Buckaroo
Graduate Poster
This is my feeling on the matter as well. It is likely to become a partisan matter. If you're in bed with the science deniers, you'll conclude it's fake. If you accept the scientific consensus, you won't conclude it's fake.
Not necessarily. I accept the consensus, yet I also suspect the memo, while containing mostly accurate factual information, is a fake created by an overzealous actor (possibly Gleick himself) for the purpose the enhancing negative spin. The circumstantial evidence is strong, and I'm frankly baffled by its dismissal by people in this forum whose opinion I usually find unassailable.