Homeopathic Cough Medicine

(1) Even if "[j]ournalists always make mistakes when reporting on scientific research", why is it that they seem to consistently come down against the efficacy of OTC cough medicines? Are they out to get manufacturers of those medicines? If so, why?

If a journalist passes a story to their editor, "Cough medcines in supermarkets stop you from coughing, according to research", what are the odds that the story will run?

Medical research that tends to disagree with peoples' expectations is much, much more likely to get reported than research that simply repeats previous results. When you combine that with the rather poor quality of much reporting of technical and scientific information, the popular press is simply a terrible place to get this sort of information from.

Yes, but the debate here is about the efficacy of OTC cough medicines. What you seem to be suggesting now is that it's not enough for someone who needs a cough suppressant to purchase an OTC medicine containing Dextromethorphan; rather, (s)he must visit a doctor to obtain a prescription for a cough medicine containing that ingredient.

That's not what I understood. Your doctor can suggest you buy an OTC medicine and take a higher dose than the bottle suggests. They don't need to write a prescription to tell you to take more of the stuff.

Since you're still around, Rodney, have you had a chance to explain your previous questions about brand? You asked a lot of people about that, and still haven't explained your reasoning, or what you meant by "identical."
 
Two sets of questions:

(1) Even if "[j]ournalists always make mistakes when reporting on scientific research", why is it that they seem to consistently come down against the efficacy of OTC cough medicines? Are they out to get manufacturers of those medicines? If so, why?

I don't they have anything against cough medicines. It just makes a more interesting story to dis something that we tend to take for granted.

(2) How do you explain these quotes from MDs? --

"We found that there is little evidence for or against the effectiveness of over-the-counter cough medicines," says lead author Knut Schroeder, MD, researcher at University of Bristol, Englandger. See
http://www.webmd.com/content/article/18/1689_51929

"There is no clinical evidence that over-the-counter cough expectorants or suppressants actually relieve cough," said Dr Richard Irwin, panel chair of the American College of Chest Physicians which drew up the latest US guidelines.
See http://www.dailymail.co.uk/pages/li...ain.html?in_article_id=373758&in_page_id=1774

Probably a combination of quotes taken out of context, and the journalist rephrasing the quote to make it more understandable to lay people and inadvertently changing the meaning. I have had this argument with a few journalists. I think if they quoted word for word everything the expert says, there would be a lot less misunderstanding even though there may be less understanding. The journalists counter with "it's their job to act as a translator for the layperson, so it's necessary for them to make it understandable". They aren't as concerned about getting it wrong as I thought they would be.

And it may be that those quotes accurately represent those doctors' opinions. There's some joke about if you have 10 doctors in a room you'll hear 11 different opinions. That's why you should pay more attention to the results portion of the study than the conclusion.

Yes, but the debate here is about the efficacy of OTC cough medicines. What you seem to be suggesting now is that it's not enough for someone who needs a cough suppressant to purchase an OTC medicine containing Dextromethorphan; rather, (s)he must visit a doctor to obtain a prescription for a cough medicine containing that ingredient.

I was suggesting that if a physician recommended a cough medicine, they should recommend an effective dose.

On the one hand, I wish the label for OTC drugs always reflected the recommended dose (this applies to all OTC drugs, not just cough medicine), but on the other hand, I understand the need to decrease the likelihood that people will inadvertently harm themselves.

Linda
 
I don't they have anything against cough medicines. It just makes a more interesting story to dis something that we tend to take for granted.
Maybe for inexperienced journalists who are looking for "the big story", but I don't think that's true of experienced journalists.

Probably a combination of quotes taken out of context, and the journalist rephrasing the quote to make it more understandable to lay people and inadvertently changing the meaning. I have had this argument with a few journalists. I think if they quoted word for word everything the expert says, there would be a lot less misunderstanding even though there may be less understanding. The journalists counter with "it's their job to act as a translator for the layperson, so it's necessary for them to make it understandable". They aren't as concerned about getting it wrong as I thought they would be.

And it may be that those quotes accurately represent those doctors' opinions. There's some joke about if you have 10 doctors in a room you'll hear 11 different opinions. That's why you should pay more attention to the results portion of the study than the conclusion.
From what I've read so far, the study results of OTC cough medicines are mixed. Aren't study results more clear-cut with respect to many other OTC medicines?

I was suggesting that if a physician recommended cough medicine, they should recommend an effective dose.

On the one hand, I wish the label for OTC drugs always reflected the recommended dose (this applies to all OTC drugs, not just cough medicine), but on the other hand, I understand the need to decrease the likelihood that people will inadvertently harm themselves.
Linda
Okay, but I think that defeats the purpose of an OTC medicine. Most folks figure, if they have a cough, it's a choice between going through the hassle of seeing a doctor or simply buying an OTC medicine and following the recommended dose on the label.
 
Yes, but the debate here is about the efficacy of OTC cough medicines.
Specifically (I've just had a look back at the OP), it is about the efficacy of OTC homoeopathic cough medicines, which you appear to be reluctant to discuss. Found any evidence yet?
 
Maybe for inexperienced journalists who are looking for "the big story", but I don't think that's true of experienced journalists.
The journalists don't matter. The paper will print whatever the editor thinks will sell.
 
Since you're still around, Rodney, have you had a chance to explain your previous questions about brand? You asked a lot of people about that, and still haven't explained your reasoning, or what you meant by "identical."
By "identical" I meant "identical." ;) It's not enough to say that an OTC cough medicine contains an ingredient or ingredients that have been found to be marginally effective in treating a cough. That specific formulation needs to be tested. The proof of the pudding is in the eating and the proof of any medicine is in the efficacy in controlled tests.
 
By "identical" I meant "identical." ;) It's not enough to say that an OTC cough medicine contains an ingredient or ingredients that have been found to be marginally effective in treating a cough. That specific formulation needs to be tested. The proof of the pudding is in the eating and the proof of any medicine is in the efficacy in controlled tests.
I thought the formulations tested were identical to the OTC medicines.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2111431#post2111431

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=2111640#post2111640
 
Specifically (I've just had a look back at the OP), it is about the efficacy of OTC homoeopathic cough medicines, which you appear to be reluctant to discuss. Found any evidence yet?
You didn't read the OP carefully enough. It states, in relevant part:

"My wife has a recurring cough that won't go away. She's a nonsmoker.

"A work colleague suggested a 'wonder remedy' which had been recommended to her by someone else. The colleague duly went out and bought the remedy and has waxed lyrical about its healing qualities ever since.

"Describing this amazing substance, the colleague dropped the 'H' word -- the cough medicine was homeopathic."

So all we have to go on is the work colleague's belief that her cough medicine: (a) is homeopathic, and (b) works. Now, if you or someone else here wants to investigate the efficacy of this cough medicine in a controlled test, I'm all in favor of it. :)
 
So all we have to go on is the work colleague's belief that her cough medicine: (a) is homeopathic, and (b) works.
You want an affidavit with that? ;)

We went into the general ignorance of the public regarding the definition of homoeopathy on the first page of the thread.

Regardless of the beliefs of the coworker, the thread is about cough medicines described and/or marketed as homoeopathic.

Do you have any evidence that a cough medicine marketed or described as homoeopathic actually works?

If so, do you have evidence that it actually is homoeopathic?
 
Anyway, let's go back to a couple of questions you asked (in adjacent posts) on page one of the thread:
Have any non-homeopathic cough medicines been shown to be efficacious in controlled tests? See http://www.webmd.com/content/article/18/1689_51929

And are you also crusading against all non-homeopathic products -- including those recommended by medical doctors -- that don't work?
What you are effectively doing here is complaining that people are "crusading" against homoeopathic medicines, while leaving "orthodox" medicines alone. The context of the thread is a discussion of homoeopathic cough medicines.

Evidence has been provided that non-homoeopathic cough medicines have some efficacy.

Can you provide any evidence that homoeopathic cough medicines are effective?
 
Last edited:
Ok, this is getting a little bit ridiculous.

Rodney: Fls clearly KNOWS what she is talking about. She is able to produce actual medical studies to support her claims.

These studies that are being referenced are highly controlled to eliminate as much error as possible. What they have shown is that OTC cough medicines DO SEEM TO HAVE AN EFFECT!

What has also been shown are studies that conclude that homeopathic remedies do NOT have an effect. After controlling for bias in a homeopathic study, it seems that any greater than chance positive effect goes away.

What you have so far produced to justify your position are journalistic pieces (which have questionable accuracy and are not as strong as actual study results), and quotes made by individual doctors (very poor evidence, as different doctors can have different opinions [a key word here]; and the doctor may have been taken out of context).

In other words, the evidence supporting fls is Mike Tyson, and in your corner you have Woody Allen.

I mean, sure, he's funny and quirky, but he's not going to win the fight.
 
Last edited:
I've had some good OTC non-homeopathic products, Billy, some so good that I use them even when I don't have a cough.
Well, as long as you keep under four standard glasses... ;)

You need to be educated, son.
Perhaps I should start at page one and see....
Reading from where I came in, though, there seem to be a number of self-serving responses and a bit of congratulatory back-slapping which do not augur well for this thread. :(
But, perhaps I should read first....
 
Maybe for inexperienced journalists who are looking for "the big story", but I don't think that's true of experienced journalists.

Unfortunately, if they exist, they aren't writing the articles that you and others are reading.

From what I've read so far, the study results of OTC cough medicines are mixed. Aren't study results more clear-cut with respect to many other OTC medicines?

I think that part of the problem is that the category "cough medicine" is very heterogeneous. If you have multiple medications for treating the same problem, or multiple indications for a single medication, you are going to get "mixed" results. If we had all along been talking about one medication for one indication, our perception of the research would be more straightforward.

Okay, but I think that defeats the purpose of an OTC medicine. Most folks figure, if they have a cough, it's a choice between going through the hassle of seeing a doctor or simply buying an OTC medicine and following the recommended dose on the label.

It's a trade-off between usefulness and safety (like most stuff that we do). Most OTC medication is intended for use in minor, self-limiting illness, so some under-treatment isn't going to be harmful. It's not really supposed to be a choice between seeing a doctor or buying an OTC medicine - if you need the medicine that badly, you may be sicker than you think and should see the doctor anyway.

Linda
 
By "identical" I meant "identical." ;) It's not enough to say that an OTC cough medicine contains an ingredient or ingredients that have been found to be marginally effective in treating a cough. That specific formulation needs to be tested. The proof of the pudding is in the eating and the proof of any medicine is in the efficacy in controlled tests.

When we use the term "effective" in medicine, it means that has been tested in controlled clinical trials. You are essentially saying that "It's not enough to say than OTC cough medicine contains an ingredient or ingredients that have been found to be marginally effective in controlled clinical trials. The proof is in the effectiveness in controlled clinical trials." You are making a distinction where none exists.

And we have been using "efficacy" and "effectiveness" inter-changeably here. I don't think it makes a difference in this discussion, but they are separate terms when referring to medical research. Efficacy studies are done to see whether a drug has a clinical effect, so the design and execution is kept very straightforward - e.g. Phase II and III clinical trials. Effectiveness studies are more of a real world test. For example, an efficacy study on whether or not Echinacea helps reduce colds may consist of a group of volunteers that stay at a research facility for the duration of the study, are deliberately exposed to the virus, and undergo close medical observation. An effectiveness study may involve volunteers that stay in the community, wait until they catch a cold naturally, and depend upon self-diagnosis.

Linda
 
(in)effectiveness Of Cough Mixtures

Here is my first reference:
This is a Royal Children's Hospital (Melb, Australia) Fact Sheet for patients

http://www.rch.org.au/kidsinfo/factsheets.cfm?doc_id=9920

Are cough medicines helpful?

Cough medicines are not useful in treating cough in children. However, some cough medicines may make children feel a bit sleepy, and help them have a more settled night’s sleep.
 
Dangers of Cough Mixtures

Here's one especially for Moochie's educational requirements*
(Because I have his best interest at heart :D )

http://www.samhsa.gov/newsroom/advisories/061109CoughMed1123.aspx



*I am referring, of course, to Moochie's post:

Originally Posted by Moochie

I've had some good OTC non-homeopathic products, Billy, some so good that I use them even when I don't have a cough.

You need to be educated, son.
 
(In)effectiveness of Cough Mixtures

Another one:
(This one is from America - Mayo clinic)

http://www.mayoclinic.com/health/cold-remedies/ID00036

This quote compares saline nasal sprays to decongestants in cough mixtures:
Saline nasal sprays. Over-the-counter saline nasal sprays combat stuffiness and congestion. Unlike nasal decongestants, saline sprays don't lead to a rebound effect — a worsening of symptoms when the medication is discontinued — and most are safe and nonirritating, even for children.


Over-the-counter cold medications. Nonprescription decongestants and pain relievers offer some symptom relief, but they won't prevent a cold or shorten its duration, and most have some side effects. If used for more than a few days, they can actually make symptoms worse.

Antihistamines. Although antihistamines can help the runny nose, watery eyes and sneezing that occur with allergies, they have the opposite effect on cold symptoms, further drying nasal membranes and impeding the flow of mucus.

Over-the-counter (OTC) cough syrups. In winter, nonprescription cough syrups practically fly off the drugstore shelves. But the American College of Chest Physicians strongly discourages the use of these medications because they're not effective at treating the underlying cause of cough due to colds. Some contain ingredients that may alleviate coughing, but the amounts are too small to do much good and may actually be harmful for children. In fact, the college has strongly recommended against using OTC cough syrups or cold medicines for any child younger than 14.


regards,
BillyJoe
 
Here is my first reference:
This is a Royal Children's Hospital (Melb, Australia) Fact Sheet for patients

http://www.rch.org.au/kidsinfo/factsheets.cfm?doc_id=9920

We haven't been talking about children, but what the heck. Let's make this as confusing as possible. <g>

We are talking about a heterogeneous group of drugs used to treat a heterogeneous group of disorders in a heterogeneous group of people. The evidence on this subject cannot be summed up in one line on a hospital website.

Linda
 
(In)effectiveness of Cough Mixtures:

This one is from Choice Magazine so take it or leave it:

http://www.choice.com.au/viewArticl...e=Kids+and+cough+medicine+don't+mix+(archived)

As a general rule, medicines should not be given unless they do more good than harm, but unfortunately most over-the-counter cough mixtures don’t follow this rule.
There is no evidence from clinical tests that cough suppressants, expectorants and mucolytics actually work.
Cough suppressants often contain codeine derivatives which can sedate children – while they may sleep more it does not help the cough go away.
Many cough mixtures contain complicated mixtures of different medications in doses that are less than what would be recommended to be effective that can increase the risk of side effects. For example, the addition of an antihistamine increases the sedative effect, and by making the mucous thicker, can make it more difficult to cough up, causing a second infection. Decongestants may help clear the nose but again can make children “hyped up” and irritable. So, although many children seem to be OK when given cough mixtures, they are not harmless and probably don’t do much good either.
 
We haven't been talking about children, but what the heck. Let's make this as confusing as possible. <g>

We are talking about a heterogeneous group of drugs used to treat a heterogeneous group of disorders in a heterogeneous group of people. The evidence on this subject cannot be summed up in one line on a hospital website.

Linda
I think you initial posts on this thread were very good. The one nominated was excellent as was another couple I came across when I read this thread just now.
But some of your recent posts are a little self-serving sorry to say.

This particular excerpt you are dismissing is a summary of the recommended treatment by physicians from a major children's hospital who treat patients with these conditions. It is the recommendation they give to patients, and to Family Physicians treating these patients, on how to manage these conditions based on best available evidence.

I don't think their advice can be just ignored.

regards,
BillyJoe


-------------------------------------------------------------------------------


The advice in the above Fact Sheet for patients is repeated in the Clinical Guidelines for Family Physicians:

http://www.rch.org.au/clinicalguide/cpg.cfm?doc_id=9744

There is no evidence that cough medicines, decongestants, antihistamines or antibiotics have a role in treatment.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom