Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

Interesting:...
Said Gleick’s lawyer John Keker, “Heartland no doubt will seek to exploit Dr. Gleick’s admitted lapse in judgement in order to further its agenda in the ongoing debate about climate change, but if it wants to pursue this matter legally, it will learn that our legal system provides for a level playing field.” Keker added, “Dr. Gleick looks forward to using discovery to understand more about the veracity of the documents, lay bare the implications of Heartland’s propaganda plans and, in particular, determine once and for all who is truly behind Heartland and why".
Whatever one's position on AGW, the legal issues here are interesting. Why would Gleik get to apply discovery to Heartland? I mean, if I want evidence on my neighbor John Gatti (not really) can I steal flowers from his yard and then, brought up on petty theft and trespass charges, get his income tax statements and bank statements? I don't see that.
 
I see that those who argue that lying, stealing identity, and fraud are ok if in the pursuit of the Greater Gud of Gaia have gone conspicuously quite.
When the action is taken against an unethical bunch of sleazeballs, not as bad as if some sleazebasll does it to an innocent party, like the sludge monster and his pet pimp did to ACORN and Planned Parenthood.
 
I mean, if I want evidence on my neighbor John Gatti (not really) can I steal flowers from his yard and then, brought up on petty theft and trespass charges, get his income tax statements and bank statements? I don't see that.

Look at it this way. You're a private detective whose best friend is being bullied by the mob. You know that they keep some records that could cause them a lot of embarrassment and hassle. So you tell some low-level soldier in the particular mob family that you are one of the capos and that you need to take some information to the next man up in the hierarchy, and the mook gives it to you. You make it public because you know the cops are not going to do anything about the mob family for whatever reason.

The mobs sues you to shut your website down.

The rights of the mob have not really been violated because there is no inherent right to commit a crime and to silence those who know you committed a crime. It is, of course, libelous if you post known falsehoods, but then the mob has to present proof that the assertions are false. Discovery allows the defendant to gather further evidence that his statements and assertions are true.

Bottom line, if you are caught dirty in a situaton where you will not suffer additional harm by remaining silent, just shut up and put up with it.
 
No, that doesn't wash. HI hasn't done anything illegal; they may be a propaganda mill, but free speech is their protected right. They do have an inherent right to do what they do. And it's never the case that a party about whom claims are made which they complain are libelous must prove the statements are "false". It's always the case that the claimant must prove he has reason to believe the statements are true and made in good faith. There is no "discovery", either: the claimant has to prove he had that good faith reason at the time he made the statements.

And a forged document is practically the definition of "bad faith". A forged document would be libelous even if the forger has reason to believe the information he writes into it is true.
 
Last edited:
I had my doubts about the memo from the very first excerpts I read of it, and my doubts increased when I read the whole thing. Then I read Megan McCardle's impressive article, which Brainster cited on the first page of this thread:




The Heartland Institute has said the memo is fake, but has not denied the authenticity of the other documents, which (as McCardle noted) confirm most of what is said in the memo. It looks to me as though the memo is fake, but the other documents are probably real.

It is possible that someone sent the memo to Gleick as a way of tempting him to take the unethical next steps and to take the fall for it.

It is possible, but it seems like a very slim possibility to me. McCardle pointed out that the questioned letter's creation date was only a day before the "story broke" as it were:

2. *The date on the memo file is different from the other documents.*And indeed, when you look at the information on the PDFs that Heartland acknowledges, almost all of them were created by printing to PDF on January 16th, the day before Heartland's board meeting. *There is a Board Directory that was created on the 25th of January, also by printing to PDF. *And then there is the memo, which was created via an Epson scanner at 3:41 PM on February 13th. *

That seems to be just about 24 hours before this broke on the climate blogs. *The timing seems odd, and somewhat suspicious. The fact that this document, and it alone, was scanned rather than printed to PDF or emailed as a word document, is even more so.

If the timing is to be believed, the forger had to create the document and send it, Gliek had to receive it, make the decision to set up the fake email account, make the request, get sent the materials, and pass them on to the blogger all in a 24-hour time frame. It is possible, but there's room for suspicion.

Gliek has already claimed to be willing to show his email to "prove" that he got all the documents he says he did without editing. It's quite simple: let him do so, and if the date of the email predates the creation date of the suspicious file, then not only is the memo exposed as an imposture but Gliek is implicated as a party to its creation.
 
Last edited:
And it's never the case that a party about whom claims are made which they complain are libelous must prove the statements are "false". It's always the case that the claimant must prove he has reason to believe the statements are true and made in good faith. There is no "discovery", either: the claimant has to prove he had that good faith reason at the time he made the statements.
It should not be hard to prove that the statements made criticizing HI are true and that any rational person has a good reason to believe they are true. Phillip Morris.

And a forged document is practically the definition of "bad faith". A forged document would be libelous even if the forger has reason to believe the information he writes into it is true.

HI will have to make some positive assertions to disprove the authenticity of the documents. Think like the wolf. Isn't that the sort of thing you do not want to have on the hard drives of your computers and servers if your non-profit status comes under IRS review?

Do corporate types use the same style discussing strategies in the meeting room that they use in public presentations or inter-office memos? I kind of doubt it.

I fall back on my military experience to some degree here.

I would use an entirely different style addressing my shift in the kitchen while trying to get Thanksgiving Day dinner on line than I would use giving a lecture to the entire food service section on how to roast a turkey.
 
HI will have to make some positive assertions to disprove the authenticity of the documents. Think like the wolf. Isn't that the sort of thing you do not want to have on the hard drives of your computers and servers if your non-profit status comes under IRS review?

What is this conspiratoid thinking? There's nothing in the memo that puts their non-profit status in jeopardy. Receiving significant donations from corporations isn't even suspicious; how many corporations donate to the Special Olympics or the ACS?
 
What is this conspiratoid thinking? There's nothing in the memo that puts their non-profit status in jeopardy. Receiving significant donations from corporations isn't even suspicious; how many corporations donate to the Special Olympics or the ACS?
how many of them pay psuedo scientist to concoct BS "educational materials" meant to defeat the very purpose of public education?
 
That's rhetoric which represents the viewpoint of their opponents, lefty; the anti-global-warming contingent simply does not describe its own point of view that way.

If the point of the dodgy provenance of the memo was deliberate to keep the information "off their hard drives" then why is all the verifiable information in the memo in fact on their hard drives anyway in the form of the disparate board meeting packet PDFs? The only thing the memo actually adds at all is moustache-twirling commentary on things already discussed in the board documents.
 
We'll see how it plays out in the courts. And actually it does not matter. The undisputed documents criminalize Heartland, and may ultimately destroy it. It is certain that it will cause repercussions for Heartland donors, commercial repercussions.
 
IIRC non-profits don't get taxed based on income, so I'm not sure what in the documents suggests they should have been taxed; but I'll allow that people who know more about that business would see something in those documents that I don't.

I do think that a lot of HI's donors might abandon it, however. Contrary to popular wisdom, there is such a thing as bad publicity - especially when it comes to politics.
 
IIRC non-profits don't get taxed based on income, so I'm not sure what in the documents suggests they should have been taxed; but I'll allow that people who know more about that business would see something in those documents that I don't.

I do think that a lot of HI's donors might abandon it, however. Contrary to popular wisdom, there is such a thing as bad publicity - especially when it comes to politics.

If they are doing certain sorts of work, they lose their non-profit status. If it can be shown through audits that this was a condition that had persisted for years, then we have years of fraudulently maintaining a non-profit status, and years of back taxes owed. Also every donor who wrote off donations for all of those years now has a federal tax issue to deal with that can run into millions.
 
If they are doing certain sorts of work, they lose their non-profit status1. If it can be shown through audits that this was a condition that had persisted for years, then we have years of fraudulently maintaining a non-profit status, and years of back taxes owed. Also every donor who wrote off donations for all of those years now has a federal tax issue to deal with that can run into millions2.
1. (a) What sort of work would lose Heartland their tax exemption? (b) Did Heartland do this work?
2. This I doubt, unless the IRS can show that the donor knew that Heartland engaged in non-tax-exempt activities and intended to pay for those activities. My charitable contributions "for" starving African orphans may subsidize a commercial porn studio in Michigan, but unless I knew that, I don't see that I'm exposed to any legal sanction. I'd be a victim, not a criminal.
 
What sorts of work was HI doing that would render them ineligible? Again, it all looks like pretty standard "friends of issue X" stuff to me.
 
If they are doing certain sorts of work, they lose their non-profit status. If it can be shown through audits that this was a condition that had persisted for years, then we have years of fraudulently maintaining a non-profit status, and years of back taxes owed. Also every donor who wrote off donations for all of those years now has a federal tax issue to deal with that can run into millions.
You mean, like the 4 largest environmental non profits have done for years, only putting political donations to Democrats?
 
Federal law clearly states that a 501(c)(3) publicly supported charity may devote no more than an "insubstantial" portion of its activities to lobbying. The discussions I read centered around whether the lobby efforts were insubstantial or not.
 
I'm going to remain dubious on that. I don't know the exact wording of the statute, but there's all kinds of 501(c)(3)s that quite visibly devote substantial resources to lobbying without being threatened with audits. The NRA being the biggest one that immediately comes to mind.
 
Last edited:
Federal law clearly states that a 501(c)(3) publicly supported charity may devote no more than an "insubstantial" portion of its activities to lobbying. The discussions I read centered around whether the lobby efforts were insubstantial or not.
You're probably right, here, about the law. I suspect that the legal distinction between "advocacy" and "lobbying" depends more on where and to whom you present your statements than on the content of the statements. If some wealthy person says on the radio "__X__ is good policy. I will support candidates who vote for __Y__ (legislation), that's advocacy. If he says the same thing over lunch to a US Senator, that's lobbying.

Nod to Checkmite: Just leave off the "I will support..." part and you can say it over lunch to your Senator, and it's still just advocacy.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom