How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

No one has mentioned Mythbusters yet.
Ehhh... I really wouldn't trust them to get a complete picture either. I would bet you a $100.00 that you have come in contact with one of the free energy devices they busted.:D :D :D :D :D
I am not familiar with London, but of course Galloping Gertie was a special case.

I just never liked the history and analysis of the marching breaking a bridge, because they only claimed to look at resonance, and sure resonance can be a problem, but having all those feet coming down at once you are getting momentary loading far higher than the weight of people, likely by a factor of say 3 or 4 at least.

Add to that the relatively poor state of many early bridges(at a historic recreation I used to work at there was record of a bridge that washed away every spring for several years)

I just really do not like how the Myth-Busters handled that myth.
Actually, they did really confirm the myth when they busted Tesla's earthquake machine. Oddly enough that little weight was resonating with the bridge. The problem being that the dampening factor involved would always cancel out some of the energy in the vibrations so you can't actually reach the point of fatal catastrophe.
"if a fat man and a skinny man coast down a hill on bicycles, the fat man arrives at the bottom first"
Ummmm... This is true if we are talking about real life. Otherwise in an ideal world it's not going to happen.
Unless I've finally lost it, it's "red". The shade will vary depending upon oxygenation levels (I think); I've seen very deep red, all the way to scarlet.
What am I looking at that is blue then in my wrist? Why are bruises blue? Why does your face turn blue when you hold your breath? In all seriousness that's why everyone thinks blood is blue. Is that just the color of the veins?
AC Power travels over long distances better than DC - False! False! This has been taught many times that it's because AC power is inherently better in that manner. All things being equal, DC will actually do better because it does have have the same issues of impedance and "skin effect" or other conductor problems. AC is superior because it can easily be converted to high voltage and then back down to more usable and safe voltage using a simple inductive transformer. DC must be generated, distributed and used at the same voltage, which is very limited.
My boss told me there are places that use DC power. Boston had a place that still used DC power until very recently (There is a reason why you never give out lifetime contracts).
We are skeptics, NAME ANY contribution to art/science or what societal advantages any African country has ever given to fellow mankind?
There was an African king here in Boston a year ago for an opening of an exhibit in the Musuem of Fine Arts.
electricity is not the motion at the speed of light of electrons but of the electrical potential. The electrons move a lot slower, depending on the conductor, if at all. In AC they just kinda vibrate a bit. Not really a flow of them.
I can't really tell if this is similar to the toothpaste tube analogy. You push the toothpaste at one end and then you have toothpaste come out the other end. The electrons bump into each other.
 
Last edited:
Ok, I'm interested in getting to the bottom of this one. I always figured the same thing as BillC, that a change in pressure inside the container caused gas to be removed when it was heated, and then the cooling allowed water to rise to make the differece.

Robinson's way sounds plausible, however I've never seen that much water vapour inside the container when I've done this (in fact, I just did it then, and couldn't see any condensate at all) and wouldn't think the change in gases would account for that much of a rise in water, which is fairly significant.

How could I go about testing Bill's and my hypothesis against Robinsons? Anybody got any links for this one?

Athon
When I read Robinson's reply, I had a go at testing it, but was not able to make any definitive judgements. I did however think that shouldn't the evolved CO2 and O2 have the same volume as each other?

On googling, I found a link to the experiment may be found at Robert Krampf's Experiment of the Week. His explanation is the same as mine and Athon's -- which of course does not prove that it is the right one. I would be interested in knowing.
 
You owe me $100. :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D :D
I'm assuming that you have no clue what Im talking about. Basically, one of the devices the Mythbusters tested on the free energy episode is exactly how passive RFID chips work. Passive RFID chips have no energy source. They get their energy exactly in the same way that the giant antenna supplied voltage from radio waves. Remember Adam said that 1 volt isn't enough to do anything useful. He was wrong. Now technically speaking it wasn't even a free energy device to start with but it was lumped in with the Bedini motor. So yeah you own me a $100.00 :):):)
 
Last edited:
"if a fat man and a skinny man coast down a hill on bicycles, the fat man arrives at the bottom first"

Ummmm... This is true if we are talking about real life. Otherwise in an ideal world it's not going to happen.
What do you mean? I don't guess you're talking about Utopian political structure or any such thing. . . .maybe in a vacuum (or ignoring some force)?

Re: marching on bridges and the resonance question--

Do the same issue apply to collapse of structures (like cantilevered mezzanine dance floors) in discos? I'd think this is a more common failure situation because it's probably easier to overstructure a bridge (especially with regards to pedestrian traffic) whereas discos very often get to and beyond their "maximum occupancy"--and then having everyone moving in time.

For clarity, the alternative theory to "resonance" is just everyone contributing their bit of force at the same time, like when sailors all "heave ho!" on a rope at the same time or hospital staff transferring an unconscious patient do a "1, 2, 3 lift", isn't it?
 
There's this gem: Humans only use 10% of their brains.
What does that even mean?

This came from the fact that scientists discovered that only about 10% of the actual mass is used for thinking. People jumped on this claiming we would be so much smarter if we would quit being so lazy and use the other 90%.

Unfortunately, the other 90% is the life support system for the 10%, it can't be used in the manner they think it can.
 
When I read Robinson's reply, I had a go at testing it, but was not able to make any definitive judgements. I did however think that shouldn't the evolved CO2 and O2 have the same volume as each other?

On googling, I found a link to the experiment may be found at Robert Krampf's Experiment of the Week. His explanation is the same as mine and Athon's -- which of course does not prove that it is the right one. I would be interested in knowing.

1 O2 -> 1 CO2 does keep the number of gas molecules constant, and this does mean the system should return to the same pressure. However, unless you are burning pure carbon, such as graphite, diamonds, or types of charcoal, there will be a lot of 1 O2 -> 2 H2O. This water vapour increases the number of gas molecules at first, but it will condense very quickly and create a vacuum.

I'd guess that the condensation mostly balances the extra pressure of the hot and more numerous gas molecules, until the candle goes out. I haven't tried it to see if it bubbles, though.

JoeTheJuggler said:
What do you mean? I don't guess you're talking about Utopian political structure or any such thing. . . .maybe in a vacuum (or ignoring some force)?

He means that in the real world, heavier vehicles coast down hills faster than lighter vehicles. Offhand, I'd give two reasons. First, the fat guy has a lot more mass, but only a little more surface area. This means he experiences proportionally less drag than the thin guy. Second, the fat guy has a larger normal force, and I think this helps by giving him a smother ride, so energy isn't lost in vibration.

Regarding discos: buildings aren't built to handle resonating loads. It's generally a force like "75 lbs per square foot" (a complete guess for discos), plus the weight of the floor itself. Good construction is really difficult to destroy with a static load. A resonating load, like a crowd trying to bound up and down in time with the floor, would require a much stronger floor.

A crowd working together once, like your sailors on a rope, wouldn't be that bad. Materials need a lot of energy to break apart, and the large-but-brief force of a person jumping once doesn't actually have all that much energy. It might dent the floor, but breaking it entirely requires either a huge force, capable of transferring huge energies even over short times, or a resonating force, which slowly adds energy until it becomes too much.
 
He means that in the real world, heavier vehicles coast down hills faster than lighter vehicles. Offhand, I'd give two reasons. First, the fat guy has a lot more mass, but only a little more surface area. This means he experiences proportionally less drag than the thin guy.

Does this explain the science behind how the railroads weigh freight cars? They let them coast down a track that has a dip to it. The cars coast up the other side. The know the weight. How?
 
Does this explain the science behind how the railroads weigh freight cars? They let them coast down a track that has a dip to it. The cars coast up the other side. The know the weight. How?

If freight cars have a really consistent coefficient of friction, I guess that would work. They would return to a height be equal to the initial height, minus a constant friction term, minus an air resistance term inversely proportional to mass. The further up it gets, the more it weighs.
 
zero gravityThere's more, go to the link.

It appears we are both correct depending on whether we are talking about apparent weight or true weight.
As it happens, sg is right, at least according to relativity- but not for the reasons given in her quote.

In the quote, it is asserted that the feeling of weightlessness- that is, apparent weight of zero- is due to the opposition of the centrifugal acceleration of the orbit to the force of gravity. In fact, the matter is much simpler than that. You must always remember that in relativity, forces are local phenomena, measured by local experimentation. You can measure an inertial path and decide whether you are being accelerated or not, by releasing an object without exerting any force on it. If it moves, then you are being accelerated. If it does not, then you are not. In a gravity field, the path of inertial movement is toward the source of the gravity field, accelerating all the way. Anything not experiencing local acceleration is not experiencing a force in its own frame of reference, no matter what someone in some other frame thinks they see.

We see from this that if you do not locally experience acceleration, then you cannot be under the influence of a force. If you are inertial, and accelerating relative to another inertial observer, then you are in a gravity field. Gravity fields warp space and time so that the spacetime path of an inertial object is not a straight line. The spacetime path of an inertial object is called a geodesic and in a gravity field, all geodesics are curved by the field, either in space or in time or both. It is only with respect to an inertial observer outside the field, or an accelerated observer inside the field, that you appear to accelerate. To another inertial observer inside the field, you may appear to move, but you will not accelerate.

Now, this is only strictly true in the case of a non-existent entity called a "planar gravity field." Real gravity fields in our universe are not planar; they are spherical, and surround objects, approximately appearing to emanate from their centers of mass, and with the degree of curvature (which is classically described as "the strength of the force") falling off as the square of the distance. Thus, two inertial and comoving objects some distance apart perpendicular to the geodesics will appear to move toward each other as they move closer to the source of the field; and two objects some distance apart parallel to the geodesics will appear to accelerate away from each other, because their accelerations will be different due to the inverse square law of all spherical effects. This last effect, of course, is produced by the difference in the curvature of time between the two objects.

This approach is relativity, and has been shown to be a much more effective theory of gravitation than the one involving the "force" of gravity and all that classical mechanics that makes assumptions about absolute motion and things like that that you can't measure. Relativity asserts that there is no absolute motion, only absolute acceleration- and proves it because you can't measure absolute motion, but you CAN measure absolute acceleration.
 
Last edited:
I think you know what I am talking about. If you are floating around in a capsule, and you're not in inter-galactic space, then it's not because you are away from the influence of gravity but because you and the capsul have the same acceleration. I suppose even in inter-galactic space you would be pulled toward the nearest galaxy

But eh.. fine. I guess that was not clear and that's not really my point, given that nobody has been further than lunar orbit anyways
Robinson is right. It's like saying, "and tomorrow, there will be no weather."
 
What do you mean? I don't guess you're talking about Utopian political structure or any such thing. . . .maybe in a vacuum (or ignoring some force)?
Well real life as in not ignoring friction. Even in a vacuum the fact man would still win.
He means that in the real world, heavier vehicles coast down hills faster than lighter vehicles. Offhand, I'd give two reasons. First, the fat guy has a lot more mass, but only a little more surface area. This means he experiences proportionally less drag than the thin guy. Second, the fat guy has a larger normal force, and I think this helps by giving him a smother ride, so energy isn't lost in vibration.
I was thinking about friction when I wrote that. As I pointed out above even in a vacuum the fat man would still win namly because of the normal force which would overcome the frictional force faster.
 
Last edited:
Well real life as in not ignoring friction.
<snip>
I was thinking about friction when I wrote that. As I pointed out above even in a vacuum the fat man would still win namly because of the normal force which would overcome the frictional force faster.

Thanks--I didn't know what the difference between "real world" and "ideal world" meant. It was ignoring or not ignoring friction.
 
Hmmm, actually I think it's the skinny guy; rolling friction on his tires will be less. That's because the deformation of his tires will be less, because he puts less weight on them, which reduces the contact patch, which reduces the friction. Look here.
 
Hmmm, actually I think it's the skinny guy; rolling friction on his tires will be less. That's because the deformation of his tires will be less, because he puts less weight on them, which reduces the contact patch, which reduces the friction. Look here.

By first approximation, rolling friction is like sliding friction: proportional to the normal force. The normal force and the force causing acceleration (a vector component of gravity), are both proportional to mass. The mass cancels out, and they should accelerate at the same rate.
 
Hmmm, actually I think it's the skinny guy; rolling friction on his tires will be less. That's because the deformation of his tires will be less, because he puts less weight on them, which reduces the contact patch, which reduces the friction. Look here.
You know. Surface area and friction is one of those contraversial areas that I'm not entirly sure if it's correct. If you go by a straight physics formula then it shouldn't matter. Oddly enough though my physics book also mentions that other factors are in play.
 
"How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?"

1,765,234,664,587



No, after this one it is

1,765,234,664,588
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom