I'm tempted to leave this to Athon, as he does get to the point so well. However.
I go away for a little while (real medicine you know, sick animals need to be dealt with), and look how the thread has gone.
"But it works, I tell you!" (Argument from anecdote. Not even trying to address all the arguments about why selected anecdotes never proved anything. Consider Perkinism.)
"Thousands of doctors can't be wrong!" (Argument from authority/popularity. Funny, millions of doctors can apparently be very wrong about other things according to these posters. Doctors, of course, are just as gullible as anyone else. As I said, fully 0.7% of the British veterinary profession supports homoeopathy. Now what sort of percentage of the entire European medical profession would be represented by 100,000? Probably not even that. [Edited to add: Still, 100,000? Where did you get that from? I got my 140 veterinary homoeopaths from the web site of the BAHVS. Every country will have a society to which medical homoeopaths belong. If the 100,000 was arrived at by totting up all these - and from which countries, pray tell us - then fair enough. But if it's just a wild guess by someone intent on talking up homoeopathy, sorry, won't do.])
"Lots of people swear by it!" (More blatant argument from popularity. As Badly Shaved Monkey points out, thousands of Aztecs firmly believed that sacrificing a virgin was necessary to ensure that the sun rose in the morning. Most of the homoeopaths' anecdotes are of the "sunrise happened" variety. Oh, and consider Perkinism again.)
"I cured glue ear!" (Specific example of "sunrise happened". Now if you really want to do some good, spread the word that glue ear gets better on its own and surgical intervention is seldom necessary. This is quite well known, and homoeopathy is just as unnecessary as surgery, though admittedly less invasive.)
Accusations that I've been seeking out the negative studies. No, you dolt, what I did was post the homoeopaths' very best and most favourite studies, since Naturalhealth hadn't got round to that bit. It's not my fault that these very best studies are really pretty negative when you look at what they actually say. If you want the truly negative ones, that's going to take considerably longer.
Oh, and homoeopathy was invented in Germany. How does that make it not "Western medicine"?
But absolutely no attempt to discuss the real evidence, controlled studies, the way the effect disappears the more you scrutinise it and so on. Not even any response to the great news that if homoeopaths can do what they say, there is a million bucks waiting for the first one to get their act together.
News flash. Pretty much all of us who are involved in real medicine have been struck by the fervour of the cries from the proponents - "it works!" "I see it work every day in my clinic, I will never believe it can be a delusion!" So, being scientists, and understanding that absence of a plausible mechanism of action doesn't in itself mean that there can be no effect, we investigate. What is the basis for this fervent belief? Show us your evidence!
But all we find are sad colleagues who have lost all critical faculties and instead of merely being grateful when a patient improves all by its own little self, actually believe that they cured it. Or sometimes they look at a patient which is really no better at all, but what they see is a great triumph for homoeopathy. We positively beg for controlled trials and objective evidence and documented recoveries. We get none of these, just abuse, accusations of being closed-minded (which seems to mean, being open to the possibility that homoeopathy may not work, as opposed to open-minded, which means being closed to any possible suggestion to that effect), accusations that we're somehow afraid of the homoeopaths, and accusations that we've been rude (you want rude, I'll show you a homoeopath under pressure).
In the end, the conclusion is reached that this is more of a psychology/mental health issue than anything else. Which still doesn't tell us why it's so persistent when Perkinism died out on cue, but the answer, whatever it is, doesn't lie with any efficacy of the method.
Rolfe.