Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

This is my feeling on the matter as well. It is likely to become a partisan matter. If you're in bed with the science deniers, you'll conclude it's fake. If you accept the scientific consensus, you won't conclude it's fake.

Not necessarily. I accept the consensus, yet I also suspect the memo, while containing mostly accurate factual information, is a fake created by an overzealous actor (possibly Gleick himself) for the purpose the enhancing negative spin. The circumstantial evidence is strong, and I'm frankly baffled by its dismissal by people in this forum whose opinion I usually find unassailable.
 
This is my feeling on the matter as well. It is likely to become a partisan matter. If you're in bed with the science deniers, you'll conclude it's fake. If you accept the scientific consensus, you won't conclude it's fake.
Except, only people who take the "AGW is real and urgent" position describe people on the other side as "science deniers" or "anti-science".

There's a test that can detect fraud in people who claim to have suffered hearing loss: place headphones over their ears, have them read a couple hundred words of text, and play back their words with a fraction of a second delay. People who can hear will stutter and stumble.
There's a test which can detect whether someone who claims to be unable to read __X__ (language) can read __X__: provide a list of words in the language that they claim to be unable to read...
1. Red
2. Green
3. Blue
4. Orange
5. Yellow
where the text is in the color that the text word names, then provide a list where the color named does not match the text color. People who can read the text will answer faster if the text matches the color.

No one on the "AGW is NOT urgent, and Michael Mann is a liar" side of the argument describes his own position as "anti-science", would call Freeman Dyson a "science denier", or would propose to end teaching science in schools. This is like calling onself "stupid" or "evil". People don't do that, even if they are.

The document that Heartland claims is fake, is fake.
 
Except, only people who take the "AGW is real and urgent" position describe people on the other side as "science deniers" or "anti-science".

That's because only the people who take the "AGW is real and urgent" position can describe people on the other side as "science deniers" or "anti-science" and be right.

The document that Heartland claims is fake, is fake.

The document that Heartland claims is fake, might well be real.

So, about our deal? You do realise that the more you run away from it, the more you come off as a coward, yes?
 
It sounds very much like a phrase no pro-global warming advocate would put into a forged document because it would be stupid to make a forgery so transparent.
Just as it's stupid to call Freeman Dyson or Lubos Motl "anti-science" or "science deniers". Yet some do. But only people on the "AGW is real and urgent" do. It's a tell.
 
That's because only the people who take the "AGW is real and urgent" position can describe people on the other side as "science deniers" or "anti-science" and be right.
False. How 'bout "Why should we give you our data; you'd just try to find holes in it", or "I hope they never find out that Britain has a FOI act"? That is what emails from the Hokey Team expressed. Science is about repeatable experiments and analysis. If you won't share your raw data, your analysis is not repeatable and what you're doing is not science.
 
It sounds very much like a phrase no pro-global warming advocate would put into a forged document because it would be stupid to make a forgery so transparent.

Presumes there's no such thing as a stupid pro-global-warning advocate.

"It's so transparently ridiculous that it has to be real" is a non sequitur.
 
Again, no successful legal action means a presumption of authenticity.
We will agree, here, if you accept the possibility of an out-of-court settlement or a non-disclosure agreement. That is, there may be successful legal action that by agreement does not go public. This is unlikely. Heartland is out for blood, now.
 
The question was wherther the term "anti-science" describes these people, not whether they publish in the same journals that publish Briffa, Hansen, Jones, Mann, and Trenberth. Further...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_&_Environment
Yes, a journal where the editor admits the journal has little impact and admits she publishes AGW-skeptic papers because of her political agenda.

And do you really contend that computer modeling is irrelevant to climate science? If that's the case, what is left beyond raw instrument data, proxy data, and lab experiments with CO2, sun lamps and pieces of rock? Theory without data is theology. Data without theory is baby talk ("cow", "horsie"). Theory and data meet in models.

No, computer modelling is relevant, but one or two computer programmers aren't. Why should I believe that they have found holes that basically the entire scientific community missed, and that bring down the huge swaths of data and different models that all conclude AGW to be real?
 
No, computer modelling is relevant, but one or two computer programmers aren't. Why should I believe that they have found holes that basically the entire scientific community missed, and that bring down the huge swaths of data and different models that all conclude AGW to be real?
Okay, so expertise in computer modeling matters. That's all I wanted to get from you. Thanks. If your rule is "he differs from the herd so I don't have to ask why" you will abide within the herd forever.
 
Okay, so expertise in computer modeling matters. That's all I wanted to get from you. Thanks. If your rule is "he differs from the herd so I don't have to ask why" you will abide within the herd forever.

It's comforting to know that by your definition, my mate who's a computer programmer is as much of an expert in climate science as anyone at NASA or CRU.

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed perosnal comment


:D
 
Last edited by a moderator:
It's comforting to know that by your definition, my mate who's a computer programmer is as much of an expert in climate science as anyone at NASA or CRU...
Climate science is an amorphous science that takes evidence and methods from diverse disciplines. Plant physiologists can assess the assumptions that paleobotanists use when they use tree rings as temperature proxies. Geochemists can assess the assumptions that climate modelers use about the incorporation of atmospheric CO2 into exposed surface rocks (how does mountain-building affect atmospheric CO2?). Computer modelers can assess computer models. Where do you disagree?

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed personal comment
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Climate science is an amorphous science that takes evidence and methods from diverse disciplines. Plant physiologists can assess the assumptions that paleobotanists use when they use tree rings as temperature proxies. Geochemists can assess the assumptions that climate modelers use about the incorporation of atmospheric CO2 into exposed surface rocks (how does mountain-building affect atmospheric CO2?). Computer modelers can assess computer models. Where do you disagree?

Where you assert that computer programming should be counted as an expert in climate science despite the programmer in question not having released any peer-reviewed papers relating to climate science.

Keep dodging and weaving.

Oh, and keep running. :D
 
Keep it civil & on topic. The topic is not the other posters. I don't really care what deals you think you may have made with them, you ALL made a deal when you signed up here that you are breaking when you're uncivil and off topic, it's called the Membership Agreement. Cut it out.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: kmortis
 
Pretty much. I don't think Heartland is under any illusions as to wether science supports their position or not. They know it doesn't, just like they knew it didn't when they advocated that smoking wasn't harmful. Science and reason is their primary enemy, so it wouldn't surprise me at all if they talked internally about dissuading teachers from teaching it.

The ideologues among the deniers think the science supports their position. Mercenaries like HI think whatever it takes to keep the money coming.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom