Own goal since neither money nor property was requested or sent.
Fail. we are not talking about giving business secrets to a competitor so ti doesn't apply.
It isn't nearly as cut and dry as you are asserting. Documents that contain confidential information were requested and sent. They were, by Gleick's admission, obtained by fraudulent representations. I concede that
Carpenter is not directly on point, and to the extent it bears on the question of whether "property" was obtained, it would be dicta. But it is dicta that would lend support to the argument that property was obtained. The Court clearly held that information
can count as property. It would be an extension of
Carpenter to apply that principle to some of the information in these documents, but it wouldn't be that much of an extension. In addition,
Carpenter makes it clear that the acquisition of property through deceit can satisfy the definition of fraud even if the victim suffers no monetary loss and the offender realizes no monetary gain.
You correctly identify that it would come down to whether the documents, and the information they contain, constitute "property" within the meaning of the statute. You reveal your ignorance of how the law develops in being so dismissive of the possibility that the information obtained here would count as property. Yes,
Carpenter dealt with confidential
business information. But you do not seem to realize that this is exactly how legal arguments are made. Very rarely do the facts of a case line up perfectly with any particular precedent. But principles announced in earlier cases are frequently applied to somewhat similar but distinguishable fact patterns. Sometimes such arguments are successful, sometimes not. But courts extend the law in such ways all the time. You would be shocked at some of the theories of fraud liability the courts have accepted.
And by the way, donor information arguably
is business information when your organization is funded by donations, and these leaks did and do have the potential to cause financial harm to HI.
Finally, Gleick may have also violated the criminal provisions of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, as he used a computer to fraudulently obtain confidential information, which probably counts as "exceeding authorized access." Since every computer connected to the internet is a protected computer, the only question would be whether he used a computer to obtain unauthorized access to information. The statute is incredibly broad (and in my opinion needs to be narrowed, but for now it is what it is). And note that since he solicited and received information from another computer, the fact that he didn't hack HI's computers would not be a defense. I do not mean to argue this point with much confidence, because the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act is so vague and broad it arguably criminalizes lying about your age on Facebook. It is very unclear, and still being litigated, exactly what conduct constitutes a violation. But an ambitious federal prosecutor might try it in this case, and he would not be laughed out of court even if he lost.
Just for the record, I had never even heard of the Heartland Institute before this story, and in fact one of the most interesting facts contained in the documents is just how poorly funded they are, as advocacy orgs go. They are certainly not nearly as well funded as environmentalist organizations, so I don't see why they are considered such a threat. I am angry about what Gleick did because he has set back the cause of climate mitigation by years at least, and those defending his actions as ethical are doing damage to the cause as well. Gleick's actions will hurt climate mitigation proposals among independent and low-information voters - exactly the voters needed if any policy of climate mitigation is to be implemented. Low-information voters will not trust a proven liar, even if the science backs up his position on an issue. Climate science is very complex. Gleick's deceit is very easy to understand. It is obvious which is easier to explain to people who do not follow these issues closely.
Of course, whether Gleick's actions were illegal or not is a separate question, and I have no problem with those arguing, as you are, that he did not break the law. But I would appreciate it if you would cut the snark, because it is unwarranted and unbecoming. I am arguing in good faith, and I have refrained from using personal invective. Also, I know just a bit more about criminal law than you seem to be giving me credit for. I am not sure Gleick will be prosecuted, and if he is I do not know if the government's likely theory of criminal liability would be allowed to proceed. But it is firmly within the realm of possibility that he will be charged with crimes, and if he is charged I think it is more likely than not (but certainly not a slam dunk) that he would not be able to get the charges dismissed with the arguments you are making.