Homeoskeptic said:
Please tell me which doctors and vets that have trained as homeopaths say that it does not work? I have never met any of my doctor colleagues who have said this.
Also, please provide the evidence of the cases that have been so called messed up by homeopathic treatment? First you say it is dangerous and then you say that it does not work. Try getting your story straight. You can't have it both ways.
By the way, I am an MFHom and am proud of it.
As for the vets,
Mike Jessop is the most vocal. I'd need to trawl the BMJ letters columns to find the medics, and it's getting late.
If you read back a couple of pages, you'll find a post by BSM with a couple of good instances of homoeopaths "messing up" cases by simply doing the nothing the homoeopathic way. Yes, about 70% of cases seen in general practice will get better even if you just throw them out in the yard. Lucky for all of us. And about 10% are lost causes, all we can do is palliate and prolong good quality life as best we can. But about 20% really do need proper medical care and aren't going to get better (or not nearly so quickly) unless they get it. The hyperthyroid cat and the dog with acute moist dermatitis cited by BSM are two classic examples.
You know, we seem to be back at the beginning of this thread, with the still-unanswered question. Is homoeopathy safe or dangerous?
Now, if the remedies really do have a biological effect, I think we can all agree fairly easily that it is dangerous. Nobody understands the effect, "powerful" remedies are available with virtually no instructions over-the-counter, and we only have to look at the homoeopaths' own forums for tales of nasty aggravations and unpleasant proving effects and amateur wannabees messing things up. Not to mention
Souresh Ebrahimi, who wanted to make Ben Goldacre very ill with homoeopathy.
Funny there aren't multiple reports of serious harm being caused by all these little sugar pills Boots sells, isn't it?
But even if they don't have any biological effect, can we say homoeopathy is safe? Of course not.
- Real illness may go untreated, long enough to compromise the patient's health, if content-free remedies are relied on.
- Unregulated remedies may be irresponsibly prepared by rougue pharmacies, and instead of being content-free, something quite nasty might unwittingly be dispensed.
- The lack of regulation around the whole area opens the door for unscrupulous vendors to label as homoeopathic preparations which should be licensed as real medicine, with dangerous consequences - as happened in the Zicam affair.
Wow, back on-topic after all these pages!
Naturalhealth, if you have any medical training, please start posting as if you do. You should know the sort of detail necessary to present a case to a colleague - "I saw someone who was ill, I gave them a remedy, they seemed better (or worse), so this proves everything I've been saying" isn't exactly how they approach it at the best teaching hospitals.
Rolfe.