Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Tricky one this for the homeopaths. I asked this and was told that homeopathy can cause aggravations ( what in the real world would an adverse reaction). these aggravations can get pretty bad , but apparently not actually kill you. I was curious as to why not but my questions got no where. HS above seems to contradict what i was told. Homeopaths not agreeing, well thats hardly suprising.

The difficulty is that homeopathic remedies have to produce some effect. We know homeopaths claim anything after the remedy as caused by the remedy. However if they say homeopathy can be potentially lethal then they may get unwanted attention from official bodies interested in their claims. Its a bit of a mess and you will get a differnt answer from every homeopath depending on how much they have thought it through.

If homeoskeptic you think homepathic remedies can be fatal, apparently at random then shouldn't there be some safety data? COSHH etc. Ah..... that might invlove real science and proof of efficacy and that is rather difficult for homeopathy.

Oh and NH you owe p53 an explanation on "Cancer". Bluff called.
 
Homeopathic toxic. Sure killing with a homeopathic remey is pretty easy. Killing with a homeopathic remedy of normal potency would be pretty much imposible.

Aside from the chemistry and toxicaology Hannerman claimed that homeopathy could kill (it's not in the oragon but in one of his lesser writings). Most homeopaths tend to dodge the question.

1M means 1000C.

Btw in an attempt to poisen myself with homeopathy I spent a couple of days drinking nothing but a remedy (I garentee that it was a remedy I made it up myself using the K method). I'm still here.

As for regulating it beyond arvergardos limit that would be quite an effective way of getting rid of any remedy containing sodium and how would you apply it to water (yes there is a homeopathic remedy called water).
 
geni said:
how would you apply it to water (yes there is a homeopathic remedy called water).
And alcohol too, I believe, even though there's alcohol in the solvent they use.

I still can't get Naturalhealth to tell me about the purity of the alcohol, or the proportion of alcohol to water, or how that affects the alleged "memory" of water, or whether the famous memory effect was actually demonstrated using a proper homoeopathic water/alcohol solvent at the right proportions....

Rolfe.
 
1M means 1000C.

Whew, I feel much better about Arsenicum now.

So let me see if I have this straight: We're going to dilute the living hell out of the Arsenicum, to the point of utter absurdity, to ensure:
  • That it is not actually poisonous.
  • That it is of hyper-ultra-high homeopathic potency.
Do I have that right?

~~ Paul
 
Not exactly in the line of the thread, but, anyways, and also, this is my first ever post on jref forum, so please bare with me:

In 1847 the physician Semmelweiss makes an incredible discovery: Doctors that don’t wash their hands after making an autopsy somehow kills mothers just after they’ve given birth. He also finds out that making the doctors wash their hands before they give new mothers an examination cut the death rate at an obstetrician ward from 13 % to just 2 %. Years’ later science discovers that germs are the cause of many a deadly sickness.

The father of homeopathy, Hahnemann, dies in 1843. I.e. Hahnemann had no idea what killed or made people sick. If Hahnemann was a doctor delivering babies or examined mothers, and at the same time performed autopsies, there’s a good chance he also caused the death of a few new mothers.

If homeopathy works as well as, for example, penicillin, homeopathic remedies should kill germs as well as penicillin, because there are no other way to kill bacteria (save fire and alcohol). That is, if the homeopaths agree that some bacteria cause diseases.

Anyway, let’s try this: Take bacteria that cause some kind of non-lethal(what the heck, make it lethal) disease for mice. Inject the bacteria into, lets say 20, poor mice. Keep them separated in groups of 10. Feed one of the groups, group A, some homeopathic remedy that complies with the specific disease. Feed the other group, group B, some off-the-shelf antibiotic. After a few days, count live mice in the A group and count live mice in group B. Write report.

Or if we are somewhat squeamish, use 20 petri-dishies, prepare with agar, and some bacteria. Separate in two groups of 10, group A’ and B’. Pour a homeopathic remedy in the group A petris, and pour some off-the-shelf antibiotic into the group B petris. Wait a couple of days. Count bacteria in group A and Group B petris. Write report.

Someone wanna go out on a limb and guess how many mice or in group A or petris without bacteria in Group A’?
 
The water we use is ultra pure - it's called nuclear grade pure which is just about the purest you can get. We use a combination filtration and reverse-osmosis system with constent monitoring of the water conductivity.

As for the idea of the "memory of water" is a basis for justifying and understanding the homoeopathic dilution principle - I wouldn't rest too much weight on it. It opens the door to paradoxes. Each subsequent dilution/succussion would give a less distinct and more disordered trace of the original - like a recording of a recording of a recording. There are different approaches to describing the actual "concentration" of the dynamic principle with each subsequent dilution/succussion which the "memory" notion can't account for. Changes to the crystal structure of the water that can be detected can be a sign of potentisation - a change attendant to potentisation - rather than something like "memory" which some have attributed to it.

They also use one of the purest forms of alcohol. This is from of one of the leading homeopathic pharmacies in England.

Why not e-mail them yourself for a full explanation? I am sure they can keep it very simple and about at the level you will understand, just!!

O, also, I have a great case for you. I had a patient who came to see me recently that I gave OPIUM 1M to. They did very well on the remedy. Patient was an acupuncturist.

Try and work this one out if you can. I doubt it though as it seems to take you about 10 posts just to work out what a 1M is. You keep saying that you know something about homeopathy - well it is pretty evident that you know nothing!! Keep trying hey, you might get there one day!! We won't hold out breath though.
 
Anders said:
Not exactly in the line of the thread, but, anyways, and also, this is my first ever post on jref forum, so please bare with me:

In 1847 the physician Semmelweiss makes an incredible discovery: Doctors that don’t wash their hands after making an autopsy somehow kills mothers just after they’ve given birth. He also finds out that making the doctors wash their hands before they give new mothers an examination cut the death rate at an obstetrician ward from 13 % to just 2 %. Years’ later science discovers that germs are the cause of many a deadly sickness.

The father of homeopathy, Hahnemann, dies in 1843. I.e. Hahnemann had no idea what killed or made people sick. If Hahnemann was a doctor delivering babies or examined mothers, and at the same time performed autopsies, there’s a good chance he also caused the death of a few new mothers.

It goes further Hahnemann said we shouldn't look for the things that caused desease.
If homeopathy works as well as, for example, penicillin, homeopathic remedies should kill germs as well as penicillin, because there are no other way to kill bacteria (save fire and alcohol). That is, if the homeopaths agree that some bacteria cause diseases.

Anyway, let’s try this: Take bacteria that cause some kind of non-lethal(what the heck, make it lethal) disease for mice. Inject the bacteria into, lets say 20, poor mice. Keep them separated in groups of 10. Feed one of the groups, group A, some homeopathic remedy that complies with the specific disease. Feed the other group, group B, some off-the-shelf antibiotic. After a few days, count live mice in the A group and count live mice in group B. Write report.

Or if we are somewhat squeamish, use 20 petri-dishies, prepare with agar, and some bacteria. Separate in two groups of 10, group A’ and B’. Pour a homeopathic remedy in the group A petris, and pour some off-the-shelf antibiotic into the group B petris. Wait a couple of days. Count bacteria in group A and Group B petris. Write report.

Someone wanna go out on a limb and guess how many mice or in group A or petris without bacteria in Group A’? [/B]

Better tests have been done. Everything that is alive is ment to have a vital force it should be posible to tests on bacteria but I doubt that it would be posible to do indivdualsation. Tests been done on humans. When properly conducted they produce results that are negative for homeopathy. Of course homeoipaths reject these tests claiming that they are not properly conduted by homeopathic standards. It should be noted that in most cases the homeopaths that were consulted in advance expected the test to work. It should be also noted that homeopaths to not follow the methods that you would expect them to if they were consistant with their post test complaints
 
Homeoskeptic said:
The water we use is ultra pure - it's called nuclear grade pure which is just about the purest you can get. We use a combination filtration and reverse-osmosis system with constent monitoring of the water conductivity.

I've dected stuff in water purified by that method. There is a reason I have to use quwenching agents when I run certian tests. This to me suggests that it is not that pure.

As for the idea of the "memory of water" is a basis for justifying and understanding the homoeopathic dilution principle - I wouldn't rest too much weight on it. It opens the door to paradoxes. Each subsequent dilution/succussion would give a less distinct and more disordered trace of the original - like a recording of a recording of a recording. There are different approaches to describing the actual "concentration" of the dynamic principle with each subsequent dilution/succussion which the "memory" notion can't account for. Changes to the crystal structure of the water that can be detected can be a sign of potentisation - a change attendant to potentisation - rather than something like "memory" which some have attributed to it.

water doesn't have a crystal structure when liquid. At anythinbg like room temp water is a liquid. Ethanol is also a liquid at room temp
They also use one of the purest forms of alcohol. This is from of one of the leading homeopathic pharmacies in England.

Name the form and give me a breakdown of the impurites. Considering the cost of ultra pure ethanol (and the fact the it contains benzene and therefor is not fit for human consumption) I rather doubt that they use it.

Why not e-mail them yourself for a full explanation? I am sure they can keep it very simple and about at the level you will understand, just!!

Which pharmacy are you talking about? I know several in England

O, also, I have a great case for you. I had a patient who came to see me recently that I gave OPIUM 1M to. They did very well on the remedy. Patient was an acupuncturist.

So?

Try and work this one out if you can. I doubt it though as it seems to take you about 10 posts just to work out what a 1M is.

Took me one.
You keep saying that you know something about homeopathy - well it is pretty evident that you know nothing!! Keep trying hey, you might get there one day!! We won't hold out breath though.

You know nothinbg about medcine. Doesn't stop you trying to hjave a go at it. I know enogh about homeopathy to see that you do not follow it's rules. I know enough about chemistry biology and physic to know that homeopathy fighs all of them. I know enough about expermental desighn to know where you lot go wrong.
 
What a load of utter rubbish. Of course we know that bacteria and viruses cause disease and homeopaths do not dispute this. We treat acute infections in our patients and we totally accept this.

Yes, homeopathic remedies work just as well and if not better than antibiotics in cases of bacterial and viral infection. Otitis media responds extremely well and quickly to the indicated homeopathic remedy and so does something like strep throat. Strep throat responds fantastically well to Belladonna if it is the indicated remedy.

Hey mate, if this is your first post, then let it stay that way. Don't allow yourself to get sucked in to this total rubbish that this lot spout all the time.
Get out whilst the going is good or at least try to be open minded. The other pretend to be but are not.

Also watch out, ROLFE AND GENI ARE THE BIGGEST IDIOTS I HAVE EVER SEEN POSTING ON THESE BOARDS. NO SURPRISE THERE THEN.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
The water we use is ultra pure - it's called nuclear grade pure which is just about the purest you can get. We use a combination filtration and reverse-osmosis system with constent monitoring of the water conductivity.

Hogwash. Filtration and reverse osmosis is not called nuclear grade pure. It is pretty pure, but there are millions of contaminant molecules in there. What did Hahnemann use? You still haven't answered the question, so I'll answer it for you: Nobody knows. He probably used tap water.

Water conductivity is several orders of magnitudes short of being able to indicate "nuclear grade pure". Trust me, I'm a specialist here.

I will not accuse you of lying here, I will assume you are just ignorant.


As for the idea of the "memory of water" is a basis for justifying and understanding the homoeopathic dilution principle - I wouldn't rest too much weight on it.

I quite agree: Memory of water is hogwasn too.

It opens the door to paradoxes. Each subsequent dilution/succussion would give a less distinct and more disordered trace of the original - like a recording of a recording of a recording. There are different approaches to describing the actual "concentration" of the dynamic principle with each subsequent dilution/succussion which the "memory" notion can't account for. Changes to the crystal structure of the water that can be detected can be a sign of potentisation - a change attendant to potentisation - rather than something like "memory" which some have attributed to it.

They also use one of the purest forms of alcohol. This is from of one of the leading homeopathic pharmacies in England.

What is "one of the purest forms of alcohol" supposed to mean. Let me answer for you: You don't have the slightest idea :rolleyes:.

Why not e-mail them yourself for a full explanation? I am sure they can keep it very simple and about at the level you will understand, just!!

Yet another example of the "do my homework for me" fallacy. YOU are advocating the case of homeopathy here. YOU provide the evidence for homeopathy here.

O, also, I have a great case for you. I had a patient who came to see me recently that I gave OPIUM 1M to. They did very well on the remedy. Patient was an acupuncturist.

Try and work this one out if you can. I doubt it though as it seems to take you about 10 posts just to work out what a 1M is. You keep saying that you know something about homeopathy - well it is pretty evident that you know nothing!! Keep trying hey, you might get there one day!! We won't hold out breath though.

It is of secondary importance to this discussion what various potencies mean, as long as we lack even the slightest evidence that it is all anything but shaken water.

Hans
 
Homeoskeptic said:
ROLFE AND GENI ARE THE BIGGEST IDIOTS I HAVE EVER SEEN POSTING ON THESE BOARDS. NO SURPRISE THERE THEN.

LOL. Rolfe asked the question about Hahnemann's source of water that you have not answered.

I do hope you don't think we don't know the answers to the questions you are being posed, the aim is to try to get you to show yourself why you are talking nonsense.

Now, what water did Hahnemann use and how come you claim to need ultrapure water now? We haven't forgotten that you don't actually know what how purity is defined and have already confirmed that the water in use for making modern remedies is far from pure.

On you go then, we're waiting.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Also watch out, ROLFE AND GENI ARE THE BIGGEST IDIOTS I HAVE EVER SEEN POSTING ON THESE BOARDS. NO SURPRISE THERE THEN.
Oh, this has moved me almost to tears. To be singled out for such high praise (for insults from NH/HS are praise indeed) is an honour of no small degree.

Still, I'd rather s/he had a more thoughtful go at the questions I've been asking. Assertions about something called "nuclear water" (sorry, I'm having visions of a glass of protons and neutrons all on their own....) being very pure don't mean a thing, and simply bring us back to the matter of why particularly pure water should be necessary in the first place when it all seemed to work OK for Hahnemann. Assertions about some sort of imaginary crystal structure in water again bring us back to the proportions of water and alcohol, which surely must be critical for these extraordinary properties, but never get a mention.

And if it's possible to identify "potentised" materials from non-potentised, any way you like, why has nobody even had a crack at the million dollars?

But no, all we're ever going to get are more selected anecdotes, and more unsubstantiated assertions that "it works". Well, I've got plenty anecdotes where the patient wasn't quite so lucky (or co-operative, depending how you look at it), and I've got just as much grounds for asserting that "it doesn't work" as NH/HS has for her/his assertions.

Rolfe.
 
Anders said:
Not exactly in the line of the thread, but, anyways, and also, this is my first ever post on jref forum, so please bare with me:



I tried, but the secretary in the office opposite must have called the police, because a couple of them are ju st ddragginggg mm e awway nnnoww. w
w
 
geni said:
Everything that is alive is ment to have a vital force it should be posible to tests on bacteria
I have a homooepahtic acquaintance who keeps banging on about tests on plants. I still don't know how these are valid as I don't know how you prove a remedy in any way that relates to plants, or whether Hahnemann ever declared that his methods had horticultural applications.

However, as you probably guessed, the systems chosen for these tests are very subjective, unstable situations, so you can probably figure out how it goes....

Rolfe.
 
NH/HS

long on posts, short on content.

How about some sort of evidence to back up your assertions on ottits media and "strep throat".

More claims without evidence, standard fare for homeopaths, come on bacteriology is my field............


Yes, homeopathic remedies work just as well and if not better than antibiotics in cases of bacterial and viral infection.

Well we will put the claim that homeopathy works as well as antibiotics on viral infections to one side, and my, we a re left with a testable claim. Hmm lets see , what do you give your child when s/he gets Neiseria menigitis, errr homeopathic remedy or Antibiotic (prob penicillin). I know what my child will get. Now answer honestly, what does your child get ? Now explain your statement above. Squirm. Lie. BS. Because we all know really that homeopathy is a fkkin CON. You take money for a chat and a fake remedy, and you ain't got diddly squat to prove otherwise.
Have a nice day. (rant over)
 
Homeoskeptic said:
What a load of utter rubbish. Of course we know that bacteria and viruses cause disease and homeopaths do not dispute this. We treat acute infections in our patients and we totally accept this.

Can homeopathy cure an HIV infection?
 
Homeo said:
Changes to the crystal structure of the water that can be detected can be a sign of potentisation - a change attendant to potentisation - rather than something like "memory" which some have attributed to it.
Well, at least our misgivings about Benveniste and Josephson weren't misplaced.

~~ Paul
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Also watch out, ROLFE AND GENI ARE THE BIGGEST IDIOTS I HAVE EVER SEEN POSTING ON THESE BOARDS. NO SURPRISE THERE THEN.

You really need to consider an advanced course on Insults.

I'm going to suggest Insults 102, it's just down the hall from Validating With Anecdotes 101.

Oh, just one question from the gallery... how much "Nuclear Grade Pure" water was available before say... 1950?

In fact, as can obviously be pointed out... in these levels of concentration, tap water has all known homeopathic cures combined in it's "memory". So why aren't we drinking tap water? Oh, that's right... there is no difference. :D
 
A DESCRIPTION OF ANXIETY AMONST THOSE WITH BELIEF IN THE PARANORMAL/SUPERNATURAL POSTING ON A SKEPTICS MESSAGEBOARD.
Reviewer: Yahweh

Homeoskeptic said:
What a load of utter rubbish. Of course we know that bacteria and viruses cause disease and homeopaths do not dispute this. We treat acute infections in our patients and we totally accept this.
In the first paragraph, our subject, a homepathic practioner of 20 years (data subject to question due to comprimised integrity concerns previously). Our subject is confident as well as direct (see "What a load of rubbish" remark).

He begins by stating a generalized assertion - "we know that bacteria cause disease" -, this assertion is reasonable.

He goes on to state "we [homeopaths] treat acute infections in our patients", many skeptics of the practice of homeopathy find this statement disturbing due to the overtly irresponsible claim this is. If true, this is an admission of the dangers of homeopathy; acute illnesses left without proper medical treatment pose a serious healthrisk.

Yes, homeopathic remedies work just as well and if not better than antibiotics in cases of bacterial and viral infection. Otitis media responds extremely well and quickly to the indicated homeopathic remedy and so does something like strep throat. Strep throat responds fantastically well to Belladonna if it is the indicated remedy.
Two FANTASTIC examples of Post hoc ergo propter hoc (the fallacy which states something is assumed to be the cause of an event merely because it happened before that event).

Homeoskeptic appears to believe that the homeopathic remedies have objectified effects those with bacterial and viral infections (which are not acute illnesses). He accepts this misjudgement almost axiomatically, his reasoning is based on firm inner convictions and what is commonly called "confirmation bias".

This portion of the post denotes the climax of self-assurred pride.

Hey mate, if this is your first post, then let it stay that way. Don't allow yourself to get sucked in to this total rubbish that this lot spout all the time.
Get out whilst the going is good or at least try to be open minded. The other pretend to be but are not.
This is a "soft" example of "demonizing the unbelievers". This irrational unjustified behavior is common.

He believes that the people on this website are "closeminded". Our subject is certainly not the first (and certainly not the last) to make such a claim. It would be helpful to know how he defines "closeminded", but for all intents and purposes the word "closeminded" will be defined as "Intolerant of the beliefs and opinions of others; stubbornly unreceptive to new ideas". Many of the people on this board support (and make use of) the practice of making practical and reasoned observations of the world around them, then logically analyzing these observations. This is known as "skepticism", this is the antithesis of closeminded. If those logical analyses lead one to reject the value of homeopathy as a legitimate practice, then so be it, that rejection does not logically infer closemindedness. Therefore, our subjects claim is a "false", and ill-justifed.

Also watch out, ROLFE AND GENI ARE THE BIGGEST IDIOTS I HAVE EVER SEEN POSTING ON THESE BOARDS. NO SURPRISE THERE THEN.
Cognitive dissonance is the word we use to describe this.

Our subject uses the risky "ALL-CAPS Gambit", this is used for accentuating points and purposes.

There is irony in our subject's statement, in that two of the JREF members who engage him most often are in fact uneducated. There frequent engagment is by no means a criteria for determining their intelligence.

By this time, our subject's confidence has plummeted, his pride dwindles, and his ability to make use of reasoned discourse is all but non-existent.



Thank you, Homeoskeptic, you silly beliefs are an invaluable psychological resource.
 
Paul C. Anagnostopoulos said:

Well, at least our misgivings about Benveniste and Josephson weren't misplaced.

~~ Paul
Sorry I didn't respond to this sooner, Paul, but I had just stepped into the shower, and d*** if I didn't get cut by some water crystals. Those freaking homeoquacks must have dumped something in my well when I wasn't looking. To make a long story short, I wrapped some towels around to stop the bleeding and ran down to the local pharamacy to get a boatload of antibiotics and band-aids.

You think water is a liquid? Hah! I'm here to tell you those water crystals are like little knife-blades, man.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom