Heiwa Challenge to be Explained at NMSR

I wouldn't waste your time, Kyle. We've already been over this. Trifor is just trying to re-bunk this point. :)

Yeah, don't waste your time trying to rebut something that he has no clue about. Neither do you.

It's cool though. Arguments from personal ignorance rock!!
 
I'd be happy if you could acknowledge the blatantly obvious fact that it's the perimeter that needed all that lateral braising, being the long thin walls it was, and the core that provided them lateral resistance, being the the thick truck of columns and beams that it was.
This is why you don't understand 911. The core was for gravity loads (vertical). ... I got this from the chief structural engineer, first person, not the failed made up junk you come up with.

The shell supplied the lateral load support, it was the lateral load support. Maybe you don't know what lateral support means. You don't understand 911, and you don't understand the WTC towers. Brush up on those engineering skills.
 
Last edited:
Yeah, don't waste your time trying to rebut something that he has no clue about.
YOu can't back up this claim, can you?:

The fact that the type of design it was, the core was not able to stand on it's own. That would be from the designers IIRC.
Again, that lateral bracing in the core which you were apparently unaware of can be seen here:

construction1.jpg


And can also be seen section drawings here.
 
whole lot of pics to look at in your link. Do you have a single image that shows an example of lateral bracing in place after construction was finished? The image in your post shows a pic during construction. Thx.
 
I'd be happy if you could acknowledge the blatantly obvious fact that it's the perimeter that needed all that lateral braising, being the long thin walls it was, and the core that provided them lateral resistance, being the the thick truck of columns and beams that it was.

What's better at resisting overturning forces:

1) A 200 foot long perimeter wall.
2) A 80 foot long interior braced frame.
 
whole lot of pics to look at in your link.
Again, look at the section drawings, like this one.

Do you have a single image that shows an example of lateral bracing in place after construction was finished?
No, when construction was finished all that bracing was covered by walls and such.

What's better at resisting overturning forces:

1) A 200 foot long perimeter wall.
2) A 80 foot long interior braced frame.
The towers ~150x90 foot interior braced core were far better at resisting overturning forces than than their ~200x2 foot perimeter walls, and that core supported those walls in high winds and such.
 
Again, look at the section drawings, like this one.


No, when construction was finished all that bracing was covered by walls and such.


The towers ~150x90 foot interior braced core were far better at resisting overturning forces than than their ~200x2 foot perimeter walls, and that core supported those walls in high winds and such.

your cross section illustration? That's the hat truss, the rest of your post is ignorant incredulity. The cores were only braced at the mechanical floors and just above the multi story atrium. Read the construction documents, not that ******** at "911research"
 
That's the top few floors, and there's cross brassing all the way down, I just linked one of the sections drawings because it is the most obvious in those, just as it can be seen going up in pictures and video of the towers being built, and seen in the core remnants as the stood for a few moments after the rest of the buildings had come down.
 
That's the top few floors, and there's cross brassing all the way down,
no there isn't http://www.google.com/m/url?ei=zrfk...MQFjAA&usg=AFQjCNGSWY1l_yIyhCrtSn7Tur6mJZqTDQ
I just linked one of the sections drawings because it is the most obvious in those, just as it can be seen going up in pictures and video of the towers being built
No it can't
, and seen in the core remnants as the stood for a few moments after the rest of the buildings had come down.
nope, documents prove otherwise.
 
Please quote specifically whatever in that document you believe best supports your claim.
 
It seems you are referring to the bracing of the perimeter on the core at those levels, but you linked the draft which isn't protected, so again please quote specifically whatever in that document you believe best supports your claim.
 
It seems you are referring to the bracing of the perimeter on the core at those levels, but you linked the draft which isn't protected, so again please quote specifically whatever in that document you believe best supports your claim.

you can remain ignorant. You do it well. I'm posting from my phone at the moment. If you are too lazy to read the documents that describe the construction of the towers. And make no mention at all of core bracing beyond the hat truss, atrium floors, and mechanical levels. Then you can wallow in your ignorance.
 
Again, the cross brassing can be seen throughout the cores, as can be seen in the structural drawings, in pictures and video of the towers being built, and in the core remnants as the stood for a few moments after the rest of the buildings had come down. What you are seeing mentioned in the NIST report is obviously the bracing of the perimeter on the core at those levels.
 
Again, the cross brassing can be seen throughout the cores, as can be seen in the structural drawings, in pictures and video of the towers being built, and in the core remnants as the stood for a few moments after the rest of the buildings had come down. What you are seeing mentioned in the NIST report is obviously the bracing of the perimeter on the core at those levels.

Are you going to acknowledge the shell was the lateral support. Are you going to admit you were wrong?
 
Again, the cross brassing can be seen throughout the cores, as can be seen in the structural drawings, in pictures and video of the towers being built, and in the core remnants as the stood for a few moments after the rest of the buildings had come down. What you are seeing mentioned in the NIST report is obviously the bracing of the perimeter on the core at those levels.

kyle - the core was diagonally braced at the basement and lowest few above-ground floors, the hat truss and the mechanical floors.

NCSTAR 1-1 p11 (pdf p73):

Core columns
....
Diagonal bracing was used at the mechanical floors and the area of the hat truss

The diagonal bracing you're spotting at all the way up was, as has been pointed out, temporary support for construction purposes.

And, yes, it was the external walls that resisted horizontal overturning loads.

NCSTAR 1-2 p.lv (pdf page 57):

Resistance of the Towers to shear sliding and overturning moment
...
Resistance of the towers to shear sliding and overturning due to wind was provided by the dead loads that acted on the exterior walls of the towers.

Of course, you could have taken the trouble to look this stuff up for yourself.
 
Last edited:
Again, the cross brassing can be seen throughout the cores, as can be seen in the structural drawings, in pictures and video of the towers being built, and in the core remnants as the stood for a few moments after the rest of the buildings had come down. What you are seeing mentioned in the NIST report is obviously the bracing of the perimeter on the core at those levels.

Please post pictures or links of the structural drawings.
 
Again, look at the section drawings, like this one.

That's an architectural drawing of the hat truss. It's at the very top of the building.

The towers ~150x90 foot interior braced core were far better at resisting overturning forces than than their ~200x2 foot perimeter walls, and that core supported those walls in high winds and such.

Wrong answer. And patently ignorant as well. A line of bracing (which didn't exist on the vast majority of the floors) would run from column to column. The core is a grid of 8x6 columns. It has floor to floor openings in it to allow for hallways, see pdf page 36. At best, there's (16) 45' long braces.

All other things equal, the perimeter walls are about twice as stiff strong as interior walls would be. They are about 9 times as stiff. But the interior isn't something that can be approximated as walls, they would be braced frames which are about an order of magnitude less stiff than a wall.
 
Last edited:
Did you guys invite him? He's on another board claiming you did, and that nobody objected to his calculations etc:

https://www.flashback.org/sp26898941

He also gives a description on his homepage:
Originally Posted by Heiwa
The audience quickly understood that no skyscraper can ever collapse from top down due to a structural failure (or fire) up top and that allegedly scientific reports by professor Bazant of Northwestern University and Dr. Sunder of NIST are false. The audience also understood that all videos and pictures of a structural collapse from top down on 911 are false! One lady in the audience asked who could have produced the movie that was shown "live on TV" on 9-11? Good question. And the good news are that the Federal Bureau of Investigation, FBI, at Albuquerque, is investigating that right now! They contacted me after the presentation to this effect! I wonder what FBI will do.


On both boards he claimed FBI contacted him after the presentation. I have asked him on the other board to clarify.


I polled the attendees, and have received 10 responses thus far (so about a 40% return on the poll).

The poll question:

It appears our speaker, Anders Bjorkman, has his own bizarrely unique perspective on how his talk to NMSR last Wednesday was received.

He writes on his website:
http://heiwaco.tripod.com/news.htm

"Meeting at Albuquerque, 10 November, 2010

You can study the presentation here! The meeting was very popular. The audience quickly understood that no skyscraper can ever collapse from top down due to a structural failure (or fire) up top and that allegedly scientific reports by professor Bazant of Northwestern University and Dr. Sunder of NIST are false. The audience also understood that all videos and pictures of a structural collapse from top down on 911 are false! One lady in the audience asked who could have produced the movie that was shown 'live on TV' on 9-11? Good question. And the good news are that the Federal Bureau of Investigation, FBI, at Albuquerque, is investigating that right now! They contacted me after the presentation to this effect! I wonder what FBI will do."


IF you were at this meeting, would you please answer these two questions, either to me personally, or to the the group if you wish.

(1) Do you agree with Bjorkman that "no skyscraper can ever collapse from top down due to a structural failure (or fire) up top and that allegedly scientific reports by professor Bazant of Northwestern University and Dr. Sunder of NIST are false"?

(2) Do you agree with Bjorkman that "all videos and pictures of a structural collapse from top down on 911 are false!"?

I'd like to get an informal tally to send along (sans your names, of course) to Bjorkman.

Thanks, Dave Thomas

The responses thus far:

(1) Do you agree with Bjorkman that "no skyscraper can ever collapse from top down due to a structural failure (or fire) up top and that allegedly scientific reports by professor Bazant of Northwestern University and Dr. Sunder of NIST are false"?
No.
(2) Do you agree with Bjorkman that "all videos and pictures of a structural collapse from top down on 911 are false!"?
Absolutely Not.
-Jerry


I do not agree with either proposition.

Nancy.


Per your questions to tally our answers on 9/11 tower collapses:

no, and no, respectively

John C.


1) No, I do not agree with Bjorkman's "axiom" that a building cannot be brought down if the top part falling on the rest below. I'm fine with the NIST report's conclusion on that.

2) No sir, I don't believe that Mickey Mouse was involved in some conspiracy to make fake videos of a 767 flying into a building, or videos of the towers coming down. It might have been a bit more believable if he had blamed the Muppets of perpetrating 9/11 in order to exact revenge for the secret biological weapon that was used on Jim Henson, and that they were using Disney as a patsy to get rid of the competition. I mean, Disney is known for its antisemitism and we all know that the WTC was a symbol of Jewish power, so of course people would believe that The Mouse was involved. That sounds perfectly plausible, right?

Seriously though, those videos were not faked.

Cheers, Jesse


Dave:

I was at last Wednesday's NMSR meeting.

Except for the lady's question, all of Bjorkman's summary of the meeting is false. And I'm convinced his
"good news" about the FBI investigating the building collapse is nothing more than Bjorkman's fantasy.


(1) Do you agree with Bjorkman that "no skyscraper can ever collapse from top down due to a structural failure (or fire) up top and that allegedly scientific reports by professor Bazant of Northwestern University! and Dr. Sunder of NIST are false"?
Answer: NO!

(2) Do you agree with Bjorkman that "all videos and pictures of a structural collapse from top down on 911 are false!"?
Answer: NO!

Harry


I disagree with him on both counts. How he ever came to those conclusions reminds me of how creationists come to theirs. In fact - that's probably a pretty good comparison.

PS: Every video or picture he showed was supposed to be fake. It was one big transformers movie as far as he was concerned.

He's not quite all there, simply dismissing the thousands of witnesses and asking where were the interviews, which used to be accessible on the web, though I haven't tried for a long time.

PPS: For those who care, I wrote to the FBI (same address Bjorkman used) and they said they would pass what I said along. I also invited them to attend a meeting, and if they liked it, to please become members - seriously. They said they'd consider that. (I told them the basic deal with Bjorman, and that he seemed relatively harmless but nuttier than a fruit cake and not worth their time, first ;-)
-Kim


No and No.

Ted


Dave,
I don't agree with Bjorkman on either point.
John G.


No. No.

And I was the "lady that asked the question." I tried to push him in a corner on that one, but he side-stepped it.

I don't think anything will change this guy's mind. As I have said before, you can't convert a creo (or insert truther, birther, global-warming denier). You have to convince everyone else and get these wackadoodles out of positions of power or influence.

I don't think most people will understand the physics, but they will understand his claim that all the film footage was a movie or faked. Push him on that to really discredit him. That is what most of the world can comprehend.

-- Marilyn


Yes I was there. Of course, I say no to the two questions.

What a nut case!

Jack


It looks like Bjorkman is as good at reading audiences as he is at doing physics.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom