Heiwa Challenge to be Explained at NMSR

As regards no-planes just say the word and I will show you a video that you will not want to comment on in ppublic. Or hopefully maybe you will..

Are you sure that none of your NMSR members are not in the FBI's pocket ?

"The Word"

C'mon Bill.
 
It seems that what kylebisme refers to as 'bracing' are the horizontal steel girders. Everbody else here assumes 'bracing' would mean diagonal members.

Which strikes me as just plain weird. As if the entire core would rise to that height composed of nothing but vertical steel?


He's used both "cross bracing" and "lateral bracing" in his posts. I'm no engineer, but I'm pretty sure those are two different things...
 
It looks to me as if Heiwa's intention was to face down in person your good self and potentially your colleague Kim on your own ground. Did that happen or not ?

Why else would he have visited NMSR ?

Yes, we actually met and had a public meeting. Is that so surprising?

As regards no-planes just say the word and I will show you a video that you will not want to comment on in public. Or hopefully maybe you will..

Mods, since this thread is about Bjorkman, and Bjorkman is a well-known no-planer, I think Bill's suggestion of a video regarding the 'no plane theory' is pretty much on-topic.

Whether or not you were thinking about another thread, Ms. Smith, I'd like to see your video, as would others.

No excuses, just post the link. Sarite?

Are you sure that none of your NMSR members are not in the FBI's pocket ?

Yup.
 
No excuses, just post the link. Sarite?


bill smith has this bizarre habit of trying to intimidate people with the threat of YouTube videos. In almost all (being conservative) cases, it's been a video we've all been aware of for years.

I can almost guarantee that the video he will post is the one that had been edited to remove the plane, thus showing only a fireball erupting from the tower.
 
Please quote specifically whatever in that document you believe best supports your claim.

im off my smart phone now and on my PC
The models included all primary structural components in
the towers, including exterior walls (columns and spandrel beams), core columns,
exterior wall bracing in the basement floors, core bracing at the mechanical floors, core
bracing at the main lobby atrium levels,
hat trusses, and rigid and flexible diaphragms
representing the floor systems.

This is due to the fact that core
columns and hat truss members do not significantly contribute to wind load resistance
 
Please quote specifically whatever in that document you believe best supports your claim.
Bump for Kyle
1186615727424.gif


The models included all primary structural components in
the towers, including exterior walls (columns and spandrel beams), core columns,
exterior wall bracing in the basement floors, core bracing at the mechanical floors, core
bracing at the main lobby atrium levels,
hat trusses, and rigid and flexible diaphragms
representing the floor systems.

This is due to the fact that core
columns and hat truss members do not significantly contribute to wind load resistance
 
Once again, that's a section at the roof of the building where the hat truss is located.
No, this is multiple sections, with the top of the first being the upper mechanical floor and the top of the rest being tenant space.

Now look at the 9th floor core plan. There is no diagonal bracing called out.
Right just upset beams, and that is what images of the core both going up and coming down show; diagonal bracing on some stories and lateral bracing throughout.
 
No, this is multiple sections, with the top of the first being the upper mechanical floor and the top of the rest being tenant space.

There's no bracing shown in any of those sections.


Right just upset beams, and that is what images of the core both going up and coming down show; diagonal bracing on some stories and lateral bracing throughout.

Horizontal beams do not automatically create lateral bracing. That's where you're slipping up.

Lateral bracing is provided by a connection to a diaphragm (the floor) that is also connected to a lateral force resisting system (the perimeter walls or a trussed up set of core columns). This connection must also have minimum strengths and stiffness.

For horizontal beams to brace a column it must have a stiffness such that there is no rotation from the beam to column as the beam or column is loaded. In the case of the WTC, the angle between the beam and the column must always be at 90 degrees, as soon as that angle changes, the beam is unable to brace the column from buckling. This can only be achieved by using a connection that fixes (either by welding or through slip-critical bolts) the flange (the top and bottom part of the I) to the column. This connection did not exist on the WTC core columns.
 
Last edited:
What is "brassing"? It does not fill one with confidence when you can't even spell the engineering terms correctly.Where did you study the subject and what qualifications do you have?

I thought that maybe "cross brassing" was crabby trumpet players.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom