Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

No, it's not easy at all given that he says he received the strategy document in a separate email from an anonymous source, and that he got the documents from HI in order to verify the information in the first document.

Then there literally is zero provenance; the document itself becomes a claim that must be proven. The anonymous source will be able to verify it's authenticity by providing an original or a source from within HI.
 
Then there literally is zero provenance; the document itself becomes a claim that must be proven.

Like I said, a matter of trust. I trust Glieck more than HI for one, and I think HI would gain from claiming the document was a fake even if it was real.

The anonymous source will be able to verify it's authenticity by providing an original or a source from within HI.

Given that the anonymous source might well be a HI staffer, or someone connected with such, I think that's unlikely to happen.
 
Oh, I agree completely. I was refering to Gliecks actions over all, not to him forging the document.

Oh, agreed. If it turns out he did break some law or other in using subterfuge to verify his story, then good on him and I hope the jury sees it that way too. It's a story of corruption, plutocracy and dishonesty that needs to be told, and I'd hope that if I was put in a position where I could break the law to the same (hypothetical) degree to bust equally deserving scumbags, I'd have the courage to do it and face the consequences.

As long as he bent or broke the law to obtain the needed proof, as opposed to making stuff up, I'm with you.
 
Given that the anonymous source might well be a HI staffer, or someone connected with such, I think that's unlikely to happen.

I sympathize; but that's not HI's problem. I could "anonymously leak" a document from HI revealing that it is their secret intention to replace all American science classes with bible classes; you would believe it just because you're predisposed to believe something bad about HI; but an unvetted document is an unvetted document, ruthers aside.
 
Like I said above, I think it's equally likely that a HI staffer made that error as that a scientist did.

Equally likely? Their actual revenues in 2011 were $4.6 million. If Koch had actually donated $200K in 2011 that would have been about 4.3% of their total. They actually donated about 0.5%. And as I noted above, Koch's donation was earmarked to health care efforts, not to global warming. Another curious mistake for an HI staffer to make.

I also trust Glieck over HI.

Confirmation bias afflicts us all. Gleick is already known to have lied in this incident, passing himself off as a board member. Falsus in unum, falsus in omnibus is a legal maxim for a good reason.
 
Last edited:
...Climate science is under heavy attack by science deniers, including the Heartland Institute. I hope for all our sake that Gleick can recover from the damage this will do to his career. This world is a better place if Gleick can continue to produce science and screw up the plans of science deniers.
When you call people "science deniers", do you mean that they dispute your conclusions or that they disagree with the experimental method generally? Do you call Freeman Dyson, Lubos Motl, Richard Lindzen, Allen Simmons and Doug Hoffman, and Steve McIntyre "science deniers"?

Why call Heartland "science deniers"? They support free market solutions to social problems. I have long been a fan of the Heartland Institute, for their support of school choice. Markets institutionalize an experimental approach. "What works?" is an emprical question which an experiment (in resource allocation and commodity production questions, a competitive market) will answer more accurately than will a State-monopoly enterprise. Why call Heartland "science deniers"?

Gleick is seriously damaged goods, now that he has demonstrated a willingness to deceive. As Megan McArdle observed, once you convince people that you will lie for your cause, you will have a hard time convincing them of anything else. I suppose he could sell his expertise as a hydrologist, but his career as an advocate is over. Unless he wants to change sides like Eldridge Cleaver or Alexander Barmine. Then he can go on the road like Marjoe Gortner and testify to the allure of the Green Goddess and how she'l lead men astray with delusions of messianic importance.
 
When you call people "science deniers", do you mean that they dispute your conclusions or that they disagree with the experimental method generally? Do you call Freeman Dyson, Lubos Motl, Richard Lindzen, Allen Simmons and Doug Hoffman, and Steve McIntyre "science deniers"?/QUOTE]Don't know about the others, but that one is mostly a professional pain in the ass.

Why call Heartland "science deniers"? [HILITES]They support free market solutions to social problems.[/HILITE]
Superstitious twits, at best.

I have long been a fan of the Heartland Institute, for their support of school choice. Markets institutionalize an experimental approach. "What works?" is an emprical question which an experiment (in resource allocation and commodity production questions, a competitive market) will answer more accurately than will a State-monopoly enterprise.
The free market was not getting kids educated in a way that enhanced upward ecconomic mobility. That's why we have public schools.

Why call Heartland "science deniers"?
Quite right. "Intellectual prostitutes" is more appropriate.

Gleick is seriously damaged goods, now that he has demonstrated a willingness to deceive. As Megan McArdle observed, once you convince people that you will lie for your cause, you will have a hard time convincing them of anything else. I suppose he could sell his expertise as a hydrologist, but his career as an advocate is over. Unless he wants to change sides like Eldridge Cleaver or Alexander Barmine. Then he can go on the road like Marjoe Gortner and testify to the allure of the Green Goddess and how she'l lead men astray with delusions of messianic importance.
Acting with blatant criminal iuntent to ruin the lives of innocent people, knowing that he was selling ******** doesn't seem to have harmed a certain coniving, lying, blustering right-wing internet sludge monster. Gleick actually looks like a more rational person and did not try to inflict pain and suffering on people for the fun of it.
 
Last edited:
That's not true at all. It would be relatively easy to prove that Glieck received the questioned document at the same time in the same email from the organization as the rest of them.

ETA: It's curious that you say you trust Gliek over HI when the former has basically confessed to lying and the worst thing the latter has been shown to have done so far is hold a political position contrary to yours. AFAIK, HI hasn't pretended to be anything other than anti-global-warming.

I see the whole issue as the story of a person who was naively suckered into the environmental Alarmist hysteria on global warming and broke the law for the "greater good". Even in his apology although he shows remorse over breaking the law, he doesn't see the causative factors, the propaganda and it's effects.

Should he get a stiff sentence? Hard to see where that would do anyone any good. Should it be taken to court? I've got mixed feelings there, how would society benefit or the wronged party be righted? One interesting outcome would be not jail but a fine. Gliek ordered to pay 20,000 to his arch enemy.

That'd be pretty funny.
 
Desmogblog has conducted their own evaluation of the allegedly fake document and come to the conclusion that it is real:

http://www.desmogblog.com/evaluation-shows-faked-heartland-climate-strategy-memo-authentic

Sure, they have a vested interest in seeing the document as real, but their evaluation is quite on the mark.

The only reason to conclude it is a fake is the insistence of those it criminalizes; namely Heartland. I called my senators demanding an audit of Heartland, and I suggest everybody here who cares about tax justice do the same.

No way a group of 1%-ers should be able to write off millions given to a professional for-profit lobby organization masquerading as a charity.

No matter what you think of how these documents came out, no matter what you think the top tax rate ought to be, if they are in violation and you don't support legal sanctions, you are a hypocrite.
 
Then there literally is zero provenance; the document itself becomes a claim that must be proven. The anonymous source will be able to verify it's authenticity by providing an original or a source from within HI.

If it is not real, there will be legal action to prove it is forged.

If no legal action happens, it can be presumed to be real.
 
Do you call Freeman Dyson,

Dyson has no climate science background, his research is mostly in quantum mechanics. On top of that, he doesn't actually deny that we are causing global warming. Here is an article debunking one of his more famous articles: http://init.planet3.org/2007/08/dyson-exegesis.html

Lubos Motl

Motl rehashes that same old debunked crap like "it's the sun". Here are some of his choicier quotes being debunked: http://www.skepticalscience.com/skeptic_Lubos_Motl.htm

Richard Lindzen

More respectable than most, but also believes some silly science. Start here: http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2006/02/richard-lindzens-hol-testimony/

Allen Simmons
Appears to be mianly a computer programmer and blogger. See no evidence of any relevant peer-reviewed research.

Doug Hoffman

Basically the same. Why should I care what this guy thinks?

Steve McIntyre

Not a scientist. Tried to be one, failed (paper rejected by Nature). http://www.realclimate.org/index.ph...-regarding-the-mann-et-al-1998reconstruction/

...so, yes, you did come up with a list of people i'd consider "science deniers". Or just irrelevent.
 
Dyson has no climate science background, his research is mostly in quantum mechanics. On top of that, he doesn't actually deny that we are causing global warming. Here is an article debunking one of his more famous articles: http://init.planet3.org/2007/08/dyson-exegesis.html



Motl rehashes that same old debunked crap like "it's the sun". Here are some of his choicier quotes being debunked: http://www.skepticalscience.com/skeptic_Lubos_Motl.htm

.
Do you seriously think that the paid propagandist, John Cook, would even understand a third of the background theory issues behind Motl's arguments? Oh, and by the way. Most of what you quoted there by Cook was criticisms of Motl's brief summary of published work that wasn't in line with what Cook was paid to promote. So it's not even what you said it was, was it?
 
Do you seriously think that the paid propagandist, John Cook, would even understand a third of the background theory issues behind Motl's arguments? Oh, and by the way. Most of what you quoted there by Cook was criticisms of Motl's brief summary of published work that wasn't in line with what Cook was paid to promote. So it's not even what you said it was, was it?

What I posted was a list of examples of Motl being wrong. I'm not particularly interested in debating this with you though; as science denying goes, your previous post where you hand-waved away the opinions of every major scientific establishment in the world is probably the best example i've ever seen on this forum.
 
When you call people "science deniers", do you mean that they dispute your conclusions or that they disagree with the experimental method generally? Do you call Freeman Dyson, Lubos Motl, Richard Lindzen, Allen Simmons and Doug Hoffman, and Steve McIntyre "science deniers"?

Why call Heartland "science deniers"? They support free market solutions to social problems. I have long been a fan of the Heartland Institute, for their support of school choice. Markets institutionalize an experimental approach. "What works?" is an emprical question which an experiment (in resource allocation and commodity production questions, a competitive market) will answer more accurately than will a State-monopoly enterprise. Why call Heartland "science deniers"?

Gleick is seriously damaged goods, now that he has demonstrated a willingness to deceive. As Megan McArdle observed, once you convince people that you will lie for your cause, you will have a hard time convincing them of anything else. I suppose he could sell his expertise as a hydrologist, but his career as an advocate is over. Unless he wants to change sides like Eldridge Cleaver or Alexander Barmine. Then he can go on the road like Marjoe Gortner and testify to the allure of the Green Goddess and how she'l lead men astray with delusions of messianic importance.

Do we have a deal or not? Eight McIntyre posts for eight independent investigations? I'm not letting this go.

Oh, and the people on your list are science deniers.
 
The only reason to conclude it is a fake is the insistence of those it criminalizes; namely Heartland.

This is my feeling on the matter as well. It is likely to become a partisan matter. If you're in bed with the science deniers, you'll conclude it's fake. If you accept the scientific consensus, you won't conclude it's fake.
 
Dyson has no climate science background...
Motl rehashes that same old debunked...
(Lindzen): More respectable than most...
(Simmons): Appears to be mianly a computer programmer and blogger. See no evidence of any relevant peer-reviewed research.
(Hoffman): Basically the same...
(McIntyre): Not a scientist. Tried to be one, failed (paper rejected by Nature).
The question was wherther the term "anti-science" describes these people, not whether they publish in the same journals that publish Briffa, Hansen, Jones, Mann, and Trenberth. Further...
Wikipedia said:
...In October 2003, a paper by Stephen McIntyre and Ross McKitrick on "Corrections to the Mann et al. (1998) Proxy Data Base and Northern Hemisphere Average Temperature Series" was published in Energy & Environment (MM03)...
And do you really contend that computer modeling is irrelevant to climate science? If that's the case, what is left beyond raw instrument data, proxy data, and lab experiments with CO2, sun lamps and pieces of rock? Theory without data is theology. Data without theory is baby talk ("cow", "horsie"). Theory and data meet in models.
 
The only reason to conclude it is a fake is the insistence of those it criminalizes; namely Heartland.

No; again, something like this isn't "true until proven fake". One more person who has inexplicably forgotten where the burden of proof lies.

As someone has before linked, there's already a few things about the document that cast its authenticity into doubt. For me, the clincher is the "dissuade them from teaching science" statement. Use some critical thinking here for a moment: that anti-global-warming folks are by definition "anti-science" is solely a rhetorical declaration of the pro-global-warming side. Even a cursory review of anti-global warming literature and rhetoric reveals that the linchpin of their argument is that science actually supports their position rather than the reality of global warming. They would not have a goal of "dissuading teachers from teaching science"; they would have a goal of convincing teachers that anti-global-warming is better science so they'll teach that instead. It sounds very much to me like the sort of phrase a pro-global warming advocate might use to describe the intentions of a group like Heartland.
 
It sounds very much to me like the sort of phrase a pro-global warming advocate might use to describe the intentions of a group like Heartland.

It sounds very much like a phrase no pro-global warming advocate would put into a forged document because it would be stupid to make a forgery so transparent.
 
The question was wherther the term "anti-science" describes these people, not whether they publish in the same journals that publish Briffa, Hansen, Jones, Mann, and Trenberth. Further...And do you really contend that computer modeling is irrelevant to climate science? If that's the case, what is left beyond raw instrument data, proxy data, and lab experiments with CO2, sun lamps and pieces of rock? Theory without data is theology. Data without theory is baby talk ("cow", "horsie"). Theory and data meet in models.

The term "anti-science" describes those people adequately when regards to climate science. They reject good science in favor of conjecture and doubt-mongering. They have no science of their own that can stand up to scrutiny, but they insist on spouting off outside their own area of expertise.
 
It sounds very much like a phrase no pro-global warming advocate would put into a forged document because it would be stupid to make a forgery so transparent.

Pretty much. I don't think Heartland is under any illusions as to wether science supports their position or not. They know it doesn't, just like they knew it didn't when they advocated that smoking wasn't harmful. Science and reason is their primary enemy, so it wouldn't surprise me at all if they talked internally about dissuading teachers from teaching it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom