Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

Do you expect Gleick to do science for free? Because that's what you're implying. Now, if you want to talk about your conspiracy theory regarding climate change - that the scientists made it up for the money - take it to the conspiracy forum where it belongs.
Make up your mind. Either money motivates people or it does not. No, I don't expect Briffa, Emmanuel, Gleick, Hansen, Jones, or Trenberth to work for free. Neither do I expect Anthony Watts, Roy Spencer, Steve McIntyre, Ross McKitrick, or Heartland to work for free.
I suggest that academic science departments promote people who bring grant money, and that grant money flows to "important" issues. Global threats are "important", so academics have a clear incentive to emphasize the downside to neglect of their area of expertise.
 
Why are you assuming that the Koch roaches have a conscience?
Oh, I am sure they have not been able to forgive themselves for a black man becoming president on their watch!!*













*i.e. they have a sort-of conscience but it is like actually an anti-conscience.
 
And HI has from the very start served the Harlot of Revelations.

Theproblem with your whacky conspiracy theory is that the research has to produce verifiable results. Other scientists with no financial interest will be looking over your shoulder.

That is why so many scientists are throwing bricks at HI's scholastic whores.
Really?

You've got some really mean scientists there.

Well.

We knew that.
 
Make up your mind. Either money motivates people or it does not. No, I don't expect Briffa, Emmanuel, Gleick, Hansen, Jones, or Trenberth to work for free. Neither do I expect Anthony Watts, Roy Spencer, Steve McIntyre, Ross McKitrick, or Heartland to work for free.
Which does not excuse their whoring themselves out to slime like Phillip Morris or the Koch roaches to massage the facts into lies that serve the purposes of unethical vulture capitalists and polluters.

Real scientists have to convince other scientists that they have the answers. Corporate whores are paid to convince us that government and academia are lying to us.
 
Last edited:
I'm sure the local AGW fanatics can stomach still using it to describe phenomena to which it applies?

Like using it to describe what happens when people want to save the world from communism.
 
Now if you you could make the jump and realize you are one of those useful idiots...
The ancient Greeks considered the use of ad hominem argument to be defacto admission of loss of a debate, and so do I.

Continue, please.
 
Make up your mind. Either money motivates people or it does not.

What are you talking about? Are you trying to equate getting payed for your work in science (the climate scientists) with paying someone to lie about science (HI)?

Your conspiracy theory falls flat on its face when you do the least amount of critical thinking.
 
What are you talking about? Are you trying to equate getting payed for your work in science (the climate scientists) with paying someone to lie about science (HI)?
The critical term here is "for". What do dornors pay "for"? Do the academic administrators who promote on the basis of the amount of grant money a scholar receives care about the theory that generated the revenue? I doubt it. As we see with Gleick, lying can erode your veracity. The people who conduct research to counter the research from the "AGW is real and urgent" side have as large a stake in maintaining their credibility as do those on the "it's real and urgent" side. In abstract, money no more corrupts one side than the other.

If corruption is proportionate to the amount of money, consider: Heartland's "climate" budget is probably less than Penn State's or the UEA's.

Your conspiracy theory falls flat on its face when you do the least amount of critical thinking.[/QUOTE]
 
The ancient Greeks considered the use of ad hominem argument to be defacto admission of loss of a debate, and so do I.

Shouldn't you learn what an ad hominem argument is before making such conclusions? Hint, an ad hominem argument takes the form:

"You are stupid and therefor your argument is wrong"

an insult, which is not an ad hominem argument, would be of the from:

"you are stupid"

An observation, which is also not an ad hominem argument, could be of the form:

"your posts are idiotic therefor you must be an idiot"

What I did is closest to the middle form, an insult, though I think your being a "useful idiot" could well be supported by your overall posting history. Either way my post plays on the irony of the fact you are the very thing, a "useful idiot", you were using to insult others.

Predictably you took issue with being referred to with the same terms you use in reference to others. This makes you a hypocrite. This of course falls squarely into the third category, that of an observation.

hope this helps! :D
 
The critical term here is "for". What do dornors pay "for"?

Kind of obvious, really, given the information in the leaked documents. The donors pay for HI's keeping up with their campaign to muddy the science of AGW.

Do the academic administrators who promote on the basis of the amount of grant money a scholar receives care about the theory that generated the revenue? I doubt it.

Maybe you should look it up instead of just "doubting it"? It's not really a secret how research grants work, you know.

As we see with Gleick, lying can erode your veracity.

Hardly. It might erode your "credibility", but it doesn't erode your veracity. Gleick isn't proud of what he did, and it was definitely ethically questionable, but it was also important. We have learned more about how HI and fellow science-denying organisations function and who funds them.

The people who conduct research to counter the research from the "AGW is real and urgent" side have as large a stake in maintaining their credibility as do those on the "it's real and urgent" side. In abstract, money no more corrupts one side than the other.

You might have had a point if HI's money went to research. As we see in the budget documents, it doesn't, so you have no point.

If corruption is proportionate to the amount of money, consider: Heartland's "climate" budget is probably less than Penn State's or the UEA's.

"Probably"? Why don't you check things before you opine? Are you only here to troll?

Your conspiracy theory falls flat on its face when you do the least amount of critical thinking.

Don't know if you left this here on purpose, but I suppose you feel like your only defense for being called out as a conspiracy theorist is to go "NO U". Kind of laughable.

:D
 
Last edited:
Removed breach.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: LashL
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Shouldn't you learn what an ad hominem argument is before making such conclusions? Hint, an ad hominem argument takes the form:

"You are stupid and therefor your argument is wrong"

an insult, which is not an ad hominem argument, would be of the from:

"you are stupid"

An observation, which is also not an ad hominem argument, could be of the form:

"your posts are idiotic therefor you must be an idiot"

What I did is closest to the middle form, an insult, though I think your being a "useful idiot" could well be supported by your overall posting history. Either way my post plays on the irony of the fact you are the very thing, a "useful idiot", you were using to insult others.

Predictably you took issue with being referred to with the same terms you use in reference to others. This makes you a hypocrite. This of course falls squarely into the third category, that of an observation.

hope this helps! :D

Don't confuse him with facts.
 
...an ad hominem argument takes the form:
"You are stupid and therefor your argument is wrong"

an insult, which is not an ad hominem argument, would be of the from:
"you are stupid"
Splitting hairs, seems to me. Anyway, I thought ad hominem was "he is ___ (fill in the blank with any insult), therefore his argument is wrong", or "you're argument is mistaken because you don't bathe often enough and your sister is a ho". But I could be wrong. The term evolves.

The psychology of insults deserves a discussion. Seems to me they generally mean one of the following:
1. "I don't like you and I want you to know it" (when spoken to the insulted person).
2. "I don't like him and I want you to join me in making his life miserable".
3. "I really like you and I demonstrate this by calling you a name that only a friend could get away with using."

What makes #1 strange is information is valuable, yet this form is common. Why alert an enemy that he can expect an attack? There has to be an evolutionary explanation.
 
Last edited:
Splitting hairs, seems to me. Anyway, I thought ad hominem was "he is ___ (fill in the blank with any insult), therefore his argument is wrong",

That's an ad hominem, yes, and it takes exactly the form lomiller described. Perhaps you should read his post before replying next time?

As for the psychology of insults, please take it to another forum as it is off topic here.
 
Last edited:
That's an ad hominem, yes, and it takes exactly the form lomiller described.

Yup. One final side-note. As most people know there is a valid and invalid form of appeal to authority. The valid form is appeal to legitimate authority, they invalid form is the appeal to illegitimate authority.

When someone makes an appeal to authority it's perfectly valid to attack the credentials of that authority on the subject at hand since this is the key to whether the appeal is fallacious or not. This can sometimes be mistaken for an ad hominem.


Generally speaking you need to confine this type of attack on a persons credentials to issues that are directly relevant. I.E. pointing out that someone has little or no record of publishing climate papers and saying they are therefor not a climate scientist and we should not take them at their word on climate maters is perfectly valid.


Conversely, saying someone is a Liberal and therefor you should not believe what they have to say about climate science, (when in fact they have an impressive publication record) would not be a valid attack on that persons ability to speak as an authority on the matter.
 
Edited by LashL: 
Removed quote of and response to moderated content.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The critical term here is "for". What do dornors pay "for"? Do the academic administrators who promote on the basis of the amount of grant money a scholar receives care about the theory that generated the revenue? I doubt it. As we see with Gleick, lying can erode your veracity.
And if he tries to sell BS research results to the academic community, which is the market for most research grant address, they get treated the way most academics treat Steve Jones or that twit Nils Harrit.

The people who conduct research to counter the research from the "AGW is real and urgent" side have as large a stake in maintaining their credibility as do those on the "it's real and urgent" side.
The HI doxies are not selling their stuff to academics. They are feeding their "research resuilts" the drooling morons who think Fox Boobs is still an authentic news outlet.

In abstract, money no more corrupts one side than the other.
As I have shown above, this is BS.

If corruption is proportionate to the amount of money, consider: Heartland's "climate" budget is probably less than Penn State's or the UEA's.
Stink tanks likie HI don't have to have actual measuring devices, aside, prehaps, from the scales on which they measure their Peruvian marching powder.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom