How many things have we been taught were true but aren't?

And let's not forget the wondrous cleaning benefits of Benzene (in the lab) that was used outside of a hood, by hand.

:)
When I was in grade school, each classroom had one or more hand powered carbon-tet (CCl4) fire extinguishers.

Mostly used for paper fires in steel wastebaskets, and such.

Marvelous for the liver.:(
 
Henry Fold was the first to use the assembly line - No. It had been used by manufacturers. Even cars had been made this way, with the Oldsmobile. However, it was on a small scare. Ford was the first to introduce a large mass-production assembly-line system for low-cost cars. Not to take away that, but it wasn't the first.

Whether or not Henry Ford was the first to use the assembly line depends on how you define the idea of the assembly line.

What Henry Ford invented is more precisely called the moving assembly line. The key idea being that people stand still and the parts they need come to them. Setting these up was rather difficult, but was an important innovation.

The idea of a division of labour and an assembly line already existed. You can find it documented in various places, including one for pins in The Wealth of Nations by Adam Smith. However this was several times less efficient than what Henry Ford did because in previous arrangements most of your workers' time was spent walking around. In Ford's arrangement, no time was wasted in walking.
 
non-science is wrong, so conclude it is all bunk

science is wrong, so conclude we just had incomplete data at the time.

;)
 
My apologies for a drive-by provocative post followed by a month of being elsewhere. (New job and all that.)

Get a life dude, just look at the stats of fatal accidents with and without seatbelts.

I'm well aware of those statistics.

I'm sorry but this kind of woo is dangerous and frankly angers me having lost a loved one who wasn't wearing his seatbelt.

I'm sorry for your loss. It is unfortunately common. In fact I can come up with people I personally know who have died due to not using seatbelts (girl in my TA in highschool), are only alive because they wore seatbelts (my brother), killed a passenger who wasn't using a seatbelt (my father-in-law), survived a serious accident when not wearing a seatbelt (my mother while 8 months pregnant), and a pedestrian who was hit by a car (my sister's best friend). Please believe me when I say that we're in agreement that cars are dangerous, and seatbelts offer significant protection.

But that does not affect the validity of the paper's reasoning or make its conclusion woo. The paper claims that people have a fixed risk tolerance. If you make them feel safer, they'll become more aggressive. The question of whether the outcome of a safety measure results in fewer, more, or the same number of fatalities becomes an empirical question. The evidence summarized in that paper is that for safety measures where people's judgement is unimpaired, the result is that fatalities stay the same.

Anecdotally, were seatbelts less widely used, my brother probably would have died and my sister's best friend likely would still be alive.

I'm not sure I accept the data in this paper at face value but even if true it merely says So whether their figures are actual or the 1,000 was an estimate and the 200 the actual measurement, they still credit the seatbelts for saving 200 lives. And why were the back seat passengers still dying? Didn't they have seatbelts on? And we aren't told how many fatalities were passengers and how many were pedestrians. It could be the 1,000 was an estimate that would have been accurate if only back seat passengers had belts on too or had shoulder straps.

Apparently you didn't read the paper very closely.

1000 was the initial official estimate of lives saved in the UK. After an ongoing trend towards lower fatalities was factored in, the official estimate was revised downwards to 200. However the authors of the official estimate later acknowledged that they had failed to take into account the effects of a drunk driving campaign that was coincident with the seatbest law. When you look at the fatalities by hour of the day, the entire reduction over the general trend happened from 10 PM to 4 AM. Which is easily explainable by the drunk driving campaign, and is not explainable by general seatbelt legislation.

It is worth re-emphasizing a point that the paper had already made, which is that the UK is the only jurisdiction in which seatbelt use gave any evidence of reduction in overall fatalities. In 80 other jurisdictions no correlation was found. So the UK data should be viewed as an anomaly, and the existence of an alternate explanation for that data leaves no jurisdictions where fatality rates suggest that seatbelt laws save lives.

The author simply puts forth an hypothesis about increased high risk driving but the evidence doesn't address the details of the accidents that would actually test the hypothesis.

The example of seatbelt use is actually tangential to the point of that paper. If you're really interested in the research on seatbelt use, I would suggest following up the references in that paper.


And how about pedestrians like my sister's friend Pat? There is simply no way that seatbelts could have saved her, and there is a very real possibility that seatbelt use by a reckless driver contributed to her death.
 
Yet another of the responses on seatbelts.

Consider a car crash much loved by conspiracy nuts this side of the Atlantic:

100mph crash in a tunnel; Fayad and Diana in back seat, not wearing seat belts - killed; driver, not wearing seat belt - killed; bodyguard in front passenger seat, wearing seat belt - survives.

This might be relevant if I, or that paper, had ever claimed that seatbelts don't help you survive an accident. But we didn't. So it's not.

Next time I'd suggest that you read my capsule summary even if you don't want to go read the paper.
 
And another person who I hadn't gotten back to...

On the contrary, studies show that wearing a seat belt significantly increases your chances to survive a car crash.

See:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Seat_belts

Look at the references here, and follow the links to the PubMed papers.

Cheers,
TGHO

As I said to someone else, this might be relevant if I, or that paper, had ever claimed that seatbelts don't help you survive an accident. But we didn't. So it's not.

But the wikipedia article has a section on compensating behaviour and that cites http://www.law.harvard.edu/programs/olin_center/papers/pdf/341.pdf which is 2001 research on exactly that topic. If you read that paper, they claim that the evidence prior to their paper (note that the 1999 one that I pointed people to was prior to 2001) was inconclusive. Their conclusion from US data is that there is a real reduction from seatbelt laws, but that reduction is substantially lower than official estimates. They also claim to have disproven the compensation theory.

I have not gone through that paper in great detail, but I will note that when I see a paper admit that the previous research was inconclusive, then it is only in extraordinary instances that the paper in question makes it conclusive. I also note that their argument against the compensation theory depends on the assumption that people outside the car do not modify their behaviour in response to more reckless drivers. (See footnote #6 on page 5.) Contrary to their claim that this assumption is reasonable, this lack of modification runs directly counter to the psychological theories that compensation is based on. Anecdotally speaking, I can definitely say that exposure to people talking on their cellphones while driving SUVs in California has substantially modified my behaviour from what it was when I was growing up with saner Canadian traffic!
 
I was told that seat belts increased your chances of being injured in a car crash. The reason was that for every person seat belts saved from injury it also saved more than one person's life. However they would be injured. I cannot give any sources.

Yes, seat belts do save lives. When Australia made seat belts compulsory the number of people killed on the roads went down. As this was a state legislation it happened at different times in different states.

No I do not have any links for you.

Two papers have so far been cited on seatbelt use and fatalities. They have opposite biases - one claims there is a correlation, and one claims there is not. Both of them discussed decades of research that included Australian data. Both agreed that this body of research did not provide clear evidence that seatbelt use reduced fatalities.

I therefore think that I'm fairly safe in concluding that if you tracked down the Australian data, you would not find good evidence that seatbelt use reduces fatalities.

I should note that the "state by state" legislation sounds like you're confusing Australia's situation with the 2001 paper that wikipedia cites.
 
I see that you (and a bunch of other people) beat me to it. This looks like anti-seatbelt propaganda rather than a legitimate claim about false information taught in schools.

Look at the source: Cato Institute. They're a "free market" think tank specializing in rhetorical arguments against any government regulation of industry. They tend to be less interested in the merits of an issue and more interested in finding a way to spin things to show that regulation is unnecessary and that the free market will magically do what's best for everyone.

I like the Cato Institute as little as you do. That doesn't stop me from critically analyzing stuff that comes from them, and shouldn't stop you from doing so as well.

I should note that the paper I cited is one that is described as "a classic paper" at http://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~rja14/econsec.html, which is an excellent resource on the economics of security and is highly regarded by many people that I respect.

Take a look at their positions on global warming, for instance. The Cato Institute tends to dismiss the bulk of research, since it leads to conclusions they don't like. They strain at any gnat in the work of qualified scientists whose work indicates global warming is a problem while swallowing any bull which says it isn't. In general they prefer to put their faith in what economists say rather than what scientists show. If they are doing the same thing with seat belts, then I'm not surprised they have concluded that seat belts don't save lives. It was, for them, a foregone conclusion.

While I'm not going to support the Cato institute, I'm going to point out that some of the stuff they host is worthwhile. I'm also going to point out that of the various non-sciences out there, economics comes the closest to the standards of the hard sciences.

With regard to seat belts, studies done with crash test dummies have shown that a person wearing a seat belt will in general suffer less injury in a crash than a person not wearing a seatbelt. I don't think that's in dispute. So if that is what schools are teaching, then what schools are teaching is correct.

It sounds (from Ben Tilley's post) as if the Cato Institute is arguing that people wearing seat belts will drive more dangerously and have more serious crashes than people not wearing seat belts. That's possible, but I'd like to see an explanation of how that was determined. It's fairly easy to design tests which will measure how much damage a test dummy sustains in comparable crashes (a) when wearing a seat belt and (b) when not wearing a seat belt. It's a lot harder to test how fast and how dangerously people drive (a) when wearing seat belts and (b) when not wearing seat belts.

First a note on reading comprehension. My last name is Tilly, not Tilley. Please make the effort to spell it correctly in the future.

You could have read the paper to see how that was determined. But you couldn't be bothered to read it - you have a foregone conclusion about anything that has Cato or economics in its influences. Not that you'd necessarily have read it closely anyways if you tried. (See your inability to spell my name.)

Since you're still unlikely to read it, I'll answer your question. There have been many countries which have produced seatbelt legislation. There is strong evidence that seatbelt legislation increases the rate of seatbelt use. We also have detailed statistics on traffic fatality rates through this sudden increase. If seatbelts save lives on the whole, you'd expect to see a sudden reduction in fatality rates that is coincident with the increase in seatbelt use.

I'm not saying this can't be studied scientifically. I am saying I doubt the Cato Institute's ability to do a valid scientific test of such a question. They have never shown such a capability in the past. Their specialty is economics and rhetorical argument -- not scientific testing.

And, no, I am not going to click on the Cato Institute link to wade through their article to try to dig out precisely what it is they are asserting regarding seat belts and what evidence they have to support their assertions. That's the responsibility of the person posting the claim. If Ben Tilley seriously believes that schools teach incorrect information about seat belts, it is his responsibility to post what it is that schools are teaching and what the evidence is which shows this to be wrong.

There appears to be no danger of your having a chance to exercise your critical thinking ability here. You've stopped at the point of being unwilling to notice possibly contrary evidence. (In fact you stopped before you reached the point of being able to spell my name correctly. Quite annoying, that.)

Posting a link is not an acceptable substitute for stating clearly what one's claim is and what the evidence supporting one's claim is. Simply waving a link around, without quoting or summarizing the specific items at the link which one wishes to offer into evidence, is what people tend do when they don't actually have good evidence to support their point.

Posting a link is not an acceptable substitute, but being a first class jerk who dismisses evidence out of hand and can't even be bothered to spell my name correctly is? Not in my world.

Funnily enough, I summarized their explanation of the underlying phenomena and from the responses I got it seems that most didn't bother to read even that. Would anyone have read a longer summary had I written one?
 
Getting back to the original topic.
Americans are drowning in a watery medical myth!
The OP says
Next time anyone pesters you to drink 8 glasses of water a day, turn the table on your tormentor with one simple question. WHY?
Know what? NOBODY KNOWS WHY. In the words of a famous nutritionist at Penn State University, 'I can't tell you...and I've written a book on water.'
Maybe your kidneys need it? No, according to a kidney expert at the National Institute of Health, the average adult gets all the water he or she needs from solid food alone. And, in fact, drinking too much water stresses your kidneys and encourages renal failure!

More water myths to flush away... ​
  • 'If you get thirsty, it means you're already dehydrated.' HOW COULD IT? If this were true, every animal on earth would have collapsed and died long ago. Have you ever seen a dog that drinks when he's not thirsty? Of course not, he hasn't read the articles telling him to drink until he bursts.
  • Drinking lots of water is good for your circulation. NOPE. In fact, drinking too much water can dilute the potassium levels in your blood, raising your stroke risk.
  • Coffee and tea dehydrate you. THEY DON'T! This tactic is designed to sell you bottled water at a 1,000 percent markup.
 
The seat belt thing is like all of the other safety related or 'odds reduction' mechanisms. YOUR odds of suffering a loss are one in a million. Add the mechanism, and now your chance of loss is 1/2 what it was, one in TWO million. This is not significant to any one person. However, it is VERY significant to larger entities, like insurance companies. This concept holds for so many things- seat belts, safety glasses, Statin drugs, quitting bad habits. So the insurance companies reap the benefits, but YOU are the one that pays for the seat belts, and the drugs.

I'm sure there is a name for this phenomenon, in the statistical fields ? Anybody?
 
'm sure there is a name for this phenomenon, in the statistical fields ? Anybody?

Nope. But the name in the statistical fields for the phenomenon you're ignoring, and thus making a horrible error about, is Bayesian probability

If I'm wearing a seatbelt, the chances that I will have a horrible accident and survive are not much greater than the chances that I will have a horrible accident, true. However, my chances of surviving, given that I do have a horrible accident are a different matter.

Geddit?
 
Nope. But the name in the statistical fields for the phenomenon you're ignoring, and thus making a horrible error about, is Bayesian probability

If I'm wearing a seatbelt, the chances that I will have a horrible accident and survive are not much greater than the chances that I will have a horrible accident, true. However, my chances of surviving, given that I do have a horrible accident are a different matter.

Geddit?

Aren't we talking Relative risk, vs Comparative risk:

Relative: wear a seat belt, cut the death rate in auto accidents by 50%. Sounds impressive.

Comparative: 99 percent of us DO NOT die in auto accidents. Wear a seat belt belt, increase your chance to 99 1/2%. Sounds petty.

(my numbers are made up)

ETA: re: Bayesian probability- I think setting the point spread is the best example. The point spread is reflective of how bettors are betting. The point spread shifts, rather than the odds, to maintain the difference of opinion that is so critical to the bookie.

I don't mean that effect. I meant that a bigger subject size, for a bigger bettor, will shift his decision basis... or maybe that is Bayesian too. But should it matter? Since I pay the premiums, based on my small share of the pool, and my premiums ought to reflect actual odds rather than perceived odds, then it all ought to be a wash. The insurance company expects me to behave like everybody else, to keep an even field. But to how petty of their expectations should I endorse that? We're talking plus or minus 1/2%?
 
Last edited:
Since you're still unlikely to read it, I'll answer your question. There have been many countries which have produced seatbelt legislation. There is strong evidence that seatbelt legislation increases the rate of seatbelt use. We also have detailed statistics on traffic fatality rates through this sudden increase. If seatbelts save lives on the whole, you'd expect to see a sudden reduction in fatality rates that is coincident with the increase in seatbelt use.

You mean like this? Seatbelt use became mandatory in 1985 in Norway, the curve indicates number of traffic fatalities, the columns are injuries.
 

Attachments

  • Capture-1.jpg
    Capture-1.jpg
    27.3 KB · Views: 2
Bjornart, what changed in 1970? Thats when the downward trend starteed.
 
Bjornart, what changed in 1970? Thats when the downward trend starteed.

I don't know, but I did find some better info on seatbelt laws.

1971 - all new cars required to have seat belts mounted for front seats
1975 - use of front seat seatbelts required
1979 - ticketing for seatbelt non-usage
1984 - all new cars required to have seat belts also for the passenger seats
1985 - use of all seatbelts required, where mounted
1989 - seatbelts and proper cushion/seat compulsory when children are passengers

I'm guessing that the start of the downward trend coincides with an increased awareness of traffic deaths and the increased focus on safety information and campaigns.
 
My ship was passing through the Gulf of Oman on the way to Diego Garcia. I was on the fantail, admiring the deep blue hue of the water. A sailor turns to the Chief Petty Officer and asks why is the water so blue

"It's reflecting the color of the sky." replied the chief

"But Chief" says I, "The sky is heavily overcast, thus rendering said reflection an imposibility."

"Huh?" sayeth the others.

"Clouds in sky. Clouds grey. Not blue. Water blue. Why water blue?"

"Petty Officer Fnord, don't you have to report for duty somewhere?"

"Uhh ... no?"

"I bet you would if you looked around down belowdecks."

I took the Chief's not-so-subtle hint and found somewhere else to be, and never did get the chance to explain that the color of the water in that location was casued not by any reflection of the sky, but by a massive population of blue-green algae common to those waters.

It were a right purty blue, too!
 
Columbus was a brilliant navigator who knew that the world was round, despite almost all others saying that was crazy and the world was obviously flat. He showed his great skills by discovering the Americas...

At the time of Columbus's voyage it was well established that the world was round, based on astronomical observations going back to the Greeks and earlier. No saylor or navigator believed that the world was flat.

Columbus claimed that there would be a safe and relatively short passage to to India and China by going west. He was entirely wrong. Most believed (correctly) that the "ocean sea" or Atlantic Ocean route to the east would be much longer and more difficult than more direct ways.

Columbus managed to get funding and headed west. He hit land and thought he had reached East Asia. He would believe this until the time he died. He was very very wrong twice over. Suspicions that it was not Asia and was a newly discovered area were immediate, but Columbus denied this...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom