Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

olaf said:
It seems a sure bet that if the malcontents are bashing it on these forums then there could very well be something to it. I see a pattern over and over where people here refuse to look at the evidence or continually twist the evidence in order to expose the smallest of flaws.

the "AGENDA" as I call it.
"The smallest of flaws?" The basic flaw, sir, is the concept violates Avogadro's limit for many of the purported dilution strengths. It is no small flaw to violate underlying scientific foundations. It is no mean feat to tap-dance around this utterly fatal flaw. What is required, scientifically, is that so-called homeopathic researchers cut the crap and provide definitive tests to prove there is anything to the concept whatsovever. Very basic tests. The easiest is one proposed by Randi: the challenge there is to be given bottles, half of which are homeopathic nostrums, half of which are not, and to be able to tell the difference between them. If you don't like that, or believe that only a living system can tell that difference, then provide the large-scale, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies demonstrating efficacy.
 
Homeopathy has nothing to do with belief at all.

The right remedy will work on even the hardest nosed sceptic such as you. I have treated several in my practice and it has worked every time.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Unfortunately, lots of cases of glue ear do not clear on their own and with repeated ear infections can lead to the necessity for grommets.

Homeopathy has helped a lot of these kids and prevented them needing grommets. Yes, a lot of kids do grow out of it, but another certain few do not and may need grommets, however, a well indicated remedy will prevent this.


What proof do you have that homeopathy cured the glue ear and they didn't just heal on their own. I'm looking for studies, BTW, not more anecdotes.

And why is your anecdotal evidence better than my anecdotal evidence?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
the homeopathic vets of which there are thousands at the Faculty of Homeopathy. ....
Forty-one. Three Fellows (Edited to add, including BSM's "CD") and 38 Members (including the perpetrator of BSM's other horrible story). You want me to post a list of all their names?

All right, I don't have a list of the people with the kindergarten Licentiate award. Which is why I used the larger 140 figure, the claimed membership roll of the BAHVS. This allows for the Members, the Licentiates, and the fellow-travellers, so it's more than generous.

So, once again we see the degree of truthfulness adhered to by Naturalhealth. Why should we believe a single word of her/his fairy-stories about glue ear or anything else?

Rolfe.
 
There is a study about this that demonstrates that homeopathy worked very well in cases of glue ear and as I said before, a lot of cases do not just spontaneously.

One of the authors was someone called Alison Fixen.
 
P.S.

Has anyone else noticed the pattern of Olaf's posts?


A newbie claiming to be skeptical, and actually seeking the truth, whatever it may be, but getting all sideways when presented with the tiresome arguments that have been recounted here time after time?

O.K., everyone, wipe that turnip dust off your knickers...
 
OK, it does seem to be time to wheel out a couple of illustrative anecdotes. First it is important to realise that these are not of the 'yah, boo sucks, here's an example where homoeopathy didn't help this case. These show respected homeopaths simply lying and misreperesenting, and that is much more instructive.

Homeopaths are typically portrayed as benign souls whose main interest is to serve their patients, but my professional experience of them is that they are woefully self-deluding. It is difficult to get concrete proof of this, but how about the following story.

Some time ago, BBC Radio 4 presented a series comparing the services of vets and NHS GPs. The presenter Dr Graham Easton visited a well-known veterinary homeopath (Let's call him CD). CD displayed to Dr Easton a cat sufferng from hyperthyroidism. He showed Dr Easton all of the classic features of hyperthyroidism that were present in this case. They were certainly at the extreme end of what we, as vets, usually see. The funny thing was that the owner of the cat was also present, there to express her gratitude to CD for his prolonged homeopathic treatment of her cat and for keeping it alive.

Hyperthyroidism is common and conventional treatments yield prompt responses relieving the animal's signs and prolonging life. CD, then, was presenting this cat's survival as proof of the efficacy of his remedies, while at the same time demonstrating its unaltered clinical signs. Survival is often prolonged without treatment, so provides no anecdotal evidence for an effect of homeopathic treatment, but relief of clinical signs is essential for genuine long term health in these patients and this had simply not been achieved, yet this was being proclaimed as an example of successful treatment.

So the case was more of a failure than a success, yet being portrayed as the opposite. I wonder why.


Here's another;


Dogs can suffer from acute moist dermatitis, in which they are itchy and scratch at an area sufficiently to break the skin. Bacteria colonise the broken skin and reinforce the itchiness. The lesion is typically reddened, denuded, wet with serum, possibly with a frankly purulent discharge. It is painful.

This is easily treated by some or all of the following (in descending order of preference): clip the hair to reveal a cordon sanitaire of healthy skin; clean the lesion and repeat once or twice daily; apply topical steroid + antibiotic creams; maybe use systemic antibiotics. It is very important to prevent re-traumatisation if at all possible. These lesions mostly resolve in 1 week, but may require another round of clipping and cleaning. Persistence is almost always the result of the owner being reluctant to use the appropriate collar or bandage to stop the dog reinitiating the lesion all the time.

A veterinary had a case treated once before by a homeopath which followed a rather uneven course to recovery as the owner stopped and started my colleague's advice and patchily followed the homeopath’s. My colleague informed the owner that she was not prepared in future to have her treatment compromised by the involvement of a homeopath muddying the waters, so….

The next time, the animal presented with a 5cm lesion on top of its head. This time the owner went to a veterinary homeopaths and my colleague did not treat the case, but, unknown to the homeopath the progress of the case was witnessed by a third party who reported back to us. After a week the condition spread over its entire head and shoulders. None of the basic cleaning regime had been done. Apparently this deterioration is all right because ‘it’s the poisons leaving the system’. As others may recall, homeopaths often excuse deterioration after treatment in this manner. The owner now had to take the dog every 2 days to see the homeopath, because he’s ‘going to help them see it through’. Ultimately the poor animal was affected over the entire top surface of its body before the condition eventually ran its course and began to heal (usually this is because the hair in the affected area falls out of the inflamed skin and the lesion can they dry up and heal).

It’s an anecdote, but powerful evidence because it’s presented against a background of standard knowledge about this problem and a routine expectation for simple recovery. And here we are again with another example of not just treatment-failure, but failure reported as success. At the same time this animal was rigid with pain. So much for the bleating from the homeopaths about it being hard to conceive of harm being done by failure to access proper medicine. And wass the homeopath embarrassed by this case? No he wasn’t because it all went according to plan, and by the way he got to see the client every two days with the opportunity to charge more money. But of course homeopaths have no vested interest do they?

Homeoskeptic, you and your colleagues make me sick!
 
I believe the number is over 75,000, and I think that Germany might have the greatest numbers of medical doctors who practice homeopathy.

First it was, "close to 100,000", now it's "over 75,000"... that's about a 25% margin of error over the course of just one hour...

Your attention to detail, and dedication to hard fact is truly impressive.

Once again --just as in RV-- I am inclined to believe that there is something going on that just is not explained at the moment.

Maybe you should concern yourself more with the "not adequately demonstrated" aspect of homeopathy, and less with the "not explained" problem.

It seems a sure bet that if the malcontents are bashing it on these forums then there could very well be something to it. I see a pattern over and over where people here refuse to look at the evidence or continually twist the evidence in order to expose the smallest of flaws.

Evidence? The stuff you saw on the net, and read in books? That evidence?

the "AGENDA" as I call it.

Yeah, you've gotta watch out for people with agendas...

Western medicine seems to be making a mess of things with one wonder pill after the next coming on the market. We are becoming a nation of people in search of the next pill to undo the damaging side effects of all the previous pills. Don't even get me started on antibiotics. what a nightmare those are turning out to be. It is only a matter of time before resistant organisms are spread to everyone.
 
BillHoyt said:

"The smallest of flaws?" The basic flaw, sir, is the concept violates Avogadro's limit for many of the purported dilution strengths. It is no small flaw to violate underlying scientific foundations. It is no mean feat to tap-dance around this utterly fatal flaw. What is required, scientifically, is that so-called homeopathic researchers cut the crap and provide definitive tests to prove there is anything to the concept whatsovever. Very basic tests. The easiest is one proposed by Randi: the challenge there is to be given bottles, half of which are homeopathic nostrums, half of which are not, and to be able to tell the difference between them. If you don't like that, or believe that only a living system can tell that difference, then provide the large-scale, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies demonstrating efficacy.
First of all the whole Randi business is a joke. He forces people to do the impossible. Then acts like he has the final answer to all life's mysteries. I like Targ's response, "Randi seems like an angry..... man"

Hoyt, I believe your mistake is that you are perpetually hung up on this false notion that only chemicals can exert an action on the body. There is a whole 'nother field out their called energy medicine. It is not about how many molecules are left in solution it is about the underpinnings that make up all matter/energy that counts.

Until you grasp this basic concept there is not much more that I can do for you son.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
There is a study about this that demonstrates that homeopathy worked very well in cases of glue ear and as I said before, a lot of cases do not just spontaneously.

One of the authors was someone called Alison Fixen.

Put Fixen [au] into PubMed. Nothing relevant.

We do have this crapy little piece of work, which was puffed by the homemopaths some time ago.

http://my.webmd.com/content/article/30/1728_72611.htm?z=1830_00000_0000_f1_03

http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/...ve&db=PubMed&list_uids=11224838&dopt=Abstract

Is this the best you can do?

Remember you were supposed to be explaining why homeopathy can't fix the broken vital force of genetic disease and why you decided to show off about how pure the water is that is used in remedies, but then ignore the problems that arise for you both if you claim that it is essential and if you claim that it doesn't matter after all.
 
I read the study of homeopathic glue ear treatment. It comes down to this:

33 children were followed.

A smaller number of the homeopathically treated children has hearing loss, although the authors admit it was statiscally insignificant.

More homeopathy patients had a normal tympanogram.

Referrals to specialists and antibiotic use were smaller amongst the homeopathic kids. But again, the authors admit the difference was insignificant.

It ends with saying 270 patients would be needed for a definitive trial.

So Homeoskeptic, I'm not convinced by this study. Sorry.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
I bet that animals treated by vets homeopathically and so much healthier.

I was just wondering how much Rolfe knew about TCM if anything. We shall see?
You bet. You think. Evidence, please?

I could easily embark on my store of sickening anecdotes about animals which were trusted to the not-so-tender care of these homoeopathic vets for too long, and were in a pitiful state by the time their owners woke up and sought help from a sane colleague. (Edited to add, OK, I can skip that for now, as I see BSM was doing pretty much that while I was typing this up - and finding the links to the references, NH!) However, I have no more quotable evidence for these stories than Naturalhealth has for her/his stories (well, apart from the one that went to court, "CD" again as it happens, surprising how much destruction so few people can cause, but I don't know how to access these records anyway).

Therefore, I will quote what is verifiable.

Scott et al., 2002
Abstract — A commercial homeopathic remedy and a placebo were administered orally as individual agents to 18 dogs with atopic dermatitis. The pruritus was reduced by less than 50% in only 2/18 dogs; 1 of these dogs was receiving the homeopathic remedy, the other was receiving the placebo. One dog vomited after administration of the homeopathic remedy.
de Verdier Klingenberg et al., 2003
No clinically or statistically significant difference between the 2 groups was demonstrated. Calves treated with Podophyllum had an average of 3.1 days of diarrhoea compared with 2.9 days for the placebo group. Depression, inappetence and fever were presented equally in the 2 groups. These results support the widely held opinion that scientific proof for the efficacy of veterinary homeopathy is lacking. In the European Union this implies a considerable risk for animal welfare, since in some countries priority is given to homeopathic treatments in organic farming.
Taylor et al., 1989 (not available on-line, but this is in the Veterinary Record, of which I have a paper copy)
No antibody could be demonstrated in either group, mortality in both groups was high, and there was no difference in the number or morphology of the worms recovered from the groups post mortem. The conclusion was that "There were no discernable differences between the treated and the control groups in their manifestations of resistance to D. viviparus or their clinical responses to the diseases produced."
As far as I know, there are no other controlled veterinary trials published in peer-reviewed journals, positive or negative.

Yes, I do also have a small collection of published letters from individual homoeopaths claiming the obligatory one-off miracle cures. They're all of the "wild coincidence, never again repeated" variety. And there we are, right back to the embarrassing fact that if there's anything at all in these claims of miracle cures, the effects should be quite easy to demonstrate. But they're so shy, and just run away and hide at the very suggestion of a controlled trial....

And no, I don't propose to post here an essay about TCM "or anything" for anyone's edification. If I make an erroneous point, correct me. But be sure you can substantiate your assertions.

Rolfe.
 
Diogenes said:
P.S.

Has anyone else noticed the pattern of Olaf's posts?


A newbie claiming to be skeptical, and actually seeking the truth, whatever it may be, but getting all sideways when presented with the tiresome arguments that have been recounted here time after time?

O.K., everyone, wipe that turnip dust off your knickers...

Heretofore known as...

-The Homeoskeptic Conversion

-The olaf Diversion

-The NaturalHealth Gambit

-"pulling an olaf/homeoskeptic"
 
It still boggles my mind that somewhere in the vicinity of 75,000 to 100,000 MD's use homeopathy. What a wonderful thing that they can use a treatment that they are not certain as to how it works. Of course, the same can be said for many drugs. they do not know why a drug works but they use it.

The only thing that matters i guess is that good results are obtained. I strongly suspect that results are being obtained and that is why homeopathy is growing all around the world.

100,000 ='s 1000 + 1000 + 1000 + 1000 + ..... boy is that a lot!
 
Homeoskeptic said:
One of the authors was someone called Alison Fixen.

You should find it on the alt-med part of medline.
Come on! When we cite references, we post the links or at least cite the proper reference. Were you hoping that by not doing this, the fact that the differences reported did not reach statistical significance?

You know, the way the placebo actually did better than the Podophyllum in the calf diarrhoea study, but nobody is trumpeting great miracles for placebo because that wasn't statistically significant either....

Rolfe.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Homeopathy has nothing to do with belief at all.

Then I'm sure you you don't mind providing some evidence?

The right remedy will work on even the hardest nosed sceptic such as you. I have treated several in my practice and it has worked every time.

Don't be daft! A real skeptic wouldn't be seen dead in your clinic.

----

There is a study about this that demonstrates that homeopathy worked very well in cases of glue ear and as I said before, a lot of cases do not just spontaneously.

One of the authors was someone called Alison Fixen.

Are you really this obtuse? References, pal. References.

We are not gonna take your word for it. In fact we're not gonna trust you to tell us the time. That's what you get for lying repeatedly to people.


-----

Homeopathy does in fact have an physiological effect on the body.

No, based on current evidence it has not. How is the test you are designing coming along?

All the cases that I have posted are of clinical experience. Clinical experience and evidence is extremely valuable and not anecdotal at all.

No they are anecdotes. There is such a thing as clinical data, but I have not yet seen a homeopath provide it. All anybody has provided is evidence that they don't know what clinical data is.

Please, NH: Do you think you are impressing anybody here with all your nonsense? All you are doing is undermining what might be left of the credibility of homeopathy.

And your "friend" "Olaf" is doing even worse.

Maybe you think you can wear out our resistance with your unfounded allegations and repeated inane mantras, but that is not how things work here. We will keep calling your bluff for as long as it takes, and there are no friendly adminstrators that are gonna silence us here (please notice that they also allow YOU to continue).

But we are a forgiving lot. Start arguing seriously, and we're game, no matter how great a fool you have made of yourself previously (well, almost, I guess).

Hans
 
olaf said:
The only thing that matters i guess is that good results are obtained. I strongly suspect that results are being obtained and that is why homeopathy is growing all around the world.

100,000 ='s 1000 + 1000 + 1000 + 1000 + ..... boy is that a lot!
Now, about that evidence that the people who get their prescribed remedy actually have, on average, a better chance of improving than a comparable group who only thought they were getting their remedy? That's the only way to tell if there's a real effect, but so far no dice.

You suspect results are being obtained!!!! How about you just open that closed-like-a-steel-trap mind of yours for just one second and look at the objective facts?

Oh, are we back to 100,000 now? You were going to cite the source of this, show that it was obtained from reliable data on members of organisations and things like that? That it's not just some homoeopath's wildly optimistic figure plucked out of the air, with about as much substance as Naturalhealth's "thousands" of veterinary homoepaths who turn out to be 41?

Rolfe.
 
Homeoskeptic,

The Field tells the story of a group of frontier scientists who discovered that the Zero Point Field - an ocean of subatomic vibrations in the space between things - connects everything in the universe, much like the Force in Star Wars.
The Field offers a radically new view of the way our world and our bodies work. The human mind and body are not distinct and separate from their environment, but a packet of pulsating energy constantly interacting with this vast energy sea.
The Field creates a picture of an interconnected universe and a new scientific theory which makes sense of 'supernatural 'phenomena.

Above all, The Field is a book of hope and inspiration.

http://www.wddty.co.uk/thefield/main.asp

Attention: negative, pessimistic, malcontent skeptics --- you should not read this book it is beyond your grasp.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom