Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

The you should have no problems point to the law that applies. Wire fraud does not because no property changed hands. If he's asked them to send him money then yes, it would apply, but that's not what he did.

http://www.ojp.usdoj.gov/ovc/pubs/ID_theft/idtheftlaws.html

http://frwebgate.access.gpo.gov/cgi...=105_cong_public_laws&docid=f:publ318.105.pdf

It wasn’t until Congress passed the Identity Theft and Assumption Deterrence Act of 1998 that identity theft was officially listed as a federal crime. The act strengthened the criminal laws governing identity theft. Specifically, it amended 18 U.S.C. § 1028 ("Fraud and related activity in connection with identification documents") to make it a federal crime to—

knowingly transfer or use, without lawful authority, a means of identification of another person with the intent to commit, or to aid or abet, any unlawful activity that constitutes a violation of Federal law, or that constitutes a felony under any applicable State or local law. (See http://www.ftc.gov/os/statutes/itada/itadact.htm.)
The Identity Theft and Assumption Deterrence Act accomplished four things:

It made identity theft a separate crime against the individual whose identity was stolen and credit destroyed. Previously, victims had been defined solely by financial loss and often the emphasis was on banks and other financial institutions, rather than on individuals.

It established the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) as the Federal Government’s one central point of contact for reporting instances of identity theft by creating the Identity Theft Data Clearinghouse.

It increased criminal penalties for identity theft and fraud. Specifically, the crime now carries a maximum penalty of 15 years imprisonment and substantial fines.

It closed legal loopholes, which previously had made it a crime to produce or possess false identity documents, but not to steal another personal’s personal identifying information.
 
The you should have no problems point to the law that applies. Wire fraud does not because no property changed hands. If he's asked them to send him money then yes, it would apply, but that's not what he did.


Indeed, I will have no problem. Here is one applicable statute. It is likely that Gleick violated more than one federal criminal statute, but this is probably the most serious. 18 U.S.C. 1343 provides in relevant part:

18 U.S.C.1343 said:
Whoever, having devised or intending to devise any scheme or artifice to defraud, or for obtaining money or property by means of false or fraudulent pretenses, representations, or promises, transmits or causes to be transmitted by means of wire, radio, or television communication in interstate or foreign commerce, any writings, signs, signals, pictures, or sounds for the purpose of executing such scheme or artifice, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 20 years, or both.


Emphasis mine. The interstate commerce language is a jurisdictional hook, and it is satisfied if the offender sent information from a computer in one state to a computer in another state. See also Carpenter v. United States, in which the Supreme Court stated:

Carpenter v. United States said:
Petitioners cannot successfully contend based on Associated Press that a scheme to defraud requires a monetary loss, such as giving the information to a competitor; it is sufficient that the Journal has been deprived of its right to exclusive use of the information, for exclusivity is an important aspect of confidential business information and most private property for that matter.


So you are incorrect that wire fraud requires a monetary loss to the victim or a monetary gain to the offender. I would argue that the documents contain confidential information, which, in light of Carpenter, counts as "property" within the meaning of the wire fraud statute. While few things are indisputable in the law, there is a very strong argument that Gleick's conduct violated 18 U.S.C. 1343.
 
Last edited:
Thanks, Gleick!

I would like to leak on the Heartland Institute.

I don't remember all this angst on their part when the theft of the emails involved in 'Climategate' was revealed.
 
Thanks, Gleick!

I would like to leak on the Heartland Institute.

I don't remember all this angst on their part when the theft of the emails involved in 'Climategate' was revealed.

Wait, are you telling me that political partisans are hypocrites? Get out!
 
ETA: Things look bad for Gleick. Apparently suspicion was already centering on him, based on similarity in writing style between things he has written and the bogus memo:

Unless they can show their work to prove that this alleged "similarity in writing style" is based on something more than voodoo I'm very skeptical. It's possible to do good evidence-based work in that area but an awful lot of it is total rubbish.

As for the difference in style, well, I've read some leaked stuff in the past that's had a notably different tone from the organisation's official stuff, which doesn't paint them in a good light at all. Particularly in politics, where in my experience lying and deception is seen as fair game by many participants on both sides, I'm not in the least surprised if an organisation plays it straight in one set of documents and explicitly advocates sleazy tactics in a different set which was never intended to see the light of day.

It's entirely possible I could be convinced by them if they produced the data that purportedly shows Gleick authored the most incriminating document, but I won't think it likely based only on their say-so.
 
Unless they can show their work to prove that this alleged "similarity in writing style" is based on something more than voodoo I'm very skeptical. It's possible to do good evidence-based work in that area but an awful lot of it is total rubbish.

As for the difference in style, well, I've read some leaked stuff in the past that's had a notably different tone from the organisation's official stuff, which doesn't paint them in a good light at all. Particularly in politics, where in my experience lying and deception is seen as fair game by many participants on both sides, I'm not in the least surprised if an organisation plays it straight in one set of documents and explicitly advocates sleazy tactics in a different set which was never intended to see the light of day.

It's entirely possible I could be convinced by them if they produced the data that purportedly shows Gleick authored the most incriminating document, but I won't think it likely based only on their say-so.

This isn't going to go away, and it is highly likely the author of the memo will either admit authorship or be discovered. I am content to wait until that happens before reaching a conclusion as to the memo's provenance. It is pointless to argue over it when the truth is very likely to come out in due time.
 
Unless they can show their work to prove that this alleged "similarity in writing style" is based on something more than voodoo I'm very skeptical. It's possible to do good evidence-based work in that area but an awful lot of it is total rubbish.

Like some fools claimed they had proven that William Ayres ghost-wrote Obama's book?
 
With their refusal to share the raw data, manipulation of the peer review process, intimidation of journal editors, Mann, Jones, Trenberth, and now Gleick have betrayed that trust.

Seriously, Malcolm, stop lying, and I mean now.

This is exactly the reason I challenged you to read the eight independent investigations exhonerating the accused climate scientists of the things you keep accusing them of.

Now, get on with our deal or, kindly, stfu.
 
Indeed, I will have no problem. Here is one applicable statute. It is likely that Gleick violated more than one federal criminal statute, but this is probably the most serious. 18 U.S.C. 1343 provides in relevant part:

Whoever, having devised or intending to devise any scheme or artifice to defraud, or for obtaining money or property by means of false or fraudulent pretenses, representations, or promises, transmits or causes to be transmitted by means of wire, radio, or television communication in interstate or foreign commerce, any writings, signs, signals, pictures, or sounds for the purpose of executing such scheme or artifice, shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than 20 years, or both.


Own goal since neither money nor property was requested or sent.


Petitioners cannot successfully contend based on Associated Press that a scheme to defraud requires a monetary loss, such as giving the information to a competitor; it is sufficient that the Journal has been deprived of its right to exclusive use of the information, f

Fail. we are not talking about giving business secrets to a competitor so ti doesn't apply.
 
Last edited:
It wasn’t until Congress passed the Identity Theft and Assumption Deterrence Act of 1998 that identity theft was officially listed as a federal crime. The act strengthened the criminal laws governing identity theft. Specifically, it amended 18 U.S.C. § 1028 ("Fraud and related activity in connection with identification documents") to make it a federal crime to—


Another fail. No identity papers were forged or even used.
 
Seriously, Malcolm, stop lying, and I mean now.
This is exactly the reason I challenged you to read the eight independent investigations exhonerating the accused climate scientists of the things you keep accusing them of. Now, get on with our deal or, kindly, stfu.
Read Climate Audit and What's Up With That. According to the leaked emails, Jones and Mann conspired to evade requests for raw data. They steered friendly papers to insiders for review and reviewed papers critical of their position. They leaned on journal editors. Penn State's investigation did not interview any critics. That's like a trial with no prosecution witnesses.
"Lying" and stfu" are not "kindly",
 
Read Climate Audit and What's Up With That. According to the leaked emails, Jones and Mann conspired to evade requests for raw data. They steered friendly papers to insiders for review and reviewed papers critical of their position. They leaned on journal editors. Penn State's investigation did not interview any critics. That's like a trial with no prosecution witnesses.
"Lying" and stfu" are not "kindly",


*facepalm*

Send me eight McIntyre posts and in return, read the eight independent investigations clearing the climate scientists of the things you keep accusing them of. That was our deal. Instead, you just keep accusing the exhonerated scientists. It's beyond pathetic.

You are lying, so I don't care if you think I'm being kind or not.

Now, do we have a deal or not?

ETA: For the record, Climate Audit and What's up his Butt are blogs run by proven liars.
 
Last edited:
Another fail. No identity papers were forged or even used.

(7) knowingly transfers, possesses, or uses, without lawful authority, a means of identification of another person

(B) the means of identification, identification document, false identification document, or document-making implement is transported in the mail in the course of the production, transfer, possession, or use prohibited by this section.
(7) the term “means of identification” means any name or number that may be used, alone or in conjunction with any other information, to identify a specific individual, including any—
(A) name, social security number, date of birth, official State or government issued driver’s license or identification number, alien registration number, government passport number, employer or taxpayer identification number;


Lomiller's attempt to call theft legal is ended.
 
Last edited:
Own goal since neither money nor property was requested or sent.



Fail. we are not talking about giving business secrets to a competitor so ti doesn't apply.

It isn't nearly as cut and dry as you are asserting. Documents that contain confidential information were requested and sent. They were, by Gleick's admission, obtained by fraudulent representations. I concede that Carpenter is not directly on point, and to the extent it bears on the question of whether "property" was obtained, it would be dicta. But it is dicta that would lend support to the argument that property was obtained. The Court clearly held that information can count as property. It would be an extension of Carpenter to apply that principle to some of the information in these documents, but it wouldn't be that much of an extension. In addition, Carpenter makes it clear that the acquisition of property through deceit can satisfy the definition of fraud even if the victim suffers no monetary loss and the offender realizes no monetary gain.

You correctly identify that it would come down to whether the documents, and the information they contain, constitute "property" within the meaning of the statute. You reveal your ignorance of how the law develops in being so dismissive of the possibility that the information obtained here would count as property. Yes, Carpenter dealt with confidential business information. But you do not seem to realize that this is exactly how legal arguments are made. Very rarely do the facts of a case line up perfectly with any particular precedent. But principles announced in earlier cases are frequently applied to somewhat similar but distinguishable fact patterns. Sometimes such arguments are successful, sometimes not. But courts extend the law in such ways all the time. You would be shocked at some of the theories of fraud liability the courts have accepted.

And by the way, donor information arguably is business information when your organization is funded by donations, and these leaks did and do have the potential to cause financial harm to HI.

Finally, Gleick may have also violated the criminal provisions of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, as he used a computer to fraudulently obtain confidential information, which probably counts as "exceeding authorized access." Since every computer connected to the internet is a protected computer, the only question would be whether he used a computer to obtain unauthorized access to information. The statute is incredibly broad (and in my opinion needs to be narrowed, but for now it is what it is). And note that since he solicited and received information from another computer, the fact that he didn't hack HI's computers would not be a defense. I do not mean to argue this point with much confidence, because the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act is so vague and broad it arguably criminalizes lying about your age on Facebook. It is very unclear, and still being litigated, exactly what conduct constitutes a violation. But an ambitious federal prosecutor might try it in this case, and he would not be laughed out of court even if he lost.

Just for the record, I had never even heard of the Heartland Institute before this story, and in fact one of the most interesting facts contained in the documents is just how poorly funded they are, as advocacy orgs go. They are certainly not nearly as well funded as environmentalist organizations, so I don't see why they are considered such a threat. I am angry about what Gleick did because he has set back the cause of climate mitigation by years at least, and those defending his actions as ethical are doing damage to the cause as well. Gleick's actions will hurt climate mitigation proposals among independent and low-information voters - exactly the voters needed if any policy of climate mitigation is to be implemented. Low-information voters will not trust a proven liar, even if the science backs up his position on an issue. Climate science is very complex. Gleick's deceit is very easy to understand. It is obvious which is easier to explain to people who do not follow these issues closely.

Of course, whether Gleick's actions were illegal or not is a separate question, and I have no problem with those arguing, as you are, that he did not break the law. But I would appreciate it if you would cut the snark, because it is unwarranted and unbecoming. I am arguing in good faith, and I have refrained from using personal invective. Also, I know just a bit more about criminal law than you seem to be giving me credit for. I am not sure Gleick will be prosecuted, and if he is I do not know if the government's likely theory of criminal liability would be allowed to proceed. But it is firmly within the realm of possibility that he will be charged with crimes, and if he is charged I think it is more likely than not (but certainly not a slam dunk) that he would not be able to get the charges dismissed with the arguments you are making.
 
Last edited:
I am angry because Gleick has set back the cause of climate mitigation, and those defending his actions as ethical are hurting their own cause among independent and low-information voters - exactly the voters they need if any policy of climate mitigation is to be implemented.

I'm not too sure. It didn't seem to hurt the denialists' cause to openly flaunt the hacked emails. Even Heartland did that.

It also seems to me that Hearland is in a bit of trouble based on the contents of the documents (even disregarding the alleged fake). Their charity status would seem to have to be reconsidered. And I don't know if there's a penalty for being a lobby group without being "licensed" as such.
 
Last edited:
I'm not too sure. It didn't seem to hurt the denialists' cause to openly flaunt the hacked emails. Even Heartland did that.

You may be right. But there was a lot more juicy stuff in those emails (much of it taken out of context, but that fact didn't emerge until later). "Hide the decline" got most of the the attention. Here, all of the documents besides the possibly fake memo are quite mundane. Apart from that document, which is of questionable provenance, there really isn't anything juicy to distract from the manner in which they were obtained. And if the memo turns out to be a fake, it will be many times as bad.
 
You may be right. But there was a lot more juicy stuff in those emails (much of it taken out of context, but that fact didn't emerge until later). "Hide the decline" got most of the the attention. Here, all of the documents besides the possibly fake memo are quite mundane. Apart from that document which is of questionable provenance, there really isn't anything juicy to distract from the manner in which they were obtained. And if the memo turns out to be a fake, it will be many times as bad.

Well, the juicy part is where Heartland is supposed to be a charity organization, when they quite clearly are a lobby group. It's also pretty juicy for those of us arguing against science denial to have solid evidence of oil interest funding. The best part is that it's all in context, too.

I really don't see the alleged fake as that important. It basically just says what the other documents say in a bit more "evil" language.
 
Last edited:
Well, the juicy part is where Heartland is supposed to be a charity organization, when they quite clearly are a lobby group. It's also pretty juicy for those of us arguing against science denial to have solid evidence of oil interest funding. The best part is that it's all in context, too.

Aren't they in the same category of non-profit organization as (for example) Media Matters? They are non-profit, but I was not aware of any pretense to being a charity.
 
Aren't they in the same category of non-profit organization as (for example) Media Matters? They are non-profit, but I was not aware of any pretense to being a charity.

This organization is tax-exempt under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code. It is eligible to receive contributions deductible as charitable donations for federal income tax purposes.

http://www.bbb.org/charity-reviews/chicago/the-heartland-institute-in-chicago-il-11172

To be tax-exempt under section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code, an organization must be organized and operated exclusively for exempt purposes set forth in section 501(c)(3), and none of its earnings may inure to any private shareholder or individual. In addition, it may not be an action organization, i.e., it may not attempt to influence legislation as a substantial part of its activities and it may not participate in any campaign activity for or against political candidates.

Organizations described in section 501(c)(3) are commonly referred to as charitable organizations. Organizations described in section 501(c)(3), other than testing for public safety organizations, are eligible to receive tax-deductible contributions in accordance with Code section 170.

The organization must not be organized or operated for the benefit of private interests, and no part of a section 501(c)(3) organization's net earnings may inure to the benefit of any private shareholder or individual. If the organization engages in an excess benefit transaction with a person having substantial influence over the organization, an excise tax may be imposed on the person and any organization managers agreeing to the transaction.

Section 501(c)(3) organizations are restricted in how much political and legislative (lobbying) activities they may conduct. For a detailed discussion, see Political and Lobbying Activities. For more information about lobbying activities by charities, see the article Lobbying Issues; for more information about political activities of charities, see the FY-2002 CPE topic Election Year Issues.

http://www.irs.gov/charities/charitable/article/0,,id=96099,00.html

(My emphasis)
 
I really don't see the alleged fake as that important. It basically just says what the other documents say in a bit more "evil" language.

If the memo is a forgery, and particularly if Gleick knew that, that is an entirely different level of dishonesty. It is one thing to use tricks to obtain genuine documents, and then to leak them without alteration. The methods may be unethical and perhaps even illegal, but the information in the documents themselves is true.

Think of it this way: Suppose you were a lawyer. Would you hire an expert witness who had been caught fabricating evidence in a prior case? Would you expect a jury to trust that expert after learning on cross examination that he had fabricated evidence in the past? If you were a juror, would you trust that expert?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom