Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

Heartland is also lying on their own webpage where they describe the CRU emails as being leaked by a whistleblower as opposed to stolen by a hacker. I'd say it's high time someone stuck it to these ******s.
How does anyone other than the leaker/hacker know? I read somewhere recently that the local constabulary lean toward "leak", but I can't remember where.
Not what I have heard. It is referred to everywhere as a hack and I have no reason to doubt it. I know that the police verified at the time that the computers had been hacked. I know that HI and other science deniers like to think that it was a whistleblower, but nobody but the science deniers thinks so. The HI website lies and says that it was a whistleblower which goes against all current sources except other deniers.
Here'a Guardian story that refers to "leaks". That appears to be one angle the police investigation, anyway.
A scientist at the University of East Anglia has been questioned by detectives investigating how controversial emails were leaked from the campus's climate research unit.

Norfolk police have interviewed and taken a formal statement from Paul Dennis, 54, another climate researcher who heads an adjacent laboratory.
The article go on...
The police left me very much with the impression that they were working on the theory that this was an outside hack and was done deliberately to disrupt Copenhagen."
but throughout the piece uses "leak" and "leaked" and not "hacked".
 
Here'a Guardian story that refers to "leaks". That appears to be one angle the police investigation, anyway.The article go on... but throughout the piece uses "leak" and "leaked" and not "hacked".
Do you want to own a falacy of language or inability to properly read English for comprehension?

The subject was left with the impression that it was an outside job.

In other words:

"HACKED."

Are we clear on that now?
 
Do you want to own a falacy of language or inability to properly read English for comprehension?

The subject was left with the impression that it was an outside job.

In other words:

"HACKED."

Are we clear on that now?

Some people only see what they want to see. Of course the computers were hacked. There is no logical alternative.
 
Note that having read more about this, Gleick may have gone over the line here.

It matters a lot what you say when you social engineer information out of people, and he did not confine himself to what was safe.
 
Some people only see what they want to see. Of course the computers were hacked. There is no logical alternative.
Why the attention to insiders' possible motives, then? And why did the Guardian use "leaked" throughout?
Ps. I separated and supplied the "outside job" part. There was no "overlooked", except by people who (impossibly) imagine that I missed it.
 
Last edited:
Why the attention to insiders' possible motives, then? And why did the Guardian use "leaked" throughout?

Perhaps you should read and try to understand the article. It says clearly that the impression Dennis got was that the police were looking at this as a hacking. Why the Guardian uses the word "leaked" instead of the word "hacked" is beyond me, as it doesn't describe the situation.

The CRU hack couldn't have been just a "leak". The emails were private and the computers were private. If this was a leak, the leaker would have had to be one of the accused scientists, which quite clearly isn't the case. The leaker in question would also have had to aquire emails from other places beyond his normal access, forcing him to hack other systems, so logically, hacking was involved.

Then there's the fact that RealClimate.org was hacked and the site was used to publicise the hacked and stolen emails.

The whole "Whistleblower" thing is just denialist wishful thinking and a failure of critical thinking. Heartland Institute, however, doesn't have any qualms about lying about the whole affair on their webpage, calling is a leak when it was a hack, and conveniently neglecting to inform their readers about how the investigations into the affair (which you keep running away from having to read) all cleared the accused scientists. Dishonest is the least you can call that.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps you should read and try to understand the article. It says clearly that the impression Dennis got was that the police were looking at this as a hacking. Why the Guardian uses the word "leaked" instead of the word "hacked" is beyond me, as it doesn't describe the situation.

The CRU hack couldn't have been just a "leak". The emails were private and the computers were private. If this was a leak, the leaker would have had to be one of the accused scientists, which quite clearly isn't the case. The leaker in question would also have had to aquire emails from other places beyond his normal access, forcing him to hack other systems, so logically, hacking was involved.

Then there's the fact that RealClimate.org was hacked and the site was used to publicise the hacked and stolen emails.

The whole "Whistleblower" thing is just denialist wishful thinking and a failure of critical thinking. Heartland Institute, however, doesn't have any qualms about lying about the whole affair on their webpage, calling is a leak when it was a hack, and conveniently neglecting to inform their readers about how the investigations into the affair (which you keep running away from having to read) all cleared the accused scientists. Dishonest is the least you can call that.

I've read this a couple of times and tried to understand it.

It seems that what you are saying is that the climate realists, those who are skeptical of ridiculous alarmist propaganda such as you push around...are really clever. Like you mean they hacked in and then put the goods on realcrapclimate? That pretty funny.

Now this Gliek guy, he just look stupid and silly.

What can one say?
 
Perhaps you should read and try to understand the article. It says clearly that the impression Dennis got was that the police were looking at this as a hacking.... Heartland Institute, however, doesn't have any qualms about lying about the whole affair on their webpage, calling is a leak when it was a hack, and conveniently neglecting to inform their readers about how the investigations into the affair (which you keep running away from having to read) all cleared the accused scientists. Dishonest is the least you can call that.
. Is the Guardian also "lying"? Why would it be easier to hack multiple private machines than to hack (or harvest) stored emails in a university computer? Is there a middle ground between "leak" and "hack", where an insider makes access easier to an outsider and tells the outsider where to look?
Anyway, since I believe it was more likely a courageous insider (or a mix, as above), than an outsider, I'd prefer that the police seek an outsider.
 
Last edited:
I do have to say that modern hackers, and in particular those from china, have the ability to get into computer networks invisibly, and stay in for years. Hacking is actually inevitable if you have something somebody wants. I wouldn't have said this a few years ago, but hackers have advanced.
 
...Now this Gliek guy, he just look stupid and silly.
What can one say?
He fell hard for the Green Goddess and for his savior superhero self-image. Also, selling the scare brought hundreds of thousands in grant money. But that's probably a minor consideration.
 
He fell hard for the Green Goddess and for his savior superhero self-image. Also, selling the scare brought hundreds of thousands in grant money. But that's probably a minor consideration.

I guess nothing would be better for the ego than Saving the Planet.

I mean, that's really big.

Too Big To Fail?

;)
 
. Is the Guardian also "lying"?

No, I didn't say they were. As the article is pretty old and still makes it clear that the impression is that the Police is labelling the incident as a hacking, they aren't lying. They are using erroneous language. HI is lying, though.

Why would it be easier to hack multiple private machines than to hack (or harvest) stored emails in a university computer? Is there a middle ground between "leak" and "hack", where an insider makes access easier to an outsider and tells the outsider where to look?

Don't know what you're talking about. If computers where hacked - as it is clear they were as there is no other logical explanation - the incident was a hacking. If you or Heartland have evidence that would implicate a CRU employee in the hacking, I'd suggest you forward it to the UK Police. If you don't, start describing the incident for what it was - a hacking.

Anyway, since I believe it was more likely a courageous insider (or a mix, as above), than an outsider, I'd prefer that the police seek an outsider.

Again, no idea what you're talking about, other than that you once again discard logic for wishful thinking.
 
Also, selling the scare brought hundreds of thousands in grant money. But that's probably a minor consideration.

Oh yes, we can't forget the conspiracy theory at the heart of climate denialism. Thank you for reminding us that denialsts are necessarily conspiracy theorists.
 
Oh yes, we can't forget the conspiracy theory at the heart of climate denialism. Thank you for reminding us that denialsts are necessarily conspiracy theorists.
Did Gleick's organization receive tax-funded EPA contracts to study economic implications of climate change, or not? If money motivates Heartland's contractors, why would it not motivate the EPA's contractors?
 
It's about time for Exxon to get mentioned. Then the lies can be trotted out about Exxon. Add some for the Koch brothers. Did I miss anyone?

:)
 
Did Gleick's organization receive tax-funded EPA contracts to study economic implications of climate change, or not? If money motivates Heartland's contractors, why would it not motivate the EPA's contractors?

Do you expect Gleick to do science for free? Because that's what you're implying.

Now, if you want to talk about your conspiracy theory regarding climate change - that the scientists made it up for the money - take it to the conspiracy forum where it belongs.
 
He fell hard for the Green Goddess and for his savior superhero self-image.
And HI has from the very start served the Harlot of Revelations.

Also, selling the scare brought hundreds of thousands in grant money. But that's probably a minor consideration.
Theproblem with your whacky conspiracy theory is that the research has to produce verifiable results. Other scientists with no financial interest will be looking over your shoulder.

That is why so many scientists are throwing bricks at HI's scholastic whores.
 
Do you expect Gleick to do science for free? Because that's what you're implying....

Is he actually doing any? He's editor of something, and does the lecture circuit. Pacific Institute is policy analysis, right?

Maybe revise that to "do you expect him to lecture, or go on NPR, or help with ecology fresh water policy analysis", for free.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom