Kumar said:
The only aspect of ' How ultra-molecular remedy's substances works or can work' is yet to be proved by CST otherwise all other aspects are clear.
So what you are saying is that you believe that ultradilute remedies have a definite biological effect, that is, they "work". This you characterise as the "part-full" aspect of the glass.
However, you also acknowledge that there is no plausible mechanism of action for such an effect. This you characterise as the "part-empty" aspect of the glass.
I think I understand you now, but I don't think I agree with you.
If we were sure that there was an effect there, or even felt that it was quite probable that there was an effect, of course you would be right. And this would be the most pressing problem in the basic sciences of chemistry and physics. Researchers the world over would be fighting to be the first to discover the mechanism of action, knowing that fame and Nobel Prizes await whoever is successful. You must understand that nobody is biassed against homoeopathy, and nobody is trying to cover up anything it can do. Scientists love a real mystery, and if this was one of those they'd be all over it.
But this isn't happening. Apart from a few mavericks on the fringes of biology, nobody is paying the slightest bit of attention to ultramolecular preparations. You must ask yourself, why not? The reason is that while solving a real mystery is a great career move, spending years trying to find a cause for an effect that isn't there is professional suicide. Researchers who have looked at the evidence for ultramolecular preparations having an effect have pretty much unanimously come to the conclusion that there's nothing there but a lot of people kidding themselves and kidding other people, by selective interpretation of the data.
Now, if you come here determined to assert that there is an effect there, you mustn't expect us to agree with you without question. There will be a lot of questions.
Problem one is that the homoeopaths are continually making claims of what almost amount to miracle cures. If homoeopathy were really that good, it would be no problem to design a trial to convince even the most sceptical observer. However, the more you scrutinise them, the more these miracle cures turn out to be the exception rather than the rule.
Many of the cases cited, on closer inspection, turn out to be things that would probably have got better on their own anyway - like the glue ear. Many more turn out to be not nearly as much improved as the homoeopath implied - a bit like poor Xanta's IBD. And when you see the whole spectrum of cases in the homoeopaths' books, you also come across the ones where the patient got worse, or didn't improve. The real "miracle cures" turn out to be rare enough that they may well be pure coincidence at work.
Now the homoeopaths have answers for this. They say homoeopathy has a very variable effect. Sometimes it works very quickly, but sometimes it can take months - so any improvement which happens to occur within months of taking a remedy can be claimed as success. They say sometimes it causes "aggravations", when the patient gets worse - but they still ascribe that to an action of the remedy. So you see they have all the bases covered. Anything that happens after treatment can be explained in terms of the remedies having an effect.
However, looked at dispassionately, we see in effect no more than conditions taking their natural course - sometimes getting better quickly, sometimes slowly, and sometimes getting worse.
So we ask the homoeopaths to prove that their remedies are actually affecting the outcome of their cases. We ask them to show that a group of people given their prescribed remedy have, on average, a better chance of recovery than a comparable group of people who only
thought they were taking their remedy (but were instead given a placebo).
Can't be done. As soon as all concerned are unaware of who has been given the remedy and who hasn't, the effect disappears. Just as many people in the control (placebo) group get better as in the treated group. Just as many people in the treated group get worse as in the control group.
The evidence strongly suggests that the remedies are having no objective effect, and all the perceived effect is purely subjective, on the part of the observer.
Problem two is that the whole of homoeopathy rests on the doctrine of the provings, where healthy people take a remedy and report what they subsequently feel. However, this too breaks down the minute people are unaware of what they are taking. Homoeopaths can't tell the difference between a group of people "proving" a remedy, and a similar group of people who are "proving" only a placebo. Both groups write down interesting sensations and feelings in their diaries, and the diaries can't be told apart.
Not only that, the homoeopaths themselves can't tell whether they've been given a remedy of their choice or a chemically identical placebo. They claim to feel such striking sensations when they "prove" a remedy, but when they don't know whether what they've been given is the real remedy or not, they can't tell. And as you know, the JREF million dollars is on offer for the first person who succeeds in doing this. So far, in spite of the millions of committed homoeopaths around the world, most of whom seem to be convinced that remedies produce striking proving symptoms, nobody is even trying for the money.
Problem three is the moving goalposts. The homoeopaths can't agree among themselves how it ought to be done. You'll have seen this for yourself at H'pathy and HH. Xanta says coffee will negate the effects of belladonna. Divina says no it won't. One says everything is curable by homoeopathy, others disagree. Some say that real medicine is bad and interferes with homoeopathic remedies, others (Leela and David, mainly) say that patients need their real medicine, and homoeopathy only tries to help a little more on top of that. Some say remedies will have an almost instant effect, others that the effect may be delayed by weeks or even months. There is even no agreement on how to condict a valid proving, with no consensus even on how often the remedy needs to be taken or how long for.
This makes designing a trial to test homoeopathic claims quite difficult, as there is always someone who will say, well, of course it didn't work because the procedure was wrong. Which is why we keep coming back to the simple tests. Treat the patients exactly as you think best, but then show that the ones who got the remedy fared better than the ones who were given a placebo instead. Or take away these bottles of remedy or placebo, and sort them out into which is which - any way you like.
But it seems that both of these challenges are impossible.
The biggest problem when talking to homoeopaths is their closed minds. Just consider, for a minute, the possibility that the remedies may do nothing. They won't do it. No matter what happens, they always believe the remedy did something. If you are irrevocably of that camp, we will never agree. However, if you want to examine the evidence and discover the truth, we're with you all the way.
Note, we haven't even mentioned mechanism of action. That's because, first we need to be convinced there is an action.
We say, imagine that homoeopathy works. How would things be? Well, we would expect that people who were really given their remedy would have a better chance of getting better than people who were slipped a placebo instead. We try this, and there is no difference. We would also expect that trained homoeopaths would be able to tell, somehow, which bottles contained real remedy and which didn't. But they don't seem to be able to do this either, even with a million dollars as the prize.
So really, the world looks exactly as we would expect it to look if homoeopathy
didn't work. If you want to challenge that, please present some new facts.
We'd rather postpone discussions about possible mechanisms of action (of which very many have been postulated) until the first question has been settled as a yes - but it's looking awfully like a no at the moment.
Rolfe.