Heiwa Challenge to be Explained at NMSR

I am almost certain that the "3m safety zone" referred to in the Verinage patent does not refer to how far away from the building people must stand to be safe during the induced collapse, but how far away the public must be kept from the equipment for safety (of both the public and the demolition personnel) during the preparation. (Isn't it completely obvious that standing 3m from a Verinage collapse or any collapse of even a one story building would be dangerous, and ridiculously dangerous if the building were a mere three stories?)

For an explosive demolition, even before the first charge is put into place, the public must be excluded from a distance over which a person could likely be injured by shrapnel from an unexpected detonation of explosives being stored or prepared at the scene. Whereas for a Verinage demolition, they must only be excluded from a distance over which a person could be injured by malfunctioning hydraulic compressors and actuators. Hence, 3m instead of 300m, for most of the typical many weeks of preparation. That's a big difference in expense and, at many sites, feasibility.

Once the actuators are in place and any of the hydraulics are made capable of holding pressure, the safety zone for a Verinage demo would be much larger -- but that would be needed only for a few hours or days of final preparation and the actual induced collapse.

I think anyone "skilled in the art" reading the patent would figure this out.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
Yet the cores of the towers were most obviously built to stand on their own, as can be seen both in the blueprints and pictures taken during their destruction. How did you come to imagine otherwise?


When I see large corporations doing something that costs them more, when an obvious alternative exists that would cost them less and have the same results, I conclude that there is a reason for that, and that the reason is NOT "they were too stupid to notice the obvious alternative."

In this case, the obvious alternative that would have cost less, IF the twin tower cores were designed to "stand on their own," would have been to construct the entire height of the cores first, before adding any of the exteriors and floors around them. This would have significantly reduced the time and cost required to hoist the core materials into place, by virtue of a much shorter lateral reach.

In the actual construction, the cores were built only a few stories higher than the surrounding floors at any given time. So, the hypothesis of the cores being able to stand on their own is falsified. Proof by spenduction.

Of course, there is also the builders explaining repeatedly, in both the technical and the popular press, at the time of construction, that the design was based on the necessity of the floors bracing the core. But maybe they were, you know, just saying that for no reason. Spenduction proves otherwise.

Respectfully,
Myriad
 
ergo exactly what would it take for you to say "hmmmm, maybe I could be wrong about this" to yourself? How many people who know what they are talking about telling you that you DON'T would it take?

I realize you don't trust JREF. So, take your questions to your local university physics department and ask them. I really am curious as to how many experts you would need to laugh in your face before you began to suspect that you may not understand the collapses like you think you do.

I blame Newton. Seriously. He phrased that 3rd law so badly that idiots like Heiwa take it to mean that all conflicting forces must be equal at all times.
 
First, good points on spenduction.
Of course, there is also the builders explaining repeatedly, in both the technical and the popular press, at the time of construction, that the design was based on the necessity of the floors bracing the core. But maybe they were, you know, just saying that for no reason. Spenduction proves otherwise.

Respectfully,
Myriad
I know that the truthy people don't get analogies (part of a crippled epistemology I guess), but this one seems simple.
  • Take a cheapie Ikea bookcase.
  • Build it according to directions.
  • Fill it with books.
  • Note the stability.
  • Now, remove the flimsy fiberboard backing.
  • CAREFULLY note the lack of stability.

That's fairly analogous to what the thin floors provided in the WTC design, right?
 
:) Hey, it's your sacred lotus flower, not mine.

Point being that purely gravitational collapses do not produce high speed lateral ejections the way the WTC Towers did

Nor do controlled demolitions.

Special pleading coming in 5, 4, 3, 2,...
 
DaveThomasNMSR - if you got the audio in a file, I'd very much like to listen to it, even if its not edited. Would you be willing to send it to me, give me a PM here!
 
http://img530.imageshack.us/img530/1830/construction1.jpg
Where are your designers claiming the core was not built to be able to stand on it's own?

I'm a structural engineer.

The core was not built to be able to stand on it's own. It needs to be connected to the lateral system, which was the perimeter columns, through a structural diaphragm to be stable.

The bottom most floors (IIRC: bottom seven), the mechanical floors, and the very top of the structural (the roof hat truss) had cross-bracing for various structural purposes: distributing gravity and lateral forces to reduce foundation size, increasing the lateral resistance to wind sway, etc.

Happy?
 
I'd be happy if you could acknowledge the blatantly obvious fact that it's the perimeter that needed all that lateral braising, being the long thin walls it was, and the core that provided them lateral resistance, being the the thick truck of columns and beams that it was.
 
I'd be happy if you could acknowledge the blatantly obvious fact that it's the perimeter that needed all that lateral braising, being the long thin walls it was, and the core that provided them lateral resistance, being the the thick truck of columns and beams that it was.
Why would that make you happy? Are you happiest when your wrong?
 
huh?

I'd be happy if you could acknowledge the blatantly obvious fact that it's the perimeter that needed all that lateral braising, being the long thin walls it was, and the core that provided them lateral resistance, being the the thick truck of columns and beams that it was.

:confused:

You just received a clear, easy-to-understand response from a real structural engineer, and you come back with this?
 
Last edited:
I've listened to the first 10 minutes. Heiwa claims that he had an article published in the ASCE. This is a lie, one that he as tried several times. He published a non-peer reviewed comment to the peer-reviewed article by Bazant. He also claims that the editor, Ross Corotis has resigned due to realizing that Bazant "is a fraud". I'm gonna go out on a limb here and claim that is a lie as well.

The rest of the first part of his presentation seems to be the same argument over and over again, with somewhat different wording.
 
DaveThomasNMSR - if you got the audio in a file, I'd very much like to listen to it, even if its not edited. Would you be willing to send it to me, give me a PM here!

I must say that Heiwa seems to be the Star at the centre of your universe,
 
I've listened to the first 10 minutes. Heiwa claims that he had an article published in the ASCE. This is a lie, one that he as tried several times. He published a non-peer reviewed comment to the peer-reviewed article by Bazant. He also claims that the editor, Ross Corotis has resigned due to realizing that Bazant "is a fraud". I'm gonna go out on a limb here and claim that is a lie as well.

The rest of the first part of his presentation seems to be the same argument over and over again, with somewhat different wording.

Yeah, I was wondering about that too. It sure looks like another case of "The reports of my death resignation are greatly exaggerated."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom