Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Lisa Simpson said:


Yes, I did read it, I've just slept since then.

I like your laser theory, but will your laser/homeopathy theory work to cure my sons of their genetic connective tissue disorder?

***tries to keep straight face***

Well uh, See, the HIV is dna, and the lasers get it outta the genes. THe laser can't get genes back into cells though.

You need ANOTHER form of homeopath therapy for that. See, you get water that has had the missing genes in it...all proved up/down to 30c. Then you take it until the genes get built up in the body.

It's very natural and that will be $1200.00.

:)
 
Well see, it's not that they have a missing gene, it's that they have a defective gene. So instead of little lasers, I guess I need homeopathic essence of carpenter. To rebuild the defective connective tissue.
 
Lisa Simpson said:
Well see, it's not that they have a missing gene, it's that they have a defective gene. So instead of little lasers, I guess I need homeopathic essence of carpenter. To rebuild the defective connective tissue.

Hmm, yes, the water has to go through a carpenter...:D :D :D

Now gene therapy, there's an area that would cause the homeopath brain to shut down from overload.
 
Meanwhile, back at the ranch, still trying to get HS to answer a straight question.

Tell us why you need 'ultrapure' water these days? (Let's ignore the secondary issue of you not understanding what ultrapure means)

Tell us how homeopathy will replace the missing X-chromosome in Turner's syndrome? What about trisomy 21? Hey folks, no more genetic defects. Hooray!

No misdirection please with another placebo-response anecdote.

Do you really think we forget about these unanswerable questions when you try to wander off at a tangent?
 
Here it is in a nutshell, folks (my bold) -

From BSM's link -
So how this naked eye preperation of our drugs can be explained to modern science of to-day.They have some laws like Avagadrow's laws and the laws of molecular theory which are not sufficient to prove Homoeopathy as a science. Instead of digrading Homeopathy,they should still study physics deeply to dicover such laws which can prove Homeopathy as a science.
So, if science says that homeopathy is nonsense, then it's the science that's wrong because homeopathy works.
If you were in any doubt that, for people like Homeoskeptic/Naturalhealth and val_drjkr, belief in homeopathy is based on faith, not objective evidence, then wonder no longer.
 
HS/NH I know it may be tiresome, but perhaps instead of shouting that homeopathy works you could answer some of the questions that you have been asked.

Do you really not understand why your anecdotes don't prove anything. Really you should try to understand a bit more about what science really is, because i think you have a warped view of it.

I am particuarly intrested in your responce to BSMs questions, i'll repeat here to save you the bother of scrolling up the page:

Tell us why you need 'ultrapure' water these days? (Let's ignore the secondary issue of you not understanding what ultrapure means)


and

Tell us how homeopathy will replace the missing X-chromosome in Turner's syndrome? What about trisomy 21? Hey folks, no more genetic defects. Hooray

PJ
 
I would also say HS/NH that we understand your view that homeopathy works. We also understand that you have reached this view from practise of homeopathy and seeing its' apparent effects on your "patients". What we would like to do now is move the discussion forward and examine the field in more depth.

For example you claim that the effects of homeopathy are so obvious that they are clearly discernable by just observing patients after they have recieved homeopathic therapy. They have notable recovery or amelioration of symptoms.
Now when clinical trials of homeopathy are performed, even with the help of professional homeopaths, these effects completely disapear. Remember that the trials are to detect an effect, the cause of the effect is irrelevant. Clinical trials are capable of detecting incredibly tiny effects that are not obvious from casual observations. The claimed effects of homeopathy should stand out in clinical trials. They don't though. Why do you think this is so ?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Why not try reading the right book. The book he has written that explains about homeopathy is actually called A Companion to Homeopathic Studies. He has also written a book called The New Physics of Homeopathy.

Also, Lionel Milgrom is a homeopathy and practices as such.

He is a homeopath as well as a chemist.

So we have a chemist writing about physics. Are you fermilia with the appeal to authority logical fallicy?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Chemistry has everything to do with curing disease.

It has nothing ot do with homeopathy I should know. Pure chemistry doesn't have much to dowith curing desease outside working out synthersis routes for drugs. The medical stuff is mostly biochemistry and I don't think Milogram works in those fields

I have my cases from at least 20 years of practice to prove that homeopathy works.

We have evidence of aztecs sacrifing people to make the sun rise for far more than a couple of decades and that "worked".
 
You very obviously know absolutely nothing though do you, or you would have been able to explain my case for me.

I have hundreds more cases such as this of patients who have got better and have been able to stop taking all of their conventional medication.

How about the case of eczema. Patient was given Thuja 30c, then increasing through 200c to 1M. Eczema was on face and then slowly worked its way down the body to the feet and then disappeared for good, never to return.

How about the case of the little boy who had breathing problems and was hyperactive. He was a mouth breather and had never been able to breathe through his nose. After just one dose of Sulphur LM1 he could breathe through his nose for the first time.

Also, a child will lack of assimilation on all levels with attention deficit disorder. Also antibiotic suppression. Was given one dose of Silica 30c with immediate improvement. Later was moved to an LM due to aggravation. This potency reduces the risk.

I have lots more cases.

Try to explain these if it does not work.

With a lot of these cases, there was an immediate response following the administration of the remedy.

Try to explain that if you can!! Ha, Ha.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
.

Try to explain that if you can!! Ha, Ha.

Loon.

large-smiley-053.gif
 
Homeoskeptic said:
How about the case of eczema. Patient was given Thuja 30c, then increasing through 200c to 1M. Eczema was on face and then slowly worked its way down the body to the feet and then disappeared for good, never to return.

Never? How long has the follow up been? Do you know the level of spontainiuos remition of eczema? Are yoqualified to make the dianosis and if not who made the diagnosis? Is this independantly varified?

How about the case of the little boy who had breathing problems and was hyperactive. He was a mouth breather and had never been able to breathe through his nose. After just one dose of Sulphur LM1 he could breathe through his nose for the first time.

Never been able to breath through his nose? You have proper records of this claim

Also, a child will lack of assimilation on all levels with attention deficit disorder. Also antibiotic suppression. Was given one dose of Silica 30c with immediate improvement. Later was moved to an LM due to aggravation. This potency reduces the risk.

What is antibiotic suppression (I know what it mean from a homeopathic point of view but I don't know if this is how you are using the term)? Is that reconiesed by convetional medcine and if not why not? Where did the dianosis of ADD come from?
I lots more cases.

I have thousands of cases of people being sacrifced making the sun rise.
 
Homeoskeptic, why don't you post one of your case histories, after removing the person's name? You know, findings, dates, doses, results, that sort of thing.

~~ Paul
 
Sigh, you do not appear to want to address anything actually substantial, as i said, we understand that you think all your anecdotes prove homeopathy works. You do not appear to understand why this is not sufficient evidence for us.

Ok Lets looks at this:

Also, a child will lack of assimilation on all levels with attention deficit disorder. Also antibiotic suppression. Was given one dose of Silica 30c with immediate improvement. Later was moved to an LM due to aggravation. This potency reduces the risk.

1: What is antibiotic suppression ?
2: Apparent recovery after inital dose
3: Patient then gets worse, attributed to aggravation
4: Reduced potency given

So basically got better then worse, and then returned to base level ? So no real improvement of condition overall then, but a number of changes in condition that were attributed to homeopathy ?

How about you start to actually discuss some of the relevant points raised


Important Questions Homeoskeptic refuses to answer:

Tell us why you need 'ultrapure' water these days?
- obviously Hanherman didn't have access to "nuclear grade" water, whatever that is.


Tell us how homeopathy will replace the missing X-chromosome in Turner's syndrome? What about trisomy 21?
An easily verfyable feat that would revolutionise medicine.
 
[derail] Billhoyt: I respect your posts; you are a wonderful person and an asset to JREF. But I also feel the desire to beg you to please not call anyone Loon. Loon is also a very nice poster and has done nothing to even remotely deserve to be lumped in with the ilk you mentioned. [/derail]
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom