Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Actually, there is one very interesting fact. Quite a few years ago now one doctor gave polio patients an injection of some snake venon from the Indian Cobra snake (Naja) and the patients did very well on this. It was because the snake had extremely similar characteristics to patients with polio. He was using homeopathic principles here and did not realise it and the snake venon was extremely effective in treating thed polio. Very small quantities of a similar substance.

There are lots of snake remedies that exist that are extremely useful homeopathically.

Hering proved Lachesis and a lot of the snake remedies. They are extremely effective.

As a student, I had to do a presentation on the snake remedies and I was challenged to prove Lachesis by some of my fellow class mates. I did so and took just one dose of 30c and it had an extremely profound effect on me. I only needed one 30c.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
These days, the trituration process is used for substances that are insoluble before the potentisation process is undertaken.

If a substance is soluble then is goes through the potentisation process. If a substance is insoluble then it will be triturated to be made soluble and then the potentisation process can be undertaken. Potentisation consists of serial dilution and succussion.

How does trituration make a substance soluble? Whether a substance is soluble (in water) is a chemical property. No amount of trituration will change that.


How does this differ from what anyone else does? All the pharmacies make remedies in this way.

What pharmacies?

Massimo is a doctor and yes, these may be his musings, but he has hundreds of cases that he can back up with evidence.

You have repeatedly referred to his hundreds of cases, here and elsewhere. First of all, hundreds of cases don't quite cut it. Since this gentleman has practeced homeopathy for decades, he must have treated thousands of patients. A few hundred selected stories are not that interesting. Secondly, where ARE those cases? Where can we read about them?

I will go and design my own trial that I am satisfied with that actually meets homeopathic requirements to test that it works, however, this is not the best way.

You have said that before, and submitted a sketch of your protocol. This was rather heavily criticised, then you lost interest. Are you going to continue after all?

O, just to let you know, we have helped quite a few people over at Hpathy. They ask us for advice and we have recommended remedies that have helped them greatly.

Lots of people have filled in our questionnaire and we have prescribed remedies that have helped them greatly.

"Lots of" is perhaps exaggarating a little, but there are some. However, how can you know you helped them? You never met those people. You have no idea what was really wrong with them. You don't know how their disease developed. You don't know if they took the medication at all. You don't even know if they existed at all. The web is full of fictuous characters and attention junkies.

I think the person that you were referring to was Divina. She has a bad name anyway over at Hpathy.

Well, here we agree, at least ;).

Remember also that Lionel Milgrom is also a practicing homeopath as well as a chemist.

And?

Also, Colin Lessel is a doctor, dentist and homeopath.

And?

The two last ones are called "appeal to authority". Now, to mention that somebody with a medical education is a proponent of homeopathy (I will, for now, assume that their credentials are real) is, of course, interesting, but hey, I can name doctors who are NOT proponents of homeopathy till the cows come home, so where does that lead us?

Hans
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Actually, there is one very interesting fact.

And, if it is a fact, I'm sure you can point to some documentation?

Quite a few years ago now one doctor gave polio patients an injection of some snake venon from the Indian Cobra snake (Naja) and the patients did very well on this.

"Did very well"? What exactly does that mean? Were they cured? Did patients with paralysis recover?

It was because the snake had extremely similar characteristics to patients with polio.

You cannot make that conclusion. Chinoa bark has very similar symptoms to malaria, but that is not the reason it works against it.

He was using homeopathic principles here and did not realise it and the snake venon was extremely effective in treating thed polio. Very small quantities of a similar substance.

Now, you need to make up your mind what is true homeopathy and what isn't. Was that snake venom potenized? If not and you still claim it for homeopathy, then we are back to the questions about why tap water and sea water is not a homeopathic preparation of all it has been near since the dawn of ages. Are you SURE you wanna do that?

There are lots of snake remedies that exist that are extremely useful homeopathically.

Not a valid claim. Since the effect of any homeopathic rmeedy is exactly what we refute, your (undocumented) claim of their usefulness is irrelevant.

Hering proved Lachesis and a lot of the snake remedies. They are extremely effective.

Since we do not accept "proving" as proof....

As a student, I had to do a presentation on the snake remedies and I was challenged to prove Lachesis by some of my fellow class mates. I did so and took just one dose of 30c and it had an extremely profound effect on me. I only needed one 30c.

No, you took a pill and felt something. You have no way to know if there was a causative link. If I had taken such pills and reported I did NOT feel anything, you would have rejected it.

Nice to see that we might be on a path that could lead to intelligent debate, however :).

Hans
 
Homeoskeptic said:
I think the person that you were referring to was Divina. She has a bad name anyway over at Hpathy.
Really? Such a bad name that she regularly contributes (grossly misleading) articles to their ridiculous ezine, has people like Barb gushing things like "oh, you are such a strong and capable woman" at her, and seems to be the leading voice which is listened to when anyone talking any sort of sense is banned from the forum?

We know who Lionel Milgrom is. He researches in chemistry. He has no medical training, but makes a hobby of practising as a homoeopath on the side, and inventing ridiculous pseudo-scientific explanations (or really, metaphors) to try to explain the huge embarrassment caused by the absolute failure of any homoeopathic remedy to demonstrate the slightest effect in properly controlled trials.

If he's the best you can do, I'm sorry for you. Anyway, what's your view on his take that homoeopathy is essentially an effect of the mind of the practitioner, with the administration of the remedy having more a symbolic effect than a physical one?

Rolfe.
 
Yes, as far as I am aware, the cases of polio were cured and the paralysis resolved.

You can e-mail Massimo for details of his cases.

He keeps them all on his database that he developed specially for this purpose. He wrote some of the programme in conjunction with a friend of his. All of his cases have been followed for a reasonable length of time and have been cured with the same remedy.

What I actually took, was not a substance, it was Lachesis 30c and the effect was within 2 seconds of taking the remedy.

If you had taken the same remedy and had felt nothing, this proves nothing also. I would not have said anything other than you are not sensitive to that remedy. We can not all be sensitive to all the remedies that exist.

I would definitely continue to design a trial of my own that would meet with my requirements from a homeopathic point of view to prove that it works.
 
No. Not at all. Divina does not say things that we all agree with at all. Her's is not the first and the last voice at all.

I have disagreed with a lot of what she has said and do not practice her methods at all. I mostly practice classical homeopathy, but then I have experience of what works too, so I sometimes practice according to my experience too.

Lionel Milgrom is actually a practicing homeopath. He is fully trained and does not do it as a hobby at all.

You might find Colin Lessel to be a better read.

Remedies do have a physical effect on the body too, but you do have to remember that the mind and the body are linked and can never be separated.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Yes, as far as I am aware, the cases of polio were cured and the paralysis resolved.

Well, I'm sorry, but "as far as I'm aware" is not quite enough for us to start changing the world. Now, if you have some documentation, we might do business. There are millions of people with paralysis from polio waiting for this.

You can e-mail Massimo for details of his cases.

He keeps them all on his database that he developed specially for this purpose. He wrote some of the programme in conjunction with a friend of his. All of his cases have been followed for a reasonable length of time and have been cured with the same remedy.

Well, I'd hate to contact a complete stranger and essentially say: "Sir, I am privately believing you to be a quack. While I have no authority to ask this of you, would you be kind enough to provide me with comprehensive case data from your practice?"

I rather think his reply would be similar to those James Randi provides for some of the people mailing him.

Perhaps you should contact him for this information? I assume he will be more interested in dealing with a fellow homeopath fighting the cause of homeopathy.

Oh, and "cured with the same remedy"??? That does not sound as true homeopathy?


What I actually took, was not a substance, it was Lachesis 30c and the effect was within 2 seconds of taking the remedy.

Yeah, you said it was 30c, I know there is no substance in it.

2 secs? That is very strange. Now, sometimes homeopathic remedies are said to work almost instantly, other times it takes days, even weeks. Do you have any explanation for this?


If you had taken the same remedy and had felt nothing, this proves nothing also. I would not have said anything other than you are not sensitive to that remedy. We can not all be sensitive to all the remedies that exist.

No, or maybe the remedies do not have any physical effect. However, it seems you agree that a one-person subjective test is worthless, irrespective of the result. Fine! I'm glad we finally got that behind us:).

I would definitely continue to design a trial of my own that would meet with my requirements from a homeopathic point of view to prove that it works.

And, we would be perfectly happy to help you, so that your trial is acceptable, both from a homeopathic and a scientific POV. I would advice, however, that it is also conferred with other homeopaths, otherwise I predict that we will, after you conduct the test, be faced with the NEXT homeopath telling us that "this is not good homeopathy".

I'm sorry for being this suspicious, but it comes from hard experience.

Hans
 
Homeoskeptic said:
No. Not at all. Divina does not say things that we all agree with at all. Her's is not the first and the last voice at all.

Fine! Very good. No problem at all. I'm sure we all agree that there can be bad eggs in any basket. You are certainly not responsible for what DIvina/ChaChaHeels does or says.

I have disagreed with a lot of what she has said and do not practice her methods at all. I mostly practice classical homeopathy, but then I have experience of what works too, so I sometimes practice according to my experience too.

Well, perhaps it was some of your more unmeditated posts here that led people to believe that you and she were in agreement? But we know better now, I'm sure.

Lionel Milgrom is actually a practicing homeopath. He is fully trained and does not do it as a hobby at all.

You might find Colin Lessel to be a better read.

What makes these two gentlemen especially interesting, compared to so many other homeopaths out there?

Remedies do have a physical effect on the body too,

Well, that is what we are debating, remember? And we have been refuting any evidence brought forth so far.

but you do have to remember that the mind and the body are linked and can never be separated.

Well, that is exactly our point. If you believe it to work, you are going to perceive it to work. To a certain degree, that is. Mere belief is not going to cure something really serious.

Hans
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Remember also that Lionel Milgrom is also a practicing homeopath as well as a chemist.
So what? Why don't you address my refutations of your claims? Milgrom does not do quantum theory work, does he? Massimo's "evidence" is not published in peer-reviewed journals, is it?

Look, if you want to keep dancing, I'll just keep the six-shooter aimed at your feet to motivate you.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Lionel Milgrom is actually a practicing homeopath. He is fully trained and does not do it as a hobby at all.
Lionel Milgrom is a research chemist. What he does with his spare time, whether or not he is "trained", and whether or not he gets paid for it, I would classify as a hobby.

If remedies have a physical effect on the body, if you can tell whether you've been given a remedy of your choice rather than a placebo, if these things are so "extremely effective" and have "a very profound effect", why do these effects always disappear under scientific testing conditions?

We all agree that you can often make people feel a lot better by talking to them and letting them talk to you for half an hour or an hour or so, and instilling a feeling of confidence that all is being taken care of. We believe that this is the sole mechanism by which homoeopathy can "help" people - basic psychology, the "therapeutic consultation".

What we are disputing is that the remedies as such have any effect or value in and of themselves.

To demonstrate that, it is necessary to separate the remedy-taking from the rest of the homoepathic fol-de-rol, and ensure that nobody concerned knows whether the patients concerned have actually been given their prescribed remedy or not. All the repeated assertions that patients felt better after seeing you (or maybe felt worse, but never mind, at least that shows the remedy is doing something) count for nothing against the fact that when the remedies themselves are investigated for effect, they are found to have none.
What I actually took, was not a substance, it was Lachesis 30c and the effect was within 2 seconds of taking the remedy.
Psychosomatic, anyone?

If you could reliably tell whether you'd been given Lachesis 30C or not, without knowing in advance, I'd be more impressed. And you'd be a million dollars richer, remember?

Rolfe.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
What I actually took, was not a substance, it was Lachesis 30c and the effect was within 2 seconds of taking the remedy.
This is interesting. Which effect was this, and for how long did it last?

-Øyvind
 
Homeoskeptic wrote:

These days, the trituration process is used for substances that are insoluble before the potentisation process is undertaken.

But tritruation is also a method of potentisation exclusive to dilution and succession, is it not? Which of these two statements is false?:

Trituration is not the same as potentisation at all.

or

Drugs are potentised by two methods:
2. Trituration - in case of insoluble substances.

Is trituration a valid method of potentisation(as Hahnemann claimed), or is it not(as you seem to be claiming)?

If a substance is soluble then is goes through the potentisation process. If a substance is insoluble then it will be triturated to be made soluble and then the potentisation process can be undertaken. Potentisation consists of serial dilution and succussion.

So... what is your opinion of the following potentisation process?:
FOLLOWING IS THE PROTOCOL FOR THE C4 TRITURATION/PROVING:

100 grams milk sugar (it is about a handful), divide this in 3 equal portions.
A clean mortar and pestle
10 grams of the proving substance

Put 1/3 of the milk sugar and the substance in the mortar:
7 minutes of trituration then 3 minutes of scraping
7 minutes of trituration then 3 minutes of scraping
7 minutes of trituration then 3 minutes of scraping
Add another 1/3 of the milk sugar
7 minutes of trituration then 3 minutes of scraping
7 minutes of trituration then 3 minutes of scraping
7 minutes of trituration then 3 minutes of scraping
Add another 1/3 of the milk sugar
7 minutes of trituration then 3 minutes of scraping
7 minutes of trituration then 3 minutes of scraping
7 minutes of trituration then 3 minutes of scraping
This is the C1 C1 works on the level of needs and instincts on the physical, organic level. Nourishment, etc.
Sure seems to be describing potentisation through trituration to me... no? I see no mention of any dilution and succession taking place, yet potentisation is clearly being claimed... hence the "C1". That is a term used to denote a level of potentisation, is it not?

Since, "Trituration is not the same as potentisation at all." then the homeopaths of the Hahnemann Instituut Nederland must be a bunch of incompetent boobs, correct?

http://www.hahnemanninstituut.nl/c4_protocol.htm
 
I see homeoskeptic is still around, still not actually answering questions, still trotting out unsubstiantiable anecdotes, still not actually understanding what science is.

Remedies do have a physical effect on the body too, but you do have to remember that the mind and the body are linked and can never be separated.

But not under controlled circumstances, ie the effect is all in the mind, either of the observer or recipient.



Now, how about answering these then?


Tell us why you need 'ultrapure' water these days?


Tell us how homeopathy will replace the missing X-chromosome in Turner's syndrome? What about trisomy 21?


bit difficult are they? or is it that you know full well your answers will be so convoluted as to be laughable?
 
Prester John said:
I see homeoskeptic is still around, still not actually answering questions, still trotting out unsubstiantiable anecdotes, still not actually understanding what science is.
Mmmm, that just about sums it up.

S/he piles in with dogmatic statements if s/he notices anything s/he doesn't consider to be "true homoeopathy" (small slip-ups in homoeopathic terminology from sceptics of course nullify any points they may have made, no matter how unrelated to said slip-up), but is still studiously ignoring the very reasonable questions we've been putting.

But you know, this triturition stuff, I'm not sure we're even dealing with a properly trained homeopath here. No matter how much triturition may have fallen into disuse in mainstream homoeopathic practice, it's always been part of the classic Hahnemanian procedure. But Naturalhealth dosn't seem to know this....

Still, try the questions again. If you can, Naturalhealth, please give up on the "I gave someone something and they thought they were better", and think of a few answers to these modest inquiries.

Since ordinary German tap water worked fine for Hahnemann, why is is necessary to use anything different these days? In fact, might varying the water preparation not risk negating the effects the "master" recorded?

How pure does the alcohol have to be? What proportion of alcohol to water is used? How does this affect affect the esoteric nuclear physics reactions that are postulated to occur in this astonishing substance?

If the curative effects of homoeopathy are so obvious and so self-evident, why do they vanish entirely as soon as everybody concerned is blinded as to which patient has been given the prescribed remedy and which not? If somebody was secretly dispensing an unpotentised placebo to half of your patients, and the correct remedy to the other half, would you be able to tell which was which? Do you realise that no homoeopath can do this?

If you can reliably tell a high-potency remedy of your choice (yes, Lachesis 30C will do nicely) from a chemically identical sham, you stand to win a million dollars. Why don't you want to try it? Why do you think, out of all those thousands of convinced homoeopaths in the world, not one of them wants to come forward to claim the money?

Rolfe.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
How does this differ from what anyone else does? All the pharmacies make remedies in this way.

Well, you have also told us that ultrapure water is an essential ingredient by virtue of your own self-contradictory assertion (Why self-contradictory? How can it ever be pure enough?) How come Hahnemann managed with whatever they drank 200yrs ago?

You've still studiously ignored the challenge to explain how homeopathy restores the missing X-chromosome to a Turner's sydrome patient or excised one from trisomy patient.

You keep popping up in these discussions, so you can hardly fail to have read these questions, so I think the only possible conclusion is that you know you can't answer them and that inability proves you are a fraud.
 
No. Not at all.

Perhaps you should actually read what I wrote. I never wrote anything about the fact that homeopathy could cure Turner's Syndrome. This is you reading what you want to into my post.

Read it again. It did not say anything about curing Turner's Syndrome.

The homeopathic pharmacies use nuclear grade water to make remedies these days just because it is available. It was not available in Hahnemann's day and you do not necessarily need to use nuclear grade water. Remedies still work without this.

I use ordinary tap water for 'plussing' remedies all the time and they work perfectly well. I would normally plus a 30c.
 
Trituration is not normally used as part of homeopathic practice routinely unless a substance is insoluble before potentisation.

If a substance is soluble, then it can be potentised without trituration. It just undergoes serial dilution and succussion.

Of course I am trained. I am a member of the Faculty of Homeopathy and have passed all of their required exams. However, all these exams related to patients, case taking, presentations and materia medica. It revolved around patients themselves and did not extend to homeopathic pharmacy. We leave this to the pharmacists who train via the Faculty too, as do your colleagues the vets, of which there are many.
 
Wrath of the Swarm said:
Again: what is "nuclear grade" water? In what way does "nuclear" denote a rating system for water quality?
You'll be lucky! I don't think it knows itself. It just phoned a homoeopathic pharmacy and they handed it the bullsh!t line they hand out to anyone who comes up with the question.

I'm still favouring the idea of all these little protons and neutrons in there all by their own little selves. You'd certainly get some strange nuclear physics effects from that!

But now it's admitted it doesn't matter. Since not even the purest water on earth can eliminate impurities at appreciable homoeopathic levels, might as well give up and say it's irrelevant. Doesn't matter what you've got in there, the remedy magically knows what it is you want to potentise - both the right substance distinguished from the contaminants, and the beneficial effects distinguished from the harmful ones. It's all explained by Lionel Milgrom's quantum metaphor, as being a factor of the intent of the practitioner - or as Walach says, it is in effect a magic spell being cast by the homoeopath, and the intent is the important thing, not the detail of the recipe. Of course, to allow their maths you have to get rid of Planck's constant, which puts a pretty enormous crimp in the whole idea, but never mind, it keeps the poor dears amused.

So the water doesn't matter, never mind the contaminating substances, we "know it works" anyway. :nope:

So how about the purity of the alcohol, does that not matter either? But the proportion of alcohol surely must be vital, for the unexplained nuclear reactions to occur? No? :rolleyes: How about at least addressing this point?

Naturalhealth actually said it thought homoeopathy could "help" someone with a genetic disorder. Didn't define "help". Keep their mind off their problems for the duration of the consultation, give them a bit of false hope, might work wonders, you never know. But cures come a bit harder. Oh but I forgot. Homoeopaths always claim to "cure". Homoeopathy can (in theory) cure anything, if only these evil allopaths didn't get in their first and get the patients addicted beyond rescue to evil drugs like insulin. Except that when you really push them, this does tend to reduce to vague claims of "help", and maybe reducing the dose of the real medicine (another verifiable claim that has never been shown to have any substance to it).

So how about the next bit. Just show by any objective assessment you like, that a group of patients who get their homoeopathic remedy on average did better than a group who only thought they got their remedy. Naturalhealth, doesn't it even occur to you that if a tenth of what you claim is true, this should be as easy as falling off a log? So why can't it be done? Back to the magic of the mind of the practitioner, perhaps? Or could it be that you simply claim any outcome at all as success? It sure looks like that at me.

So never mind the patients, awkward subjective lot that they are. Just show us that you can differentiate a potentised remedy of your choice from a chemically identical placebo. And fame and fortune shall be yours. So long as you can get in before these many, many skilled homoeopaths who must surely be honing their protocols even now, can't imagine why it's taking them so long, but you crack on there now.

Unless you can't do it of course.

Rolfe.
 
Homeoskeptic wrote:

Trituration is not normally used as part of homeopathic practice routinely unless a substance is insoluble before potentisation.

*sigh*

It's like trying to nail jelly to a wall.

OK... we'll try multiple choice.

Which of these two statements is correct?:

A) Trituration is not the same as potentisation at all.

or

B) Trituration is a method of potentisation.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom