How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?


As they conclude
Could this be called a resonant phenomenon? It would appear not to contradict the qualitative definition of resonance quoted earlier, if we now identify the source of the periodic impulses as self-induced, the wind supplying the power, and the motion supplying the power-tapping mechanism. If one wishes to argue, however, that it was a case of externally forced linear resonance, the mathematical distinction between Eqs (1) and (3) is quite clear, self-excited systems differing strongly enough from ordinary linear resonant ones. The texts we have consulted have not gone this far in explanation.

It was a matter of matching periods causing large oscillations, which is what people generally are thinking of when they say resonance. It's just that most physics textbooks do a poor job of explaining what those periods were from, if they offer any explanation at all.
 
As they conclude


It was a matter of matching periods causing large oscillations, which is what people generally are thinking of when they say resonance. It's just that most physics textbooks do a poor job of explaining what those periods were from, if they offer any explanation at all.

That is what I understood, out of it. It can be seen as some form of resonance (sort of), but not the usual kind they refer to in textbooks (especially not like the kind a "marching army" could theoretically generate, which is part of why the Mythbusters' experiment could not reproduce the a Tacoma Narrow bridge like collapse). I just like to point this out ever since the prof in a Dynamic Systems class I took back as an undergrad mentioned out that the usual resonance explanation did not hold water, and that viewed as a chaotic system (through that self-excitation mentioned in the link), it made perfect sense.

/next, I'll mention that the usual definition of life expectancy is BS too
 
Nope. From here, the freezing point decreases by 0.0073 Kelvin per atmosphere.

A 100 kg person has about 1000 Newtons of force to exert. An atmosphere is 101325 Newtons per square metre. To exert 100 atmospheres, reducing the freezing point by a mere 0.73 degrees, with standard 1/8" (3mm) skate blade, there would have to be only 1.2" (31mm) of skate in contact with the ice. They'd never be able to keep upright with that little distance.
My daughter's figure skate blades are curved, not flat. I wonder just how much of the blade is in contact with the ice at any given time. I think I'll give it a look-see.
 
Wrong. Cathode rays are not emitted. X-rays, and visible light can be, but the stream of electrons (Cathode rays) does not leave the tube. This is a good thing.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cathode_rays

No, not wrong.
e·mit(-mt)
tr.v. e·mit·ted, e·mit·ting, e·mits
1. To give or send out (matter or energy)

Electrons (cathode rays) are emitted from an element at one end of the tube. If you're going to be pedantic at least try to be right.
 
As they conclude


It was a matter of matching periods causing large oscillations, which is what people generally are thinking of when they say resonance. It's just that most physics textbooks do a poor job of explaining what those periods were from, if they offer any explanation at all.

The problem is that getting an understanding of the real effects is very hard because they are very complicated.

I remember hearing in one physics class that the solution that they got was mostly by luck correct because they did not have the computers to do effective modeling at the time and really see exactly what was going on.

So is this a case of an older explanation that is not as correct as modern explanations holding on?
 
As recently as the 50s medical texts claimed masturbation was unhealthy and dangerous.

I think a statistical analysis comparing curve direction of the penis vs. handedness of the owner would be quite shocking.
 
Well, the existence of the dinosaur identified as Brontosaurus certainly isn't in dispute. What's in dispute is whether it's distinct enough from a previously discovered species of Apatosaurus to go into a separate genus. This is a taxonomic issue, and hence more a matter of deciding the most sensible convention than of the correctness of the science involved.
Yes and no. I feel that having the wrong skull on the mounted skeleton for nearly 70 years might make the name a little less valid than that. :p
 
In a sorta-related topic, there's several things which teachers teach which aren't strictly true, but are good approximations. Like in Primary school (sorry non-Brits, not sure what the local equivalent is), pupils do an experiment where they weigh a lump of plasticene, then change its shape, then weigh it again. So we say, look - weight is constant. Then later we tell them, actually, its mass that is constant, weight varies with gravitational field strength. Then later mass is not constant, but depends on the velocity of the observer, but energy is constant.

On the other hand, from the definitely-not-true-file, I'm pretty sure its still taught that living things are either plants or animals.
 
In a sorta-related topic, there's several things which teachers teach which aren't strictly true, but are good approximations. Like in Primary school (sorry non-Brits, not sure what the local equivalent is), pupils do an experiment where they weigh a lump of plasticene, then change its shape, then weigh it again. So we say, look - weight is constant. Then later we tell them, actually, its mass that is constant, weight varies with gravitational field strength. Then later mass is not constant, but depends on the velocity of the observer, but energy is constant.

On the other hand, from the definitely-not-true-file, I'm pretty sure its still taught that living things are either plants or animals.

Energy, or mass-energy, varies with velocity. Rest mass is a constant for a particle, and the energy of a particle stays the same so long as it doesn't do anything.

ponderingturtle said:
The problem is that getting an understanding of the real effects is very hard because they are very complicated.

I remember hearing in one physics class that the solution that they got was mostly by luck correct because they did not have the computers to do effective modeling at the time and really see exactly what was going on.

So is this a case of an older explanation that is not as correct as modern explanations holding on?

The issue in the paper is that there is a particular sort of 2nd order differential equation taught to physics students, and it's response to a sinusoidal force at it's natural frequency is called resonance. In addition to the mass and restoring force, there's a damping coefficient, which can be 0, leading to infinitely large oscillations, or positive, leading to large but finite oscillations.

What happened with the bridge, though, was a particular mode reacted to the more-or-less constant wind, and effectively had a negative damping coefficient. Physics books don't mention negative damping coefficients, as generally they don't happen. However, they mention that resonance destroyed the bridge, so students are left with the general impression that the wind was somehow sinusoidal, which it wasn't. Some go into more detail, mentioning that a constant wind can shed vortices to create a periodic force, but that wasn't what happened either.
 
Something I was taught that was wrong:

The myth: The winter that George Washington camped at Valley Forge was the worst on record, and many soldiers died there of frostbite as a result.

The Truth: The following winter, when he camped at Jockey Hollow, NJ, was much worse. And although frostbite was a problem at Valley Forge, diseases like dysentary were worse. And the number of people who died at Valley Forge that winter? Zero.
 
I remember being told at school -- and shown a demonstration -- that a candle placed in a bell jar placed in a vat of water causes the water level to rise because it has consumed that volume of oxygen.
 
No, the reason why water is drawn up inside the jar is quite different. There are two effects that occur that are not described in the explanation provided:

1. While the candle burns, bubbling from underneath the jar can be seen.
2. The water is drawn up into the jar a few seconds after the candle has gone out.

What actually happens is that the candle, while burning, heats the air in the jar, causing it to expand. A little escapes from under the jar, as is shown by the bubbling. The candle indeed consumes the available oxygen and is extinguished. With the candle out, the air inside the jar cools, and contracts, reducing the pressure inside. Atmospheric pressure then drives the water level inside the jar above that of the vat.

This can be shown by using three or more candles. As might be expected, they consume the oxygen at three times the rate. However, they heat the air more, causing more expansion, and making the water level rise more afterwards that it did with a single candle. This effect is not explainable under the original theory.
 
Did Carroll explicitly state that this was the inspiration for the Mad Hatter? I'm always sceptical of things that sound like retrospective explanations for things.

The expression "mad as a hatter" (and also "mad as a March Hare") long predate Carroll... I think there are citations and examples going back to the 1700s. Basically, it was a live and active cliche at the time.....
 
No, the reason why water is drawn up inside the jar is quite different. There are two effects that occur that are not described in the explanation provided:

1. While the candle burns, bubbling from underneath the jar can be seen.
2. The water is drawn up into the jar a few seconds after the candle has gone out.

If air escapes then the experiment is not being done right. Assume no air is transfered, as that is no important, nor part of the experiment.

Yes, the water rises after the flame goes out.

What actually happens is that the candle, while burning, heats the air in the jar, causing it to expand. A little escapes from under the jar, as is shown by the bubbling.

No, ignore that. It doesn't cause the effect.

The candle indeed consumes the available oxygen and is extinguished. With the candle out, the air inside the jar cools, and contracts, reducing the pressure inside. Atmospheric pressure then drives the water level inside the jar above that of the vat.

No. That isn't the reason.

This can be shown by using three or more candles. As might be expected, they consume the oxygen at three times the rate. However, they heat the air more, causing more expansion, and making the water level rise more afterwards that it did with a single candle. This effect is not explainable under the original theory.

I'm not sure about that, but the same experiment can be done with burning paper, or other carbon sources, (hydrocarbons). It works even if no air escapes through the water. In fact, if that happens, the experiment is invalid.

The burning (oxidation) results in O2 becoming CO2 and H2O. The CO2 and heated H2O (water vapor) pushes the water level down. When the flame goes out, the H2O condenses rapidly on the glass, reducing the pressure, which results in the water level rising.

We used to use this fact to suck a hard boiled egg into a bottle. Light paper, drop in bottle, place egg in bottle mouth. When the flame goes out, the drop in pressure will result in the egg being pushed into the bottle. Pop! We loved that trick as kids.

Still a crowd pleaser. ;)
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure about that, but the same experiment can be done with burning paper, or other carbon sources, (hydrocarbons). It works even if no air escapes through the water. In fact, if that happens, the experiment is invalid.

The burning (oxidation) results in O2 becoming CO2 and H2O. The CO2 and heated H2O (water vapor) pushes the water level down. When the flame goes out, the H2O condenses rapidly on the glass, reducing the pressure, which results in the water level rising.

We used to use this fact to suck a hard boiled egg into a bottle. Light paper, drop in bottle, place egg in bottle mouth. When the flame goes out, the drop in pressure will result in the egg being pushed into the bottle. Pop! We loved that trick as kids.

Still a crowd pleaser. ;)

Ok, I'm interested in getting to the bottom of this one. I always figured the same thing as BillC, that a change in pressure inside the container caused gas to be removed when it was heated, and then the cooling allowed water to rise to make the differece.

Robinson's way sounds plausible, however I've never seen that much water vapour inside the container when I've done this (in fact, I just did it then, and couldn't see any condensate at all) and wouldn't think the change in gases would account for that much of a rise in water, which is fairly significant.

How could I go about testing Bill's and my hypothesis against Robinsons? Anybody got any links for this one?

Athon
 
There are several variations you can do.
1. BillC's method depends on air escaping. If you force some air out of the container before the candle burns then no air can escape. Then when the candle goes out if BullC is right nothing will happen. If Robinson is right then the water will still rise.

2. Instead of using a candle use a light bulb. That will heat up the air. When you then turn the bulb off the water would rise if BillC is right. If Robinson is right nothing will happen. However to make the air rise by 10% of the height of the container the air would need to heat up by over 27C. That is a lot.

3. You could use pure oxygen instead of air. Then the water should fill the container if BillC is right or you will see lots of bubbles if Robinson is right.

Using several candles will make no difference to the results for either method.
 
There are several variations you can do.
1. BillC's method depends on air escaping. If you force some air out of the container before the candle burns then no air can escape. Then when the candle goes out if BullC is right nothing will happen. If Robinson is right then the water will still rise.

2. Instead of using a candle use a light bulb. That will heat up the air. When you then turn the bulb off the water would rise if BillC is right. If Robinson is right nothing will happen. However to make the air rise by 10% of the height of the container the air would need to heat up by over 27C. That is a lot.

3. You could use pure oxygen instead of air. Then the water should fill the container if BillC is right or you will see lots of bubbles if Robinson is right.

Using several candles will make no difference to the results for either method.


Excellent. I'll see what I can do with this next week.

Athon
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom