Heiwa Challenge to be Explained at NMSR

John's Demo at the Meeting

I finally got around to posting a short video of NMSR VP John Geohegan's Heiwa Challenge structure, which Bjorkman witnessed (and rejected) in person.


John has commented on this experiment:
The November NMSR meeting was a presentation of the Heiwa Challenge by Anders Björkman, a presentation designed to convince us that the World Trade Center had not collapsed in the way we have seen on television, with the “proof” being that it is impossible for a building to collapse from the top down. Björkman offers a reward of 10,000 euros to anyone who can build a model that meets his requirements and collapses from the top down. The problem with his offer is that he specifies that his model be built with each floor supporting all the floors above. Such a model would perform roughly like a stack of wooden blocks. A vertical force pushing down on the upper blocks would result in first crushing the lower blocks because they would be experiencing the greatest forces.

The World Trade Center towers weren’t built in conformance with Björkman’s requirements. Instead, each floor was supported by a “tube within a tube” which transmitted the vertical forces to the ground, bypassing the lower floors. Perhaps an easier way to see the principle is to realize that a heavy person standing high up on a stepladder puts no weight on the lower steps.

I demonstrated the principle with a simple model consisting of four 2.5 pound weights supported by toothpicks and a wooden dowel. It collapsed from the top down, violating his principles, but then Mr. Björkman raised the objection that I hadn’t generated any rubble. The falling weights were meant to simulate the concrete floors of the World Trade Center, each 208 feet square and four inches thick. Thinking of those falling 50 or more stories without generating a lot of rubble would be more of an impossibility.

Apparently my demonstration had no effect on Björkman’s thinking, but I feel his challenge has been shown to be worthless.
 
LOL. Love the "collapse".

Bee dunker attempts at debunkery are so unbelievably stupid as to be shocking. You don't seem to have a clue, at any time, what principle it is you're attempting to demonstrate.

New Mexicans for Science and Reason? That's an embarrassment to New Mexicans.
 
LOL. Love the "collapse".

Bee dunker attempts at debunkery are so unbelievably stupid as to be shocking. You don't seem to have a clue, at any time, what principle it is you're attempting to demonstrate.

New Mexicans for Science and Reason? That's an embarrassment to New Mexicans.

Wouldn't it be more productive to point out if and where the demonstration violates any term Heiwa set up in his "Challenge"?
 
LOL. Love the "collapse".

Bee dunker attempts at debunkery are so unbelievably stupid as to be shocking. You don't seem to have a clue, at any time, what principle it is you're attempting to demonstrate.

The principle in this case is that Heiwa's basic claim is plain wrong, and that it's trivially easy to demonstrate this. You should perhaps search this forum for details.

Back in the days of The Heiwa Challenge he was constantly having to modify his idiotic 'challenge' in the face of simple models that met the conditions. I don't recall the generation of rubble though; that must be a new one.
 
The Heiwa Challenge.

goalposts.gif


Now it has to generate rubble? Wow.....
 
Correct. The bottom most floors, the mechanical floors and the hat truss are an exception. The core columns at those locations were "trussed up" so to speak. But the vast majority of the core column length was unbraced.


I think I understand where I'm wrong, after some thought on the subject.

When you speak of bracing, you means as a way to transfer lateral loads, etc.

I was thinking of it as bracing that would lessen the buckling length as it refers to Eulers.

Under my context ONLY, the core columns were braced then?
 
I have a question about Heiwa's description on his website.

Heiwa's website said:
Part A consists of 97 horizontal elements or floors, each with mass m (including supports just below), stacked on top of one another with vertical support elements, pillars and columns, in between of height h = 3.7 meters. Part A is supported by ground, GF. Total mass of A is 97 m! It is 358.9 meters tall.

Upper part C consists of 14 horizontal elements/floors, each with mass m as part A, stacked on top of each other with vertical support elements in between of height h. Total mass of Upper part C is 14 m. It is 51.8 meters tall.

The bold parts are what I am questioning. Correct me if I'm wrong, but isn't there a big difference between that description above and the actual steel structure of the towers and how it "functioned"? There were no "elements" in between the floors. The columns (both perimeter and core) were to the sides of the floors and were support by floors trusses that were ultimately supported by gusset plates welded to the columns. So if the upper potion of the towers rotated/twisted/leaned from center and then collapsed due to buckled columns, wouldn't gusset plates and welds be the deciding factor as to what support components were used to determine what should have happened? I mean if two people are holding a 6' long wooden plank at each end and a 250' football player jumped in the middle, would the "hand or arm support" of each person fail thus causing the board to crash to the ground? You would have to consider what the "arms or hands" could support, not the whole body in the example above.

It's not the support capacity of the structure as a whole, but the individual, welded components that failed. Case in point. Here is a photo of the still standing core of WTC2.
southcorestands-1.gif


The photo shows the floors were ripped from the core columns. This is not a "crushed by a block from above" scenario.

This also makes sense when we watch the videos and see whole sections of perimeter columns topple AWAY with no floors attached. This tells me that the debris "pile" that started at the top, fell inside, ripping the floors from their support components attached to the columns. Some perimeter column sections are seen "peeling" away from the building proper.

Why is Heiwa using the vertical support capacity of the columns and structure as a whole when he should be using the support capacity of the gusset plates attached to the insides of the perimeter columns and core columns. For example, the connections on the inside of the columns of floor 97.

I see photos of bent and ripped gusset plates all over the place.
 
My aunt and uncle were in NYC on that day. They saw the planes LIVE in person, crash into those towers.

they also saw the constant broadcast of the impacts that were caught on film and video in the days, weeks, months and even years later, and they , to this day, have not refuted that any of the video footage or photo image, DIFFER from what they saw LIVE and in person.

He is ultimately calling my aunt and uncle liars. and I do not put up with anyone who calls anyone I know personally liars, for them experiencing what a horrific day that was.

And your aunt & uncle were just one of thousands of people who saw the plane impacts.....and yet Heiwa is not at all concerned that none of these thousands of people are speaking up & saying "hey...that's not what I saw"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom