MRC_Hans said:
The succussion process tunes the solvent medium to this substance, so that the whole mass of the medium has now attained the special characteristic of the medical substance.
As you say, that wasn't hard, was it? I'd thought of that one myself earlier, also the opposite one where you declare that the impurities are at a constant level at all dilutions, while only the remedy is being serially diluted away, and the water knows to remember the molecule which is gradually disappearing.
Both explanations are complete BS, but it always gives one something to say!
As you say, the problem is that we have to find this elusive water memory before we can pin this one down. Pity all the work done so far has only succeeded in demonstrating the complete forgetfulness of water.
But hey, homoeopaths don't use just water for their preparations, we're told it's a water/alcohol mixture. Could it possibly be that it is this special mixture which has the amazing memory properties, and all the scientists have been misled by investigating just water? How critical is the alcohol part of these wonderful effects, Naturalhealth? What homoeopathic research has been done to establish the critical proportions?
Oh dear, King Bio advertises that they don't use any nasty alcohol in their homoeopathic preparations, so they're eminently suitable for teetotallers. Homoeopaths still seem to think their remedies work. So bang goes that idea.
Wonderful memory this, seems to be present with or without unspecified amounts of alcohol cluttering up the mix.
(As an aside, we've been frequently told that alcohol is a homoeopathic remedy. Diluted and succussed in yet more alcohol, we presume?

So in that case, with Hans' explanation, how come every remedy isn't proving alcohol as well, as that is present in large enough quantities to "tune the whole medium" to its presence. Do tell - is there a homoeopathic remedy "acqua" as well?

)
The memory effect also seems to be magically transferable to the sugar pill, too! Remember, no molecular content to the liquid-phase 30C remedy apart from water, maybe an unspecified amount of alcohol, and those pesky ppm contaminants. Just the mysterious unmeasurable and undetectable memory or whatever. Then this is dropped on a sugar pill and allowed to evaporate, and the sugar pill miraculously takes on the properties of the remedy. Heap powerful medicine!
However, Naturalhealth has said that it doesn't really give much credence to the memory of water, and thinks it's some sort of unknown nuclear physics reaction. As if that gets it off any hooks at all!
As Geni keeps saying, we'd know about any of the suggested nuclear reactions, because of the stream of high-energy particles that would be coming off the remedy. Fortunately, there seem to be no such particles being given off! And even Kumar seems to have realised that atoms, and indeed most small molecules like water, are pretty stable things and difficult to split. He correctly stated that homoeopaths really had to look for molecular-level effects to explain what they claim is going on, and was it that remark that got the thread locked? He's right of course, but Naturalhealth doesn't seem to have got that far.
Of course they're between the devil and the deep blue sea. Nuclear reactions are preposterous and impossible, but at least they are mysterious enough to bamboozle the masses with. Molecular-scale effects ought to be detectable with relative ease, and of course no such effects have ever been demonstrated.
I can just picture Naturalhealth now, faced with the implausible piled on the ridiculous piled on the preposterous, and having no sensible answer at all (just resorting to calling us names and declaring that we're all stupid), setting its jaw in a mulish expression and declaring "but it works!"
Well, if it did, if even a tenth of the claimed "cures" are true, it should be easy to prove this to even the most sceptical doubter. This is always the sticking point.
Look, when you really get down to it, mechanism of action isn't the most important thing. Demonstrating that there is some action there in the first place is the key. "If it happens, it must be possible", and if homoeopathic effects were demonstrably happening then research scientists would be all over them trying to figure out how. The problem with homoeopathy isn't really that it lacks a plausible mechanism of action, but that there doesn't seem to be anything happening there in the first place.
Naturalhealth will no doubt tell us of yet more gullible people who had some unspecified complaint, were given some remedy, and maybe got better immediately, or maybe got worse for a while, but that proves it, end of story.
Well, I can give you equally strong cases where homoeopathic treatment has made not the slightest bit of difference to the patient, and in the end the animal has had to be presented for real medicine. Duel by anecdote could go on all night.
The only way to settle any of this is by demonstrating that people who get their prescribed remedy have on average a better chance of recovery than people who only thought they got the remedy. But this can't be done. As I keep saying, Naturalhealth can have all the stories it likes, but we know that the minute everyone involved is blinded as to who got the remedy and who didn't, the effect disappears. If someone was sneakily substituting a placebo for the remedy in half of Naturalhealth's caseload (assuming s/he has one, and that isn't just a pack of lies like the Italian degree and the woo-woo wife and being a GP), s/he would never know which ones had had their remedy and which hadn't.
S/he can't even differentiate between a remedy of her/his choice and a chemically identical placebo, and neither can any other homoeopath, not even with a million dollars at stake.
Sorry to keep repeating this, but it would be nice to see Naturalhealth actually addressing some of the issues. We seem to have decided that homoeopathy can't cure genetic diseases (though it may "help" in some woolly and unspecified way), and that pure water isn't necessary for proper homoeopathic preparation (though we can't really explain how come the impurities don't potentise). How about trying a few more of the questions?
Rolfe.