Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

This is weak. Show that a majority of experts in each of these individual subjects who are actively publishing material related to climate science do not agree with the consensus1. Wikipedia lists institutions from several fields and their statements on climate change - can you guess which way they align themselves? We already know that 97% of climate scientists believe AGW to be real and that on average, climate scientists believing AGW to be true are better qualified than those who believe it to be false2. On top of that, there isn't a single major scientific institution in the world that holds a stance against AGW being real.

You've also failed to show evidence of a conspiracy by governments to falsify evidence or mislead the public3. Here is an article by Monbiot showing examples of the fossil fuel industry seeking to mislead the public. On top of that, you've failed to explain why governments that would clearly benefit from climate change not being true (such as the australian government) haven't managed to convince their scientists to argue against it4.
1. "Who are actively publishing on climate science" is an irrelevant restriction. If one person with relevant expertise (e.g., a plant physiologist who can demonstrate that trees of some species don't respond the way dendroclimatologists assume to make their proxies work) punctures the theory, then the theory needs a patch, even if most plant physiologists take no interest in climate history and those who do work with other species or methods of reconstruction (e.g., pollen ratios in lake sediments).
2. "We already know that climate scientists..." A self-selected sample. If you have relevant expertise but apply it elsewhere, the expertise still applies.
3. This is not, in legal speak, "an element of the offense".
4. Interest group politics determines the behavior of politicians. Academics are articulate, well-paid, and have abundant free time. Government funding varies with the urgency of the topic. Academics have a strong financial stake in painting the subject of their research as urgent.

You're clutching at straws. /QUOTE]
 
1. "Who are actively publishing on climate science" is an irrelevant restriction. If one person with relevant expertise (e.g., a plant physiologist who can demonstrate that trees of some species don't respond the way dendroclimatologists assume to make their proxies work) punctures the theory, then the theory needs a patch, even if most plant physiologists take no interest in climate history and those who do work with other species or methods of reconstruction (e.g., pollen ratios in lake sediments).

You haven't shown that there is a group of the above who have demonstrated that climate models are wrong.

2. "We already know that climate scientists..." A self-selected sample. If you have relevant expertise but apply it elsewhere, the expertise still applies.

The method of selection is "people who are actively publishing research in the field of climate science". That's the best possible selection criteria.

3. This is not, in legal speak, "an element of the offense".

I don't know what that means, and I don't care. Every major government in the developed world and every major scientific institution in the world believes AGW to be real, and so it is perfectly reasonable to ask objectors to show evidence of a conspiracy.

4. Interest group politics determines the behavior of politicians. Academics are articulate, well-paid, and have abundant free time. Government funding varies with the urgency of the topic. Academics have a strong financial stake in painting the subject of their research as urgent.

Academics stand to gain hugely from book and tv deals as well as apparently good money from fossil fuel industries if they can expose a worldwide scientific conspiracy. But they can't, because the evidence just doesn't side with them.

Aligning myself with basically everyone is not "clutching at straws". Aligning yourself with a small minority of objectors with little credibility and little involvement in the field, many of whom are actively funded by corporations with an obvious stake in objection to the consensus is clutching at straws.
 
Many of the people who oppose the "AGW is real and urgent" position are highly credentialed in relevant fields. I suggest you start here. Also here.

This is crappola of a high order eminating from doofuses who are not climate scientists.

How very apropos in a Heartland thread.
Pardon me Ben, for helping to derail the thread by taking this asinine bait. I should have referred Malcolm here.
 
1. "Who are actively publishing on climate science" is an irrelevant restriction. If one person with relevant expertise (e.g., a plant physiologist who can demonstrate that trees of some species don't respond the way dendroclimatologists assume

The way said plant physiologist would demonstrate this would be to write a detailed paper supporting his ideas, and then publish this paper. This means anyone who meets your criteria is already part of that actively publishing scientist group, 97% of whom say AGW is happening.

The people who don’t get in this group are the ones who post on the internet about what hot shot plant experts they are but can’t seem to put together a paper worth publishing, so they just keep posting their opinions on blogs and internet forums to try and convince the gullible that their “science” is worth listening too.
 
Okay, it's one thing to tell someone your name is Freddy Newendyke or whatever but you're telling me it's perfectly acceptable and LEGAL for me to call up the place you work and tell them I'm you and have them send me documents? It's totally cool to just call Berkshire Hathaway tell them it's Warren on the line and send over the notes from that meeting earlier and the cops won't do ****-all?
 
It's totally cool to just call Berkshire Hathaway tell them it's Warren on the line and send over the notes from that meeting earlier and the cops won't do ****-all?

If it’s not government documents you are asking for, then the police wouldn’t do a thing. You could also get yourself in trouble trying to get information that would allow access to their bank accounts because that involves properly which you presumably intend to steal.

Of course Berkshire Hathaway is a little more competent that Heartland and would certainly ask for some proof you are who you say you are before handing over anything.
 
The way said plant physiologist would demonstrate this would be to write a detailed paper supporting his ideas, and then publish this paper. This means anyone who meets your criteria is already part of that actively publishing scientist group, 97% of whom say AGW is happening.
This "97%" I doubt, and it's not really important. Most scientists are not climate scienists. Probably they could give the issue intelligent consideration if they had the time, but even experts in relevant disciplines have to trust other experts. Paleobotanists have to trust plant physiologists. Meteorologists have to trust solar physicists. Statisticians and modelers have to trust experimentalists for the accuracy of the data. With their refusal to share the raw data, manipulation of the peer review process, intimidation of journal editors, Mann, Jones, Trenberth, and now Gleick have betrayed that trust.
 
Okay, it's one thing to tell someone your name is Freddy Newendyke or whatever but you're telling me it's perfectly acceptable and LEGAL for me to call up the place you work and tell them I'm you and have them send me documents? It's totally cool to just call Berkshire Hathaway tell them it's Warren on the line and send over the notes from that meeting earlier and the cops won't do ****-all?

Yes, identity theft is legal in the warped brains of sniveling cowards of the left, when the purpose is the Greater Goodiness of Gaia, and the aim is to eviserate the Black Hearts of the Evil Oil Barons.
 
This "97%" I doubt, and it's not really important. Most scientists are not climate scienists.

If they were publishing papers on using tree rings to study climate history., as you speculated then yes they would be climate scientists for the purpose of this study. Nearly everyone publishing climate related work in credible journals agrees that AGW is happening. Your "credible scientist making a case against the consensus" simply doesn't exist.
 
Yes; I think that by using another real person's name to gain access to private communications and confidential data, this person can be accused of identity theft at best.

The faked document does not help matters either.

On the other hand, the real documents are now public knowledge and the information in them is not protected from public scrutiny.
 
Okay, it's one thing to tell someone your name is Freddy Newendyke or whatever but you're telling me it's perfectly acceptable and LEGAL for me to call up the place you work and tell them I'm you and have them send me documents? It's totally cool to just call Berkshire Hathaway tell them it's Warren on the line and send over the notes from that meeting earlier and the cops won't do ****-all?

Or, say you're Lomiller's boss and you call up his doctor pretending to be Lomiller, and request complete copies of his medical records. Completely legal, apparently. Of course, a former federal prosecutor and current professor of law disagrees, but he's probably a global warming denier.
 
Yes; I think that by using another real person's name to gain access to private communications and confidential data, this person can be accused of identity theft at best.

The faked document does not help matters either.

On the other hand, the real documents are now public knowledge and the information in them is not protected from public scrutiny.

I still see no basis for thinking it is faked.
 
this person can be accused of identity theft at best.

If he'd presented a fake ID like a drivers license or passport then that may be the case, but from what we know Heartland simply didn't bother to try and prove the identity of they person they sent the documents too.
 
Remember this part of his confession?

IANAL, but it is clear that he did not simply "convince" them to send him the stuff; more like he simply "conned" them.

Apparently he impersonated an HI board member in order to obtain confidential documents under false pretenses. What he has admitted is sufficient for a wire fraud conviction (a felony). It may also be a felony violation of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act, but that statute is so impossibly vague it's difficult to say. Gleick has retained a lawyer. Smart move, as he'll need one.

I think the evidence indicates that the memo is likely fake, but I will withhold forming a definite opinion on that (and on the identity of the author) until this shakes out a bit more. I imagine there will be civil litigation even if federal prosecutors decline to prosecute, and it is highly likely that the investigation and/or discovery will reveal not only whether the memo is genuine, but also the identity of the author.
 
Last edited:
With their refusal to share the raw data, manipulation of the peer review process, intimidation of journal editors, Mann, Jones, Trenberth, and now Gleick have betrayed that trust.
Cow cookies. They told some schmendrick that they did not want to release some papers they were still working on.

McIntyre has an entirely too inflated sense of his own stature in the scientific community.

His kind are a dime a dozen in the twoofer community.
 
If he'd presented a fake ID like a drivers license or passport then that may be the case, but from what we know Heartland simply didn't bother to try and prove the identity of they person they sent the documents too.

If he sent an email in which he lied about his identity in order to obtain property to which he is not entitled (and confidential information counts), then he committed wire fraud. The fact that they believed him without checking is irrelevant. Heartland may have been stupid not to check into his request more thoroughly, but stealing is stealing even if the victim leaves his front door open.
 
Last edited:
I still see no basis for thinking it is faked.

There are at least four passages that are problematic:

1. The mention of Koch:
We will also pursue additional support from the Charles G. Koch Foundation. They returned as a Heartland donor in 2011 with a contribution of $200,000.

Koch's donation was specifically earmarked for Heartland's heath care work, not for global warming and thus the inclusion here seems intended to throw in the current liberal bogeyman.

2. The education passage:
His effort will focus on providing curriculum that shows that the topic of climate change is controversial and uncertain–two key points that are effective at dissuading teachers from teaching science.

Even if you believe that the Heartland Institute believes in AGW but is simply maintaining a skeptical stance towards the issue for the benefit of their donors, does it really make sense that they would admit it by saying that their objective is to dissuade teachers from teaching science? Wouldn't it be more likely that they would phrase it something like "dissuading teachers from teaching unsettled science"?

This part is really quite comical; it's almost as if some feminist came up with a document from abortion opponents stating "Our efforts to control women's bodies continues...."

3. More loaded language:
At present we sponsor the NIPCC to undermine the official United Nation’s IPCC reports....
Again, wouldn't they be more likely to say "we sponsor the NIPCC to counter the so-called official...."

4. And again, discussing Forbes Magazine, which apparently recently published a piece by Gleick:
This influential audience has usually been reliably anti-climate and it is important to keep opposing voices out.
Anti-climate? It's laughable.
 
Last edited:
Apparently he impersonated an HI board member in order to obtain confidential documents under false pretenses. What he has admitted is sufficient for a wire fraud conviction (a felony).


The you should have no problems point to the law that applies. Wire fraud does not because no property changed hands. If he's asked them to send him money then yes, it would apply, but that's not what he did.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom