Heartland Institute Threatens To Sue Anyone Who Comments On Leaked Documents

What I posted was a list of examples of Motl being wrong. I'm not particularly interested in debating this with you though; as science denying goes, your previous post where you hand-waved away the opinions of every major scientific establishment in the world is probably the best example i've ever seen on this forum.
So you've ignored my comment that the examples the paid propagandist, Cook, showed are not even examples of Motl's thinking, but his reporting and summarizing published articles?

It's an error, by Cook, but that's expected. You've now been informed of it, and not to correct your thinking is evidence of denial. And I thought you were not a denier. Hmm...
 
Okay, so expertise in computer modeling matters. That's all I wanted to get from you. Thanks. If your rule is "he differs from the herd so I don't have to ask why" you will abide within the herd forever.

When the herd is the overwhelming majority of experts on the subject along with every major scientific institution in the world, and the outliers are bloggers with vaguely related degrees, you can consider that fine by me.
 
When the herd is the overwhelming majority of experts on the subject along with every major scientific institution in the world, and the outliers are bloggers with vaguely related degrees, you can consider that fine by me.

And when the online proponents are self-described Libertarians who are an embarrassment to the concept of Libertarianism, you know that any argument is a waste of time.

The matter is settled science.
 
So you've ignored my comment that the examples the paid propagandist, Cook, showed are not even examples of Motl's thinking, but his reporting and summarizing published articles?

It's an error, by Cook, but that's expected. You've now been informed of it, and not to correct your thinking is evidence of denial. And I thought you were not a denier. Hmm...

I didn't ignore it immediately. I checked the first source, and saw you were partially right. Then I checked the second and third sources and noticed you were wrong, and given your track record of saying things of... shall we say, questionable veracity, I decided to dismiss your opinion off-hand, in a similar manner to how you dismissed off-hand the stance of every major scientific institution earlier in the thread. Consider yourself back on ignore; good day, sir.
 
I didn't ignore it immediately. I checked the first source, and saw you were partially right. Then I checked the second and third sources and noticed you were wrong, and given your track record of saying things of... shall we say, questionable veracity, I decided to dismiss your opinion off-hand, in a similar manner to how you dismissed off-hand the stance of every major scientific institution earlier in the thread. Consider yourself back on ignore; good day, sir.
Yes, you need to hurry away, otherwise, embarrasing things could come up. Didn't I say you couldn't trust Cook? Let's check item number two on the list.

What Motl Said:

More seriously, it is preposterous to compare leprechauns to the clouds, solar activity, volcanoes, ocean cycles, and cosmic rays because all these phenomena - except for leprechauns - have been driving the Earth's climate for 4.7 billion years and are still doing so.

What Cook claimed Motl said:

ocean cycles...have been driving the Earth's climate for 4.7 billion years and are still doing so

How Cook responded to what Cook claimed Motl said:

The PDO shows no trend and therefor the PDO is not responsible for the trend of global warming.

I started out, and said Cook was a paid propagandist, and shouldn't be trusted. Well, this is a pretty good example of that, in my opinion.

Want to go on to #3? It basically shows Cook isn't the smartest tool in the shed. But that was part of what I said at the beginning wasn't it?

Gee....
 
Last edited:
MHaze, I really think there are ideas you need to be exposed to.

If I give you a class assignment, will you do the work?

The Teaching Company has a "Great Courses" series in which Professor Richard Wolfson, Ph.D., Dartmouth College, did one called "Earth's Changing Climate" which is quite good.

http://www.thegreatcourses.com/tgc/courses/course_detail.aspx?cid=1219

It's $90 as download, or you can do what I did and request it through inter-library loan. (I did have to clean the CDs though - people don't take care of library materials as they should.)

I'm serious here, you need to learn this material even if you are only learning it to properly criticize it.

Make sure you look at the charts in the included book as he discusses them. The video course is probably easier to get through, but I listen to these on my commute.
 
The only reason to conclude it is a fake is the insistence of those it criminalizes; namely Heartland.

This is my feeling on the matter as well. It is likely to become a partisan matter. If you're in bed with the science deniers, you'll conclude it's fake. If you accept the scientific consensus, you won't conclude it's fake.
I disagree.

I agree with Checkmite and Buckaroo:

No; again, something like this isn't "true until proven fake". One more person who has inexplicably forgotten where the burden of proof lies.

As someone has before linked, there's already a few things about the document that cast its authenticity into doubt.

Not necessarily. I accept the consensus, yet I also suspect the memo, while containing mostly accurate factual information, is a fake created by an overzealous actor (possibly Gleick himself) for the purpose the enhancing negative spin. The circumstantial evidence is strong, and I'm frankly baffled by its dismissal by people in this forum whose opinion I usually find unassailable.


I had my doubts about the memo from the very first excerpts I read of it, and my doubts increased when I read the whole thing. Then I read Megan McCardle's impressive article, which Brainster cited on the first page of this thread:

Megan McCardle has a pretty good article on the faked document that should give real skeptics reason to doubt its veracity:


The Heartland Institute has said the memo is fake, but has not denied the authenticity of the other documents, which (as McCardle noted) confirm most of what is said in the memo. It looks to me as though the memo is fake, but the other documents are probably real.

It is possible that someone sent the memo to Gleick as a way of tempting him to take the unethical next steps and to take the fall for it.

According to an automated textual analysis run by Shawn Lawrence Otto, the style of the memo looks less like Peter Gleick than Joe Bast (president of the Heartland Institute). I do not interpret that result as evidence that Joe Bast wrote the memo, but it does count as evidence against the hypothesis that Gleick wrote it.

Like Brainster, I'm willing to wait and see.
 
Like Brainster, I'm willing to wait and see.

As am I. I'm just arguing against deemig it a fake right now, as I don't think there's sufficient evidence to know either way.

If it - in the end - comes down to a matter of trust, I know where to put mine.

Now, as steering the discourse towards wether the document is fake or not might have been HI's objective, I'd like for the discussion to get back to what we do know to be genuine: The other documents that say the same thing as the alleged fake, only sometimes in other words.
 
Last edited:
Damn, I had to go look at their web site, and they have a SALE. I think my money is trying to squirm out of my wallet right now.

ETA: I've already done this one, but it is worth your time; http://www.thegreatcourses.com/tgc/courses/course_detail.aspx?cid=8050

ETA2: Yes, I am totally off topic. [/derail]
I've listened to dozens of their courses and you are right it's a great resource and very reasonable. A lot of the stuff is rotated on sale. That climate one I believe i started and rejected, been a while.

But this is not related to these idiotic assertions that Cook can debunk Motls. Cook can't even understand some of what Motls says. Actually this has NOTHING to do with the underlying arguments, just the matter of Cook and Motl.
 
Last edited:
And when the online proponents are self-described Libertarians who are an embarrassment to the concept of Libertarianism, you know that any argument is a waste of time. The matter is settled science.
Which online proponents of the "not(AGW is real and urgent)" position are Libertarian? I don't doubt that some are. Just curious.
 
That's because only the people who take the "AGW is real and urgent" position can describe people on the other side as "science deniers" or "anti-science" and be right.
Okay. You've just granted that that the document that Heartland claims was forged was forged.
So, about our deal? You do realise that the more you run away from it, the more you come off as a coward, yes?
Pointless insults lower the interest. You're not even my third priority.
 
Own goal since neither money nor property was requested or sent.

Fail. we are not talking about giving business secrets to a competitor so ti doesn't apply.

I see that those who argue that lying, stealing identity, and fraud are ok if in the pursuit of the Greater Gud of Gaia have gone conspicuously quite.
 
I don't know about suing, but if the veracity of the document is in question of course it is legitimate to stop people from spreading it, as it might be libelious. I mean, if I posted on the internet a fake document that pretends to show Mr. X is a pedophile, I don't get a protection from libel just by saying, "Well, it's just purportedly fake, according to Mr. X". The "climategate" documents, on the other hand, are surely real, and nobody denied it.

So JREF could be sued for the links contained herein. But the discussion continues with links and quotes.

But climategate couldn't be linked to or quoted. That was clamped down on by mods.

Latent bias is obvious.
 
Last edited:
Okay. You've just granted that that the document that Heartland claims was forged was forged.

:confused:

How did you manage to read that into what I said? Neither of us know if the document is forged or not, so how could I "grant" that?

Pointless insults lower the interest. You're not even my third priority.

I don't really care. Everyone reading your posts will see how you ran away and think less of your opinions for it. You're only hurting your own cause by continuing to run.

:D
 
Last edited:
How did you manage to read that into what I said? Neither of us know if the document is forged or not, so how could I "grant" that?

I think what he meant is that you have "confirmed" that it is proponents of AGW, and not deniers (for lack of a better term; I don't intend it as a pejorative), who are inclined to use those terms to describe deniers. Since you asserted that it is appropriate to use such terms to describe those who deny AGW. Those who deny AGW do not self-describe using those terms, at least in my experience. They wouldn't be likely to talk about preventing the teaching of "science." Rather, they would talk about stopping teachers from "indoctrinating" kids with "propaganda."

I am not particularly persuaded by the explanation that those at HI and others who deny AGW are doing so in bad faith. Even if that were true, they would avoid using language that gives that away, even in documents not intended for public consumption. I think they are sincere, as I know well-educated and sincere people who at least doubt the extent to which human activity is responsible for climate change, and I know many educated and sincere people who believe in AGW but are more than a little skeptical that the usual proposed solutions would have enough of an effect to justify their cost. Which is, of course, a completely different argument, one that does not deny the science demonstrating that climate change is real and that human activity is contributing to it.

That said, I disagree with him that what you said is any sort of "proof" that the document is fake. I do think it is highly unlikely that HI staffers would self-identify as "anti-climate" or anti-science, even in private correspondence. Even if they do believe in AGW privately but argue otherwise publicly for money, since they know well that "private" communications do not always remain private.

(As an aside, that sort of bad faith is an assumption I refuse to make. Lots of people are very sincere and simultaneously very wrong about lots of things, particularly on complicated subjects that most people, and even most scientists who are not specialists, do not understand very well. Assuming your opponents are arguing in bad faith makes any reasonable discussion impossible. I understand that some people, possibly including some in this thread, are not persuadable (at least not in this medium). But that is not true of everyone, and it is worth making arguments that assume the good faith of your opponents, since arguments that do not will turn off the open-minded, and will have no effect on the closed-minded anyway. Certainly tactics like ridicule and snark can be effective, and they have their place. I just think it would be nice if there were also serious and civil discussion between smart and sincere people who disagree. Nastiness and ridicule have always been part of political discourse, but only recently have they seemed to become the whole of political discourse.)

And in fact there are several terms in the memo that are usually used by those who are frustrated with those who deny AGW, not the deniers. Of course, that falls well short of proof, especially since you were just expressing your opinion. Your opinion cannot have any causal relationship to the authorship of the memo (obviously). One can hardly "admit" something one clearly does not know, or even claim to know.

So I guess all of that was a long way of saying I mostly agree with you.:)
 
Last edited:
I think what he meant is that you have "confirmed" that it is proponents of AGW, and not deniers (for lack of a better term; I don't intend it as a pejorative), who are inclined to use those terms to describe deniers. Those who deny AGW do not self-describe using those terms, at least in my experience. They wouldn't be likely to talk about preventing the teaching of "science." Rather, they would talk about stopping teachers from "indoctrinating" kids with "propaganda."

Well, of course deniers don't call themselves that, but I think there's a real disconnect, especially when it comes to mercenaries like HI. I wouldn't put it past them to be honest enough amongst their inner circle to call what they plan to do by it's proper nomenclature.

Such bad faith is, by the way, an assumption I refuse to make. Lots of people are very sincere and also very wrong about lots of things, particularly on complicated subjects that most people, and even most scientists who are not specialists, do not understand very well. Assuming your opponents are arguing in bad faith makes any reasonable discussion impossible. I understand that some people, possibly including some in this thread, are not persuadable (at least not in this medium). But that is not true of everyone, and it is worth making arguments that assume the good faith of your opponents, since those that do not will turn off the open-minded, and will have no effect on the closed-minded anyway.

When it comes to HI, I think it can be assumed that they are arguing in bad faith. After all, that's what they did when they claimed smoking wasn't bad for you.

And in fact there are several terms in the memo that are usually used by those who are frustrated with those who deny AGW, not the deniers. Of course, that falls well short of proof, especially since you were just expressing your opinion. Your opinion cannot have any causal relationship to the authorship of the memo (obviously). One can hardly "admit" something one clearly does not know, or even claim to know.

So I guess all of that was a long way of saying I mostly agree with you.:)

While I will disagree that there's terms in the memo that I wouldn't expect HI to use, I can't take a firm stance on whether the document is faked or not. I tend to mistrust HI, and I tend to trust scientists, so I suppose that's my bias.

I would like to point out that all this waffling about the one allegedly faked document draws attention away from the many verified documents, and I wouldn't put it past HI to have intended for that to happen. We should spend more time going through what HI is doing, who they are paying and who's paying them. After all, that information is all contained in the verified documents.
 
Well, of course deniers don't call themselves that, but I think there's a real disconnect, especially when it comes to mercenaries like HI. I wouldn't put it past them to be honest enough amongst their inner circle to call what they plan to do by it's proper nomenclature.



When it comes to HI, I think it can be assumed that they are arguing in bad faith. After all, that's what they did when they claimed smoking wasn't bad for you.



While I will disagree that there's terms in the memo that I wouldn't expect HI to use, I can't take a firm stance on whether the document is faked or not. I tend to mistrust HI, and I tend to trust scientists, so I suppose that's my bias.

I would like to point out that all this waffling about the one allegedly faked document draws attention away from the many verified documents, and I wouldn't put it past HI to have intended for that to happen. We should spend more time going through what HI is doing, who they are paying and who's paying them. After all, that information is all contained in the verified documents.

All I'll say is that it is the disputed document which, if genuine, is the most revealing. It is the only document that baldly admits bad faith, and that admission, if it is genuine, is in my opinion the most newsworthy aspect of this whole affair. Of course, if it is fake, then that is the most newsworthy aspect of the whole affair. So either way, I don't think the focus on that document is misplaced.

As to the rest, I don't think you are being unreasonable. I find it harder to believe than you do that HI staffers would write that way, but I don't claim to know all that much about HI. However, I didn't have just HI in mind when I was talking about assumptions of bad faith. I'm just frustrated that I see it so often on every issue and from both sides.

Since we are both withholding judgment on the disputed document for now, there really isn't any major dispute between us.
 
From Roger Pielke (jr)'s blog (comments)...
6. Stan said
Since when does an editor without any background in the science at issue have the power to decree that a paper (Spencer and Braswell, Remote Sensing, not withdrawn) is "fundamentally flawed"? Gleick's comment is more than just stupid. It shows that he is so determined to try to score political points that he is willing to sacrifice his own reputation to do so.
Fri Sep 02, 03:57:00 PM MDT
Prescient, huh?.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom