Homeoskeptic said:
I bet that animals treated by vets homeopathically and so much healthier.
I was just wondering how much Rolfe knew about TCM if anything. We shall see?
You bet. You think. Evidence, please?
I could easily embark on my store of sickening anecdotes about animals which were trusted to the not-so-tender care of these homoeopathic vets for too long, and were in a pitiful state by the time their owners woke up and sought help from a sane colleague. (
Edited to add, OK, I can skip that for now, as I see BSM was doing pretty much that while I was typing this up - and
finding the links to the references, NH!) However, I have no more quotable evidence for these stories than Naturalhealth has for her/his stories (well, apart from the one that went to court, "CD" again as it happens, surprising how much destruction so few people can cause, but I don't know how to access these records anyway).
Therefore, I will quote what is verifiable.
Scott et al., 2002
Abstract — A commercial homeopathic remedy and a placebo were administered orally as individual agents to 18 dogs with atopic dermatitis. The pruritus was reduced by less than 50% in only 2/18 dogs; 1 of these dogs was receiving the homeopathic remedy, the other was receiving the placebo. One dog vomited after administration of the homeopathic remedy.
de Verdier Klingenberg et al., 2003
No clinically or statistically significant difference between the 2 groups was demonstrated. Calves treated with Podophyllum had an average of 3.1 days of diarrhoea compared with 2.9 days for the placebo group. Depression, inappetence and fever were presented equally in the 2 groups. These results support the widely held opinion that scientific proof for the efficacy of veterinary homeopathy is lacking. In the European Union this implies a considerable risk for animal welfare, since in some countries priority is given to homeopathic treatments in organic farming.
Taylor
et al., 1989 (not available on-line, but this is in the
Veterinary Record, of which I have a paper copy)
No antibody could be demonstrated in either group, mortality in both groups was high, and there was no difference in the number or morphology of the worms recovered from the groups post mortem. The conclusion was that "There were no discernable differences between the treated and the control groups in their manifestations of resistance to D. viviparus or their clinical responses to the diseases produced."
As far as I know, there are no other controlled veterinary trials published in peer-reviewed journals, positive or negative.
Yes, I do also have a small collection of published letters from individual homoeopaths claiming the obligatory one-off miracle cures. They're all of the "wild coincidence, never again repeated" variety. And there we are, right back to the embarrassing fact that if there's anything at all in these claims of miracle cures, the effects should be quite easy to demonstrate. But they're so shy, and just run away and hide at the very suggestion of a controlled trial....
And no, I don't propose to post here an essay about TCM "or anything" for anyone's edification. If I make an erroneous point, correct me. But be sure you can substantiate your assertions.
Rolfe.