Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

olaf said:
There is a whole 'nother field out their called energy medicine. It is not about how many molecules are left in solution it is about the underpinnings that make up all matter/energy that counts.
Now, someone remind me of which one of the Laws of Thermodynamics would be crashing in pieces if there was any truth in this?

Science can measure energy, in all its forms. If Geni were here, he would tell you. Nobody can measure this energy, nobody can describe it, in fact nobody can find it at all.

The best word for it is "magic".

Never mind, mechanism of action doesn't matter. Just show that there is an action there in the first place. Oh I forgot you can't do that.

Rolfe.
 
olaf said:
Homeoskeptic,

The Field tells the story of a group of frontier scientists who discovered that the Zero Point Field - an ocean of subatomic vibrations in the space between things - connects everything in the universe, much like the Force in Star Wars.
The Field offers a radically new view of the way our world and our bodies work. The human mind and body are not distinct and separate from their environment, but a packet of pulsating energy constantly interacting with this vast energy sea.
The Field creates a picture of an interconnected universe and a new scientific theory which makes sense of 'supernatural 'phenomena.

Above all, The Field is a book of hope and inspiration.

Above all, if it is anything like yousay, it is a load of pseudoscientific mumbo-jumbo.

http://www.wddty.co.uk/thefield/main.asp

Attention: negative, pessimistic, malcontent skeptics --- you should not read this book it is beyond your grasp.

Yeah. All we care for is evidence. Hard evidence. Care to provide some? :rolleyes: I thought not.

Hans
 
Rolfe said:

Oh, are we back to 100,000 now? You were going to cite the source of this, show that it was obtained from reliable data on members of organisations and things like that? That it's not just some homoeopath's wildly optimistic figure plucked out of the air, with about as much substance as Naturalhealth's "thousands" of veterinary homoepaths who turn out to be 41?

Rolfe.

In all countries homeopaths are organised. India has the largest number of homeopaths. The Central Body of Registration has over 125 000 registered homeopathic practitioners on its register. In France 18 000 (32%) of all general practitioners, 700 veterinarians and 2 000 dentists (5%) prescribe homeopathic medicines to their patients. This does however not mean that they consider themselves homeopaths. Some give their patients homeopathic medicines only, but most of them do it to a variable degree. Most of them are not organised in associations for homeopaths.


http://www.homeopathy-ecch.org/survey.html

Gee, it looks like 75,000 is a bit conservative considering that France has a whopping 18,000!


I am thinking that I have to go with the 100,000 MD's.
 
First of all the whole Randi business is a joke. He forces people to do the impossible. Then acts like he has the final answer to all life's mysteries.

Well, he's got us there, guys. Randi does drag homeopaths in at gunpoint and demand they do the impossible...

tell the difference between homeopathic water, and the non-magical variety.

I like Targ's response, "Randi seems like an angry..... man"

I like Targ too. I especially enjoyed his book:

http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/detail/-/1577310705/104-2572754-2675129?v=glance

Miracles of Mind: Exploring Nonlocal Consciousness and Spiritual Healing

The credulous tales of "psychic surgery" sessions had me in stitches. I like Targ... he's crazy.:crazy:
 
olaf said:
In France 18 000 (32%) of all general practitioners, 700 veterinarians and 2 000 dentists (5%) prescribe homeopathic medicines to their patients. This does however not mean that they consider themselves homeopaths.
Too true. I'm a bit doubtful of that 32% figure, but there is a long as dishonourable tradition among GPs in France of dishing out a homoeopathic remedy to keep the patient quiet while nature takes its course - the true meaning of the word "placebo". They don't believe a word of it, any more than I do.

Which is why I'm asking about verifiable figures for people who really set some store by it, who mostly do join these associations.

Rolfe.
 
Above all, if it is anything like yousay, it is a load of pseudoscientific mumbo-jumbo.

That is the problem. It is on the cutting edge. It is using the latest findings of quantum mechanics (ww 10 points!) to give us the answers to questions that puzzle us.

Your thinking may be in the stone age and therefore you will not be able to grasp these incredible ideas, facts, truths, theories.
 
olaf said:
First of all the whole Randi business is a joke. He forces people to do the impossible.
Randi invites people to demonstrate that they can do what they claim to be able to do, and offers them a million dollars if they can do this successfully. If what they claim they can do is in fact impossible, then it seems to me that this is their problem rather than Randi's.

First sign of anyone addressing the Challenge aspect of this, though. Actually, Naturalhealth (whom I don't really think is Olaf, I think we have double-troll here) was making a better fist of this by simply ignoring every mention of it.

Just show that you can tell the difference between a "potentised" remedy of your own selection and a chemically identical sham. Any way you like. Often enough to prove you're not just a lucky guesser. And collect the money.

Olaf is quite right, it is impossible. So what sort of fraud does that make Naturalhealth and al those thousands of other medical and lay homoeopaths who take people's money for things they can't even distinguish from sugar pills?

Rolfe.
 
olaf said:


That is the problem. It is on the cutting edge. It is using the latest findings of quantum mechanics (ww 10 points!) to give us the answers to questions that puzzle us.

Your thinking may be in the stone age and therefore you will not be able to grasp these incredible ideas, facts, truths, theories.
Oh yeah, that's why it's published in a fringe book, not in the mainstream scientific press. I see. I can't wait for the next Nobel nomination :rolleyes:.

Hans
 
olaf said:
That is the problem. It is on the cutting edge. It is using the latest findings of quantum mechanics (ww 10 points!) to give us the answers to questions that puzzle us.
Quantum mechanics like the kind Lionel Milgrom peddles (see earlier part of thread)? The kind the homoeopaths dreamed up for themselves one slack day, which has the interesting feature of dispensing with Planck's constant? Which introduces only the teensy little problem that the whole of the rest of quantum theory falls apart. (A<FONT SIZE="-1">TMANSPACHER</FONT>, H., R<FONT SIZE="-1">ÖMER</FONT>, H. & W<FONT SIZE="-1">ALACH</FONT>, H. (2002) Weak Quantum Theory: Complementarity and entanglement in physics and beyond. Foundations of Physics 32, 379-406.)

Don't even get me started on the way quantum theory doesn't explain homoeopathy - it just doesn't. The papers that cite it explicitly admit that they are only using it as a metaphor. When they get down to the maths it boils down to, well, if Planck's constant didn't exist, or was a much larger number we could make up as we went along, the universe would be like this. To which the only answer is that we're afraid Planck's constant does exist, and it's the magnitude it is (very, very small). So what you have written is a rather boring piece of speculative fiction in the "alternate universe" category.

Now, quit with trying to find a fanciful explanation, and get back to the question of whether there is or is not an effect to explain. The evidence to date says there isn't - or not the kind you mean, at least.

I'm still intrigued by the psychology behind the extreme believer of the medically qualified variety, and the extraordinary power delusion and self-deception can have over minds intelligent enough to know better.

Rolfe.
 
100,000 European MD's out of who knows. 1/2 million, 1 million, 1.5 million, several million I do not know, but I know that it is a lot of MD's that know that it works.

European
 
olaf said:
100,000 MD's that is a lot wouldn't you say?
Oh God it's the stuck record again. Maybe it's not Naturalhealth, but didn't Xanta get stuck on something similar once?

No, it's not necessarily a lot if you also tell us the total population you're comparing it with. And you still haven't provided the slightest piece of evidence to support the figure (except to revise it down to 75,000 for a while). I'm betting it's as reliable as Naturalhealth's claim of "thousands" of veterinary members of the Faculty of Homoeopathy - just a shame I have a list of all these people, and I can add up till I get to 41.

Olaf, note the way Naturalhealth simply ignores embarrassing points like this - I don't imagine s/he will ever even refer to it again, let alone acknowledge s/he's been caught out in a whopping lie. You could learn from this, perhaps. :rolleyes:

Rolfe.
 
I don't know much about the fallacies that others trot out. Is it a fallacy that just because 100,000 people think it's real, that doesn't make it so?
 
olaf said:
I do not know.
Truest statement we've had from this guy to date.

Now, provide evidence for the claimed figure. I can easily provide the evidence for my claim of 140 vets in the UK who appear to give some credence to homoeopathy, and of the total 20,000 (approx) of vets registered in the country. So, put up or shut up.

And, we're not talking about the doctors who might use homeopathic remedies to fob off difficult patients. We're talking been on training courses and swallow the whole nine yards of like cures like, the proving of the content-free preparation, and the "vital force".

I suspect that the 100,000 will go down in much the same proportion as Naturalhealth's claimed "thousands" went down to 41.

Rolfe.
 
Lisa Simpson said:
I don't know much about the fallacies that others trot out. Is it a fallacy that just because 100,000 people think it's real, that doesn't make it so?
It's a combination of appeal to popularity with appeal to authority. Combined with pure lying inflationary figures, I strongly suspect.

You see, Olaf scorns doctors, and wouldn't give tuppence for anything they recommended - except that if 100,000 of them think there's something in homoeopathy, then these are such intelligent and trustworthy people that this must make it so!

Olaf, we don't care how many delusional doctors there are out there (and Eos, I can quote a few names, Peter Fisher is the most famous but there's a Kathy Ryan putting herself about a bit, and I can find more if you like). We want objective evidence from them, or you, or indeed anybody at all that can manage to design a good-quality study, that there's anything there once you stop all concerned from knowing whether anyone has actually been given the real remedy or not.

Can't do it? Then do go on about the fictional 100,000 if it makes you feel better, but don't think that cuts any ice at all.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom