Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

If the memo is a forgery, and particularly if Gleick knew that, that is an entirely different level of dishonesty. It is one thing to use tricks to obtain genuine documents, and then to leak them without alteration. The methods may be unethical and perhaps even illegal, but the information in the documents themselves is true.

Think of it this way: Suppose you were a lawyer. Would you hire an expert witness who had been caught fabricating evidence in a prior case? Would you expect a jury to trust that expert after learning on cross examination that he had fabricated evidence in the past? If you were a juror, would you trust that expert?

I don't see it as a matter of trust. Heartland has verified that the other documents are real. Nobody has disputed them. They are real.

If I was that lawyer, I would simply point out this fact to the jury.
 

Okay, but I believe Media Matters is also a 501(c)(3), and they are clearly an opinionated organization as well. I am going to see if I can find more 501(c)(3) orgs that have similar missions. I think there are many think tank type organizations with clear ideologies (of all stripes) that are 501(c)(3)'s. They are just careful not to advocate for or against bills or candidates by name. They keep their status by staying within the letter, if not the spirit, of the law. If I am correct in remembering this, then this isn't really news. I will report back in an edit to this post.
 
Okay, but I believe Media Matters is also a 501(c)(3), and they are clearly an opinionated organization as well. I am going to see if I can find more 501(c)(3) orgs that have similar missions. I think there are many think tank type organizations with clear ideologies (of all stripes) that are 501(c)(3)'s. They are just careful not to advocate for or against bills or candidates by name. They keep their status by staying within the letter, if not the spirit, of the law. If I am correct in remembering this, then this isn't really news. I will report back in an edit to this post.

Media Matters is the same type of organization, but they aren't really relevant to this discussion. What is relevant is the Heartland Institute, and their activities as evidenced by the leaked documents.

Heartland Institute quite clearly fails to qualify for a 501(c)(3) as they do attempt to influence legislation, are operated for the benefit of private interests and do engage in substantial lobbying activities.
 
I don't see it as a matter of trust. Heartland has verified that the other documents are real. Nobody has disputed them. They are real.

If I was that lawyer, I would simply point out this fact to the jury.

Putting a fake document into a group of real ones just looks like an additional ruse to convince people the fake one is also real. Especially when only the fake one is damaging. I could not trust someone who would do that. It would not make me doubt that the other documents in this set are genuine, but it would absolutely make me far more skeptical the next time the same person purports to have a "smoking gun" document. So skeptical that I would not believe it at all until I had independent verification of the contents of the document.
 
Media Matters is the same type of organization, but they aren't really relevant to this discussion. What is relevant is the Heartland Institute, and their activities as evidenced by the leaked documents.

Heartland Institute quite clearly fails to qualify for a 501(c)(3) as they do attempt to influence legislation, are operated for the benefit of private interests and do engage in substantial lobbying activities.

I didn't mean to use MM as a tu quoque or anything. I was just pointing out that many organizations that are active in public policy debates are classified as 501(c)(3)s. There is a very fine line between allowable and forbidden activities, and it is a bit blurry sometimes.
 
Desmogblog has conducted their own evaluation of the allegedly fake document and come to the conclusion that it is real:

http://www.desmogblog.com/evaluation-shows-faked-heartland-climate-strategy-memo-authentic

Sure, they have a vested interest in seeing the document as real, but their evaluation is quite on the mark.

They try to paper over this error:
We will also pursue additional support from the Charles G. Koch Foundation. They returned as a Heartland donor in 2011 with a contribution of $200,000. We expect to push up their level of support in 2012 and gain access to their network of philanthropists, if our focus continues to align with their interests.
They note that in fact the Koch Foundation gave only $25,000, although $200,000 is anticipated in 2012. But would a senior staffer at Heartland have been likely to have made that mistake?

That most of the "facts" in the memo are backed up by the other documents is hardly surprising if the memo is a forgery; whoever did it started from the other documents and concocted the memo based on the information in them. He made a few mistakes, and of course he loaded up the wording to make it appear more sinister. But it's a comical effort as I discussed up above.
 
Putting a fake document into a group of real ones just looks like an additional ruse to convince people the fake one is also real. Especially when only the fake one is damaging.

But it's simply not true that only the allegedly fake document is damaging. There is no information in the fake document that isn't also present in one of the verified ones.

I personally don't believe the document is fake, in any case.

I could not trust someone who would do that. It would not make me doubt that the other documents in this set are genuine, but it would absolutely make me far more skeptical the next time the same person purports to have a "smoking gun" document. So skeptical that I would not believe it at all until I had independent verification of the contents of the document.

But that's pretty irrelevant to this discussion. We have a treasure trove of verified documents outlining Heartland's plans and benefactors. What happens to the person behind the leak is frankly not that interesting to anyone but him and his peers.

I understand Gleick's actions. I don't condone what he did, but I do understand it. Climate science is under heavy attack by science deniers, including the Heartland Institute. I hope for all our sake that Gleick can recover from the damage this will do to his career. This world is a better place if Gleick can continue to produce science and screw up the plans of science deniers.
 
They try to paper over this error:

They note that in fact the Koch Foundation gave only $25,000, although $200,000 is anticipated in 2012. But would a senior staffer at Heartland have been likely to have made that mistake?

That most of the "facts" in the memo are backed up by the other documents is hardly surprising if the memo is a forgery; whoever did it started from the other documents and concocted the memo based on the information in them. He made a few mistakes, and of course he loaded up the wording to make it appear more sinister. But it's a comical effort as I discussed up above.

I think it's equally likely that a senior staffer would make that error as a scientist.

I do see your point, but I don't think there's enough reason to say the document is fake. I certainly won't take Heartland's word for it.
 
If he'd presented a fake ID like a drivers license or passport then that may be the case, but from what we know Heartland simply didn't bother to try and prove the identity of they person they sent the documents too.

It doesn't matter; all that needs to be true is that they believed they were sending them to the real Mr X. A person who impersonates a police officer for instance doesn't get out of jail free if the victims neglected to call the police department and verify his identity.
 
But it's simply not true that only the allegedly fake document is damaging. There is no information in the fake document that isn't also present in one of the verified ones.

I personally don't believe the document is fake, in any case.



But that's pretty irrelevant to this discussion. We have a treasure trove of verified documents outlining Heartland's plans and benefactors. What happens to the person behind the leak is frankly not that interesting to anyone but him and his peers.

I understand Gleick's actions. I don't condone what he did, but I do understand it. Climate science is under heavy attack by science deniers, including the Heartland Institute. I hope for all our sake that Gleick can recover from the damage this will do to his career. This world is a better place if Gleick can continue to produce science and screw up the plans of science deniers.

I think there are aspects of the memo that cast doubt on its authenticity, though I am not by any means convinced it is fake. Whoever wrote that memo made a few very basic mistakes about the contents of the other documents, as Brainster pointed out - mistakes that would not likely be made by an HI staffer, and that would not likely escape the notice of whoever looked the memo over before it went to the board.

As to Gleick's actions, which I agree were born of understandable frustration, I think Megan McArdle said it well:

Megan McArdle said:
When skeptics complain that global warming activists are apparently willing to go to any lengths–including lying–to advance their worldview, I’d say one of the movement’s top priorities should be not proving them right.
 
Because the document in question is so different from the rest of the set, the burden of proof is actually on the leaker to prove it is genuine at this point.

That's impossible, unless the someone from the Heartland Institute admits that it's real.

I would think it's equally impossible to prove it's a fake. Basically, in the case of that single document, it comes down to who you trust. I trust Glieck over the Heartland Institute.
 
I think there are aspects of the memo that cast doubt on its authenticity, though I am not by any means convinced it is fake. Whoever wrote that memo made a few very basic mistakes about the contents of the other documents, as Brainster pointed out - mistakes that would not likely be made by an HI staffer, and that would not likely escape the notice of whoever looked the memo over before it went to the board.

Like I said above, I think it's equally likely that a HI staffer made that error as that a scientist did. I also trust Glieck over HI.

As to Gleick's actions, which I agree were born of understandable frustration, I think Megan McArdle said it well:

True, but when you're in a boxing match and your opponent fights with razor wire on his gloves, you might be forgiven for equipping yourself likewise.
 
Last edited:
That's impossible, unless the someone from the Heartland Institute admits that it's real.

I would think it's equally impossible to prove it's a fake. Basically, in the case of that single document, it comes down to who you trust. I trust Glieck over the Heartland Institute.

That's not true at all. It would be relatively easy to prove that Glieck received the questioned document at the same time in the same email from the organization as the rest of them.

ETA: It's curious that you say you trust Gliek over HI when the former has basically confessed to lying and the worst thing the latter has been shown to have done so far is hold a political position contrary to yours. AFAIK, HI hasn't pretended to be anything other than anti-global-warming.
 
Last edited:
That's impossible, unless the someone from the Heartland Institute admits that it's real.

I would think it's equally impossible to prove it's a fake. Basically, in the case of that single document, it comes down to who you trust. I trust Glieck over the Heartland Institute.

Actually, I think it is likely that the author will admit authorship eventually. I expect that civil and possibly criminal proceedings will arise out of this incident, and whoever wrote the memo would be unlikely to lie about it either under oath at a deposition or in an interview with federal investigators.
 
True, but when you're in a boxing match and your opponent fights with razor wire on his gloves, you might be forgiven for equipping yourself likewise.

I still don't think the evidence available makes it likely that the material in question was forged, but we shouldn't condone it if it does turn out to be forged. A commitment to evidence-based discourse and busting liars means busting liars on both sides of the debate. If someone on the right side (right in terms of the clearly established factual truth) lies to support our side we ought to bust them as hard as we bust a climate change denier. Or harder.
 
That's not true at all. It would be relatively easy to prove that Glieck received the questioned document at the same time in the same email from the organization as the rest of them.

No, it's not easy at all given that he says he received the strategy document in a separate email from an anonymous source, and that he got the documents from HI in order to verify the information in the first document.
 
I still don't think the evidence available makes it likely that the material in question was forged, but we shouldn't condone it if it does turn out to be forged. A commitment to evidence-based discourse and busting liars means busting liars on both sides of the debate. If someone on the right side (right in terms of the clearly established factual truth) lies to support our side we ought to bust them as hard as we bust a climate change denier. Or harder.

Oh, I agree completely. I was refering to Gliecks actions over all, not to him forging the document.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom