Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Please tell me which doctors and vets that have trained as homeopaths say that it does not work? I have never met any of my doctor colleagues who have said this.

Also, please provide the evidence of the cases that have been so called messed up by homeopathic treatment? First you say it is dangerous and then you say that it does not work. Try getting your story straight. You can't have it both ways.

By the way, I am an MFHom and am proud of it.
 
Rolfe said:
I know, I'm not sure. Probably not, but there are similarities. Xanta was very big on repeated appeals to authority, including the "millions of doctors" bit. I seem to recall she said she'd phoned the homoeopathic doctors in Italy, and they wanted her to tell you (or somebody :D ) that "it works!"

And wasn't it her who waxed horrified about me regarding another acupuncture thread some months ago where I said much the same as I said this evening? How can Rolfe tell such lies about acupuncture? Or maybe that was Barb?

I have those same bells ringing

Dunno, don't care.

I also don't care. if they could come up with one sensible argument then it wouldn't matter whoever they really were

My name isn't Rolfe either, but then you knew that. The difference is, the rest of what I say is true.

Rolfe.
 
By the way. Xanta is totally cured now.

You still have not answered my question about the doctors and cases.

Give me the evidence if you can!!
 
Homeoskeptic said:
First you say it is dangerous and then you say that it does not work. Try getting your story straight. You can't have it both ways.

Please at least pretend you are paying attention.

My anecdotes show precisely the danger that is caused by failing to treat the patient. Don't flatter yourself taht I really think homeopathy cause the deterioration. mother nature makes things get sicker without your help thank you very much. You should just be grateful that she also makes many things get better again as well.

Homeopaths are the one claiming that homeopathy can be dangerous via aggravations. We don't think so, but only raise the subject from time to time to poke fun at their repeated assertions that homeopathy is so safe it doesn't need regulating. If we state a proposition as a prelude to defeating you with reductio ad absurdum that does not mean we believe the proposition, and usually means we are disproving it. Alternatively we are being ironic with humorous intent. Please try and keep up with this.

For the record, I think homeopathy is dangerous only insofar as it may prevent or delay effective treatment being used. On the other hand, it may be helpful, but only if conventional treatment has been misprescribed so that withdrawal provides a net benefit to the patient. Homeopthy=doing nothing and doing nothing is sometimes the best course of action. My skin disease anecdote demonstrates real harm being done and excused as par for the course with homeopathy. Got it now?
 
olaf said:
QM and ZPF more than likely plays some role in the action.

Also, I have read research on the strange properties of water and how the molecules behave in an odd manner upon serial dilution.

You do know that the liquid remedies are added to dry pills in many cases, don't you? All this nonsense about special behaviours in solution rather goes out the window then.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
By the way. Xanta is totally cured now.Yeah, right

You still have not answered my question about the doctors and cases.

Give me the evidence if you can!!
http://www.randi.org/vbulletin/showthread.php?s=&postid=1870403655#post1870403655 In spite of me pointing out how not to read these stories, you have still grasped the wrong end of the stick. They are not about 'messing up' cases. They are about misrepresentaion and lying. Rolfe has an even better one. It is in the public record, but may still be sub judice so may not be quotable here. I know the story and it is horrific. I don't much care whether you believe these stories or not, they're not for you, they are used to illustrate to others the level of fraud that is required to maintain the fiction of homeopathy.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:


You do know that the liquid remedies are added to dry pills in many cases, don't you? All this nonsense about special behaviours in solution rather goes out the window then.

You seem to have a good point on this issue. However, if the authors are correct on the books I am reading then the actual "energy" carried by the water is really not so much in the water but the field around the water. Once the field comes into contact with another solution/or substance the "energy", "signal", vibration or whatever it is gets transferred much as it would if a human or animal were to take in into its body or energy field. --and yes, humans are nothing more than an energy field. you see atoms and molecules but I see things at a deeper level that our physicists are beginning to explain.
 
Thanks for that Olaf.

Not at all. I have not made myself look foolish at all.

I will find the name of the article and post it. This article shows that homeopathy works very well for glue ear.

I have not read the calf diarrhea paper at all, however, I would wonder whether Podophylum is in any way the right remedy for this anyway. A test like this will never work, as the remedy has not been individualised at all and all the calves may need a different remedy to the one given. Idividualisation. That is what homeopathy is all about.

The patients I treated were at least open minded and not totally sceptical like you. The remedies still worked though and very well in fact.

Also, my cases are clinical evidence. I keep clinical data on all of my patients both before and after treatment. If these cases are not clinical data then I really don't know what is.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Please tell me which doctors and vets that have trained as homeopaths say that it does not work? I have never met any of my doctor colleagues who have said this.

Also, please provide the evidence of the cases that have been so called messed up by homeopathic treatment? First you say it is dangerous and then you say that it does not work. Try getting your story straight. You can't have it both ways.

By the way, I am an MFHom and am proud of it.
As for the vets, Mike Jessop is the most vocal. I'd need to trawl the BMJ letters columns to find the medics, and it's getting late.

If you read back a couple of pages, you'll find a post by BSM with a couple of good instances of homoeopaths "messing up" cases by simply doing the nothing the homoeopathic way. Yes, about 70% of cases seen in general practice will get better even if you just throw them out in the yard. Lucky for all of us. And about 10% are lost causes, all we can do is palliate and prolong good quality life as best we can. But about 20% really do need proper medical care and aren't going to get better (or not nearly so quickly) unless they get it. The hyperthyroid cat and the dog with acute moist dermatitis cited by BSM are two classic examples.

You know, we seem to be back at the beginning of this thread, with the still-unanswered question. Is homoeopathy safe or dangerous?

Now, if the remedies really do have a biological effect, I think we can all agree fairly easily that it is dangerous. Nobody understands the effect, "powerful" remedies are available with virtually no instructions over-the-counter, and we only have to look at the homoeopaths' own forums for tales of nasty aggravations and unpleasant proving effects and amateur wannabees messing things up. Not to mention Souresh Ebrahimi, who wanted to make Ben Goldacre very ill with homoeopathy.

Funny there aren't multiple reports of serious harm being caused by all these little sugar pills Boots sells, isn't it?

But even if they don't have any biological effect, can we say homoeopathy is safe? Of course not.
  • Real illness may go untreated, long enough to compromise the patient's health, if content-free remedies are relied on.
  • Unregulated remedies may be irresponsibly prepared by rougue pharmacies, and instead of being content-free, something quite nasty might unwittingly be dispensed.
  • The lack of regulation around the whole area opens the door for unscrupulous vendors to label as homoeopathic preparations which should be licensed as real medicine, with dangerous consequences - as happened in the Zicam affair.
Wow, back on-topic after all these pages!

Naturalhealth, if you have any medical training, please start posting as if you do. You should know the sort of detail necessary to present a case to a colleague - "I saw someone who was ill, I gave them a remedy, they seemed better (or worse), so this proves everything I've been saying" isn't exactly how they approach it at the best teaching hospitals.

Rolfe.
 
Originally posted by olaf
No matter what you may think about homeopathy when there are close to 100,000 medical doctors all over europe who use it then maybe it really works.
Either provide proof for this claim or put a sock in it !!

In Belgium, there are (according to Xanta's rant) some 2000 "prescribers" of homeopathic treatments. Now this may sound like a big number, but the total number of medical professionals that I could find for the year 2000 was between 100'000 and 150'000 people, which means that this is barely 2%. Not to mention that the quote really did say "homeopathy prescribers", not "doctors". I'd be surprised if even more than a fifth of those prescribers were anything more than nurses or flunked out med-students turned alternative medicine quacks.
The cencus I found also didn't list any veterinary doctors as it was actually about healthcare.

In other words, homeopathy is about as substantial in Belgium as the active ingredients in its medicines: very few and far between :p

I fear that your pretty little impressive sounding number is going to turn out to be very small in comparison. And I think we'll also find that you misquoted those 100'000 homeopaths as being medical doctors, which they probably aren't. Not all of them anyway, probably even less than 20% of them.

Get your "facts" straight first, and maybe then we'll educate you on the "appeal to popularity" fallacy, and why millions of meso American natives were in fact still wrong when they slaughtered people regularly to make sure the sun kept rising every day ...
 
Homeoskeptic said:
I would wonder whether Podophylum is in any way the right remedy for this anyway. A test like this will never work, as the remedy has not been individualised at all and all the calves may need a different remedy to the one given. Idividualisation. That is what homeopathy is all about.
I knew it! "No true Scotsman!!!" Naturalhealth never fails to live down to expectations.

If the trial didn't work, well, it was bad homoeopathy and how on earth could anyone have expected it to work??

Oh, and tell that stuff about individualisation to Mark Elliott. No individualisation, polypharmacy, allopathic diagnosis, isopathy as part of the treatment (and the other part selected by dowsing!), and yet it is one of the papers the veterinary homoeopaths get most excited about when trying to defend their dubious practices. Seems as if anything goes as long as the test appears to have been positive.

Unfortunately the study also had no control group, no blinding, Mark himself apparently decided if the patients were better, and several were only followed up for a short time.

Goose and gander sauce. If you want to reject de Verdier Klingenberg's paper on the grounds of wrong remedy and no individualisation, then most of the homoeopaths' own veterinary studies go out with the bathwater.

Your clinical data is not evidence precisely because it is selected. If we had access to uncensored sequential case records for a respectable length of time, with no cherrypicking, that might be a slightly different story. But you're not going to produce that, are you?

Rolfe.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
If these cases are not clinical data then I really don't know what is.

Clearly.

The problem is not so much the case records themselves but the misuse you put them to. You fail to understand the inherently biased and unreliable nature of case evidence plucked at whim from such a database.

You did do statistics as part of you 'medical' education did you? If you qualified as a doctor and it was over 20 years ago then you will have had no more than a piss-poor introductory course that really does not teach you about the scientific method or equip you to deal with data analysis. I had to teach students who suffered from the same lack of formal training. That didn't mean they were stupid, but then they weren't pretending that they did know how to analyse and report objective data.
 
Originally posted by olaf
From the looks of things there appears to be plenty of evidence that homeopathy works above and beyond placebo.
BLATANT LIES !!

From the looks of things, homeopathy performs no better than placebo. In fact, so far only a small handfull of studies has popped up, after 200 years of existence, that support the idea that maybe, there might, perhaps be something there, but a lot more research needs to be done to be sure it's not coincidence.

In other words, it probably is coincidence, since most of the studies find nothing, and a lot of them never even get published as they don't really have anything substantial to add except that homeopathy doesn't work. This is known as publication bias.
 
Originally posted by olaf
You seem to have a good point on this issue. However, if the authors are correct on the books I am reading then the actual "energy" carried by the water is really not so much in the water but the field around the water. Once the field comes into contact with another solution/or substance the "energy", "signal", vibration or whatever it is gets transferred much as it would if a human or animal were to take in into its body or energy field. --and yes, humans are nothing more than an energy field. you see atoms and molecules but I see things at a deeper level that our physicists are beginning to explain.
Entertaining the idea that you are correct about this energy, which for reasons unknown cannot be measured like all other energies:
How does the homeopathic remedy's energy know to adhere to the tablets, and not to the bottle it was contained in, or the air around the water vapor as the remedy evaporates? How do the people handling these remedies avoid being affected by those energies, and how do you prevent different remedies from affecting each other's energy patterns?

You see, most woowoo pseudo-sciences rely heavily on selective energy transfers and the like, or just plain ignoring situations that should have similar outcomes according to their wacky theories, but obviously don't.
 
Rolfe said:
I should watch that spelling, Eos dear - unless you're poking fun at Naturalhealth's embarrasingly similar gaffe earlier.

Bated breath (contraction of "abated" - holding one's breath in anticipation).

Rolfe.
;)

I did get an A in English 210 afterall. 'Course, that was 10 years ago.;)
 
Homeoskeptic said:
I have treated loads of kids with glue ear and have actually prevented them needing treatment with gromets.

Given that you are not even qualified to diagnose a medical condition, why should we believe that you cured one?

There is an organisation called Frontline Homeopathy that has taken homeopathy to the third world. They train healthcare professionals - doctors and nurses in homeopathy and they then train the others and they then take homeopathic care to their communities.

What a nasty little trick to play on the world's poorest people. For shame.
 
Homeoskeptic said:
Also, my cases are clinical evidence. I keep clinical data on all of my patients both before and after treatment. If these cases are not clinical data then I really don't know what is.

You do not have clinical evidence. You have no clinical data. You do not run a clinic. You are not a doctor.

Whilst I'm sure that you write down notes about your 'patients', the 'data' will be heavily skewed by your religiously held beliefs about homeopathic 'philosophy'. And since you are not remotely qualified to diagnose a problem in the first place, how can you ever prove that you cured it?

If you want to prove that homeopathy is effective, you will need to perform a test, in the manner that has been outlined to you. If you suceed under the auspices of the JREF, you will be $1m richer, and I will owe you and the homeopathic community at large an apology. But you won't ever do it. And the reason is that you know full well that you would fail. You'll just continue to pump bile into this forum until everyone ends up ignoring you.
 
exarch said:
Entertaining the idea that you are correct about this energy, which for reasons unknown cannot be measured like all other energies:
How does the homeopathic remedy's energy know to adhere to the tablets, and not to the bottle it was contained in, or the air around the water vapor as the remedy evaporates? How do the people handling these remedies avoid being affected by those energies, and how do you prevent different remedies from affecting each other's energy patterns?
.

exarch,

Excellent questions. These were some of the exact questions that confounded me plus i had several more.

To this day i don't know the answer to questions about glasswear contamination (i understand heat is supposed to cancel out the effect), if i ever come across a really good answer I'll let you know.

Maybe organic compounds are far more suitable for carrying the energetic vibration than glass. Concerning the surrounding area around the bottle, i don't know about the specifics.

I do know that it works in some grand mysterious way. Rather shocking. i also know that about 100,000 european medical doctors know that it works. Strange but true. Once again shocking almost unbelievable, but millions swear by it. The truth is stranger than fiction.
 
[derail/ silly moment]What I'm thinking is Olaf is secretly in love with MY Rolfe and wants to take MY Rolfe away from me! Never you kave! Come hell or high water you will never come between us, I will fight you until my last breath and even if I should know I will die I will still fight to defeat you. [/derail/silly moment]


Maybe Olaf is suffering some sort of bizarre Oedepal complex wherein lust for a parental figure and resentment over the superiority of the other gives rise to anger that targets such a person as Rolfe, who defies the fundamental flaw of misunderstanding a series of simple concepts and thus is a representation of the very basic failures that Olaf was not able to overcome in his/her own life.

Just a guess.

Ps: Naturalhealth, you have less right to ask anyone for an answer to your any question you pose when you yourself as revealing the doublestandard of not answering questions about assertions you made.
 
olaf said:
I do know that it works in some grand mysterious way. Rather shocking. i also know that about 100,000 european medical doctors know that it works. Strange but true. Once again shocking almost unbelievable, but millions swear by it. The truth is stranger than fiction.
Are you a Muslim? If not, I feel that you should be. There are millions of Muslims that all know that Islam is the One True Religion. Unbelievable, but millions swear by it.

With large numbers floating your boat as they do, I guess you'll go out and buy your Cat Stevens 'Best Of' album tomorrow. Right? Right?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom