(1) Even if "[j]ournalists always make mistakes when reporting on scientific research", why is it that they seem to consistently come down against the efficacy of OTC cough medicines? Are they out to get manufacturers of those medicines? If so, why?
If a journalist passes a story to their editor, "Cough medcines in supermarkets stop you from coughing, according to research", what are the odds that the story will run?
Medical research that tends to disagree with peoples' expectations is much, much more likely to get reported than research that simply repeats previous results. When you combine that with the rather poor quality of much reporting of technical and scientific information, the popular press is simply a terrible place to get this sort of information from.
Yes, but the debate here is about the efficacy of OTC cough medicines. What you seem to be suggesting now is that it's not enough for someone who needs a cough suppressant to purchase an OTC medicine containing Dextromethorphan; rather, (s)he must visit a doctor to obtain a prescription for a cough medicine containing that ingredient.
That's not what I understood. Your doctor can suggest you buy an OTC medicine and take a higher dose than the bottle suggests. They don't need to write a prescription to tell you to take more of the stuff.
Since you're still around, Rodney, have you had a chance to explain your previous questions about brand? You asked a lot of people about that, and still haven't explained your reasoning, or what you meant by "identical."
