Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Homeoskeptic said:
Can't keep up with the big boys hey!!

The book is called A Companion to Homeopathic Studies and also A New Physics of Homeopathy.

You never know, you just might learn something from him. You just might as you seem to know nothing at all at the moment so it shouln't be that hard now should it!!!
If by "the big boys" you're referring to yourself, and your fellow homeopaths, then I must confess that I am indeed having some difficulty keeping track of your personal attacks, logical fallacies, childish insults, contradictory claims, and evasions of even the most straighforward questions put to you.

The fact that your ilk is so predictable, doesn't make you any less baffling.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Chemistry has everything to do with curing disease.

I have my cases from at least 20 years of practice to prove that homeopathy works.

Broken. Record.

Give us your chemical rundown on curing HIV, or even the chickenpox.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
The little girl with Turners Syndrome could benefit greatly from homeopathic treatment. It could well improve her condition.

LOL. And how exactly does homeopathy replace this patient's missing X chromosome? You do know what Turner's syndrome is don't you, being a doctor and all.

Hey, HS you've still not answered Rolfe's repeated question about Hahnemann's use of water that was less than 'nuclear grade'. I wonder why.
 
So, homeopathy can help genetic disorders now, too? Okay, my two youngest sons have a genetic disorder that affects their connective tissue. What's going to fix their defective DNA? Essence of bridge, perhaps. Bridges connect things. So does my wireless LAN. Maybe essence of wireless LAN would help them.

Or maybe, they'll just have to live with it.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:
LOL. And how exactly does homeopathy replace this patient's missing X chromosome? You do know what Turner's syndrome is don't you, being a doctor and all.
I'm done with this smelly orifice. Its clearly not a doctor. It clearly knows nothing about science. It lies through its less smelly orifice on a regular basis. It avoids all the tough questions, most likely because it has no idea how even to comprehend the question let alone formulate an answer.

The rest of you can battle on with it. You may want to pursue Milgrom's homeopathy research (which it still can't admit doesn't exist) or research protocols (which is beyond its ken) or how homeopathy cures scoliosis, short stature or webbed necks.

It is now welcome to my ignore list.
 
Ok, if homeopathy does not work, then perhaps you could explain this case for me then?

A patient came to see me who had quite a lot of pathology and was medicated. Case was taken and PHOSPHORUS LM was prescribed. Did well on this.

Came back with another problem at follow up that indicated THUJA. This was prescribed in an LM and the patient did very well on this up until LM3.

Patient returned for a follow up and on analysing the follow up it was found that CARCINOSIN was now the appropriate remedy. Patient was given this in an LM potency. Patient did very well on this and started to reduce medication and was feeling a lot better.

Patient attended for next follow up and was off all medication. Following the analysis, CALC CARB was the next remedy coming through. Patient was given this in an LM and is doing very well on it and is still off all medication and feeling very well indeed.

I have a lot more like this too.

Plenty more cases where this came from.
 
A person feels well and has no significant problems for a time? How remarkable! Such events never take place outside the rarefied airs of homeopathy.

Ah, but how do you explain this chain of events:

A person comes in with a minor complaint, takes a placebo, and feels better.

Then he comes in some time later with another complaint, takes another placebo, and feels better.

Then he comes in yet again with another minor complaint, takes yet another placebo, and feels better.

Inconceivable! Clearly there must have been some form of effective treatment hidden within the supposed placebos. What else could account for his remarkable improvement?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
As I keep saying to you. YOU NEED TO TAKE A REMEDY WHEN IT IS INDICATED TO SEE THAT IT DOES ACTUALLY WORK.

I concur.


I have to say that I am really glad that that lady probably will not have listened to you. The little girl with Turners Syndrome could benefit greatly from homeopathic treatment. It could well improve her condition.

Or not. Could you give any hints on what kind of a remedy homeopathy can be to Turner Syndrome?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
The thing is that homeopathy does deliver the goods.

Then show it. Prove it. Run a controlled study. Provide the evidence.

You'll have done something that no other homeopath has ever succeeded in doing.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
As I keep saying to you. YOU NEED TO TAKE A REMEDY WHEN IT IS INDICATED TO SEE THAT IT DOES ACTUALLY WORK.
We are waaaay ahead of you.

There is also another guy - Colin Lessel who has written two books on the workings of homeopathy. He is a doctor, a dentist and a homeopathic dentist and is a member of the Faculty of Homeopathy.
Homeopathic dentist?
 
Suezoled said:
*sits watching with a bag of popcorn*

Pass some of that popcorn over here, if you would. I figure I'll have a long wait until I find out how homeopathy cures genetic disorders.
 
Because see, my point is that I recommend you get yourself infected with something really nasty and then use your mystical superpowers to cure it.
 
Lisa Simpson said:


Pass some of that popcorn over here, if you would. I figure I'll have a long wait until I find out how homeopathy cures genetic disorders.

Help yourself to Cola in the fridge, too
 
Suezoled said:
Help yourself to Cola in the fridge, too
The Cherry Pepsi is mine (thanks for that nifty label maker, ma, now I can stick "PROPERTY OF YAHWEH - HANDS OFF OR SUFFER" all over everything that is mine in the house) :)
 
I'm getting bored. No answers to my questions. Did anyone like my laser theory?

Hmm, ***chucks popcorn at unsuspecting folks chugging colas***

I didn't do it!!!
 
Eos of the Eons said:
I'm getting bored. No answers to my questions. Did anyone like my laser theory?

Hmm, ***chucks popcorn at unsuspecting folks chugging colas***

I didn't do it!!!

Bwahahaha!! I hate cola!! ***throws popcorn back***

What laser theory?
 
Lisa Simpson said:


Bwahahaha!! I hate cola!! ***throws popcorn back***

What laser theory?

***takes popcorn out of hair***

What? You didn't read my post? ***pouts***

The one where I quoted LFTKBS
 
Eos of the Eons said:


***takes popcorn out of hair***

What? You didn't read my post? ***pouts***

The one where I quoted LFTKBS

Yes, I did read it, I've just slept since then.

I like your laser theory, but will your laser/homeopathy theory work to cure my sons of their genetic connective tissue disorder?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Ok, if homeopathy does not work, then perhaps you could explain this case for me then?

A patient came to see me who had quite a lot of pathology and was medicated. Case was taken and PHOSPHORUS LM was prescribed. Did well on this.

Came back with another problem at follow up that indicated THUJA. This was prescribed in an LM and the patient did very well on this up until LM3.

Patient returned for a follow up and on analysing the follow up it was found that CARCINOSIN was now the appropriate remedy. Patient was given this in an LM potency. Patient did very well on this and started to reduce medication and was feeling a lot better.

Patient attended for next follow up and was off all medication. Following the analysis, CALC CARB was the next remedy coming through. Patient was given this in an LM and is doing very well on it and is still off all medication and feeling very well indeed.

I have a lot more like this too.

Plenty more cases where this came from.

Very good!

You see class? Homeoskeptic does a nice job of describing is complete vagueness about this validating ancedote. It's simply brilliant... a textbook example.

You alleopaths have absolutely no comeback to this one baby!

So let's sum up class...

We have:

A patient

Lots of pathology

Was medicated (don't say heavily or lightly... no need to say what medicine!)

I'm guessing this was your neighbor... Brenda... she had a cold... and was taking NyQuil!

The homeopathic cure kicked in within 5 days.... 10 at the most. Ah, another stunning example of homeopathic medicine at work.

I personally like to add chicken noodle soup to my homeopathic medicine before taking it. After all, the directions on the can call for 1 cup of water (Nuclear grade, of course!). ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom