Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

And, while we're at it:

How can trituration make an insoluble substance soluble?

Let me be more specific: Silica. Sand. Sand consists of a (suprisingly large) number of mineral compounds, prominent among which are silicon oxides. Silicon oxides are not soluble in water or alcohol. How can trituration, which is simply grinding, make silicon oxides soluble?

Hans
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Perhaps you should actually read what I wrote. I never wrote anything about the fact that homeopathy could cure Turner's Syndrome. This is you reading what you want to into my post.

Read it again. It did not say anything about curing Turner's Syndrome.

I know what you wrote, but it we cannot advance the argument by even a millimetre until you are nailed down to specific positions.

Right. So homeopathy can't cure Turner's syndrome. But all disease results from disorders of the vital force. By your own terminology the missing X-chromosome must at least be a symptom of this. If homeopathy's powers are limited and unable to cure genetic disorders what defines the parameters of this limitation?

You have snookered yourself.

By the way you must make sure that Divina doesn't read this. She has airily claimed the ability to cure genetic diseases, she just bemoans the fact the evil allopaths ensure that homeopaths do no have access to the cases.


Homeoskeptic said:

The homeopathic pharmacies use nuclear grade water to make remedies these days just because it is available. It was not available in Hahnemann's day and you do not necessarily need to use nuclear grade water. Remedies still work without this.

I use ordinary tap water for 'plussing' remedies all the time and they work perfectly well. I would normally plus a 30c.

Hmmm. That's all very well, but do you recall why we are discussing water purity? You brought it up in the effort to show off how carefully the remedies are prepared.

Snooker number 2.

Conventionally players admit defeat at this stage. But I'd love to see you try to get out of these so please carry on.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:
Hmmm. That's all very well, but do you recall why we are discussing water purity? You brought it up in the effort to show off how carefully the remedies are prepared.
In the end, does degree of water purity really matter? No matter how carefully purified, double-distilled or whatever (we still don't know what this weird "nuclear water" actually is though), there will always be a large number of trace impurities at the level of the relatively low-potency homoeopathic dilutions (a few parts per million, or whatever).

You can't eliminate this by any purification process known to the 21st century, never mind Hahnemann's day. Therefore you have to dream up some other explanation of how the water (water/alcohol? - we still haven't addressed that part) knows which are the remedy molecules to do the mojo on, and which are random contaminants to be ignored. And since you can make a homoeopathic remedy "out of absolutely anything", then there's no intrinsic reason I can see why any trace contaminant shouldn't come through just as strongly as the intended remedy.

So, Naturalhealth, how does the solvent know which is the intended remedy and which are the contaminants?

Rolfe.
 
Since NH seems to have (temporarily?) left the building, let me try to answer with an explanation I have seen at one of the homeopathy BBs (or rather, my interpretation of that explanation, since the original one was a bit long-winded):

In the initial dilution phase, there is raw substance present in an amount that far exceeds any impurities.

The succussion process tunes the solvent medium to this substance, so that the whole mass of the medium has now attained the special characteristic of the medical substance.

In each subsequent dilution, this is transferred to the next step, all the time overriding possible impurities at the start; in an nC dilution, it will be 1% of the medium, far more than impurities in even fair grade tap water. Then the succussion process tunes or aligns all the medium to the original substance, etc, etc.

As long as you accept the basic premise that a water memory mechanism exists, which is activated by succussion, I feel this makes perfect sense; the original substance provides some sort of matrix towhich all the water is aligned, then as the raw substance is diluted away, the water transferred to the next step takes over the matrix role and aligns the new batch of solvent.

See, NH, that wasn't so hard, was it;)?

What this does not explain is why there should be any difference between, say, 15C and 60C, but we might assume that there is more to water memory that mere pattern replication.

Now we only have to find that memory mechanism........

Hans
 
Your description of dilluting the homeopathic "medicine" made me think of the following question: during the making of a medicine, what is done with the surplus of the higher dillution concoctions? I suppose a large part of it has to be discarded in some way, because otherwise the whole worlds supply of water would be used to make just one type of homeopathic medicine.

So what do you do with it? Do you filter it to make pure water for further production of medicine - but how, if the poor sample of water forever remembers the substance in it, supposedly even beyond the molecular lever?

Or do you just flush it down the drain and make the whole sewage system one big stinking homeopathic medicine?
 
MRC_Hans said:


In the initial dilution phase, there is raw substance present in an amount that far exceeds any impurities.

The succussion process tunes the solvent medium to this substance, so that the whole mass of the medium has now attained the special characteristic of the medical substance.

In each subsequent dilution, this is transferred to the next step, all the time overriding possible impurities at the start; in an nC dilution, it will be 1% of the medium, far more than impurities in even fair grade tap water. Then the succussion process tunes or aligns all the medium to the original substance, etc, etc.

As long as you accept the basic premise that a water memory mechanism exists, which is activated by succussion, I feel this makes perfect sense; the original substance provides some sort of matrix towhich all the water is aligned, then as the raw substance is diluted away, the water transferred to the next step takes over the matrix role and aligns the new batch of solvent.

And that’s a theory! Nothing else, and not even a good theory because it can’t be falsified. We just can’t prove if water has memory or not (well, actually we can, but not in a way that homeopaths would except).

A fun implication of this theory is that if we have, for instance a 1 M CN, which would probably kill a person, and mix that with 2 M /insert homeopathic remedy/ the cyanide would be, according to the theory, neutralized. Actually, this would also make all food taste like the most abundant ingredient (food usually contain more water than anything else, so the memory-water is present).

I’ll eat one of my hats, if this is a correct theory that describes reality.
 
Fantastic explanation, Hans, and while I understand it's your interpretation of another's explanation, it again reminds me of the thought patterns that exist when I endeavour to make up a pseudo-scientific process for a sci-fi story.

The bottom line is that we have found no evidence for water memory; let alone any sort of 'molecular coding' that could be complicated enough to account for a wide range of substrates. Again, I could make up a system based on what I know of hydrogen bonds and walpole forces etc., but what makes this any different from speculative fiction?

It all comes down to the following;

Is homeopathy dangerous? It follows two paths -

Homoepathy works: we do not understand the mechanisms, how it affects the body or how the body's biochemistry is influenced by 'memory coded' water. Without having the vaguest idea of how biochemistry is involved, we don't know how this impacts an organism by way of metabolite production, how it influences genetics, or how it intereferes with any single drug. Not knowing any of these things is tantamount to negligence (and would be if we were looking at the creation of any synthetic drug for administration to the public). If homeopathic drugs are to be part of the pharmaceutical industry, then they should abide by the general rules and standards.

Homeopathy does not work: people are then taking drugs with the assumption that various ailments are being treated when, in reality, they are not, which ultimately leads to its own complications.

So, pick one of the above. We can discuss mechanisms until the cows come home - I could make up a couple myself. Unfortunately we're counting angels dancing on the heads of pins.

Athon
 
MRC_Hans said:
The succussion process tunes the solvent medium to this substance, so that the whole mass of the medium has now attained the special characteristic of the medical substance.
As you say, that wasn't hard, was it? I'd thought of that one myself earlier, also the opposite one where you declare that the impurities are at a constant level at all dilutions, while only the remedy is being serially diluted away, and the water knows to remember the molecule which is gradually disappearing.

Both explanations are complete BS, but it always gives one something to say! :D

As you say, the problem is that we have to find this elusive water memory before we can pin this one down. Pity all the work done so far has only succeeded in demonstrating the complete forgetfulness of water.

But hey, homoeopaths don't use just water for their preparations, we're told it's a water/alcohol mixture. Could it possibly be that it is this special mixture which has the amazing memory properties, and all the scientists have been misled by investigating just water? How critical is the alcohol part of these wonderful effects, Naturalhealth? What homoeopathic research has been done to establish the critical proportions?

Oh dear, King Bio advertises that they don't use any nasty alcohol in their homoeopathic preparations, so they're eminently suitable for teetotallers. Homoeopaths still seem to think their remedies work. So bang goes that idea.

Wonderful memory this, seems to be present with or without unspecified amounts of alcohol cluttering up the mix.

(As an aside, we've been frequently told that alcohol is a homoeopathic remedy. Diluted and succussed in yet more alcohol, we presume? :nope: So in that case, with Hans' explanation, how come every remedy isn't proving alcohol as well, as that is present in large enough quantities to "tune the whole medium" to its presence. Do tell - is there a homoeopathic remedy "acqua" as well? :rolleyes: )

The memory effect also seems to be magically transferable to the sugar pill, too! Remember, no molecular content to the liquid-phase 30C remedy apart from water, maybe an unspecified amount of alcohol, and those pesky ppm contaminants. Just the mysterious unmeasurable and undetectable memory or whatever. Then this is dropped on a sugar pill and allowed to evaporate, and the sugar pill miraculously takes on the properties of the remedy. Heap powerful medicine!

However, Naturalhealth has said that it doesn't really give much credence to the memory of water, and thinks it's some sort of unknown nuclear physics reaction. As if that gets it off any hooks at all!

As Geni keeps saying, we'd know about any of the suggested nuclear reactions, because of the stream of high-energy particles that would be coming off the remedy. Fortunately, there seem to be no such particles being given off! And even Kumar seems to have realised that atoms, and indeed most small molecules like water, are pretty stable things and difficult to split. He correctly stated that homoeopaths really had to look for molecular-level effects to explain what they claim is going on, and was it that remark that got the thread locked? He's right of course, but Naturalhealth doesn't seem to have got that far.

Of course they're between the devil and the deep blue sea. Nuclear reactions are preposterous and impossible, but at least they are mysterious enough to bamboozle the masses with. Molecular-scale effects ought to be detectable with relative ease, and of course no such effects have ever been demonstrated.

I can just picture Naturalhealth now, faced with the implausible piled on the ridiculous piled on the preposterous, and having no sensible answer at all (just resorting to calling us names and declaring that we're all stupid), setting its jaw in a mulish expression and declaring "but it works!"

Well, if it did, if even a tenth of the claimed "cures" are true, it should be easy to prove this to even the most sceptical doubter. This is always the sticking point.

Look, when you really get down to it, mechanism of action isn't the most important thing. Demonstrating that there is some action there in the first place is the key. "If it happens, it must be possible", and if homoeopathic effects were demonstrably happening then research scientists would be all over them trying to figure out how. The problem with homoeopathy isn't really that it lacks a plausible mechanism of action, but that there doesn't seem to be anything happening there in the first place.

Naturalhealth will no doubt tell us of yet more gullible people who had some unspecified complaint, were given some remedy, and maybe got better immediately, or maybe got worse for a while, but that proves it, end of story.

Well, I can give you equally strong cases where homoeopathic treatment has made not the slightest bit of difference to the patient, and in the end the animal has had to be presented for real medicine. Duel by anecdote could go on all night.

The only way to settle any of this is by demonstrating that people who get their prescribed remedy have on average a better chance of recovery than people who only thought they got the remedy. But this can't be done. As I keep saying, Naturalhealth can have all the stories it likes, but we know that the minute everyone involved is blinded as to who got the remedy and who didn't, the effect disappears. If someone was sneakily substituting a placebo for the remedy in half of Naturalhealth's caseload (assuming s/he has one, and that isn't just a pack of lies like the Italian degree and the woo-woo wife and being a GP), s/he would never know which ones had had their remedy and which hadn't.

S/he can't even differentiate between a remedy of her/his choice and a chemically identical placebo, and neither can any other homoeopath, not even with a million dollars at stake.

Sorry to keep repeating this, but it would be nice to see Naturalhealth actually addressing some of the issues. We seem to have decided that homoeopathy can't cure genetic diseases (though it may "help" in some woolly and unspecified way), and that pure water isn't necessary for proper homoeopathic preparation (though we can't really explain how come the impurities don't potentise). How about trying a few more of the questions?

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
As you say, that wasn't hard, was it? I'd thought of that one myself earlier, also the opposite one where you declare that the impurities are at a constant level at all dilutions, while only the remedy is being serially diluted away, and the water knows to remember the molecule which is gradually disappearing.

Both explanations are complete BS, but it always gives one something to say! :D

*sniiiiip * ;)
Rolfe.
Well, that only goes to show you that BS can be perfectly logic. The trick is, and it is an oft used trick, that based on the premises given it is a perfectly sound and sensible explanation. Only problem is that the premises were tailored to the explanation.

Try to read through NH's postings, and those of other homeopaths (the literate ones of'em), and you will see just this; the explanations and the logic are sound enough, if only you accept the hidden premises.

However, I think you nail it well down in the part I snipped (:p): This is not some fleeting, delicate little effect that should require complex and carefully crafted experiments to verifiy. It is a chorous of homeopaths practicing many variations of their art, but all unanimously crying "IT WORKS!", so we should be facing a simple and robust phenomenon that will show up solidly even in partly flawed experiments.

Unless we are talking about the well-known and solid phenomenon of delusion.......

Hans
 
MRC_Hans said:
This is not some fleeting, delicate little effect that should require complex and carefully crafted experiments to verifiy. It is a chorous of homeopaths practicing many variations of their art, but all unanimously crying "IT WORKS!", so we should be facing a simple and robust phenomenon that will show up solidly even in partly flawed experiments.
Mmmm, yes.

Naturalhealth, despite apparent literacy, is actually one of the most limited minds among the homoeopaths. Many of them seem to have their own little "killer phrases" which they fondly imagine will repel every argument, but NH/HS seems to have nothing but the universal mantra of "It works and you're all too stupid to see it". I have to say, though, that some of the others (like David and Leela) are just as bad.

Others are slightly more inventive....
Divina: F*ck off, troll!
Bach: Testing homoeopathy using the blind controlled trial is like trying to make meaningful measurements with a yardstick with 37 divisions.
Xanta: The Queen of England! Kleijnen, Boissel and Linde!
Barb: Oooh, I just love it when Divina swears at the trolls, it shows the depth and strength of her position so perfectly!

Invective and accusations of trolling are pretty clear defences put up by people who know very well that they don't have any answers to the questions, but would very much prefer to go on taking people's money.

Bach is fun. He started by declaring that the controlled trial was like trying to measure distance using a set of scales - the wrong tool for the job. It was pointed out to him that controlled trials were designed to measure efficacy, and he was claiming efficacy, so that was a false metaphor. He then moved on to measuring distance using a yardstick with 37 (even) divisions on it. It was smartly pointed out to him that even that inaccurate tool could be used to give precise measurements, whereupon it became a yardstick with 37 unevenly spaced divisions, and even later 37 divisions that were moving around at random!

He seems to think he's made some sort of rapier-like point with this inane analogy, and certainly didn't seem to have figured out the silliness by the time of the mass banning of the people he was arguing with. Of course it's obvious which side of the story is represented by the fickle system that changes its properties at random, isn't it....?

When Xanta was here (as "Gold"), she didn't get any further than the constant repetition of "The Queen of England!", as if Tin Lizzie's espousal of homoeopathy was the killer argument to justify it forever. However, on the H'pathy board she had a rather better argument from authority going, repeatedly posting very selective passages from the homoeopaths' pet meta-analyses, the three mainstream-journal papers that didn't wholly exclude an effect of homoeopathy. (In fact, her "quote" from Kleijnen was fabricated, which wasn't well received.)

Now these papers are worthy of a closer look, because they're the best the homoeopaths have in the way of objective evidence. As Hans said, this isn't supposed to be a fleeting or delicate effect, this is a claimed miracle medicine which can cure or "help" whatever ails you, often showing striking and even astonishing effects.

So, since Naturalhealth hasn't brought these up itself yet, what do the most favourable papers really have to say?

Kleijnen et al., 1991
CONCLUSIONS--At the moment the evidence of clinical trials is positive but not sufficient to draw definitive conclusions because most trials are of low methodological quality and because of the unknown role of publication bias.
Cucherat et al., 2000 (the published version of Boissel's 1996 report)
CONCLUSIONS: There is some evidence that homeopathic treatments are more effective than placebo; however, the strength of this evidence is low because of the low methodological quality of the trials. Studies of high methodological quality were more likely to be negative than the lower quality studies.
Linde et al., 1997
INTERPRETATION: The results of our meta-analysis are not compatible with the hypothesis that the clinical effects of homeopathy are completely due to placebo. However, we found insufficient evidence from these studies that homeopathy is clearly efficacious for any single clinical condition.
Note how elderly these studies are getting. 1997 is the most recent in actual fact, seven years ago. Also note the extremely weak support they offer for homoeopathy. As Hans said, this should be a simple and robust phenomenon that should show up clearly even in partly flawed experiments. Instead we're scratching around on the borders of statistical significance, and let's be frank, effects which are that marginal are usually pretty much useless in a clinical situation - even if the magic water can reliably reduce the frequency of your asthmatic coughs by one cough a week, is that really much help to you? Or as Bandolier commented, "If this is the best they can do, why bother?"

The thing about science is that strange effects are reported quite regularly. That's the way things get discovered. But to be accepted as real, the data have to be verified, repeated, substantiated, and stand up to critical scrutiny. These reports have managed none of that. Instead, the more recent, high-quality, rigorously-designed studies (as called for by all three sets of authors) have shown up a resounding nothing. In addition, the conclusions that there did seem to be something there have been strenuously criticised, especially as regards the Linde paper. Ernst, 2002 is the most comprehensive.
Six [articles] related to re-analyses of one landmark meta-analysis [Linde]. Collectively they implied that the overall positive result of this meta-analysis is not supported by a critical analysis of the data. Eleven independent systematic reviews were located. Collectively they failed to provide strong evidence in favour of homeopathy. In particular, there was no condition which responds convincingly better to homeopathic treatment than to placebo or other control interventions. Similarly, there was no homeopathic remedy that was demonstrated to yield clinical effects that are convincingly different from placebo.
Bandolier also quotes a separate letter from the same source, also discussing Linde:
"Some (but by no means all) methodologically astute and highly convincing homeopaths have published results that look convincing but are, in fact, not credible. Viewed in this way, the reanalysis.... can be seen as the ultimate epidemiological proof that homeopathic remedies are, in fact, placebos."
This is something people are often too polite to talk about. These "open-minded" homoeopaths are often so assured of the effect they are trying to demonstrate that they cherrypick and massage the data into an apparently positive result. It takes a skilled scrutineer to spot this, and as has been said elsewhere, not all scrutineers are perfect. It then takes careful appraisal of the data to spot the man behind the screen. Homoeopaths don't like it when their treasured "positive" trials are taken apart before their eyes, but I'm afraid that's the way of it. When you look critically at what has been reported, the flaw is always there to be seen.

So where does that leave support for Naturalhealth and "it works!"? Not a leg to stand on, I'm afraid. Let's face it, if you take any group of the sort of vague, chronic or self-limiting ailments that are likely to go to a homoeopath, about 70% would improve if you did absolutely nothing. (That includes temporary improvements, which are a great help with really chronic ailments, as patients tend to seek help when they are feeling at their worst, when the only way to go is up.) Add that to a system which has an explanation for just about anything that happens in terms of the remedy "working" (he aggravated for three days....), and you have a perfect seam from which to mine any number of positive anecdotes.

But it still doesn't work - or at least no better than a kind word and a sugar pill has always worked.

Rolfe.
 
Question:

If Homeopathy is such fraud then why do close to 100,000 European medical doctors believe it works?

Is it possible that somehow, someway it is doing as claimed?

Based on some of the odd phenomena that we see in QM I see potentially a way that substances can interact with one another.

Something is going on when that many doctors use it.
 
I do not just treat chronic cases at all. I treat acute cases and everything in between.

The chronic cases are not always at their worst as you say, there are lots of others too.

I have treated loads of kids with glue ear and have actually prevented them needing treatment with gromets. Also, there is a postive study that was conducted by an old tutor of mine about the use of remedies for children with glue ear.

This was a pilot study where kids were treated with the correct homeopathic remedies for glue ear and it was positive for homeopathy. The kids treated with homeopathy avoided the need for gromets and antiobiotics. This study showed that homeopathy was extremely effective and recommended that more studies be carried out.

The right remedy works instantly in an acute situation. One of my old tutors was in India about 30 years ago and got dysentry. He was ill and there was an Indian out there who was studying homeopathy at the time and asked if he could give him some remedies. He gave him the remedy Aloe and his dysentry was cured.

Homeopathy is spreading throughout the world. There is an organisation called Frontline Homeopathy that has taken homeopathy to the third world. They train healthcare professionals - doctors and nurses in homeopathy and they then train the others and they then take homeopathic care to their communities.

Their clinics are flourishing and their people are extremely healthy and they get better. It just shows that good things spread.

In answer to your question - this leaves me exactly where I was before. With a thriving practice and lots of healthy patients who are a lot better than they would have been had they not experienced true healing with homeopathy.

HOMEOPATHY IS HERE TO STAY, so I would just get used to it if I were you.
 
olaf said:
Question:

If Homeopathy is such fraud then why do close to 100,000 European medical doctors believe it works?



Why don't you ask some of those doctors why they believe it works? If it's because of studies, I'm sure people here would love to see references to them. If it's because of "personal experience", then they're no better than anecdotes, and I'd be rather concerned for my health going to such a doctor.

Is it possible that somehow, someway it is doing as claimed?

Logically possible? Sure! If it IS doing what it is claimed it does, then where are the controlled studies demonstrating it?

Something is going on when that many doctors use it.

Why couldn't that "Something going on" be self-delusion?
 
Homeoskeptic said:

HOMEOPATHY IS HERE TO STAY, so I would just get used to it if I were you.

Yeah, fraudulent medicine IS here to stay, doesn't mean we want to get used to it.
 
No. This is not anecdotal evidence. This is clinical experience and clinical cases. Even conventional medicine uses this, or if not, then this makes all of conventional medicine anecdotal anyway. Having said that, a lot of it is lets face it.
 
No. Not at all. As Olaf said, thousands of doctors worldwide practice homeopathy.

A lot of conventional medicine is faudulent and just look at the amount of QUACKS that practice conventional medicine!! It beggars belief at times.

At least all the homeopaths have their clinical cases and clinical experience to demonstrate that homeopathy works and is extremely effecive.

LONG LIVE HOMEOPATHY. IT IS HEAR TO STAY.
 
olaf ranted:

If Homeopathy is such fraud then why do close to 100,000 European medical doctors believe it works?

Have you any proof to support this ridiculous claim?

Thought not.

Is it possible that somehow, someway it is doing as claimed?

What possesses a person to ask such a foolishly pointless question?

Based on some of the odd phenomena that we see in QM I see potentially a way that substances can interact with one another.

QM reference- 10 woo woo points.

Something is going on when that many doctors use it.

Eat sh!t! a million flies can't be wrong!

Hark! I hear the call of the Greater Scandanavian Crested Looney.



:tr:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom