Heiwa Challenge to be Explained at NMSR

For horizontal beams to brace a column it must have a stiffness such that there is no rotation from the beam to column as the beam or column is loaded.
Nonsense. The welding you mention offers better performance in such regards, but it's not the binary matter you make it out to be by any stretch.
 
Nonsense. The welding you mention offers better performance in such regards, but it's not the binary matter you make it out to be by any stretch.

I don't know much about this stuff. Tell me again why I should believe you?
 
Nonsense. The welding you mention offers better performance in such regards, but it's not the binary matter you make it out to be by any stretch.

:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

Yea, that's why square trusses were so popular possible before Vierendeel. Square frames have no lateral resistance unless the beams are fixed to the columns. Fixing the beams costs money. Engineers don't spend money on a pointlessly redundant system.

You want to know why the vast majority of the public knows people like you and Heiwa are wrong? It's because they can spot people that just make :rule10 up.
 
Last edited:
:rolleyes::rolleyes::rolleyes:

Yea, that's why square trusses were so popular possible before Vierendeel. Square frames have no lateral resistance unless the beams are fixed to the columns. Fixing the beams costs money. Engineers don't spend money on a pointlessly redundant system.

You want to know why the vast majority of the public knows people like you and Heiwa are wrong? It's because they can spot people that just make :rule10 up.



I've always said, I suspect the vast majority of truthers have never actually built anything of note. Even a hobbyist who have built a few 2x4 framed walls or decks knows that a simple square frame has almost no side-to-side stability. They always need something else to stabilize them. When I built my Giant Cat Run last spring, it was incredible how much stiffer my wall sections were after I had added the wire mesh over top of the framing.
 
Last edited:
Wow. The only giant cat run I've come across is when my cat got in the trash and ate a delightful meal of marshmallows, chicken skin, and popcorn. It was not pleasant.
 
He also claims that the editor, Ross Corotis has resigned due to realizing that Bazant "is a fraud". I'm gonna go out on a limb here and claim that is a lie as well.


You're safe on that limb. Here's an e-mail from Mr. Corotis (reprinted with permission, but I unilaterally redacted email addresses and such)

From: Ross Corotis [mailto:]
Sent: Thursday, November 18, 2010 8:38 AM
To: []
Subject: Re: Idle Rumor

Dear [ ],

Thank you for asking. You are the second person to report this to me.
This is a complete lie. The normal rotation for the editor of the ASCE
Journal of Engineering Mechanics is five years. I stayed for six years
since this was a transition time for the old Engineering Mechanics
Division of ASCE to become the Engineering Mechanics Institute of ASCE.
The journal receives an average of more than one paper every working day
of the year, and six years is a major voluntary commitment to this
professional service. I decided it was time to let someone else have
this fun. By the way, you might be interested that the Institute
nominated me for the outstanding ASCE journal editor award for my
service (I did not win the award, but was very thankful for my
colleagues for nominating me).

Ross

Mods, since this thread is about Bjorkman, and Bjorkman is a well-known no-planer, I think Bill's suggestion of a video regarding the 'no plane theory' is pretty much on-topic.

Whether or not you were thinking about another thread, Ms. Smith, I'd like to see your video, as would others.

No excuses, just post the link. Sarite?


It would be fine in another thread, but not appropriate in this thread.
 
Last edited:
Yes, we actually met and had a public meeting. Is that so surprising?



Mods, since this thread is about Bjorkman, and Bjorkman is a well-known no-planer, I think Bill's suggestion of a video regarding the 'no plane theory' is pretty much on-topic.

Whether or not you were thinking about another thread, Ms. Smith, I'd like to see your video, as would others.

No excuses, just post the link. Sarite?





Yup.

If Heiwa went to NMSR specifically to face down yourself and Kim (as is almost a certainty) and you agree that you interreacted with him- can you tell us more about what you Kim and Heiwa discussed ? And how long did you and Kim debate with him ?

Onviously we are not much interested in what other members might have said and I'm sure that Heiwa wasn't either..

The point is I would like to see if you and Kim were potentially avoiding being closely questioned in public by Heiwa.

If you post the full audio we may be able to work it out for ourselves.

PS. Did you send Panoply Prefect the audio ? It looks like you did from a previous post.
 
Last edited:
http://img530.imageshack.us/img530/1830/construction1.jpg
Where are your designers claiming the core was not built to be able to stand on it's own?

Look at your image. What do you see?

I'll tell you what I see. I see the basement area (you can also see the "Bathtub" walls in the background). This is the widest portion of the structure but it is all below grade so once it was covered up with the plaza you might not even know that it was there. Nobody has ever said that there was no cross bracing in that part of the structure. On top of that I see a portion of the lobby section of the building. The lobby was 6 stories high and each of the columns supported 3 of the upper columns in order to make the lobby seem more airy, These columns were topped off with the "Candlesticks", your image is missing the candlesticks so they can be no more than 5 stories tall. It has been mentioned right here in this thread that floors 1 though 7 or 8 had cross bracing (it wasn't mentioned why so I'll put it here, there were no "Floors" on 1-6, again, to make the lobby open and airy so cross bracing was needed in those areas to provide the lateral supports that the floors would do on the higher stories). You then see the core. the lowest 2.5 floors of which show cross bracing and the 2 floors directly above those do not while the remaining core section looks as though there may be some temporary diagonal bracing as there doesn't appear to be the complete steel structure in place yet. Then in the corners you see the beefed up sections that the cranes sat on.

Truthers always seem to stop there in showing the core structure because there was no additional cross bracing for the core on the office floors. Cross bracing would've blocked elevator doors, bathroom doors, supply room doors, utility room doors, mail room doors and hallways. None of that is ever mentioned by the tenants (in fact they usually gushed about how open the floors were, the exact opposite of what all of your imaginary cross bracing would do).
 
This can only be achieved by using a connection that fixes (either by welding or through slip-critical bolts) the flange (the top and bottom part of the I) to the column. This connection did not exist on the WTC core columns.

Wow. I always assumed that the core area floor framing would serve double duty - so to speak - and also brace the core columns.

So this wasn't the case at all?
 
YOu can't back up this claim, can you?:


Again, that lateral bracing in the core which you were apparently unaware of can be seen here:

[qimg]http://img530.imageshack.us/img530/1830/construction1.jpg[/qimg]

And can also be seen section drawings here.

How do we know it wasn't designed to stand on it's own? Because the load analysis that was done for the entire structure as a combined unit. That means the core, the perimeter columns, and the floors all as one unit.

Go to The Skyscraper Museum site (link below) and select the World Trade Center link. After it loads, go to the Analysis/Test pane on the right. Look at the pictures of the calculations and such.
http://www.skyscraper.org/viva2/viva2.html

I see nothing in regards for calculations for the core as a stand alone structure. Again, the load and stress calculations were done for the tower as a whole (floors, perimeter columns, and core) as the site above shows.
 
Wow. I always assumed that the core area floor framing would serve double duty - so to speak - and also brace the core columns.

So this wasn't the case at all?

Correct. The bottom most floors, the mechanical floors and the hat truss are an exception. The core columns at those locations were "trussed up" so to speak. But the vast majority of the core column length was unbraced.
 
If Heiwa went to NMSR specifically to face down yourself and Kim (as is almost a certainty) and you agree that you interreacted with him- can you tell us more about what you Kim and Heiwa discussed ? And how long did you and Kim debate with him ?

Onviously we are not much interested in what other members might have said and I'm sure that Heiwa wasn't either..

The point is I would like to see if you and Kim were potentially avoiding being closely questioned in public by Heiwa. ...

The purpose of the visit was Bjorkman's explanation of the details of his challenge. He presented slides, which are online here.

We asked lots of questions about the details of the challenge, and got lots of answers.

I'll be writing a summary of the meeting for the NMSR newsletter, which comes out around the first of December this time.

Meanwhile, Bjorkman has clarified (sort of) his stance on being a no-planer.

He wrote me on Nov. 19th to say
Hi again,

pls do not call me a famous no-planer on randi! I am famous for claiming that you can fly as many planes you like into tops of skyscrapers and only local damages will take place and there is no risk of collapse of bottom part, etc, etc. I explained why to you at the meeting. And I didn't hear anybody disputing that!

Only terrorists like GWB and Condi believe that you can destroy skyscrapers by flying planes into their tops. I wonder what FBI believes.

best regards

Anders

I responded on the 19th:
Now I'm confused. At the meeting you said ALL the videos were faked - the airplane impacts, crash at the pentagon, the collapses, everything.

Are you instead saying that the live videos of the airplanes crashing into the towers/pentagon were real, and that Dreamworks/Disney only made videos of the tower collapses?

If I've mis-stated your position on the forum, I will correct it. But I want to hear it from you, first.

Were videos of the plane crashes faked, yes or no? Or just those of the towers collapsing? Answer carefully.

Regards, Dave

And received this response on the 20th:
Dave, what I said at meeting is what I always say to all my audiences:
everything shown 'live on TV' of towers, planes, holes in towers, fires, smoke up top, final destructions (the impossible crush downs) is just a movie type Independence Day (1995) when the White House, etc is blown apart. I assume same technology was used 1995 and 9-11 2001.
So all 9-11 videos of planes colliding with towers = fake!
All 9-11 videos showing holes in towers with smoke emerging (and people jumping, etc) = fake!
All 9-11 videos showing towers 'collapsing' from top in a fountain of smoke/dust = fake!

The latter is very easy to prove! No tower or structure can ever destroy itself from top down by gravity. My Challenge proves it. If you can prove me wrong, I'll give you Euro 10 000:-.

Any news from FBI?

Careful and best regards

Anders

PS - What do your millions of downtown NY eyewitnesses say? Do they exist? Or did you make them up?
PPS - The Pentagon was apparently damaged by a bomb located in the wall. The video shown - 5 pictures or so = fake! Very easy to prove. But I just focus on WTC1.

On the 21st, I asked Bjorkman this:
OK, I will tell the forum that you say you are not a famous no-planer, and that you think that all the videos of plane impacts/holes/fires/jumpers are faked.

It's still pretty confusing, though. You're not a no-planer, but there were no authentic videos of the plane impacts? Strange.

Re "PS - What do your millions of downtown NY eyewitnesses say? Do they exist? Or did you make them up?", the "millions" is more like the numbers watching on TV. However, there are thousands of interviews of people who saw it live, in person. Thousands. Well-documented and all that.

Regards, Dave

P.S. We're not your middleman to the FBI. I doubt we'll hear anything more. If you are curious, perhaps you should ask them yourself.

And, I received this response yesterday:
Yes, 100+ millions looked at the movie 'live on TV' and thousands looked on the real WTCs downtown NY. Evidently they did not watch the same thing. And then, suddenly, the south no. 2 tower collapsed - from below - using controlled demolition methods and downtown NY was covered in dust and the thousands of onlookers couldn't see anything more. What was shown 'live on TV' was something else - tower exploding up top, top tilting 18% before disappearing in a cloud of smoke, etc, etc. Just a nonsense movie and not as Bazant and NIST explain - top applying energy on bottom that collapses from top (which is impossible). When north no. 1 tower was destroyed from bottom up using controlled demolition, the movie 'live on TV' showed something amazing - floor after floor explode starting from top and continuing down with no top part C visible at all. What a lousy animation or simulation. Worse than the Independence Day movie. But it fooled 100+ millions watching TV. But not me.

I asked FBI about developments. Do you want a copy?

Best regards

Anders

PS - the randi forum is pure rubbish. Why waste your time there? Concentrate on your structure.

And there you have it. Is Heiwa a no-planer? Perhaps the real question should be "Does Heiwa realize he is a no-planer?"

Cheers, Dave
 
"It fooled 100+ millions watching TV. But not me."

damn. We at the NWO towers were told the plan was fool proof. Now look! We have at least one guy who wasn't fooled at all! Somebody's loosing their keys to the executive washroom over that one i'm afraid.
 
The purpose of the visit was Bjorkman's explanation of the details of his challenge. He presented slides, which are online here.

We asked lots of questions about the details of the challenge, and got lots of answers.

I'll be writing a summary of the meeting for the NMSR newsletter, which comes out around the first of December this time.

Meanwhile, Bjorkman has clarified (sort of) his stance on being a no-planer.

He wrote me on Nov. 19th to say


I responded on the 19th:


And received this response on the 20th:


On the 21st, I asked Bjorkman this:


And, I received this response yesterday:


And there you have it. Is Heiwa a no-planer? Perhaps the real question should be "Does Heiwa realize he is a no-planer?"

Cheers, Dave

Heh. He still won't acknowledge the fact that people saw it with their own eyes.
 
Why doesn't he take that 10k euro and hire a firm to do the analysis?
 
Heiwa is the quintessential truther.

-Claim no evidence exists that contradicts your claims.
-Then claim said evidence is fake when presented.
-Present a challenge of demonstration.
-After said challenge is met just say it hasn't.
 
Heiwa is the quintessential truther.

-Claim no evidence exists that contradicts your claims.
-Then claim said evidence is fake when presented.
-Present a challenge of demonstration.
-After said challenge is met just say it hasn't.

I don't agree. Most truthers at least try to present a self-consistent argument, although they invariably fail. Heiwa can present several mutually contradictory arguments all at the same time and fail to recognise that he's doing it. Where most truthers are simply blinded by their distrust of authority, I think Heiwa may actually be quite insane.

Dave
 
I don't agree. Most truthers at least try to present a self-consistent argument, although they invariably fail. Heiwa can present several mutually contradictory arguments all at the same time and fail to recognise that he's doing it. Where most truthers are simply blinded by their distrust of authority, I think Heiwa may actually be quite insane.

Dave
Try yes. Succeed? No. Every CD inside jobber I know claims that it was bombs and the govt yet always point to the "warning signs", as if there would be warning signs to be had if it wasn't really terrorists. For some reason our govt purposefully ignored signs to give internet detectives something to talk about.
 
And there you have it. Is Heiwa a no-planer? Perhaps the real question should be "Does Heiwa realize he is a no-planer?"

Cheers, Dave


My aunt and uncle were in NYC on that day. They saw the planes LIVE in person, crash into those towers.

they also saw the constant broadcast of the impacts that were caught on film and video in the days, weeks, months and even years later, and they , to this day, have not refuted that any of the video footage or photo image, DIFFER from what they saw LIVE and in person.

He is ultimately calling my aunt and uncle liars. and I do not put up with anyone who calls anyone I know personally liars, for them experiencing what a horrific day that was.

I would have lost them, if their Cab got to the towers 20 minutes earlier, but thank heavens to New York city traffic delaying them from their venture up to the Observation deck that day.
 
Dave, what I said at meeting is what I always say to all my audiences:
everything shown 'live on TV' of towers, planes, holes in towers, fires, smoke up top, final destructions (the impossible crush downs) is just a movie type Independence Day (1995) when the White House, etc is blown apart. I assume same technology was used 1995 and 9-11 2001.
So all 9-11 videos of planes colliding with towers = fake!
All 9-11 videos showing holes in towers with smoke emerging (and people jumping, etc) = fake!
All 9-11 videos showing towers 'collapsing' from top in a fountain of smoke/dust = fake!

Yes, 100+ millions looked at the movie 'live on TV' and thousands looked on the real WTCs downtown NY. Evidently they did not watch the same thing. And then, suddenly, the south no. 2 tower collapsed - from below - using controlled demolition methods and downtown NY was covered in dust and the thousands of onlookers couldn't see anything more. What was shown 'live on TV' was something else - tower exploding up top, top tilting 18% before disappearing in a cloud of smoke, etc, etc. Just a nonsense movie and not as Bazant and NIST explain - top applying energy on bottom that collapses from top (which is impossible). When north no. 1 tower was destroyed from bottom up using controlled demolition, the movie 'live on TV' showed something amazing - floor after floor explode starting from top and continuing down with no top part C visible at all. What a lousy animation or simulation. Worse than the Independence Day movie. But it fooled 100+ millions watching TV. But not me.



No-planer?

How's about no-brainer. That means ALL of the news agencies were "in on it", not to mention all of those people who posted videos of that day. The impossibly vast conspiracy becomes even more impossibly vast.

There you go, Truthers. There's a real star to hitch your wagon to. Still support that kind of nonsense now? Let's see the hands.

Insane.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom