Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

olaf said:

The people here have closed minds. Not all of them but most. I have done some reading on this subject. In fact I am reading a book right now that is tying together information from Zero Point Field to the possibility that remote viewing can work. it also has references to homeopathy as possibly imprinting in some manner on the ZPF. They also back up some of the observations that the Chinese and Indians have long known.

Mamma mia, here we go again, my my.....

I'm getting sooo tired of people that actually believe that quantum physics have any impact in the macroscopic world. ZPF is a pure quantum physics phenomenon and has little or none impact on anything bigger then a lepton.

But then again, that’s the same impact as homeopathy has in the macroscopic world, none. :-)
 
olaf said:


exarch,

Excellent questions. These were some of the exact questions that confounded me plus i had several more.

To this day i don't know the answer to questions about glasswear contamination (i understand heat is supposed to cancel out the effect), if i ever come across a really good answer I'll let you know.

Maybe organic compounds are far more suitable for carrying the energetic vibration than glass. Concerning the surrounding area around the bottle, i don't know about the specifics.

I do know that it works in some grand mysterious way. Rather shocking. i also know that about 100,000 european medical doctors know that it works. Strange but true. Once again shocking almost unbelievable, but millions swear by it. The truth is stranger than fiction.
Nonsense, guesswork. You have decided to believe it works, so you dream up fancy imaginary effects that might explain it, then reverse to your stupid mantra of appeal to the masses.

For every time you repeat your silly 100,000 mantra without documentation, you detract from your credibility. It is already beyond 60C.

Hans
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Thanks for that Olaf.

Not at all. I have not made myself look foolish at all.

I'm sorry, but you have. You have trolled, lied, used ad hominem, made repeated unsubstantiated claims, evaded questions, repeated your mantra ad nauseam....

You have made yourself look absolutely idiotic.


I will find the name of the article and post it. This article shows that homeopathy works very well for glue ear.

We are waiting.

I have not read the calf diarrhea paper at all, however, I would wonder whether Podophylum is in any way the right remedy for this anyway. A test like this will never work, as the remedy has not been individualised at all and all the calves may need a different remedy to the one given. Idividualisation. That is what homeopathy is all about.

Seem not reading it does not keep you from forming an opinion. Do you form all your opinions this way?

The patients I treated were at least open minded and not totally sceptical like you. The remedies still worked though and very well in fact.

No, no, you said you treated hard-nosed skeptics. DO try to keep your story straight, ehh? If all else fails, read your own posts, so you don't happen to contradict yourself too much. You know that is another thing that makes you look foolish.

Also, my cases are clinical evidence. I keep clinical data on all of my patients both before and after treatment. If these cases are not clinical data then I really don't know what is.

As long as they are not presented as verifiable, documented accounts, in their ENTIRETY, with all cases, it is not clinical data.

As long as you just relate your own pick of stories in the fashion you have done hithero, it is anecdotes.

Perhaps you should read a little about how research is done these days? I suggest you start by reading some medical journals, e.g. Lancet. Here you can see how research is planned, conducted, and reported.

Hans
 
olaf said:
I do know that it works in some grand mysterious way. Rather shocking. i also know that about 100,000 european medical doctors know that it works.
You KNOW? You KNOW?

Care to provide some evidence? Either that "it works", or that there are 100,000 doctors in Europe who are trained in and believe in homoeopathy?

Rolfe.
 
Originally posted by olaf
Excellent questions. These were some of the exact questions that confounded me plus i had several more.

To this day i don't know the answer to questions about glasswear contamination (i understand heat is supposed to cancel out the effect), if i ever come across a really good answer I'll let you know.
Here's a good one, and it explains all that's being observed perfectly:

There is no mysterious, undetectable energy, there is no freaky quantum-mechanical selective energy transfer, there is nothing in the homeopathic remedies but water, and people who get better do so because of their own natural immune system doing its job.

It is the leanest, most satisfactory explanation that accounts for all the facts. Or as we could call it, Ockhams razor.

Maybe organic compounds are far more suitable for carrying the energetic vibration than glass. Concerning the surrounding area around the bottle, i don't know about the specifics.
But water isn't organic?

I do know that it works in some grand mysterious way. Rather shocking. i also know that about 100,000 european medical doctors know that it works. Strange but true. Once again shocking almost unbelievable, but millions swear by it. The truth is stranger than fiction.
Ah yes, the old "sometimes truth is stranger than fiction" quote. Well, you're right, sometimes truth *IS* stranger than fiction. However, usually, truth is much more mundane and down to earth than fiction, as I'm sure is the case for homeopathy. Truth is that it doesn't work and you just think it does. Not very strange, but extremely true.

And your 100'000 European medical doctors is still an unsubstantiated figure. Please provide evidence or a reference for this number, so we can explain to you why sacrificing people to make sure the sun rises every day is not a true fact, stranger than fiction, but a mere misunderstanding of the physical world by millions of Azteks.
 
Can we please establish something about the history of science and our understanding of the universe.

Two common, and awfully erroneous, assumptions are:

a) It has always been believed (i.e. ancient societies, it has always been known etc.), hence is true.

b) Many people believe it, hence is true.

Until the 16th century, these formed the basis for most knowledge of the world. However, some people dared to ask questions when such assumptions failed to explain all facets of their understanding. For instance, to use a tired old example, many societies believed that the world was flat and had boundaries, beyond which was either nothing or chaos (notice I don't say all societies - in fact, it was common in many ancient societies to believe in a spherical world). Some dared to want to see these boundaries for themselves.

Now, it has always been believed that the world has these chaotic edges, and everybody believed it. Why didn't this make it true? What happened in the 16th century to change the world?

The answer is - not a lot. It merely became more acceptable for some to ask questions, because it was becoming apparent that those two accepted assumptions were wrong. Just because everybody believed it, and it had always been taken as truth, it didn't make it so.

This was the beginning of the scientific method. Today, we have to accept that our perception of the world, and how we make sense of these perceptions, is great for running away from lions but is flawed when we want to understand the mechanics of nature. It's like trying to do surgery on a gnat with our clumsy fingers. We need better tools!

So what if everybody believes something? If one man can be wrong, so can two, and it stands to reason that five men can all share the same false reasoning. Pretty soon, 100,000 men can be wrong. And for many of my beliefs, I'd accept that I could be one of those 100,000 who believe but are wrong. I'll even accept that in spite of the fact that millions do not believe we've been contacted by extra terrestrial intelligence, me being one, we could all be wrong.

What makes the difference? We have to remove the understanding from the hands of subjective opinion, and search for something more concrete. We look for two things - facts (which are irrfutable. If you don't know what a fact really is, we have problems), and correlation of facts. Correlation has to be interpreted, and is where science can become a field of debate.

Unfortunately, homeopathy is not strong in either of these, which is why it hardly even makes it to debate stage. The people here are not close minded - we just play with real science and not assumptions and opinions. We can all speculate, as I've said before. But science left speculation behind in the 16th century.

Real science is so much more.

Athon
 
Hello all,

Happy New Year,:D

I just visited casually. Still troubling. Just avoid to show appx. 30% empity glass. Full glass is with 'HIM' only. Everyone should be respected by his qualities Eg. Best Fighting qualities for his nation can be respected by opposite nation inspite of the fact it can effects them. Everyone in fully justified to fight for his nation or for his self. I could not yet see 'Earth as ..... .:D Btw, have you now justified --CMS as fully filled glass or still empity?

Best wishes to the Mr.Hans & all Ts.
 
Kumar:

And best wishes to YOU, my friend. Sorry to see the wacking they gave you at hpathy, but that's what you get for asking awkward questions.

That said, I hardly understand the rest of your post. May I suggest that till you get a better command of English, you avoid too many metaphors, symbols, and implications? At best it makes much of your writing impossible to undrstand, at worst it means you are thoroughly misunderstood. Stick to simple, direct statements.

Hans
 
Hi Kumar, nice to see you back. Drop by any time, you won't get banned here for anything you're likely to say.

I wish I understood your latest post better.

However, when you speak of people fighting for their nation and being respected for it, you are talking about partisanship. This is very understandable where national loyalties are involved. Science, though, is international. It's about finding out the factual truth. Therefore, when we talk science, people should only be respected for unbiassed fighting to understand or reveal truth - not for defending their own position when the facts are against them.

If you have a position to defend that isn't supported by the facts, you may have a hard time here. However, if you are looking for facts, and valid interpretations of those facts, welcome.

I don't really follow what you are trying to say with the metaphor about full and empty glasses. Could you state what you mean in clear terms without the use of metaphor?

Rolfe.
 
Goodness me 7 pages and we're still at Homeopathy works, heres an anecdote to prove it stage!!

HS/NH, why do the "dramatic" effects of homeopathy disapear whenever it is tested in a controlled manner?
Maybe because the effects are caused by a good chat about all your problems and some observer bias thrown in?

Homopathy claims a measurable effects, problem is no one can find it.
 
Originally posted by athon
What makes the difference? We have to remove the understanding from the hands of subjective opinion, and search for something more concrete. We look for two things - facts (which are irrfutable. If you don't know what a fact really is, we have problems), and correlation of facts. Correlation has to be interpreted, and is where science can become a field of debate.
Let's try to expand this with a practical example:

Gravity

Fact:
When objects are released in mid air, they accelerate towards the earths surface with a speed of 9.98m/s per second. This is a fact, we've observed this, measured it, we know this to be true.

Theory:
The theory is that there is an unseen but observable force that attracts all matter towards each other. We call this phenomenon gravity.

Prediction:
A predictable effect of this phenomenon is that objects in mid air will be attracted to the center of the earth. This is what we expect to happen each time, and so far, this is what has consistently been observed in scientific trials.

Alternative theories:
There are always people who think they know it better, and challenge the theory. There are probably very few of them when gravity is concerned, but for argument's sake, let's assume there are some folks who believe it isn't the matter that is being attracted to the center of the earth, but our spirit that is attracted to the big planet consciousness in the center of the earth.

At first glance this might seem to explain what is being observed, except it requires the introduction of yet another unknown force just like the established "gravitational force", plus there are some holes in the theory, like inanimate objects who have no soul/spirit who are also observed to be subject to gravity. Also, we would need to prove that humans have a spirit, and that the planet has a "planet consciousness" in order for this theory to be possible.

Now, no matter how many hundreds upon thousands of physicists and astronomers believe in this theory, and assert "IT WORKS", the fact it doesn't adequately explain how things work, and the fact that the ideas upon which it builds haven't been proven, means that it is nothing more than just an interesting, unsubstantiated idea.

As skeptics, in a case like this, we would think that those people are actually making up theories trying to prove the existence of a soul/spirit by rewriting the theories that could contradict its possibility, rather than trying to figure out exactly how gravity works. It is *THEM* who have the hidden agenda, not us who doubt their wacky claims ...

And the same goes for homeopathy of course, which makes the same mistakes and goes off on the same wacky tangents, and all to prove that their precious remedies work, which is something that, to this day, remains unproven.
 
Hi Mr Hans, Mr Rolfee,

Thanks for the welcome drink. I become bit sentimental.

It is all right at Hpthy. If one member at home is in irritated mood-it does not mean other members or home is not good. Moreover, Pre-skeptic , it was fine but now is bit contaminated. I agree that I felt some differance. However, it will come back to its origionality as Mr.Bhatia is great, respected & true person. I respect just few & one out of those is he because he could only give some satisfatory replies of my questions. One younger one may only have to bit change after experiance.

But now you can admire that I try to present the facts-- may be these are there or here, at home or at house.

I have not yet improved the language as I didn't find the 'atonyms of SIN' in this most common language.;)

Rolfee, I liked your words--"understood your latest post better, won't get banned here for anything national loyalties, people should only be respected for unbiassed fighting to understand or reveal truth - not for defending their own position when the facts are against them."

Suppose you have one glass which is partly filled. It is very common nowadays to blaim for the empity part of glass. But good side of this is to appreciate its filled part. Day is allways good then night.

As far as I could know the homeopathy/cell salts, I found it as a partlly filled glass or looks as partly filled*. The only aspect of ' How ultra-molecular remedy's substances works or can work' is yet to be proved by CST otherwise all other aspects are clear. It is just 30% empity portion of glass. We can see so many 'unknown or not yet found or not yet clear' remarks in CMS madical informations also.

Hope this will clear your curicities.
 
Kumar said:
As far as I could know the homeopathy/cell salts, I found it as a partlly filled glass or looks as partly filled*. The only aspect of ' How ultra-molecular remedy's substances works or can work' is yet to be proved by CST otherwise all other aspects are clear. It is just 30% empity portion of glass. We can see so many 'unknown or not yet found or not yet clear' remarks in CMS madical informations also.

Hope this will clear your curicities.
Thought the jury was still out on whether they worked any better than a placebo. Until an effect has been demonstrated it's not really all that productive talking about a mechanism by which effect comes about.

P.S. A large collection of anecdotes is not evidence
 
exarch said:
Let's try to expand this with a practical example:


Excellent example, Exarch.

I used to believe that it was only the 'ignorant public' who had little grasp of the tenants of science. Now I know that no such body of people exists, and that even amongst academics, doctors, teachers and amazingly scientists, there are many who have no idea what constitutes the modern tools of scientific analysis.

I had a discussion with some teachers at school the other week about teaching students concepts such as Occham's Razor and Inductive vs. Deductive reasoning, the place of anecdotes in exploration of nature etc., and had several teachers (and not stupid ones either - they knew a lot about science-stuff) admit they did not understand it.

This is where the frontline of skepticism is.

Athon
 
Kumar said:
*snip*

As far as I could know the homeopathy/cell salts, I found it as a partlly filled glass or looks as partly filled*. The only aspect of ' How ultra-molecular remedy's substances works or can work' is yet to be proved by CST otherwise all other aspects are clear. It is just 30% empity portion of glass. We can see so many 'unknown or not yet found or not yet clear' remarks in CMS madical informations also.

Hope this will clear your curicities.
I'm sorry, but you are wrong. The glass may be entirely empty. To be sure, a lot of people feel it works, and there are plenty of anecdotes that seem to support this, but on closer examination, it appears that there is nothing to it.

Once all the sources of error and bias are removed, very little, if anything remains.

Therefore, we cannot assume that your glass is half full and go looking for the top part. We must first find out if there is anything there at all.

Hans
 
Kumar said:
The only aspect of ' How ultra-molecular remedy's substances works or can work' is yet to be proved by CST otherwise all other aspects are clear.
So what you are saying is that you believe that ultradilute remedies have a definite biological effect, that is, they "work". This you characterise as the "part-full" aspect of the glass.

However, you also acknowledge that there is no plausible mechanism of action for such an effect. This you characterise as the "part-empty" aspect of the glass.

I think I understand you now, but I don't think I agree with you.

If we were sure that there was an effect there, or even felt that it was quite probable that there was an effect, of course you would be right. And this would be the most pressing problem in the basic sciences of chemistry and physics. Researchers the world over would be fighting to be the first to discover the mechanism of action, knowing that fame and Nobel Prizes await whoever is successful. You must understand that nobody is biassed against homoeopathy, and nobody is trying to cover up anything it can do. Scientists love a real mystery, and if this was one of those they'd be all over it.

But this isn't happening. Apart from a few mavericks on the fringes of biology, nobody is paying the slightest bit of attention to ultramolecular preparations. You must ask yourself, why not? The reason is that while solving a real mystery is a great career move, spending years trying to find a cause for an effect that isn't there is professional suicide. Researchers who have looked at the evidence for ultramolecular preparations having an effect have pretty much unanimously come to the conclusion that there's nothing there but a lot of people kidding themselves and kidding other people, by selective interpretation of the data.

Now, if you come here determined to assert that there is an effect there, you mustn't expect us to agree with you without question. There will be a lot of questions.

Problem one is that the homoeopaths are continually making claims of what almost amount to miracle cures. If homoeopathy were really that good, it would be no problem to design a trial to convince even the most sceptical observer. However, the more you scrutinise them, the more these miracle cures turn out to be the exception rather than the rule.

Many of the cases cited, on closer inspection, turn out to be things that would probably have got better on their own anyway - like the glue ear. Many more turn out to be not nearly as much improved as the homoeopath implied - a bit like poor Xanta's IBD. And when you see the whole spectrum of cases in the homoeopaths' books, you also come across the ones where the patient got worse, or didn't improve. The real "miracle cures" turn out to be rare enough that they may well be pure coincidence at work.

Now the homoeopaths have answers for this. They say homoeopathy has a very variable effect. Sometimes it works very quickly, but sometimes it can take months - so any improvement which happens to occur within months of taking a remedy can be claimed as success. They say sometimes it causes "aggravations", when the patient gets worse - but they still ascribe that to an action of the remedy. So you see they have all the bases covered. Anything that happens after treatment can be explained in terms of the remedies having an effect.

However, looked at dispassionately, we see in effect no more than conditions taking their natural course - sometimes getting better quickly, sometimes slowly, and sometimes getting worse.

So we ask the homoeopaths to prove that their remedies are actually affecting the outcome of their cases. We ask them to show that a group of people given their prescribed remedy have, on average, a better chance of recovery than a comparable group of people who only thought they were taking their remedy (but were instead given a placebo).

Can't be done. As soon as all concerned are unaware of who has been given the remedy and who hasn't, the effect disappears. Just as many people in the control (placebo) group get better as in the treated group. Just as many people in the treated group get worse as in the control group.

The evidence strongly suggests that the remedies are having no objective effect, and all the perceived effect is purely subjective, on the part of the observer.

Problem two is that the whole of homoeopathy rests on the doctrine of the provings, where healthy people take a remedy and report what they subsequently feel. However, this too breaks down the minute people are unaware of what they are taking. Homoeopaths can't tell the difference between a group of people "proving" a remedy, and a similar group of people who are "proving" only a placebo. Both groups write down interesting sensations and feelings in their diaries, and the diaries can't be told apart.

Not only that, the homoeopaths themselves can't tell whether they've been given a remedy of their choice or a chemically identical placebo. They claim to feel such striking sensations when they "prove" a remedy, but when they don't know whether what they've been given is the real remedy or not, they can't tell. And as you know, the JREF million dollars is on offer for the first person who succeeds in doing this. So far, in spite of the millions of committed homoeopaths around the world, most of whom seem to be convinced that remedies produce striking proving symptoms, nobody is even trying for the money.

Problem three is the moving goalposts. The homoeopaths can't agree among themselves how it ought to be done. You'll have seen this for yourself at H'pathy and HH. Xanta says coffee will negate the effects of belladonna. Divina says no it won't. One says everything is curable by homoeopathy, others disagree. Some say that real medicine is bad and interferes with homoeopathic remedies, others (Leela and David, mainly) say that patients need their real medicine, and homoeopathy only tries to help a little more on top of that. Some say remedies will have an almost instant effect, others that the effect may be delayed by weeks or even months. There is even no agreement on how to condict a valid proving, with no consensus even on how often the remedy needs to be taken or how long for.

This makes designing a trial to test homoeopathic claims quite difficult, as there is always someone who will say, well, of course it didn't work because the procedure was wrong. Which is why we keep coming back to the simple tests. Treat the patients exactly as you think best, but then show that the ones who got the remedy fared better than the ones who were given a placebo instead. Or take away these bottles of remedy or placebo, and sort them out into which is which - any way you like.

But it seems that both of these challenges are impossible.

The biggest problem when talking to homoeopaths is their closed minds. Just consider, for a minute, the possibility that the remedies may do nothing. They won't do it. No matter what happens, they always believe the remedy did something. If you are irrevocably of that camp, we will never agree. However, if you want to examine the evidence and discover the truth, we're with you all the way.

Note, we haven't even mentioned mechanism of action. That's because, first we need to be convinced there is an action.

We say, imagine that homoeopathy works. How would things be? Well, we would expect that people who were really given their remedy would have a better chance of getting better than people who were slipped a placebo instead. We try this, and there is no difference. We would also expect that trained homoeopaths would be able to tell, somehow, which bottles contained real remedy and which didn't. But they don't seem to be able to do this either, even with a million dollars as the prize.

So really, the world looks exactly as we would expect it to look if homoeopathy didn't work. If you want to challenge that, please present some new facts.

We'd rather postpone discussions about possible mechanisms of action (of which very many have been postulated) until the first question has been settled as a yes - but it's looking awfully like a no at the moment.

Rolfe.
 
exarch said:
Let's try to expand this with a practical example:
Gravity

Fact:
When objects are released in mid air, they accelerate towards the earths surface with a speed of 9.98m/s per second. This is a fact, we've observed this, measured it, we know this to be true.
Um, no. Things do not accelerate with a speed. That's an acceleration.

It's also wrong. At this distance from the Earth's center, objects acceleration due to gravity (neglecting air resistance) is 9.81 m/(s*s).
 
Originally posted by Wrath of the Swarm
Um, no. Things do not accelerate with a speed. That's an acceleration.

It's also wrong. At this distance from the Earth's center, objects acceleration due to gravity (neglecting air resistance) is 9.81 m/(s*s).
See, that's the one thing I wasn't quite sure about, whether it was 9.981 or 9.81. I was wondering about Googling it but had already spendt the better part of an hour composing the post and forgot about it.

So how would you explain 9.81m/s<SUP>2</SUP> to the lay person? How do you explain time*time? It's an acceleration, an increase in speed over time. How much increase? 9.81m/s every second. So after 2 seconds, a stationary object is going to be falling at a speed of 19.62m/s (=9.81m/s<SUP>2</SUP> * 2s), and so on until other forces stop it from accelerating any further ...

Unless I am going totally demented ... :(
 
O, Rolfe, this must be the most intelligent thing I have heard you say all the time I have been posting here.

It will be interesting to see whether vijay takes up your challenge.

Remedies never take months to work, but it differs as to whether you are treating acute or chronic cases. In acute cases a remedy will work instantly, but in chronic cases, it may take a bit longer. Up to two weeks, but never as long as a month. This is my experience of practice anyway.
 
Originally posted by Homeoskeptic
Remedies never take months to work, but it differs as to whether you are treating acute or chronic cases. In acute cases a remedy will work instantly, but in chronic cases, it may take a bit longer. Up to two weeks, but never as long as a month. This is my experience of practice anyway.
What a coincidence. Acute cases, when left untreated will heal themselves in less than a week as well, while chronic cases left untreated will cycle (hence: chronic) and go into remission after a couple of weeks. How odd ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom