Malcolm Kirkpatrick
Banned
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2006
- Messages
- 4,046
1. "Who are actively publishing on climate science" is an irrelevant restriction. If one person with relevant expertise (e.g., a plant physiologist who can demonstrate that trees of some species don't respond the way dendroclimatologists assume to make their proxies work) punctures the theory, then the theory needs a patch, even if most plant physiologists take no interest in climate history and those who do work with other species or methods of reconstruction (e.g., pollen ratios in lake sediments).This is weak. Show that a majority of experts in each of these individual subjects who are actively publishing material related to climate science do not agree with the consensus1. Wikipedia lists institutions from several fields and their statements on climate change - can you guess which way they align themselves? We already know that 97% of climate scientists believe AGW to be real and that on average, climate scientists believing AGW to be true are better qualified than those who believe it to be false2. On top of that, there isn't a single major scientific institution in the world that holds a stance against AGW being real.
You've also failed to show evidence of a conspiracy by governments to falsify evidence or mislead the public3. Here is an article by Monbiot showing examples of the fossil fuel industry seeking to mislead the public. On top of that, you've failed to explain why governments that would clearly benefit from climate change not being true (such as the australian government) haven't managed to convince their scientists to argue against it4.
2. "We already know that climate scientists..." A self-selected sample. If you have relevant expertise but apply it elsewhere, the expertise still applies.
3. This is not, in legal speak, "an element of the offense".
4. Interest group politics determines the behavior of politicians. Academics are articulate, well-paid, and have abundant free time. Government funding varies with the urgency of the topic. Academics have a strong financial stake in painting the subject of their research as urgent.
You're clutching at straws. /QUOTE]