Has Edgar Cayce made any gross errors in prophecy?

But his knowledge wasn't particularly remarkable. It reflects the sort of knowledge that was used at the time in the practice of medicine - now discredited ideas about the spinal column and nerve roots when he worked with an osteopath, now discredited ideas about magic water when he worked with a homeopath, the sorts of remedies which we now know to be largely ineffective, and the sort of often wrong ideas about physiology and pathology that reflected our own ignorance generally and his ignorance specifically. If he'd had some sort of pipeline to specialized knowledge, we would see something different from the sorts of things that a lay-person with a spotty knowledge base overlaid with a disregard for falsity that his streams-of-consciousness utterings produced.

That his range of knowledge reflected (poorly) only the knowledge of the day is what makes him unremarkable, not remarkable.


Perhaps he had the sort of range of knowledge that could have been obtained through, say, a few years worth of browsing in bookshops, followed by some time associating with osteopaths or homoeopaths?
 
Thats a lie, he worked at a series of bookshops that sold what was popular, and at that time that was theosophy books
Hoppers bookstore actually specialised in occult and osteopathic works one of which "Isis unveiled" (Blavatsky) contained most of the mystical woo crap that Cayce was to spew out later.
http://www.experiencefestival.com/a/Edgar_Cayce_-_Sources_of_Cayces_Beliefs/id/1289375 (a pro cayce webpage admits that much)
now are you lying yourself or is that another lie from the A.R.E.
or do you want to explain how Cayce came up with methods taught by theosophy all on his own ?
sorry, were you going to say that his psychic powers which demonstrate pseudo medicine available in books at the time he was selling them is somehow inexplicable ?
lolol


thats another lie
follow the link
http://simple.wikipedia.org/wiki/Edgar_Cayce#Vagueness
its actually cited on the wiki page as an example of Cayces vagueness

just so you know, apple brandy does not cure tuberculosis any more than eating wood cures cancer and the fact that she had a disease thats symptoms are about the most obvious of all the pathogens that infect mankind shows that any claims made for Cayce being a miraculous diagnostician were rubbish, a 5 year old could diagnose TB which at that time in the US was more common than the common cold.

It was a year after her death in 1946 with the development of the antibiotic streptomycin that effective treatment and cure became possible. Prior to the introduction of this drug, the only treatment besides sanatoria were surgical interventions, there was no known cure
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tuberculosis

so thats all you have, two A.R.E. sponsored lies
I'm going to start a new thread in a couple of days to show you how the A.R.E. are lying everyday for profit (note the spelling, not prophet)
i'll message you a link when I've done it
;)

As much as I respect Martin Gardner, he is wrong. Rodney is right. Edgar Cayce died January 3, 1945. Gertrude Cayce died April 1, 1945 of cancer (Kirkpatrick 523). The date of Gertrude's death is mentioned in several books, along with the fact that she outlived Cayce, was not suffering from tuberculosis at the time, and died of cancer, so that fact does not seem to be in dispute.

The claim about Hoppers Bookstore specializing in osteopathic and occult subjects is interesting, but I would like to see a source better than the one provided above before I took it as fact.

ETA: Cayce described Hoppers Bookstore (see his Memoirs) as a carrying "books of all kinds and sizes," current literature, school texts for the two colleges, office supples, picture frames and stationery, even wallpaper, art objects and window shades. He later worked selling wholesale books and stationery, then briefly in insurance, then for a bookstore called L.D. Potter Company Bookstore, in Bowling Green, which he referred to as "Potters." He did not describe that bookstore in detail.
 
Last edited:
This is an educational forum so we need to at least stick to the facts, and as much as I respect Martin Gardner, he is wrong. Rodney is right. Edgar Cayce died January 3, 1945. Gertrude Cayce died April 1, 1945 of cancer (Kirkpatrick 523).
.

Kirkpatrick is not a good source. More A.R.E. flim flam

what you are saying by using him as a source is that Gertrude had TB but was somehow miraculously cured by taking apple brandy, if that were true, apple brandy would now be the well known cure for TB, it isn't
Alternatively, it shows that Cayce did know the cure, but allowed millions of people to suffer by not telling anyone about it
 
Last edited:
Kirkpatrick is not a good source

what you are saying by using him as a source is that Gertrude had TB but was somehow miraculously cured by taking apple brandy, if that were true, apple brandy would now be the well known cure for TB, it isn't
Alternatively, it shows that Cayce did know the cure, but allowed millions of people to suffer by not telling anyone about it
What is the documentation that she TB in the first place?
 
What is the documentation that she had TB in the first place?

thats what the A.R.E. says
yeah I know

seems to me that this could be settled very easily

when you have a witness that is relied on in court, whos testimony is crucial to the conviction of the accused, if that witness is proven to be lying for personal gain, the case would be thrown out

so Rodneys testimony
+ Kirkpatricks testimony are both reliant on the A.R.E. telling the truth

So please lets drop this here before it turns into a ufo thread a la Rramjet, neither side is going to make their minds up either way, until definitive proof is given in either direction

I already mentioned I am working on a post that I will put up in a couple of days which will show without a doubt that lying is common practice with the A.R.E. and specifically purtaining to their claims for Atlantis which is their biggest money maker.

So if I prove the A.R.E. are lying about that, their credibility for everything else is moot isnt it

;)
two days
 
Last edited:
Kirkpatrick is not a good source. More A.R.E. flim flam

what you are saying by using him as a source is that Gertrude had TB but was somehow miraculously cured by taking apple brandy, if that were true, apple brandy would now be the well known cure for TB, it isn't
Alternatively, it shows that Cayce did know the cure, but allowed millions of people to suffer by not telling anyone about it

Be that as it may be, most of what we know about Cayce comes from the books written about him, letters published, etc.

What is the documentation that she TB in the first place?

The books about Cayce's life mostly tell a consistent story, including that sometime around 1911 Gertrude was diagnosed with pleurisy, then with tuberculosis by a "tuberculosis specialist" who was in town. Evidently, her brother had died from it (Sugrue). The condition, whatever it was, set in shortly after the loss of her baby.

The apple brandy fumes were supposedly to help clear the congestion in her lungs, not to cure what was suspected to be TB. Among other things, he apparently recommended some sort of heroin compound as part of the actual treatment.

Marduk will say this is A.R.E. propaganda, but regardless, that is the history as we have it from the biographies written about Cayce.

Apparently, after the onset of treatment, her condition slowly improved over a period of months and eventually she made a full recovery.
 
I'm curious, but not curious enough to do my own research: Was TB an incurable disease with a 100% non-recovery rate? Were there TB patients who recovered fully from it prior to antibiotics? Is it possible that the TB specialist who diagnosed her with TB made a misdiagnosis? Could Gertrude have been experiencing parasympathetic response to her brother's TB and having pseudo symptoms?
 
thats what the A.R.E. says
yeah I know

seems to me that this could be settled very easily

when you have a witness that is relied on in court, whos testimony is crucial to the conviction of the accused, if that witness is proven to be lying for personal gain, the case would be thrown out

so Rodneys testimony
+ Kirkpatricks testimony are both reliant on the A.R.E. telling the truth

So please lets drop this here before it turns into a ufo thread a la Rramjet, neither side is going to make their minds up either way, until definitive proof is given in either direction

I already mentioned I am working on a post that I will put up in a couple of days which will show without a doubt that lying is common practice with the A.R.E. and specifically purtaining to their claims for Atlantis which is their biggest money maker.

So if I prove the A.R.E. are lying about that, their credibility for everything else is moot isnt it

;)
two days
I will look forward to it, but I hope your research includes more than quoting uninformed weblinks. As best as I can tell, this whole thing about the Hopper Bookstore specializing in occult and osteopathic material stemmed from Martin Gardner's attempt to discredit Cayce. In investigating Cayce, it became obvious to Gardner that he was not a fraud, so Gardner developed the hypothesis that Cayce must have read a lot of such material and then unwittingly regurgitated it in readings. But the many authors who have looked first-hand at the Cayce material don't mention anything about Hopper being a bookstore specializing in the rather odd combination of the occult and osteopathic material. Even if that were true, so what? Surely many people have worked in occult and medical bookstores, so why haven't they been able to do what Cayce did? And as far as Gertrude Cayce dying of tuberculosis following an erroneous Cayce reading, that's about as accurate as the websites that inform their readers that Cayce was the first to prescribe laetrile for cancer -- omitting the inconvenient fact that laetrile was not synthesized until after Cayce's death.
 
Of note, in Cayce's own memoirs, he writes: "...And for nearly a year I was unable to give information (readings). My health seemed to fail. I was supposed to have TB or something worse..."

Again, in his own words, about Gertrude, Cayce claims the physician in charge told him: "Cayce, I'm sorry to tell you, old man, but your wife can't live another week. There's absolutely nothing we know in medical science that can do her any good in her present condition. You know she has tuberculosis. One lung is choked. No air has been going through it for months. The other is now affected and you must know from the hemorrhages that it is bleeding. With her high temperature and with her little resistance, she cannot hold out. She is very weak, and the hemorrhages are very bad. She cannot stand another one of them. If there's anything to this monkey business you've been doing with these fellows around here, you'd better try it on your wife."

At any rate, for his part he then says the druggist made up the compound and they started the recommended treatment. With the first dose she took there were no more hemorrhages. Cayce wrote, "Perhaps she wasn't ever going to have more anyway. In a few days, there was no fever. Possibly the fever had already broken, I don't know. Within two weeks she was decidely on the mend, though it was several months before she was able to go about her household duties." (From Edgar Cayce: My Life as a Seer)
 
I will look forward to it, but I hope your research includes more than quoting uninformed weblinks. As best as I can tell, this whole thing about the Hopper Bookstore specializing in occult and osteopathic material stemmed from Martin Gardner's attempt to discredit Cayce. In investigating Cayce, it became obvious to Gardner that he was not a fraud, so Gardner developed the hypothesis that Cayce must have read a lot of such material and then unwittingly regurgitated it in readings. But the many authors who have looked first-hand at the Cayce material don't mention anything about Hopper being a bookstore specializing in the rather odd combination of the occult and osteopathic material. Even if that were true, so what? Surely many people have worked in occult and medical bookstores, so why haven't they been able to do what Cayce did? And as far as Gertrude Cayce dying of tuberculosis following an erroneous Cayce reading, that's about as accurate as the websites that inform their readers that Cayce was the first to prescribe laetrile for cancer -- omitting the inconvenient fact that laetrile was not synthesized until after Cayce's death.


I edited this in to my post above since it seemed to best fit there, but the description I found in Cayce's own words did not fit with Hoppers being a bookstore specializing in occult and metaphical literature. Agreed that it doesn't really matter, but just for the record:

Cayce described Hoppers Bookstore (see his Memoirs) as a carrying "books of all kinds and sizes," current literature, school texts for the two colleges, office supples, picture frames and stationery, even wallpaper, art objects and window shades.
 
I'm curious, but not curious enough to do my own research: Was TB an incurable disease with a 100% non-recovery rate? Were there TB patients who recovered fully from it prior to antibiotics? Is it possible that the TB specialist who diagnosed her with TB made a misdiagnosis?
The PPD/Mantoux/Tuberculin test was already developed in the early 1900s but the problem with those tests is that is tests for exposure and not infection.

TB has a variable presentation. Many TB patients have suppressed TB that may reactivate later in life or are completely asymptomatic. Progressive TB can occasionally spontaneously involute.
Could Gertrude have been experiencing parasympathetic response to her brother's TB and having pseudo symptoms?
It's possible.

Again. So? Why should anyone care about this Cayce person? Rodney seems awfully silent about this for some reason. He did something somehow unexplained but he won't say what.
 
Of note, in Cayce's own memoirs, he writes: "...And for nearly a year I was unable to give information (readings). My health seemed to fail. I was supposed to have TB or something worse..."

Again, in his own words, about Gertrude, Cayce claims the physician in charge told him: "Cayce, I'm sorry to tell you, old man, but your wife can't live another week. There's absolutely nothing we know in medical science that can do her any good in her present condition. You know she has tuberculosis. One lung is choked. No air has been going through it for months. The other is now affected and you must know from the hemorrhages that it is bleeding. With her high temperature and with her little resistance, she cannot hold out. She is very weak, and the hemorrhages are very bad. She cannot stand another one of them. If there's anything to this monkey business you've been doing with these fellows around here, you'd better try it on your wife."

At any rate, for his part he then says the druggist made up the compound and they started the recommended treatment. With the first dose she took there were no more hemorrhages. Cayce wrote, "Perhaps she wasn't ever going to have more anyway. In a few days, there was no fever. Possibly the fever had already broken, I don't know. Within two weeks she was decidely on the mend, though it was several months before she was able to go about her household duties." (From Edgar Cayce: My Life as a Seer)
Sounds like Pneumonia.
 
Surely many people have worked in occult and medical bookstores, so why haven't they been able to do what Cayce did?

But what is it that you think Cayce did other than regurgitate stuff indistinguishable from the incomplete and erroneous knowledge of the time???

Linda
 
The PPD/Mantoux/Tuberculin test was already developed in the early 1900s but the problem with those tests is that is tests for exposure and not infection.

TB has a variable presentation. Many TB patients have suppressed TB that may reactivate later in life or are completely asymptomatic. Progressive TB can occasionally spontaneously involute.

It's possible.

Again. So? Why should anyone care about this Cayce person? Rodney seems awfully silent about this for some reason. He did something somehow unexplained but he won't say what.

Can I take a shot at it?

Why should anyone still care about Cayce?

Your underlying question seems to be: Why should anyone still believe Cayce was doing anything paranormal or unusual, enough to still care about him?

The answer is: If you don't think he was doing anything paranormal, there is no reason to care about him.

Why would people still believe there might have been something paranormal going on? In spite of some well-publicized failed predictions and a few big errors (like the ones we started out discussing in response to the OP!).

In my experience there are quite a few reasons. First, because he himself and his close friends and associates told stories of events that seemed to indicate his trances did involve some sort of paranormal ability. We can argue all over hell and back whether those stories (anecdotes) present a decent reason to believe, but in any case many people still find it sufficient.

Second, he provided an extensive spiritual philosophy that inspires them.

Third, he seemed like a sincere, nice guy. Even in his own memoirs and journal entries that were later published. Human but sincere, and so he has gained a more loyal following than someone, say, who made millions off of greiving widows or had been caught out in a big public way as a fraud or whose work was full of contradictions and inconsistencies.

Fourth, his story is consistent. The many biographies written by people about Cayce and by his friends and associates seem to describe the events of Cayce's life in much the same way from different angles. They also indicate that he was well-respected and that those closest to him seemed to believe something paranormal was happening. Again, this may not be sufficient evidence for everyone, but for many people it is, and so the fact is that many people still do find all of the above taken together to be fascinating.

While I no longer know what I believe about Cayce personally now, I did believe he was the real thing for many years, for many of the above reasons.
 
Can I take a shot at it?

Why should anyone still care about Cayce?

Your underlying question seems to be: Why should anyone still believe Cayce was doing anything paranormal or unusual, enough to still care about him?

The answer is: If you don't think he was doing anything paranormal, there is no reason to care about him.

Why would people still believe there might have been something paranormal going on? In spite of some well-publicized failed predictions and a few big errors (like the ones we started out discussing in response to the OP!).

In my experience there are quite a few reasons. First, because he himself and his close friends and associates told stories of events that seemed to indicate his trances did involve some sort of paranormal ability. We can argue all over hell and back whether those stories (anecdotes) present a decent reason to believe, but in any case many people still find it sufficient.

Second, he provided an extensive spiritual philosophy that inspires them.

Third, he seemed like a sincere, nice guy. Even in his own memoirs and journal entries that were later published. Human but sincere, and so he has gained a more loyal following than someone, say, who made millions off of greiving widows or had been caught out in a big public way as a fraud or whose work was full of contradictions and inconsistencies.

Fourth, his story is consistent. The many biographies written by people about Cayce and by his friends and associates seem to describe the events of Cayce's life in much the same way from different angles. They also indicate that he was well-respected and that those closest to him seemed to believe something paranormal was happening. Again, this may not be sufficient evidence for everyone, but for many people it is, and so the fact is that many people still do find all of the above taken together to be fascinating.

While I no longer know what I believe about Cayce personally now, I did believe he was the real thing for many years, for many of the above reasons.
Thanks for the reply. I'm aware that these were some of the reason why people think he is relevant. However, for some odd reason Rodney seemed awfully embarrassed to come clean with these reasons.

But like already mentioned. He's a failure at prophecy and only ever regurgitated useless, false and outdated medical platitudes. Basically I see him as a nobody. Someone not worth even remembering except as someone who helped support the woo and other such nonsense that people such as Harry Houdini worked to expose.
 
Thanks for the reply. I'm aware that these were some of the reason why people think he is relevant. However, for some odd reason Rodney seemed awfully embarrassed to come clean with these reasons.
Embarrassed? Hardly. Again, I believe that Cayce's range of knowledge -- particularly with respect to specific medical problems -- was too extensive to be explained by ordinary means.

But like already mentioned. He's a failure at prophecy and only ever regurgitated useless, false and outdated medical platitudes. Basically I see him as a nobody. Someone not worth even remembering except as someone who helped support the woo and other such nonsense that people such as Harry Houdini worked to expose.
I'm glad that you brought up Houdini. According to An American Prophet, at pp. 234-235, in 1921 Cayce met Houdini and attended the heavyweight championship fight between Jack Dempsey and Georges Carpentier as Houdini's guest. "In public and in private, Houdini remained strangely silent about his meeting with Cayce. Houdini didn't expose him as a fraud -- as he had done to hundreds of others -- but neither did he invest in the Cayce Petroleum Company or publicly acknowledge Edgar to be 'the real thing' . . . When Houdini wrote his famous exposé, A Magician Among the Spirits, he steered clear of discussing mediums who, like Cayce, didn't lift tables, produce ectoplasm, or rap out spirit messages."

So why do you suppose Houdini did not, at a minimum, expose Cayce as a regurgitator of useless information?
 
But what is it that you think Cayce did other than regurgitate stuff indistinguishable from the incomplete and erroneous knowledge of the time???

Linda
Oh, Linda, we've been through this many times: The Amy Dietrich case, the Tommy House case, his wife's case, Dr. Wesley Ketchum relying in large part on Cayce's diagnoses to treat patients, etc.
 
Embarrassed? Hardly. Again, I believe that Cayce's range of knowledge -- particularly with respect to specific medical problems -- was too extensive to be explained by ordinary means.
What knowledge?

I'm glad that you brought up Houdini. According to An American Prophet, at pp. 234-235, in 1921 Cayce met Houdini and attended the heavyweight championship fight between Jack Dempsey and Georges Carpentier as Houdini's guest. "In public and in private, Houdini remained strangely silent about his meeting with Cayce. Houdini didn't expose him as a fraud -- as he had done to hundreds of others -- but neither did he invest in the Cayce Petroleum Company or publicly acknowledge Edgar to be 'the real thing' . . . When Houdini wrote his famous exposé, A Magician Among the Spirits, he steered clear of discussing mediums who, like Cayce, didn't lift tables, produce ectoplasm, or rap out spirit messages."

So why do you suppose Houdini did not, at a minimum, expose Cayce as a regurgitator of useless information?
Don't know. Do you have any citation beyond what you regurgitate from your Bible?
Are you now going to use the "hey cayce didn't get sued/houdini never exposed Cayce therefore he must be super magic man" argument again are you?
So what did this nobody do again for anyone to care?
 
Oh, Linda, we've been through this many times: The Amy Dietrich case, the Tommy House case, his wife's case, Dr. Wesley Ketchum relying in large part on Cayce's diagnoses to treat patients, etc.
You mean stories? What what a great fairy tale you have. Didn't you already state that you have no corroborating evidence, just anecdotes?

And Cayce left what to medicine and health again? Oh yeah...nothing just the basis for debunked quackery.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom