Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Homeoskeptic said:
O, Rolfe, this must be the most intelligent thing I have heard you say all the time I have been posting here.

It will be interesting to see whether vijay takes up your challenge.

Remedies never take months to work, but it differs as to whether you are treating acute or chronic cases. In acute cases a remedy will work instantly, but in chronic cases, it may take a bit longer. Up to two weeks, but never as long as a month. This is my experience of practice anyway.
How about this?
http://www.amazoncastle.com/feminism/womart9.shtml

Acute ailments clear up rather rapidly. Chronic problems can take two to six months to show improvement.
I also stumbled across these nuggets:
http://www.hepcchallenge.org/manual/homeopathic_final.htm

Homeopathy intervenes at the level of a person's reactive, self-curative powers, with or without the person's fully conscious cooperation.
And then a little further down on the very same page:
Homeopathic medicine requires a significant commitment from the patient to make necessary lifestyle changes.
Gotta love those kooky homeopaths. :D

***Edited to fix an oopsy with the first link. No quantum guitar strings were plucked during the editing of this post.***
 
Homeoskeptic/Naturalhealth said:
Remedies never take months to work, but it differs as to whether you are treating acute or chronic cases. In acute cases a remedy will work instantly, but in chronic cases, it may take a bit longer. Up to two weeks, but never as long as a month. This is my experience of practice anyway.
Well, this is what Naturalhealth thinks. However, find ten other homoeopaths at random and the chances are you'll get ten other wildly varying opinions.

I particularly like this quote from George Vithoulkas:
In cases with such long-standing headaches a period of treatment of at least two years will be required and a sequence of several remedies before a curative effect can be clearly demonstrated.

(It is well known to all homeopaths that we usually need one month of treatment for every year of suffering, and that can happen only in very careful homeopathic prescribing, otherwise the time needed may be longer).
It is interesting to note that this quote is from a vitriolic denouncing of a paper by a fellow-homoeopath, Harald Walach, one of the authors of the original "weak quantum theory" explanation for homoeopathy. Poor Dr. Walach had the temerity to report the findings of his controlled study on the homoeopathic treatment of chronic headache, even though they were resoundingly negative. (I can't find the original online, but here is the follow-up study.)

His reward was a glowing write-up from Bandolier, and a page of hate-mail from his fellow-homoeopath, containing all the predictable objections:
The results in this study are not surprising if one takes into consideation that they are the consequences of :

1. lack of experience of those prescribing in treating such long-standing headache cases;

2. a lack of understanding of the theoretical basis of homeopathy in those involved in the study.
Always, those who report negative findings lack understanding. Even if they are simultaneously being hailed as the cutting edge of homoeopathic research, as in this case!

Maybe Naturalhealth would like to take up the question of how long remedies take to work with George Vithoulkas?

Rolfe.
 
Why would the length of time for which the headache had been present affect the effectiveness of the treatment?

Clearly headaches which have been unsuccessfully treated and hence stick around are more likely to resist any particular new treatment that is attempted. Some conditions are harder to affect than others.

But with, say, aspirin, a person who didn't try any treatments for a month will likely experience the same relief as a person who didn't try any treatments for a week or a year.
 
Wrath of the Swarm said:
Why would the length of time for which the headache had been present affect the effectiveness of the treatment?
Have a look at the links. Vithoulkas is talking about there being no chance you'll get it right with the first remedy in cases of 20 or 30 years duration.

Rolfe.
 
It is well known to all homeopaths that we usually need one month of treatment for every year of suffering.

"Professor" George Vithoulkas
So, Homeoskeptic... were you aware of this well known homeopathic fact?

Sidenote:

Heretofore I would like to be addressed as "Admiral" Psiload. Thank you.
 
Anders said:


Mamma mia, here we go again, my my.....

I'm getting sooo tired of people that actually believe that quantum physics have any impact in the macroscopic world. ZPF is a pure quantum physics phenomenon and has little or none impact on anything bigger then a lepton.

But then again, that’s the same impact as homeopathy has in the macroscopic world, none. :-)
Anders,

i think you need to get some schooling from Tez. He clearly states that molecules and atoms can be entangled.

If you want the quote ask and i will supply it.
 
olaf said:
i think you need to get some schooling from Tez. He clearly states that molecules and atoms can be entangled.
:dl:

Calling all physicists! Who wants to take first shot at explaining why this is pure imaginative fiction?

Rolfe.
 
Indeed they can be. The question is whether this entanglement can be preserved from interference and noise.

If there's anything in the environment that can affect the entangled properties of the subjects, the entanglement can quickly become lost in a background of interactions. That's why it's been so difficult to construct a working quantum computer - the mere construction of a qubit was a major accomplishment.
 
Tez quote:

" Contrary to someone's assertion, entanglement is endemic in the universe (heck, empty space -- i.e. the electromagnetic vacuum/ZPE - is HIGHLY entangled). Similarly, all atoms/molecules etc have entanglement between various different degrees of freedom. The problem is finding pure entanglement in degrees of freedom that are classically accessible (which basically means that there are fields we can control by dialing knobs in the lab that allow us to manipulate these degrees of freedom and make measurements on them...) "
 
Wrath of the Swarm said:
Indeed they can be. The question is whether this entanglement can be preserved from interference and noise.

If there's anything in the environment that can affect the entangled properties of the subjects, the entanglement can quickly become lost in a background of interactions. That's why it's been so difficult to construct a working quantum computer - the mere construction of a qubit was a major accomplishment.


What is entanglement?
 
Thank you,

Although two entangled systems can interact across large spatial separations, no useful information can be transmitted in this way, so causality cannot be violated through entanglement.

My brain is scrambled right now, but I think I understand that quote.
 
Quantum entanglement is a quantum mechanical phenomenon in which the quantum states of two or more objects have to be described with reference to each other, even though the individual objects may be spatially separated.


The quantum state is consequently a purely mathematical and abstract concept and also a source of many difficulties when first apprehending the theory. Especially, the quantum state is not the state in which a quantum object is to be found, since a quantum object can only be observed in one eigenstate of the observable, whereas when it is not observed it can be in other quantum states.


Can anyone put this in layman's terms? I have to go shake my head a bit...quite beyond my comprehension.
 
He was talking about treatment length and I was talking about a remedy response. No patient that I have ever treated has taken that long to respond to a remedy. I normally get a response at least within a week with the longest that I have had to wait being 2 weeks.

Total length of treatment is different.

Lionel Milgrom can tell you everything you need to know about quantum theory. He has written at least 4 papers on this now.

He is also an excellent homeopath with a thriving practice.

You have frightened Kumar off I see. He has come back to us in disguise now. O dear.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
He was talking about treatment length and I was talking about a remedy response. No patient that I have ever treated has taken that long to respond to a remedy. I normally get a response at least within a week with the longest that I have had to wait being 2 weeks.

Total length of treatment is different.


So if I went to a homeopath for the chronic severe migraines I've suffered for 24 years, I would get an immediate response, but still have to be treated for up to 24 months?

If it works right away, why would I have to go for so long?
 
Homeoskeptic said:
You have frightened Kumar off I see. He has come back to us in disguise now. O dear.
But you told us Kumar had been welcomed back among you with a new identity before he even posted here.
Homeoskeptic said:
vijay is back with us using another name.

He knows when he is the right place and where all the intelligent conversation takes place. Certainly can't be found here.
Edited to add: and look, he's back. Hi, Kumar!

Do look at Lionel Milgron's papers, folks.
The first one.
And the second one.
And the third.
If there's a fourth, I'd be pleased to have a link to it.

Now, note the definitive word there. "Metaphor." None of this quantum entanglement stuff has the slightest thing to do with homoeopathy. All dear Lionel is saying is, what if the universe worked differently, and the mental processes of the homoeopath were somehow able to influence the patient through the remedy? Sort of quantum, like. That's all the pages of equations and diagrams boil down to.

I've had opinions on this lot from a number of physicists, and the hardest thing was to get them to stop laughing for long enough to tell me what was so funny.

Mostly what was so funny was that in order for any of that maths to work you have to eliminate Planck's constant, and if you do that, the whole of the rest of quantum theory falls to pieces.

In fact this "weak quantum theory" thing was simply dreamed up by some homoeopaths, including Harald Walach, whose "Magic of Signs" paper is heavily drawn on by Milgrom, with the specific purpose of providing them with an "explanation" they could talk about which is far enough removed from most people's understanding to sound impressive and avoid challenge. It's completely self-referencing, and completely ignored and discounted by real physicists.

Rolfe.
 
"I'm sorry, but you are wrong. The glass may be entirely empty... Hans"

Mr.Hans, if it is entirely empty, so many people will not pose the drinking OR they will not even keep the glass in their hand.

Dear Rolfee,

I was not expecting but you learnt a lot about homeopathy. I have to be bit more prepared. Your posting has really impressed me & probably to all including HS. I do agree that whatever you have mentioned is not completely wrong. Actually, I studied very deeply- the biochemic system/cell salts or Tissue remedies. If you remember I gifted to you all as 'New Year Gift'. I don't know whether you have yet opened the gift box or not. ;)

Anyway, I use/follow this system only. It is considered as a part of homeopathy with some hesitations & repulsions. In my opinion-- it is the daughter of homeopathy its essence or real gems of it. It is mostly taken in molecular doses. These are similar to about 98% inorganic biochemicals of our body & therefore may represent 'the true Similimums'. I strongly feel that this is the only & true carry forward work of homeopathy. This is the simplest & much effective system of medication involving science, logics, sprituals. It can be well understood in accordance with the CMS --but bit differently. Science & logic of all or most of the sprituals can be easily understood by understanding this system. It is a Most BASIC & FIXED or ABSOLUTE type system as was origionally said, with least additions, amendments, contradictions & other adverses(just do google search). As desired by the formulater of this system, it really has 'sharp boundaries'. In this, only some newly created symptoms & bit changes in potencies may be needed(?). I am not trolling but it is my personal experiance of 5 years continiously.

I do feel that there is/was some mess in its mother system which was actually got cleared by this system but not yet understood by the many or most as per 'HIS' desire. It is becoming more & more comlicated beyond the capacity of individuals to apply it effectively. I have some unsolved matters in my mind & was willing to clear IN-HOUSE, but this also created heat & repulsions. Everyone just want SO MUCH & SO MANY in competition with conventional system & just to convince that we also have too much. Otherwise it is sufficient to use this simplest system most effectively. If this system is got standardized--healing history can experiance big changes in the much benefit to public.

Best wishes.
 
Rolfe said:
:dl:

Calling all physicists! Who wants to take first shot at explaining why this is pure imaginative fiction?

Rolfe.
"It's a good omen, because it's saying quantum entanglement can survive when you might not expect it to," says Bill Barnes, a photonics expert at the University of Exeter. "If they can survive this, what else can they survive?"

http://www.newscientist.com/news/news.jsp?id=ns99992564

rolfe rolfe rolfe, haven't you just learned your lesson about being careful what you say.

let it be known here and now that i am looking over your shoulder from now until doomsday. there is no escape; i am your shadow. everything you say will be put under the microscope. welcome to your worst nightmare. :D
 
In cases with such long-standing headaches a period of treatment of at least two years will be required and a sequence of several remedies before a curative effect can be clearly demonstrated.
So does "curative effect" refer to a cure of the underlying condition, or a treatment of it?

And people who stop taking painkillers will experience a worsening of their pain if they're taking the correct remedy, yes? Won't that also happen if they're taking an inert substance - or not taking any substance at all, but simply cease taking the drugs?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom