Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Homeoskeptic,

The people here have closed minds. Not all of them but most. I have done some reading on this subject. In fact I am reading a book right now that is tying together information from Zero Point Field to the possibility that remote viewing can work. it also has references to homeopathy as possibly imprinting in some manner on the ZPF. They also back up some of the observations that the Chinese and Indians have long known.

I see that homeopathy has some very nice studies that show it is doing something above placebo.

My guess is that the negative studies are what the negative skeptics are seizing upon.

Good luck trying to change their mind. it will never happen. They don't think acupuncture works.

:D :D
 
Homeoskeptic wrote:

I have treated loads of kids with glue ear and have actually prevented them needing treatment with gromets. Also, there is a postive study that was conducted by an old tutor of mine about the use of remedies for children with glue ear.

This was a pilot study where kids were treated with the correct homeopathic remedies for glue ear and it was positive for homeopathy. The kids treated with homeopathy avoided the need for gromets and antiobiotics. This study showed that homeopathy was extremely effective and recommended that more studies be carried out.

http://www.rnid.org.uk/html/factsheets/med_glue_ear.htm

What happens if glue ear is untreated?

Glue ear usually goes away by the age of seven to eight years and the condition improves on its own before puberty in 95% of children.
'Nuff said.
 
Homeoskeptic said:

I have treated loads of kids with glue ear and have actually prevented them needing treatment with gromets. Also, there is a postive study that was conducted by an old tutor of mine about the use of remedies for children with glue ear.


When no one responded to my query about glue ear, I went and looked it up. Hey, guess what? My son had that. Except our doc called chronic secretory otitis media. Those doctors, always using a $10 word, when a nickel one would do. I did learn something the doc didn't tell me, though, it's more common in kids with cleft palate deformities. My son has one of those, too.

Anyway, our doc told us that 95% of these cases clear up with no intervention at all. And my son's did too. Isn't anecdotal evidence, fun?
 
Homeoskeptic said:

Homeopathy is spreading throughout the world. There is an organisation called Frontline Homeopathy that has taken homeopathy to the third world. They train healthcare professionals - doctors and nurses in homeopathy and they then train the others and they then take homeopathic care to their communities.

Their clinics are flourishing and their people are extremely healthy and they get better. It just shows that good things spread.

In answer to your question - this leaves me exactly where I was before. With a thriving practice and lots of healthy patients who are a lot better than they would have been had they not experienced true healing with homeopathy.

HOMEOPATHY IS HERE TO STAY, so I would just get used to it if I were you.

I have to agree that when something works people will continue to use it. It is good to see that homeopathy is spreading. Western medicine seems to be making a mess of things with one wonder pill after the next coming on the market. We are becoming a nation of people in search of the next pill to undo the damaging side effects of all the previous pills. Don't even get me started on antibiotics. what a nightmare those are turning out to be. It is only a matter of time before resistant organisms are spread to everyone. Believe me it is happening no matter how many of you negative skeptics may deny it.
 
It's like we talk, and words come out...but nobody's listening!

I know we've said it all before, and the same old problems arise.

There's tons of evidence.
Oh yeah? Where?
There is!
Where?
You're just close minded!!
Where's the evidence?
Read this article!
That's not evidence.
You've got no idea what you're talking about...

And so it goes on. People ignorant of what constitutes evidence, of the weaknesses of anecdotes, of how the scientific method operates. And the circle continues.

Yes, HS, homeopathy is here to stay. Basically because the laws of how science operates will always remain beyond the grasp of many people. Nonetheless, nobody has yet ever answered my question sufficiently;

Which is it out of the following;

Homeopathy works: is it not then dangerous to be adminstering a drug without knowing how it interacts with the metabolism?

Homeopathy does not work: it does not interfere with the metabolism, it has no impact on the body's biochemistry, therefore does not work.

Questions too difficult? You can ignore them, like anybody else who believes in so-called 'alternative' medicine.

Athon
 
olaf said:


I have to agree that when something works people will continue to use it. It is good to see that homeopathy is spreading. Western medicine seems to be making a mess of things with one wonder pill after the next coming on the market. We are becoming a nation of people in search of the next pill to undo the damaging side effects of all the previous pills. Don't even get me started on antibiotics. what a nightmare those are turning out to be. It is only a matter of time before resistant organisms are spread to everyone. Believe me it is happening no matter how many of you negative skeptics may deny it.
I see your true colors shinin' through. Oh yes your true colors shinin' through...

Everybody! Sing it with me!

Dang... even Homeoskeptic managed to keep up the act longer than olaf.
 
Psiload said:
olaf ranted:

If Homeopathy is such fraud then why do close to 100,000 European medical doctors believe it works?

Have you any proof to support this ridiculous claim?

Thought not.

:tr:

Yes it seems that i do have some evidence to support this claim. It is in the book that I am reading at the library but i found a few other things on the internet that seem to back it up.

No matter what you may think about homeopathy when there are close to 100,000 medical doctors all over europe who use it then maybe it really works.

Possibly you have been brainwashed by all the corporate marketing of Western medicine. Maybe you have been fooled.
 
I have to agree that when something works people will continue to use it

No. When people feel secure (falsely or not) they will use something. The Romans used lead pipes to channel drinking water and used mercury in their makeup, because they didn't know any better. Heroin used to be sold over the counter in chemists, cocaine used to be in toothpaste...all caught on and took years to remove from the market, because people felt comfortable using it. Homeopathy is the same - people feel it has an effect, and as it carries this concept of 'natural' people are less inclined to fear it. The fact of whether it works or not has nothing to do with it.

It is good to see that homeopathy is spreading. Western medicine seems to be making a mess of things with one wonder pill after the next coming on the market. We are becoming a nation of people in search of the next pill to undo the damaging side effects of all the previous pills.

There is no such thing as 'western medicine'. Conventional medicine is an amalgamation of many methods used throughout history. Many modern drugs are based on biological materials discovered as a result of researching traditional healing treatments. The difference here is that they were tested and found to have a basis for use. They were tested for effectiveness and then modified to negate side effects, to work more efficiently in association with our biochemistry or be more economical in terms of refrigeration or shelf-life.

Sorry to shoot the old 'western medicine is the scourge of modern society' arguement, but it smacks of ignorance of modern medicine and where it comes from.

Don't even get me started on antibiotics. what a nightmare those are turning out to be. It is only a matter of time before resistant organisms are spread to everyone.

Then overuse of antibiotics and subsequent consequences is not due to the drug itself, which is effective and is responsible for saving millions of lives every year. Antibiotic resistance is a social problem, which falls into the laps of politicians, physicians and agriculturalists all over the world. Again, you show absolute ignorance here. Yes, antibiotic resistance is a concern. But if it was shown tomorrow that homeopathic remedies became less effective over time, would you call for the abolishment of homeopathy or the study of using it effectively?

Believe me it is happening no matter how many of you negative skeptics may deny it.

Why believe you? What evidence have you provided? One person's view is but an opinion. Science has nothing to do with opinion.

Athon
 
Olaf speweth forth:

Yes it seems that i do have some evidence to support this claim. It is in the book that I am reading at the library but i found a few other things on the internet that seem to back it up.

A book? Things on the internet? I apologize for doubting your claims. I had no idea you had such formidable supporting documentation. Title of the book? No, No... that's OK, I'll just assume that it's a really, really scientificy book, written by a guy with lots of impressive letters after his name.

No matter what you may think about homeopathy when there are close to 100,000 medical doctors all over europe who use it then maybe it really works.

Fair enough... who am I to questions things you saw posted on the internet, and read in books?

Possibly you have been brainwashed by all the corporate marketing of Western medicine. Maybe you have been fooled.

Could be... I haven't been wearing my tinfoil hat lately.
 
I'm tempted to leave this to Athon, as he does get to the point so well. However.

I go away for a little while (real medicine you know, sick animals need to be dealt with), and look how the thread has gone.

"But it works, I tell you!" (Argument from anecdote. Not even trying to address all the arguments about why selected anecdotes never proved anything. Consider Perkinism.)

"Thousands of doctors can't be wrong!" (Argument from authority/popularity. Funny, millions of doctors can apparently be very wrong about other things according to these posters. Doctors, of course, are just as gullible as anyone else. As I said, fully 0.7% of the British veterinary profession supports homoeopathy. Now what sort of percentage of the entire European medical profession would be represented by 100,000? Probably not even that. [Edited to add: Still, 100,000? Where did you get that from? I got my 140 veterinary homoeopaths from the web site of the BAHVS. Every country will have a society to which medical homoeopaths belong. If the 100,000 was arrived at by totting up all these - and from which countries, pray tell us - then fair enough. But if it's just a wild guess by someone intent on talking up homoeopathy, sorry, won't do.])

"Lots of people swear by it!" (More blatant argument from popularity. As Badly Shaved Monkey points out, thousands of Aztecs firmly believed that sacrificing a virgin was necessary to ensure that the sun rose in the morning. Most of the homoeopaths' anecdotes are of the "sunrise happened" variety. Oh, and consider Perkinism again.)

"I cured glue ear!" (Specific example of "sunrise happened". Now if you really want to do some good, spread the word that glue ear gets better on its own and surgical intervention is seldom necessary. This is quite well known, and homoeopathy is just as unnecessary as surgery, though admittedly less invasive.)

Accusations that I've been seeking out the negative studies. No, you dolt, what I did was post the homoeopaths' very best and most favourite studies, since Naturalhealth hadn't got round to that bit. It's not my fault that these very best studies are really pretty negative when you look at what they actually say. If you want the truly negative ones, that's going to take considerably longer.

Oh, and homoeopathy was invented in Germany. How does that make it not "Western medicine"?

But absolutely no attempt to discuss the real evidence, controlled studies, the way the effect disappears the more you scrutinise it and so on. Not even any response to the great news that if homoeopaths can do what they say, there is a million bucks waiting for the first one to get their act together.

News flash. Pretty much all of us who are involved in real medicine have been struck by the fervour of the cries from the proponents - "it works!" "I see it work every day in my clinic, I will never believe it can be a delusion!" So, being scientists, and understanding that absence of a plausible mechanism of action doesn't in itself mean that there can be no effect, we investigate. What is the basis for this fervent belief? Show us your evidence!

But all we find are sad colleagues who have lost all critical faculties and instead of merely being grateful when a patient improves all by its own little self, actually believe that they cured it. Or sometimes they look at a patient which is really no better at all, but what they see is a great triumph for homoeopathy. We positively beg for controlled trials and objective evidence and documented recoveries. We get none of these, just abuse, accusations of being closed-minded (which seems to mean, being open to the possibility that homoeopathy may not work, as opposed to open-minded, which means being closed to any possible suggestion to that effect), accusations that we're somehow afraid of the homoeopaths, and accusations that we've been rude (you want rude, I'll show you a homoeopath under pressure).

In the end, the conclusion is reached that this is more of a psychology/mental health issue than anything else. Which still doesn't tell us why it's so persistent when Perkinism died out on cue, but the answer, whatever it is, doesn't lie with any efficacy of the method.

Rolfe.
 
I believe the number is over 75,000, and I think that Germany might have the greatest numbers of medical doctors who practice homeopathy.

Once again --just as in RV-- I am inclined to believe that there is something going on that just is not explained at the moment.

It seems a sure bet that if the malcontents are bashing it on these forums then there could very well be something to it. I see a pattern over and over where people here refuse to look at the evidence or continually twist the evidence in order to expose the smallest of flaws.

the "AGENDA" as I call it.
 
olaf said:
Homeoskeptic,

Interesting evidence that you present. I enjoy it.
What evidence would that be, then? The story about the study into glue ear, for which no reference was given and which could have been invented on the spot for all we can tell? If something like this was done properly and published in a peer-reviewed journal, post the link or at least cite the reference.

By the way, "Homeoskeptic"'s actual Internet handle is Naturalhealth, as used in its natural habitat of the homoeopathy boards. The ludicrous "skeptic" title was adopted for an extremely short-lived troll in which s/he pretended to be a concerned husband anxious that his wife was caught up in "this dangerous nonsense". This was followed by more lies about having a degree in Italian, and having a degree in Medicine (come to think of it, although the behaviour has demonstrated that the Medicine claim is false, we can't be sure about the Italian one - any Italian-speakers care to sound out our hero/ine?)

Oh, I'm going to watch TV, this is just too predictable. Can't prove a thing, but determined to go on claiming you can anyway. Hey, Olaf, care to consider that Naturalhealth is making a lot of money by selling magic sugar pills to gullible people (or s/he claims s/he does, anyway), and so might just possbly have an "agenda" here?

Rolfe.
 
olaf said:
I believe the number is over 75,000, and I think that Germany might have the greatest numbers of medical doctors who practice homeopathy.

Name 1.
One little MD that practices homeopathy. We've named one, so you can't, and don't want to, use that one.

I'm waiting with baited breath.
 
olaf said:
I see a pattern over and over where people here refuse to look at the evidence or continually twist the evidence in order to expose the smallest of flaws.

the "AGENDA" as I call it.

And we see a continual pattern of people who think they have original ideas, but they are ideas that have actually been beaten beyond death..


You really do not realize the extent to which you are being patronized...
 
Unfortunately, lots of cases of glue ear do not clear on their own and with repeated ear infections can lead to the necessity for grommets.

Homeopathy has helped a lot of these kids and prevented them needing grommets. Yes, a lot of kids do grow out of it, but another certain few do not and may need grommets, however, a well indicated remedy will prevent this.

Homeopathy does in fact have an physiological effect on the body.

All the cases that I have posted are of clinical experience. Clinical experience and evidence is extremely valuable and not anecdotal at all.

I bet that animals treated by vets homeopathically and so much healthier.

I had a border collie who lived until she was 15 years old. As a homeopath myself, I treated her homeopathically all her life ever since she was a puppy and she was the healthiest dog that I know. Every ailment that she ever had was treated with the appropriate remedy by me and she responded to it brilliantly.

Good for the homeopathic vets of which there are thousands at the Faculty of Homeopathy. Good for them and I bet the animals that they treat are a lot better off.

Olaf,

What is the title of that book that you are reading? I would be interested to read it myself and yes I have seen your acupuncture post too.

I was just wondering how much Rolfe knew about TCM if anything. We shall see?
 
olaf said:
I believe the number is over 75,000, and I think that Germany might have the greatest numbers of medical doctors who practice homeopathy.
You believe. You think.

I, on the other hand, find out, when it comes to my own assertions. 140 homoeopaths out of a total of 20,000 vets in the UK. 0.7% or thereabouts.

Let's have the evidence for your assertion, counted numbers from associations of homoeopathic medics or similar.

And then express the result as a percentage of all qualified doctors in the same group of countries.

Edited to add: I just noticed that the number has already decreased by 25%. Some pretty broad approximations going on here, at best.

Rolfe.
 
Eos of the Eons said:
I'm waiting with baited breath.
I should watch that spelling, Eos dear - unless you're poking fun at Naturalhealth's embarrasingly similar gaffe earlier.

Bated breath (contraction of "abated" - holding one's breath in anticipation).

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom