Lisa Simpson said:
So has homeopathy "evolved" at all since Hahnemann's day, or are they doing the exact same thing done more than 100 years ago?
I recommend some lurking on the homoeopaths' own discussion forums. Basically this is another thing about which they fight like ferrets in a sack. There are some who revere Hahnemann almost as a God, and will only countenance exact Hahnemanian practice, while others branch out into numerous other woo-woo add-ons.
Following their "discussions" when one lot contradicts advice given by the other lot is pretty good entertainment. Actually, since there are more than two camps, it can become hilarious.
It's also a great place to bring in the "no true Scotsman" argument. Any ridiculous or embarrassing claim or anecdote may be dismissed very simply by merely pronouncing whatever the perpetrator did to be "not real homoeopathy". NH/HS has already used this argument (earlier on, when s/he was still trying to present some semblance of reasoned argument), in order to dismiss the findings of all the controlled trials which have failed to show any detectable "proving" effect of an ultradilute remedy with properly blinded participants. Of course, the homoeopaths who advised on the protocol of the provings got it wrong, and it could never have worked.
One does have to question who are these homoeopaths who design duff protocols to ensure that the controlled trials fail. Wouldn't it be easier if someone who really knew what they were doing designed a correct protocol and amazed us all? Naturalhealth won't do it of course, too busy fleecing the uninformed public by taking their money for content-free remedies, but if s/he did, and it didn't work, there would just be another line of "real" homoeopaths queueing up to explain why this protocol was unsound and of course could never have worked!
Of course, the fact that Hahnemann himself was somewhat less than wholly consistent and can be quoted against himself only adds to the fun.
The homoeopaths in their natural habitat can be found at
Homeopathy Home and
H'pathy Forums. Both lots now ban dissenting voices almost on sight, but the latter has so far not erased the sceptics posts. Still, the real deal on the strict Hahnemanians versus the various other degrees of the reformed faith can be found in threads without a sceptical voice in sight.
Rolfe.