DaveThomasNMSR
Muse
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2010
- Messages
- 877
John's Demo at the Meeting
I finally got around to posting a short video of NMSR VP John Geohegan's Heiwa Challenge structure, which Bjorkman witnessed (and rejected) in person.
John has commented on this experiment:
I finally got around to posting a short video of NMSR VP John Geohegan's Heiwa Challenge structure, which Bjorkman witnessed (and rejected) in person.
John has commented on this experiment:
The November NMSR meeting was a presentation of the Heiwa Challenge by Anders Björkman, a presentation designed to convince us that the World Trade Center had not collapsed in the way we have seen on television, with the “proof” being that it is impossible for a building to collapse from the top down. Björkman offers a reward of 10,000 euros to anyone who can build a model that meets his requirements and collapses from the top down. The problem with his offer is that he specifies that his model be built with each floor supporting all the floors above. Such a model would perform roughly like a stack of wooden blocks. A vertical force pushing down on the upper blocks would result in first crushing the lower blocks because they would be experiencing the greatest forces.
The World Trade Center towers weren’t built in conformance with Björkman’s requirements. Instead, each floor was supported by a “tube within a tube” which transmitted the vertical forces to the ground, bypassing the lower floors. Perhaps an easier way to see the principle is to realize that a heavy person standing high up on a stepladder puts no weight on the lower steps.
I demonstrated the principle with a simple model consisting of four 2.5 pound weights supported by toothpicks and a wooden dowel. It collapsed from the top down, violating his principles, but then Mr. Björkman raised the objection that I hadn’t generated any rubble. The falling weights were meant to simulate the concrete floors of the World Trade Center, each 208 feet square and four inches thick. Thinking of those falling 50 or more stories without generating a lot of rubble would be more of an impossibility.
Apparently my demonstration had no effect on Björkman’s thinking, but I feel his challenge has been shown to be worthless.
