Homeopathy: safe or dangerous

Lisa Simpson said:
I don't know much about the fallacies that others trot out. Is it a fallacy that just because 100,000 people think it's real, that doesn't make it so?
Young woman, do not be deceived by his lying ways. Proof of his deception is found in his attempt to tear down acupuncture. Most western doctors would not dare claim that acupunture is a sham, but rolfe does. it is because he has an "AGENDA". His agenda is to attack that which he does not understand. He has an anger problem therefore he spends all his free time on this forum unleashing his anger here.

He thinks it allows him to release it but what he does not know is that it is only increasing his general psychological disturbance.
 
olaf said:
Young woman, do not be deceived by his lying ways. Proof of his deception is found in his attempt to tear down acupuncture. Most western doctors would not dare claim that acupunture is a sham, but rolfe does. it is because he has an "AGENDA". His agenda is to attack that which he does not understand. He has an anger problem therefore he spends all his free time on this forum unleashing his anger here.

He thinks it allows him to release it but what he does not know is that it is only increasing his general psychological disturbance.

Thanks for your advice. But in the time I've been here at JREF and learning about homeopathy, I have next to nothing from the believers about the science of homeopathy.

That's all I'm asking for. Science.
 
olaf said:
According to my calculations there would be between 1.1 and 1.3 million doctors. Could be more.
Hmmm, I'm not sure I entirely follow your "calculations", or even how reliable that web page actually is.

Never mind, what about the membership numbers for the homoeopathic associations in these countries? Or the lists of doctors who have obtained homoeopathic "qualifications" such as the MFHom?

Pulling "100,000" out of the air does nothing but temporarily delay the next time you have to face the fact that neither you nor any one of these people, real or fictitious, can even distinguish a potentised remedy of your choice from a sham, never mind tell whether half of their patients are being given such a sham instead of the prescribed remedy - and if so, which half.

In fact it is suspected that stuff like that happens all the time, as not only is there no quality control of the finished product coming out of homoeopathic pharmacies, it would be impossible to implement such controls in any case (see above). Difficult thing to prove, but we do have details of one such instance.

So never mind that some proportion of doctors believes this stuff - why believe them rather than the much larger number who will line up and tell you what nonsense it is? Just show us the evidence.

Oh but you can't.

Rolfe.
 
Lisa Simpson said:
I don't know much about the fallacies that others trot out. Is it a fallacy that just because 100,000 people think it's real, that doesn't make it so?

What? Now you are compounding your fallacies.

You dreamed up this number as your appeal to both popularity and authority, not us.

Just remember, what you call the f*ckwit who graduated bottom of his medical school? Doctor (and quite possibly MFHom).

Nor do I find it very impressive that there are thousands of homeopaths in India. Rather, I find it to be a serious indictment of their medical system.
 
olaf said:
Young woman, do not be deceived by his lying ways. Proof of his deception is found in his attempt to tear down acupuncture. Most western doctors would not dare claim that acupunture is a sham, but rolfe does. it is because he has an "AGENDA". His agenda is to attack that which he does not understand. He has an anger problem therefore he spends all his free time on this forum unleashing his anger here.

He thinks it allows him to release it but what he does not know is that it is only increasing his general psychological disturbance.
Wow, we've got on to the anger and general psychological issues much earlier than Naturalhealth did.

Oh, these homoeopaths are so predictable.

Never mind the insults and the psycholanalysis, just cite the evidence. My agenda is evidence-based medicine for the good of animal patients who can't make up their own minds about woo-woo nonsense. I was quite disappointed to realise that there was nothing in the claims of acupuncture, but there you go, you have to face the truth even when it disappoints.

Olaf has nothing much at all to support his acupuncture claims (less than I expected in fact, as there are quite a few very bad and uncontrolled acupuncture studies out there), but won't even read the negative studies because it's obvious there is an AGENDA. He has nothing at all to support his homoeopathy ramblings other than the hoary old appeals to authority and popularity.

Millions of doctors firmly believe that homoeopathy is a sham and a delusion. So it must be so, no?

Rolfe.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:


What? Now you are compounding your fallacies.

You dreamed up this number as your appeal to both popularity and authority, not us.

Just remember, what you call the f*ckwit who graduated bottom of his medical school? Doctor (and quite possibly MFHom).

Nor do I find it very impressive that there are thousands of homeopaths in India. Rather, I find it to be a serious indictment of their medical system.

Ummm...I didn't come up with the 100,000 number. I just wondered if it was some kind of fallacy.
 
Lisa Simpson said:
Ummm...I didn't come up with the 100,000 number. I just wondered if it was some kind of fallacy.
We know you didn't, BSM just used your post to quote from.

BSM is also fond of pointing out that thousands (or was it millions) of Aztecs were convinced that they had to sacrifice a virgin or the sun wouldn't rise in the morning.

It's the fallacy of appeal to popularity - just because the majority of people might think the earth is flat (which probably they never actually did, but hey, who cares!) doesn't make it so.

It's also the fallacy of an appeal to authority. Maybe 100,000 ordinary people wouldn't mean it had to be true, but 100,000 DOCTORS can't be wrong, can they?

Trouble is, far more than 100,000 doctors are equally if not more convinced that homoeopathy is complete and utter bullsh!t. So which lot do you believe?

Rolfe.
 
Rolfe said:
We know you didn't, BSM just used your post to quote from.

BSM is also fond of pointing out that thousands (or was it millions) of Aztecs were convinced that they had to sacrifice a virgin or the sun wouldn't rise in the morning.

It's the fallacy of appeal to popularity - just because the majority of people might think the earth is flat (which probably they never actually did, but hey, who cares!) doesn't make it so.

It's also the fallacy of an appeal to authority. Maybe 100,000 ordinary people wouldn't mean it had to be true, but 100,000 DOCTORS can't be wrong, can they?

Trouble is, far more than 100,000 doctors are equally if not more convinced that homoeopathy is complete and utter bullsh!t. So which lot do you believe?

Rolfe.
The ones who attack it are the ones who spout off without ever taking a serious look at it. the same as you seem to do.

the 100,000 that know it works are the ones who have seen it work on their patients.

100,000 is a number that you can not deny. But based on your acupuncture lies you will try.
 
Lisa Simpson said:


Ummm...I didn't come up with the 100,000 number. I just wondered if it was some kind of fallacy.

Sorry. Muddled quoting, but I'll leave the original as it stands or the replies will look a bit odd.
 
Olaf has much the same tone as Xanta, but Xanta went away after revealing at Hpathy that his/her much-vaunted cure by homeopathy had broken down. Oops.

Now, Olaf, about these 100,000 doctors who use homeopathy. Who cares? They have no more evidence than you do.

How about you try answering some of the questions that NH/HS has left danglinng. What are your views on homepathy's ability to cure denetic disease?
 
I view homeopathy in the same way as RV. Although RV could go either way--valid or not. Homeopathy on the other hand is very likely to work. I have seen a lot of evidence.

100,000 MD's tells a VERY important story. the story it tells is that these men and women of high intellect have seen the evidence for themselves and they can not deny it. there is something working on an energetic level that is unexplained at the present time.

QM and ZPF more than likely plays some role in the action.

Also, I have read research on the strange properties of water and how the molecules behave in an odd manner upon serial dilution.
 
olaf said:
The ones who attack it are the ones who spout off without ever taking a serious look at it. the same as you seem to do.

the 100,000 that know it works are the ones who have seen it work on their patients.

100,000 is a number that you can not deny. But based on your acupuncture lies you will try.
You have no idea the hours I've spent taking an extremely serious look at homoeopathy. The more you look the more obvious it becomes that anyone who gives it the slightest credence must have some mental health issues.

"We've seen it work on our patients." Yes, you want the names of a few vets who say exactly the same thing? But when you ask them for evidence, it's the same old same old. Diseases take their natural course, and whatever happens the homoepath takes the credit. Including the occasional flukey coincidence of course. Just demonstrate that a group of patients given their presctibed remedy have on average a better chance of recovery than a comparable group who only thought they were getting their remedy. That's all it would take to bring the entire world to your feet, and have us lot here tucking into generous helpings of humble pie. But you can't do it, the vets can't do it and the doctors can't do it.

You know, there are indeed some mainstream medicines with rather dodgy evidence behind them. But a whole system of medicine without one single self-evident effect to point to, or one single clinical condition it can demonstrably address, or even without the ability to tell its own remedies from a fake - you just have to admire the sheer chutzpah of it all.

No, I can't deny a number for which I have been given no evidence at all. You cited the figure, we're still waiting to find out the source and its credibility. Plucked out of thin air by a homoeopath trying to further his AGENDA, was it?

And you still haven't demonstrated that a single statement I made about acupuncture was a lie.

Unlike Naturalhealth's "thousands" of veterinary members of the Faculty of Homoeopathy, who turn out to be 41.

Rolfe.
 
olaf said:
100,000 MD's tells a VERY important story. the story it tells is that these men and women of high intellect have seen the evidence for themselves and they can not deny it.
So what makes their intellect "higher" than the many millions of doctors who know equally well that it's delusional because they've seen the very plain evidence for themselves - often having to pick up the pieces of the patients homoeopathy has messed up. There are even doctors (and vets) who trained as homoeopaths and who are now perfectly prepared to tell you exactly what rubbish it is.

I warn you, if you're going to turn this into a pissing-up-the-wall contest with IQ ratings, you're on a loser.

BSM - I like it. "What do you call the student who was last in his year at medical school?" "MFHom."

Rolfe.
 
The evidence of acupuncture working is plentiful and if you attack that evidence (please keep doing so -- it makes you look dumb) then no evidence from the homeopathic literature will certainly sway you.

From the looks of things there appears to be plenty of evidence that homeopathy works above and beyond placebo.
 
olaf said:
The evidence of acupuncture working is plentiful and if you attack that evidence (please keep doing so -- it makes you look dumb) then no evidence from the homeopathic literature will certainly sway you.

From the looks of things there appears to be plenty of evidence that homeopathy works above and beyond placebo.
Take the acupuncture argument to the acupuncture thread - and provide evidence that any statement I made was a lie.

Now, how about that evidence you're talking about? How could we have missed it all these years? Just post the links to the references, please.

Rolfe.
 
Badly Shaved Monkey said:
Olaf has much the same tone as Xanta, but Xanta went away after revealing at Hpathy that his/her much-vaunted cure by homeopathy had broken down. Oops.
I know, I'm not sure. Probably not, but there are similarities. Xanta was very big on repeated appeals to authority, including the "millions of doctors" bit. I seem to recall she said she'd phoned the homoeopathic doctors in Italy, and they wanted her to tell you (or somebody :D ) that "it works!"

And wasn't it her who waxed horrified about me regarding another acupuncture thread some months ago where I said much the same as I said this evening? How can Rolfe tell such lies about acupuncture? Or maybe that was Barb?

Dunno, don't care. My name isn't Rolfe either, but then you knew that. The difference is, the rest of what I say is true.

Rolfe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom