in the intestine and it can cause mild to severe abdominal pain.

It is more likely to happen when you go swimming or do any exercise right after eating. Which foods you eat is as important as exercising after eating, but strenuous activity does slow the gut as part of the cascade of events. I don't believe it would prevent your muscles from working and is unlikely to increase the risk of drowning by much. But it is a frequently misunderstood phenomena as evidenced by the posts in this thread.

I don't know about what armies are ordered, but look up the Millenium Bridge in the UK to see a great example of what can happen when everyone walks in step.
And the stepping just happens to match the bridge "tuning". Millennium Bridge
 
My problem with their analysis of that was they only looked at resonance, and not at momentary load. For bridges when this mattered(I remember hearing about how when the Brooklyn bridge was built they did not do that to show how strong the bridge was).

So break step might well have prevented bridges from falling but it was not a resonance effect, but that when your foot comes down it applies a lot more force than is the average.
It was proven to be resonance with Galloping Gertie in Tacoma. Did they prove the resonance in London or just hypothesize it?
 
It was proven to be resonance with Galloping Gertie in Tacoma. Did they prove the resonance in London or just hypothesize it?

I am not familiar with London, but of course Galloping Gertie was a special case.

I just never liked the history and analysis of the marching breaking a bridge, because they only claimed to look at resonance, and sure resonance can be a problem, but having all those feet coming down at once you are getting momentary loading far higher than the weight of people, likely by a factor of say 3 or 4 at least.

Add to that the relatively poor state of many early bridges(at a historic recreation I used to work at there was record of a bridge that washed away every spring for several years)

I just really do not like how the Myth-Busters handled that myth.
 
Clarify: In deep space away from the influences of major bodies gravity would be negligible.

Nope. There isn't any known deep space that has negligible gravity. There isn't even a theoretical place that has "negligible gravity". At least in the way you are talking about it.
 
Last edited:
Nope. There isn't any known deep space that has negligible gravity. There isn't even a theoretical place that has "negligible gravity". At least in the way you are talking about it.

I think you know what I am talking about. If you are floating around in a capsule, and you're not in inter-galactic space, then it's not because you are away from the influence of gravity but because you and the capsul have the same acceleration. I suppose even in inter-galactic space you would be pulled toward the nearest galaxy

But eh.. fine. I guess that was not clear and that's not really my point, given that nobody has been further than lunar orbit anyways
 
I can't comment on that paper with any kind of intelligent reply since it is beyond my knowledge level in physics. I can't even tell whether the author is merely suggesting resonance is an oversimplified explanation and as such it is incorrect, or whether he is concluding resonance is an oversimplified explanation but regardless it is entirely incorrect.

If he is arguing the latter, then I'd need to know if his hypothesis has replaced the resonance hypothesis among the experts. Just because someone presents an alternate hypothesis doesn't mean the consensus changes. And after all, consensus is the best you get with pure science. Proof, to my knowledge is a mathematical concept. As such, your correction of my liberal use of the term, "proven", is noted. I stand corrected.

If he is arguing the former, then your correction of my liberal use of the term, "proven", is also noted. But it's a little nit-picky for a casual conversation. OTOH, I've suggested we be more precise in our discussions of science. I will try to purge "proven" from my causal discussions of scientific research. Feel free to remind me I said this.

:D


BTW, Gertie sure looks like a vibrating string in the film of it's demise.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom