How did you manage to read that into what I said? Neither of us know if the document is forged or not, so how could I "grant" that?
I think what he meant is that you have "confirmed" that it is proponents of AGW, and not deniers (for lack of a better term; I don't intend it as a pejorative), who are inclined to use those terms to describe deniers. Since you asserted that it is appropriate to use such terms to describe those who deny AGW. Those who deny AGW do not self-describe using those terms, at least in my experience. They wouldn't be likely to talk about preventing the teaching of "science." Rather, they would talk about stopping teachers from "indoctrinating" kids with "propaganda."
I am not particularly persuaded by the explanation that those at HI and others who deny AGW are doing so in bad faith. Even if that were true, they would avoid using language that gives that away, even in documents not intended for public consumption. I think they are sincere, as I know well-educated and sincere people who at least doubt the extent to which human activity is responsible for climate change, and I know many educated and sincere people who believe in AGW but are more than a little skeptical that the usual proposed solutions would have enough of an effect to justify their cost. Which is, of course, a completely different argument, one that does
not deny the science demonstrating that climate change is real and that human activity is contributing to it.
That said, I disagree with him that what you said is any sort of "proof" that the document is fake. I do think it is highly unlikely that HI staffers would self-identify as "anti-climate" or anti-science, even in private correspondence. Even if they do believe in AGW privately but argue otherwise publicly for money, since they know well that "private" communications do not always remain private.
(As an aside, that sort of bad faith is an assumption I refuse to make. Lots of people are very sincere and simultaneously very wrong about lots of things, particularly on complicated subjects that most people, and even most scientists who are not specialists, do not understand very well. Assuming your opponents are arguing in bad faith makes any reasonable discussion impossible. I understand that some people, possibly including some in this thread, are not persuadable (at least not in this medium). But that is not true of everyone, and it is worth making arguments that assume the good faith of your opponents, since arguments that do not will turn off the open-minded, and will have no effect on the closed-minded anyway. Certainly tactics like ridicule and snark can be effective, and they have their place. I just think it would be nice if there were also serious and civil discussion between smart and sincere people who disagree. Nastiness and ridicule have always been part of political discourse, but only recently have they seemed to become the whole of political discourse.)
And in fact there are several terms in the memo that
are usually used by those who are frustrated with those who deny AGW, not the deniers. Of course, that falls well short of proof, especially since you were just expressing your opinion. Your opinion cannot have any causal relationship to the authorship of the memo (obviously). One can hardly "admit" something one clearly does not know, or even claim to know.
So I guess all of that was a long way of saying I mostly agree with you.
