How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

My father swears that when he was in grade school that his teacher explained that the cause of thunder was the big rain clouds bumping into eachother and the lightning was the friction sparks, like if you bang to rocks together. He said he took this as fact and didn't really question it for years.

I remember being taught that the earth's shadow is what makes the moon wane and wax. That is only true during lunar eclipses, but it was said to always be true.

In the 5th grade I was once very upset by a teacher who would not believe me about nailguns. I mentioned something about a hammer and then siad something about a nailgun being faster. She asked what that was and I said "You know... it automatically puts the nails in" she insisted I was confused and that I was thinking of a drill/electric screwdriver. I insisted "No, I don't mean screws. It just pounds the nails in with air pressure" but she made me look like a fool by insisting such a thing did not exist. I hold a grudge to this day.
 

Nope. From here, the freezing point decreases by 0.0073 Kelvin per atmosphere.

A 100 kg person has about 1000 Newtons of force to exert. An atmosphere is 101325 Newtons per square metre. To exert 100 atmospheres, reducing the freezing point by a mere 0.73 degrees, with standard 1/8" (3mm) skate blade, there would have to be only 1.2" (31mm) of skate in contact with the ice. They'd never be able to keep upright with that little distance. To melt ice at a realistic temperature, like -5 C, would require more like 1000 atmospheres, and would need the skater to be balanced on a square thinner than the thickness of their blades.

So a woman in stiletto high heels might get 100 atmospheres, but unless she's skating on the point, pressure won't be helping her melt ice.

Given that people slide on ice while wearing boots, the slipperiness of ice is clearly not due to pressure melting. As usual, wikipedia has an excellent summary. Even better is their link.

From that link
Sliding temperatures of ice skates

Colbeck-SC; Najarian-I; Smith-HB, American-Journal-of-Physics. vol.65, no.6; June 1997; p.488-92

Abstract: The two theories developed to explain the low friction of ice, pressure melting and frictional heating, require opposite temperature shifts at the ice-skate interface. The arguments against pressure melting are strong, but only theoretical. A set of direct temperature measurements shows that frictional heating is the dominant mechanism because temperature behaves in the manner predicted by the theory of frictional heating. Like snow skis, ice skates are warmed by sliding and then cool when the sliding stops. The temperature increases with speed and with thermal insulation. The sliding leaves a warm track on the ice surface behind the skate and the skate sprays warm ejecta.

Pressure melting and ice skating


Colbeck-SC, American-Journal-of-Physics. vol.63, no.10; Oct. 1995; p.888-90

Abstract: Pressure melting cannot be responsible for the low friction of ice. The pressure needed to reach the melting temperature is above the compressive failure stress and, if it did occur, high squeeze losses would result in very thin films. Pure liquid water cannot coexist with ice much below -20 degrees C at any pressure and friction does not increase suddenly in that range. If frictional heating and pressure melting contribute equally, the length of the wetted contact could not exceed 15 mu m at a speed of 5 m/s, which seems much too short. If pressure melting is the dominant process, the water films are less than 0.08 mu m thick because of the high pressures.
 
Last edited:
OK, here's one that's in the rather specific sub-category "something that is not factually wrong, people use the fact wrongly, because there are other relevant factors playing in." that I used to be taught in school:

60% of all accidents happen in the home (including small areas right outdoors like the lawn, or the outdoor steps).

This, I recall, was in fact backed up by some official statistics. The number often varies a bit (and I'm sure you'll have your own variant in your own respective countries). However, in the 8th grade (at the age of 14), I read an essay that demolished the message taken out from this fact: That we are more prone to accidents at home than elsewhere.

See, this essay - which I read in quite unrelated circumstances - mentioned another interesting fact: Most (Norwegian) people used to spend more than half their awake life at home.* The writer mentioned this because his point was that we were a rather boring people, but as you sharp readers have already figured out, what -I- got out of it was to put this next to the first stat that had been repeated into my spongy brain plenty of times, and from there I came to the conclusion that home is about as dangerous as other places, and that we should just be generally more careful, no matter where we are.

*Of course, this is probably a fact that isn't accurate in today's Norwegian society. Our habits with regards to going on concerts, cafes, etc. have changed rather drastically in the last 2 decades.
 
I bet the workers weren't all-white... :D

You know, Z, it's important to remember that the individual and the collective are two different things. Even if you could establish that one group is more likely to be successful at something than another. (and I'm saying hypothetically, I'm not saying that I think any group has any inherent talent over others... just if.. hypothetically)

That has absolutely nothing to do with each member of said group. It is only a generalization and an insulting and rather useless one to make. There are plenty of individuals who world unjustified way of putting one down.

It's a dangerous mindset because it is how many racists try to justify their agenda. "Oh I can show this stereotype is based in fact. it's not entirely false." So what? Even if it is true that X group has a 10% higher incidence of something than Y group that means absolutely nothing about my neighbor Joe or my coworker Ted.

Seriously, you make yourself look bad when that sort of rhetoric is getting thrown away. It ignores the history of how this mindset has lead to horrible injustices and denies an identity to those who you don't think look enough like you. Please stop.
 
Neither did I. I'm surprised none of the astronauts commented on that. I am also skeptical about some of the "science" in that article, such as "blue+yellow=green" and "green-blue=yellow". That is only partly true for subtractive color mixture (pigments in paint) and not at all for additive color mixture where red+green=yellow.
Actually, our sun produces light that peaks in the yellow range.
 
You know, Z, it's important to remember that the individual and the collective are two different things. Even if you could establish that one group is more likely to be successful at something than another. (and I'm saying hypothetically, I'm not saying that I think any group has any inherent talent over others... just if.. hypothetically)

That has absolutely nothing to do with each member of said group. It is only a generalization and an insulting and rather useless one to make. There are plenty of individuals who world unjustified way of putting one down.

It's a dangerous mindset because it is how many racists try to justify their agenda. "Oh I can show this stereotype is based in fact. it's not entirely false." So what? Even if it is true that X group has a 10% higher incidence of something than Y group that means absolutely nothing about my neighbor Joe or my coworker Ted.

Seriously, you make yourself look bad when that sort of rhetoric is getting thrown away. It ignores the history of how this mindset has lead to horrible injustices and denies an identity to those who you don't think look enough like you. Please stop.

What ARE you babbling about?


Ground Beast Samich started a racist rant about how Africans never contributed anything and were still living in mud huts while Europeans were conquering the world. In order to demonstrate something an African could do that a European couldn't (or didn't), I jokingly mentioned pyramids; which led to a posting of the Las Vegas pyramid resort. And I responded - again jokingly - that the construction crew was most likely not all white!

So what ARE you babbling about?

Clearly, GBS was attempting to infer that Africans haven't made major contributions to the world, and I'm pretty sure that this is not only false, but blatantly racist.

And the only Pyramids built that I knew of (until that post) were the South American and African pyramids, clearly build by non-whites; this casino-resort in Vegas (if it was designed by a caucasian) would be the first major pyramidal structure that I am aware of designed by a white. If it were also build by all-whites, I'd be VERY surprised - I'm pretty sure there's a lot of hispanic construction talent in Vegas, as well as plenty of african, asian, polynesian, etc.

OTOH, maybe it was a Family project, and every single worker was of Italian ancestry. I don't know. This IS Vegas, after all.

Anyway, near as I can tell, Buzz - you're babbling.

Sorry for the derail everyone.
 
All of us ultimately came from Africa, as Michael Shermer states, "I am an Irish, English,German, French, African, Native American."
Well, he didn't say it quite that way, but it sure works for me.
There even might be a Dane in the woodpile.
 
Anyway, near as I can tell, Buzz - you're babbling.

Sorry for the derail everyone.



Oh crap. Sorry I, for some stupid reason, got the OP of that crap confused with... oh nevermind. No... my bad. No not babble... just an error of who-said-what
 
Ah... no problem. Happens to the best of us.

(and I shouldn't have said 'babble' - obviously, you've rightly posted what should have been a good reply to GBS, but attributed quotes and such to me instead...)

Anyway, no harm, no foul, no blood.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom