Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

NH is convinced by 20 years personal experience. I could start to believe by 1 well documented scientifically sound labarotory test. Funny how in 20 years there isn't one. Just anecdotes, which are fine for telling stories, but if it's reproducable for 20 years, why can't it be done in a lab?
 
Try to explain these if it does not work.

Judging by the language and ignorance, I have a hard time believing the 'ilk' is even 20, let alone 'practiced' homeopathy for 20 years.

Why not try to explain HOW these supposedly worked? What exact mechanism caused the exczema go away? We know how corticosteriods work, and why.

Oh, I forgot, it's MYSTERIOUS and MAGICAL properties that make it work. Ugh.
Do you even know what physics is? I think you're mixing it up with biology of some sort.

We also have no proof of your claims or that your anectdotes aren't totally made up.

Gimme a break already delusional 'ilk'.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:
Poor Kumar! I could almost feel sorry for him.
Posted by Naturalhealth
I think I know exactly who told you this too? It must be those fools at Randiland (JREFF), who still refuse to accept good case evidence. They are just blinkered idiots and I would never take any notice of them at all personally.
I think Kumar understood some of what he was told here, but he's still so convinced that there's an effect there that he's still sincerely looking for explanations. But questioning the "science" behind the popular explanations is no way to win friends at H'pathy.

Better approach. Someone had some ailment. I gave them a homoeopathic remedy. They got better. Or maybe they aggravated. But that shows absolute proof that homoeopathy works, how can you not see this? If you understood anything about homoeopathy you would know why this is a valid argument. Repeat ad infinitum.

Sigh.

No answer about what sort of water Hahnemann used. No answer about the proportion of alcohol to water, and how that affects the "physics" NH/HS is always on about. No answer to Prester John's question about how come nobody can find the slightest ghost of these striking and self-evident "cures" as soon as all participants are blinded to who has been dispensed the remedy and who hasn't.

And most telling of all, not even any attempt to explain how come, if it's so easy for a homoeopath to tell a remedy from a placebo, and there are all those squillions of skilled homoeopaths in the world, not one of them has decided to call Randi out on the Million Dollar Challenge.

No, NH/HS will just come back and repeat, "Someone was sick. I gave them a remedy. Something happened after that. That proves everything that needs to be proved."

If we were still in any doubt about whether or not this person is lying about being a qualified doctor, I think the abysmal grasp of how to present a medical case history for the edification of one's colleagues should just about settle it.

Rolfe.
 
HS/NH, feel free to start discussing in your own time.....


Tell us why you need 'ultrapure' water these days?


Tell us how homeopathy will replace the missing X-chromosome in Turner's syndrome? What about trisomy 21?


Come on Mr Intelligent Discussion, we're waiting........
 
I'm wondering if NH also knows if eczema can also by cyclical by genetic... hm. Guess not.
 
Homeoskeptic said:

Hey mate, if this is your first post, then let it stay that way. Don't allow yourself to get sucked in to this total rubbish that this lot spout all the time.
Get out whilst the going is good or at least try to be open minded. The other pretend to be but are not.

Why, thank you pal! Thank you so very much for the insightful advice. Problem is, I really don’t see any reason to why I should keep an open mind towards homeopathy. My education says that the hypotheses about water-memory are very well proven false. No material, except living, with DNA, has any memory of any kind, and water molecules, dihydrogenmonxid, has no DNA. Nothing there to keep the memory. Just a couple of H’s and one O. And please, don’t even get me started on why quantum theory won’t explain homeopathy, it doesn’t. And the latest news that water molecule chain in a certain way is just a revision of the former theories of water molecule chaining. Running water does chain, the new theory don’t change that in any way.

My experience tells me that using homeopathic remedies do not shorten symptoms. Homeopaths seem to ignore the fact that symptoms vary in length and strength. That is, a person with chronic back pains or with MS sometimes feel better, and that has nothing to do with where they’ve been, if they have been talking homeopathic remedies, or if they’ve been drinking water, it’s a part of the sickness.

I want to end with a short anecdote: A colleague of mine said that she wanted to try this new thing, homeopathy. I explained the principles of homeopathy to her, the dilution, the shaking, and that not even one molecule of the active ingredient is present in the remedy. To my surprise, she didn’t believe me. She thought a lied about the dilution and shaking! And all homeopaths agree with the dilution, the shaking and the non-existent active ingredient, but she didn’t believe it. So strange and unbelievable is homeopathy.
 
Unfortunately, this is not true at all. We very readily take account of the length of symptoms and exactly what is chronic and acute and the correct homeopathic remedy most certainly does shorten symptoms.

There is a case of MS which quite a famous colleague of mine reported on not long ago. She actually managed to cure a case of a patient with MS with LM potencies. The patient no longer has MS now.

Lionel Milgrom has been working on quantum theory although he is a chemist and a homeopath by training and there is also Colin Lessel who has written several books, The New Physics of Homeopathy. He is a doctor, a dentist and a practicing homeopathic dentist.

Perhaps you should take account of all the cases of all the homeopaths around the world and look at some of their cured cases.

Also, what experience might you have that allows you to comment on homeopathy not shortening any type of illness? Would it be that you are a homeopath? If not, then you most certainly do not have the necessary training or experience to comment.

Also, good for your friend at least being open minded enough to want to try it.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Unfortunately, this is not true at all. We very readily take account of the length of symptoms and exactly what is chronic and acute and the correct homeopathic remedy most certainly does shorten symptoms.
Then there should be peer-reviewed papers describing randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled studies available to support this. Please provide us these citations.
There is a case of MS which quite a famous colleague of mine reported on not long ago. She actually managed to cure a case of a patient with MS with LM potencies. The patient no longer has MS now.
This is nice, but, at most, it would be a "case history" paper. Is there a citation for this from a peer-reviewed journal?
Lionel Milgrom has been working on quantum theory although he is a chemist and a homeopath by training
No he hasn't. Lionel has been working on porphyrin chemistry. He wrote a weird paper in a homeopathy journal suggesting quantum mechanics as "a metaphor" (his words) for homeopathic healing.

This does not in any way constitute "work" in quantum theory.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
There is a case of MS which quite a famous colleague of mine reported on not long ago. She actually managed to cure a case of a patient with MS with LM potencies. The patient no longer has MS now.
This is truly fantastic! Please let the world know. If this works and holds in the very rigorous tests that all forms of medicine must go through, all MS patients in the world would be cured. Truly amazing!
Lionel Milgrom has been working on quantum theory although he is a chemist and a homeopath by training and there is also Colin Lessel who has written several books, The New Physics of Homeopathy. He is a doctor, a dentist and a practicing homeopathic dentist.
Having some insights in chemistry on university level, I would say as Einstein: Quantum physics is a little too difficult for chemists. (No, I have no source for that quote, but it’s a fun one, especial if one study quantum physics)

If you can make Ed Witten comment on the connection between “water-memory” and quantum physics, I would be Impressed. Medical programs don’t teach that much physics, and I’m almost certain that study modern physics is not compulsory to be a physician. And frankly, saying that a writer is Doctor in this or that does not make his writing true.

Also, what experience might you have that allows you to comment on homeopathy not shortening any type of illness? Would it be that you are a homeopath? If not, then you most certainly do not have the necessary training or experience to comment.
Oh, I didn't know that one must have certain training to debate homeopathy. Sorry about that. Lets make a deal, you can't comment on physics or chemistry and I can't comment on medicine, OK?

Also, good for your friend at least being open minded enough to want to try it.
Actually, what I said was that she didn’t believe that homeopathy included such things as water-memory and shaking of water.
 
So has homeopathy "evolved" at all since Hahnemann's day, or are they doing the exact same thing done more than 100 years ago?
 
Yes, of course homeopathy has evolved since Hahnemann's day.

Basically, his original priciples of classical homeopathy are the same and are still practiced, but the ways of looking at cases have changed since his day. People such as Sankaran and the Indian homeopaths and the Italians such as Massimo Mangialavori have developed homeopathy a lot.

We know more about remedies now that we did in his day and lots of new things have been developed, so yes, homeopathy has most certainly moved on since this time.

The case of the eczema was diagnosed by me and was treated homeopathically.

The patient with ADD was daignosed by another doctor and was then referred to me for homeopathic treatment.

The case of the MS patient has been published I think in a homeopathy journal. The homeopath is Finnish. She also presented this case at the Society of Homeopath's a Spring conference recently.
 
If the methods have stayed the same, why the need for ultra pure water, then? If regular old water was good enough for Hahnemann, why "nuclear grade" water now?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Yes, of course homeopathy has evolved since Hahnemann's day.

Basically, his original priciples of classical homeopathy are the same and are still practiced, but the ways of looking at cases have changed since his day. People such as Sankaran and the Indian homeopaths and the Italians such as Massimo Mangialavori have developed homeopathy a lot.
Listen, loon,

I made the mistake of looking up Mangialavori's "articles" on Mangialavori's web site. The English version of his site gives two different copies of a single article. Or so it is billed. It is actually a talk he presented at a conference in Moderno. No case histories. No study results. The talk is on "The Didactics of Homeopathy," in which he rails against the sorry state of homeopathic education, and the failure to produce either a guaranteed level of professionality to patients or to produce researchers capable of showing how good homeopathy is. He also, of course, rails against homeopaths not really having full parity with real doctors.

I'm not making this mistake again, sir. I have asked for citations. Not this childish confusion of giving speeches or writing books with research. This is not research. These are the musings of the deluded.
 
Homeoskeptic wrote:

Yes, of course homeopathy has evolved since Hahnemann's day.

Basically, his original priciples of classical homeopathy are the same and are still practiced...

......snip...

Except for Hahnemann's practice of using trituration as a method of potentisation, correct? That method must have been abandonded somewhere along the lines, right? After all, you did insist that:

Trituration is not the same as potentisation at all.
We know that Hahneman did in fact employ trituration as a valid method of potentisation at one time, didn't he? It says so right there in the Hahnemann's Organon Of Medicine, doesn't it? Yet you claim that trituration is now only used as a method of rendering insoluables into soluables in preparation for potentisation, isn't that right?

BTW... you might want to bring your pals over at the Hpathy forum up to date on this change of practice, it seems they're still following the old rules:
Drugs are potentised by two methods:

1. Trituration - in case of insoluble substances.

2. Succussion - in case of soluble substances
http://www.hpathy.com/homeopathy_principles.asp
 
Lisa Simpson said:
So has homeopathy "evolved" at all since Hahnemann's day, or are they doing the exact same thing done more than 100 years ago?
I recommend some lurking on the homoeopaths' own discussion forums. Basically this is another thing about which they fight like ferrets in a sack. There are some who revere Hahnemann almost as a God, and will only countenance exact Hahnemanian practice, while others branch out into numerous other woo-woo add-ons.

Following their "discussions" when one lot contradicts advice given by the other lot is pretty good entertainment. Actually, since there are more than two camps, it can become hilarious.

It's also a great place to bring in the "no true Scotsman" argument. Any ridiculous or embarrassing claim or anecdote may be dismissed very simply by merely pronouncing whatever the perpetrator did to be "not real homoeopathy". NH/HS has already used this argument (earlier on, when s/he was still trying to present some semblance of reasoned argument), in order to dismiss the findings of all the controlled trials which have failed to show any detectable "proving" effect of an ultradilute remedy with properly blinded participants. Of course, the homoeopaths who advised on the protocol of the provings got it wrong, and it could never have worked. :rolleyes:

One does have to question who are these homoeopaths who design duff protocols to ensure that the controlled trials fail. Wouldn't it be easier if someone who really knew what they were doing designed a correct protocol and amazed us all? Naturalhealth won't do it of course, too busy fleecing the uninformed public by taking their money for content-free remedies, but if s/he did, and it didn't work, there would just be another line of "real" homoeopaths queueing up to explain why this protocol was unsound and of course could never have worked!

Of course, the fact that Hahnemann himself was somewhat less than wholly consistent and can be quoted against himself only adds to the fun.

The homoeopaths in their natural habitat can be found at Homeopathy Home and H'pathy Forums. Both lots now ban dissenting voices almost on sight, but the latter has so far not erased the sceptics posts. Still, the real deal on the strict Hahnemanians versus the various other degrees of the reformed faith can be found in threads without a sceptical voice in sight.

Rolfe.
 
Hm... turf wars among homeopaths? Let the ganstas fight fer der turf... and who cares who get mowed down in da crossfire? Dis be war brotha... there ain't no such thing as "innocent bystanders."

More case studies by NH. No tests that could be proven in labs as he promised, no answers to case studies, just "I did it and I cured it." Yadda yadda. No answers to questions, simply insults and juvenile tricks. I am getting a very bad image of the homeopath; I had thought they were interested in helping people, but I guess it's more proving themselves right instead of learning of their mistakes is more important. No matter who gets mowed down in the crossfire between the gangs... the innocent people are the ones who suffer.
 
I did go and lurk for a little while, but I'm not sure I learned anything. It was all so contridictory and confusing. Some threads were just so sad, too. People in pain and looking for anything to ease their suffering.

The thing that amused me the most was one poster who kept referring to Hahnemann as "Our Master". Every time I read that I got a mental image of The Master from Buffy The Vampire Slayer. He was a really old, bat-faced vampire with a nasty case of fruit punch mouth. I'm easily amused.
 
Anders said:
Actually, what I said was that she didn’t believe that homeopathy included such things as water-memory and shaking of water.

That's hilarious. What does she think homeopathy is? Does she have it confused with other alt med? Not that it matters really.

Ha ha...nothing can be that bogus...except homeopathy...

Did you point your friend to the homeopath sites/forums that will happily let her know that you are right?
 
These days, the trituration process is used for substances that are insoluble before the potentisation process is undertaken.

If a substance is soluble then is goes through the potentisation process. If a substance is insoluble then it will be triturated to be made soluble and then the potentisation process can be undertaken. Potentisation consists of serial dilution and succussion.

How does this differ from what anyone else does? All the pharmacies make remedies in this way.

Massimo is a doctor and yes, these may be his musings, but he has hundreds of cases that he can back up with evidence.

I will go and design my own trial that I am satisfied with that actually meets homeopathic requirements to test that it works, however, this is not the best way.

O, just to let you know, we have helped quite a few people over at Hpathy. They ask us for advice and we have recommended remedies that have helped them greatly.

Lots of people have filled in our questionnaire and we have prescribed remedies that have helped them greatly.

I think the person that you were referring to was Divina. She has a bad name anyway over at Hpathy.

Remember also that Lionel Milgrom is also a practicing homeopath as well as a chemist.

Also, Colin Lessel is a doctor, dentist and homeopath.
 
All of this homeopathy-speculating reminds me of a short story I wrote once.

A man finds a poison that is so effective, it is virtually pure death in a bottle (this is based in the early 19th century, so use that way of thinking..). He decides to make a homeopathic remedy out of it, and spends years diluting it down.

Eventually he comes up with a remedy against death - as he sees it, immortality. He gives it to his ailing wife who is indeed cured of her ills, but as death no longer occurs in her body, she becomes one giant cancer. See Squichy's avatar for details...

It's very Paul di Filippo in its tongue-in-cheek nature. But this is why homeopathy is so interesting - until we can deduce it's nature (if it has a nature, that is), it's open to speculation, and my stories are just as plausible as any other crazy notion.

Athon
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom